Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutDowntown Parking Studies 2018 and prior� t e t N E B f R r H P 4 A C E O F M I N N PARKING COMMISSION DATE: October 19, 2018 SUBJECT: Parking studies for Downtown Stillwater FROM: Bill Turnblad, Community Development Director Over the years, the City of Stillwater has completed a number of parking surveys, inventories and studies. This document compiles such work done in 1960, 1996, 2010, 2015 and 2017. DOWNTOWN PARKING STUDY FOR STILLWATER MINNESOTA COMMUNITY PLANNING & DESIGN ASSOCIATES INC COMMUNITY PLANNING & DESIGN ASSOCIATES P L A N N I N G A R C H I T E C T U R E D E S 1 G N 9 AUGUST 1960 THE CITY COUNCIL THE PLAN14I NG COMMISSION THE CHAMBER OF COMMERCE PARKING COMMITTEE STILLWATER, MINNESOTA GENTLEMEN: CITIES OF ALL SIZES ACROSS THE NATION ARE FACING CRITICAL SHORTAGES OF PARKING SPACE IN THEIR DOWNTOWN AREA'S. THE PROVISION OF ADEQUATE PARKING TO MEET THE DEMANDS OF THE MERCHANT AND THE CONVENIENCE OF THE CUSTOMER IS GENERALLY A UNIVERSAL PROBLEM. MORE IS AT STAKE THAN MERCHANT AND CUSTOMER CONVENIENCE, HOWEVER. FROM THE CITY'S POINT OF VIEW, INADEQUATE PARKING STRANGULATES THE ALREADY OVER TAXED CIRCULATION SYSTEM AND DRIVES MANY POTENTIAL CUSTOMERS TO OTHER FACILITIES WITH ADEQUATE PARKINGJI THUS 114PAIRING THE ECONOMIC WELL-BEING OF THEIR COMMUNITY AND ULTIMATELY LOWERING ITS TAX BASE. THESE CONSIDERATIONS TEND TO MAKE THE PROVISION OF ADEQUATE PARKING EVERYONE'S BUSINESS. THE RECOGNIT.ION OF THESE FACTS LED THE CHAMBER OF COMMERCE TO STUDY THE PARKING PROBLEM. FROM THEIR EFFORTS) THE CITY COUNCIL DIRECTED THAT A PARKING STUDY BE CONDUCTED. THIS REPORT IS THE RESULT OF THE COUNCIL'S ACTION. IN THE CONDUCT OF THIS STUDY, WE WISH TO EXPRESS OUR GRATITUDE TO THE CHAMBER OF COMMERCE PARKING COMMITTEE, THE PLANNING AND ZONING COMMISSION AND THE CITY ATTORNEY FOR THEIR HELP AND GUIDANCE. SINCERELY, COMMUNITY PLANNING & DESIGN ASSOCIATES INC THOMAS H. HODNE RI : DLF DENNIS W. GREENER ROBERT L. ISAACSON THOMAS H. HODNE REYNOLD M. ROBERTS AIA 2635 UNIVERSITY AVENUE 6T. PAUL 14. MINNESOTA MIDWAY 6.8617 SUMMARY OF MAJOR FINDINGS AND RECOMMENDATIONS I. DOWNTOWN STILLWATER HAS 732 PARK114G SPACES TODAY•, ONLY 235 OF WHICH ARE OFF-STREET. ^ 2. DOWNTOWN STILLWATER HAS A CURRENT DEMAND FOR AN ADDITIONAL 500 PARKING SPACES ALL OFF-STREET. 3. THIS IMMEDIATE DCMAND CAN DE MET THROUGH THE PROVISION OF PARKING FACILITIES AT THE FOLLOWING SITES: - 300 SPACES NORTH OF LOWELL PARK EXTENDING OUT ON TO THE PENINSULA. - 50 SPACES SOUTH OF LOWELL PARK BETWEEN THE RAILROAD AND LAKE ST. CROIX. 100 SPACES IN A TWO LEVEL RAMP ON THE SOUTHEAST CORNER OF EAST MYRTLE AND NORTH SECOND. - 100 SPACES IN A TERRACED LOT ON THE NORTHWEST CORNER OF EAST OLIVE AND SOUTH SECOND. 4. THESE AND FUTURE FACILITIES MUST BE LOCATED IN RELATION TO THE RING ROAD PROPOSED IN PHASE I. THIS WOULD FACILITATE THE MOVEMENT OF TRAFFIC INTO AND OUT OF THE PARKING FACILITIES AND HELP DEFINE AND PRESERVE THE MAJOR BUSINESS DISTRICT. 5. ALTERNATE IMMEDIATE ACTIONS ARE INCLUDED TQ; PROVIDE FLEXIBILITY IN MEETING PARKING NEEDS. 6. STILLWATER'S LONG-RANGE PARKING REQUIREMEN.MS-OF FROM 2,000 TO.2,500 SPACES CAN BEST BE MET THROUGH RELATION TO PHASE II AND STILLWATER'S CONTINUING PLANNING EFFORT. 7. A COMMITTEE CONSISTING OF THE CITY ATTORNEY AND REPRESENTATIVES OF THE CITY COUNCIL, PLANNING AND ZONING COMMISSION AND BUSINESS COMMUNITY SHOULD BE FORMED TO RECOMMEND TO THE CITY COUNCIL PROCEDURES TO ACHIEVE THIS PLAN AND PROGRAM. a. REVENUE OBTAINED FROM PARKING FACILITIES SHOULD BE RESERVED IN A SPECIAL PARKING FUND. 9. THE SOLUTION TO STILLWATER'S PARKING PROBLEM 13 ONLY ONE STEP IN THE EVENTUAL REVITALIZING OF THE DOWNTOWN AREA. IV TABLE OF CONTENTS PAGE LETTER OF TRANSMITTAL . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . III SUMMARY OF MAJOR FINDINGS AND RECOMMENDATIONS . . . . , . , . Iv LIST OF TABLES . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . VI LIST OF ILLUSTRATIONS . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . v i CHAPTER 1. I NTRODUCT I ON . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1 CONCEPT PROGRAM II. STILLWATER DOWNTOWN -PARKING NEEDS . . . . . . . . . . . 3 IMMEDIATE LONG-RANGE III. RELATION TO PHASE.I PLAN.ELEMENTS . . . . . . . . . . . 4 IV. IMMEDIATE RECOMMENDATIONS . . ... . . . . . . . . . . 5 .V. LONG-RANGE RECOMMENDATIONS . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 10 VI. .ADMINISTRATIVE CONSIDERATIONS . . . . . . . . . . . . . 12 VII. APPENDIX 14 kvi LIST OF TABLES TABLE PAGE 1. SUMMARY OF NUMBER OF ADDITIONAL PARKING SPACES THROUGH IMMEDIATE RECOMMENDATIONS . . . . . . . . . a 2. CURRENT PARKING SPACES WITHIN DOWNTOWN CORE AND FRAME . . . . . . . . . .APPENDIX 1 3. SUMMARY OF DOWNTOWN CORE FLOOR AREA USE . . . . . . .APPENDIX 1 4. SUMMARY OF DOWNTOWN FRAME FLOOR AREA USE . . . . . .APPENDIX 2 5. SUMMARY OF TOTAL DOWNTOWN FLOOR AREA USE APPENDIX 2 LIST OF ILLUSTRATIONS ILLUSTRATION PAGE 1. PARKING LOCATIONS CONCEPT . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2 2. IMMEDIATE AND FUTURE PARKING SITES . . . . . . . . 6 3. EXISTING PARKINGY DOWNTOWN CORE AND FRAME . . . . . APPENDIX 6 YI I. INTRODUCTION IN DETERMINING THE MOST LOGICAL LOCATION FOR PARKING FACILITIES TO MEET DOWNTOWN STILLWATER'S IMMEDIATE AND LONG-RANGE DEMANDS, IT WAS FELT NECESSARY TO: 1. DETERMINE THE NEED FOR PARKING> BOTH IMMEDIATE AND LONG-RANGE 2. ESTIMATE FUTURE POPULATION 3. PROVIDE AN OVER-ALL FRAMEWORK WITHIN WHICH THE PROPOSED PARKING COULD BE LOCATED TO BEST SERVE THE NEEDS OF THE ENTIRE COMMUNITY. AS PART OF DETERMINING THE NEED FOR PARKING WE FIRST SURVEYED THE EXISTING SITUATION AND CONDUCTED A DETAILED BUILDING USE SURVEY OF THE DOWNTOWN AREA. AN INDICATION OF FUTURE POPULATION AND AN OVER-ALL FRAMEWORK FOR LOCATING PARKING FACILITIES WERE PROVIDED AS PART OF PHASE I OF YOUR PLANNING PROGRAM. THESE ELEMENTS, PLUS A REVIEW OF A COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS OF PARKING REQUIREMENTS, FORMED THE BASIS OF DETERMINING IMMEDIATE AND LONG-RANGE DEMAND. SEE APPENDIX) THE STUDIES AND CONCLUSIONS ARISING OUT OF THE ABOVE INVESTIGATIONS HAVE BEEN RE- VIEWED BY THE CHAMBER OF COMMERCE PARKING COMMITTEE AND ARE SUMMARIZED IN THIS REPORT. CONCEPT GENERALLY, THE BASIC CONCEPT -INVOLVED 4N PROVIDING OFF-STREET PARKING FACILITIES FOR STILLWATER IS TO LOCATE THEM ON THE "RING ROAD" SYSTEM, PRESENTED AS A RECOM- MENDATION IN PHASE I. SUCH LOCATIONS WOULD PERMIT EASY ACCESS TO PARKING FROM ALL AREAS OF STILLWATER AND PROVIDE MAJOR PARKING AREAS CLOSE TO ANY SECTION OF THE DOWNTOWN AREA. ANOTHER ADVANTAGE OF THE RING ROAD IS THAT IT WOULD FACILITATE MOVEMENT AROUND THE DOWNTOWN, AND THUS FROM ONE PARKING AREA TO ANOTHER IN THE EVENT THAT THE PARKING AREA OF FIRST CHOICE IS FULL. THE RING ROAD ALSO SERVES THE FUNCTION OF GIVING IDENTITY TO AND PROVIDING A DEFINITION OF THE MAJOR COM- MERCIAL AREA OF STILLWATER. SEE ILLUSTRATION 1) P A R K I N G LOCATION CONCEPT 0 PROGRAM TO DEST MEET THE PARKING NEEDS OF STILLWATER, AN IMMEDIATE AND LONG-RANGE PROGRAM OF ACTION IS REQUIRED. RECOGNIZING THAT A CRITICAL PROBLEM EXISTS TODAY IN RELATION TO 'ARKING, SPECIFIC RECOMMENDATIONS DESIGNED TO PROVIDE A GUIDE FOR IMMEDIATE ACTION TO SERVE CURRENT NEEDS ARE PRESENTED. ALSO RECOGNIZING THAT DEMAND INCREASES IN RELATION TO BUSINESS AND POPULATION, A PROGRAM DESIGNED TO KEEP PACE WITH PARKING NEEDS OVER A 20 YEAR PERIOD IS PRESENTED. Ii. STILLWATER DOWNTOWN PARKING NEEDS THE ESTIMATES OF STILLWATER'S CURRENT AND LONG-RANGE DOWNTOWN PARKING NEEDS WERE BASED ON EXISTING AND PROPOSED BUILDING SPACE USE, POPULATION, AND A COMPARISON OF SIMILAR SIZED CITIES. THE VARIOUS METHODS EMPLOYED TO ESTIMATE THIS NEED GAVE RESULTS THAT RANGED FROM 135 TO 858 ADDITIONAL PARKING SPACES NEEDED* IMMEDIATELY. ON A LONG-RANGE BASIS, THE TOTAL DEMAND WAS FROM BETWEEN 1,420 TO 3,250 PARKING SPACES, COVERING A PERIOD FROM NOW TO 1980. SEE APPENDIX) IMMEDIATE LOOKING FIRST AT THE IM14EDIATE DEMAND, THE RANGE APPEARS TO HAVE TWO RATHER SEVERE EXTREMITIES. A CURRENT DEMAND OF 858 ADDITIONAL PARKING SPACES SEEMS EXCESSIVE FOR A TRADE CENTER SUCH AS STILLWATER. ON THE OTHER HAND, IT SEEMS THAT 135 ADDITIONAL SPACES WOULD NOT ADEQUATELY MEET STILLWATER'S IMMEDIATE NEEDS. THIS LOWER FIGURE WAS DERIVED FROM AN ANALYSIS OF SIMILAR SIZED CITIES, AND IT IS QUITE POSSIBLE THAT STILLWATER DOES NOT POSSESS THE SAME NEEDS AND CHARACTERISTICS AS THE OTHER COMMUN- ITIES. FOR THE PURPOSE OF THIS STUDY, AN IMMEDIATE ADDITIONAL DEMAND OF APPROXIMATELY 500 PARKING SPACES WAS DEEMED TO BE ADEQUATE. THIS NUMBER REPRESENTS THE MIDPOINT IN THE ESTIMATED DEMAND. IT IS FELT THAT 500 ADDITIONAL PARKING SPACES REPRESENTS A REALISTIC AMOUNT TO PLAN ON PROVIDING IN THE IMMEDIATE FUTURE. IN EFFECT, IT PROVIDES A SCALE OF CURRENT NEED AND ESTABLISHES A GOAL TO STRIVE TOWARD. Cs ADDING THE 732 EXISTING PARKING SPACES (SEE TABLE 2 AND ILLUSTRATION 3 IN APPENDIX TO A CURRENT DEMAND OF 500 ADDITIONAL SPACES} A TOTAL CURRENT DEMAND OF APPROXIMATELY 1,230 SPACES IS DETERMINED. WE RECOMMEND THAT ALL ADDITIONAL PARKING BE PROVIDED IN OFF-STREET FACILITIES. OF THE 732 EXISTING SPACES ONLY 235 ARE OFF-STREET. LONG-RANGE USING THIS ADJUSTED TOTAL CURRENT DEMAND AS A BASE, A MORE REFINED ESTIMATE FOR 1980 CAN BE OBTAINED. THE RANGE ESSENTIALLY RESULTS FROM APPLYING THE HIGH AND LOW POPULATION ESTIMATES FOR 1980 TO THE VARIOUS METHODS USED IN DETERMINING THE CURRENT NEED. FROM THE REFINED CURRENT NEED, A RANGE OF 2,000 TO 2,500 TOTAL PARKING SPACES IS ESTIMATED FOR 1980. WE FEEL THAT THE PROVISION OF A TOTAL OF 1,230 PARKING SPACES AS AN IMMEDIATE GOAL AND BETWEEN 2)000 AND 2,500 SPACES OVER A TWENTY YEAR PERIOD WOULD ADE- QUATELY MEET THE PARKING NEEDS OF STILLWATER'S EXPANDING ECONOMY AND POPULATION. III. RELATION TO PHASE I PLAN ELEMENTS RECOMMENDATIONS PRESENTED AS PART OF YOUR PHASE I PLANNING EFFORT MUST SERVE AS THE BASIS FOR DEVELOPING A PARKING PLAN. AT THIS TIME WE FEEL CONFIDENT THAT THIS CAN BE DONE WITH ASSURANCE. THIS IS UNQUESTIONABLY SO IN RELATION TO MEETING STILLWATER'S IMMEDIATE PARKING DEMAND. OUR PROGRAM FOR LONG-RANGE RE- QUIREMENTS MUST BE TIED INTO THE PHASE II PROGRAM STILLWATER IS CURRENTLY UNDER- TAKING. BECAUSE OF THE FACT THAT DEMAND WILL FLUCTUATE WITH POPULATION AND ECONOMIC CHANGES, THE EXISTING SITUATION SHOULD BE EXAMINED FROM TIME TO TIME TO ASSURE THAT SUPPLY IS ADEQUATE FOR DEMAND AND THAT THE PROGRAM IS PROGRESSING IN RELATION TO THE COMMUNITY'S LONG-RANGE DEVELOPMENT OBJECTIVES. 5. GENERALLY IT IS OUR OPINION THAT PHASE I SETS A WORKABLE AND LOGICAL FRAMEWORK FOR THE PARKING STUDY. THE PARKING STUDY DOES MUCH TO FIRM UP MANY PHASE I RE- COMMENDATIONS IN RELATION TO THE RING ROAD AND MORE GENERAL OBJECTIVE. IV. IMMEDIATE RECOMMENDATIONS THE IMMEDIATE RECOMMENDATIONS ARE PROJECTS THAT CAN BE INITIATED AT ONCE - AS SOON AS THE MACHINERY TO DO SO IS IN GEAR. THEY MAKE UP A PROGRAM THAT SHOULD PROCEED WITH ALL DUE HASTE AND BE ACCOMPLISHED WITHIN THREE YEARS. SUCH A PERIOD SHOULD PROVIDE SUFFICIENT TIME TO MEET THE LOWER PRIORITY RATING ATTACHED TO CERTAIN ELEMENTS OF THE IMMEDIATE PROGRAM. WHENEVER THE RECOMMENDED SITE CONTAINS A STRUCTURE, IT WAS DETERMINED BY FIELD SURVEY THAT THE STRUCTURE WAS IN SUCH A POOR CONDITION THAT IT WOULD BE UNECONOMIC TO BRING IT UP TO STANDARD IN RELATION TO THE VALUE AFTER IMPROVEMENT. ACCORDING TO PRIORITY, THE FOLLOWING PROJECTS ARE RECOMMENDED TO MEET THE CRITICAL SHORTAGE OF PARKING SPACES IN DOWNTOWN STILLWATER, RECOGNIZING THAT WITHIN BUDGET LIMITATIONS AS MUCH OF THIS PROGRAM SHOULD BE INITIATED AND CARRIED ON CONCUR- RENTLY AS POSSIBLE (SEE ILLUSTRATION 2 FOR DETAILS): 1. IMPROVE FOR PARKING THE STRIP OF LAND EXTENDING NORTH FROM LOWELL PARK AND INCLUDING A MAJOR PORTION OF THE PENINSULA IMMEDIATELY SOUTH OF THE BOAT WORKS AND MARINA. THIS AREA WOULD PROVIDE 300 PARKING SPACES. IT IS SEEN AS DEVELOPING PRIMARILY TO SERVE ALL DAY, DOWNTOWN EMPLOYEE PARKING. IN ADDITION) IT WOULD SERVE THE NEEDS OF SPECIALIZED ALL -DAY PARKING AS WELL AS WEEKEND AND HOLIDAY RECREATION PARKING. ENCOURAGING EMPLOYEES TO PARK IN SPECIAL AREAS SOMEWHAT REMOTE FROM THE HEART OF DOWNTOWN AND YET WITHIN REASONABLE WALKING DISTANCE WOULD X Ll F— EAST MYRTLE CHESTNUT EAST OLIVE F 0 RAW SWA(E SuRrACE (A--ALILRNATE) 0 COMMERCIAL AVENUE STREET 3,/ 100 STREET 0 z 0 C� LC..G.RAllir 2 LCVEL ADDITION 3 LEVEL RAW "rACC PRIORI Ty,'"UER Or SPACES IMMEDIATE AND FUTURE NELSON STREET I PARKING SITES 7. HELP IN RELIEVING THE PARKING SHORTAGE DOWNTOWN FOR CUSTOMERS. 2. IMPROVE FOR PARKiNG THE AREA IMMEDIATELY SOUTH OF LOWELL PARK TO ACCOMMODATE 50 CARS. THIS AREA WOULD SERVE THE SAME PURPOSES AS 1 ABOVE. BOTH THE AREAS OF RECOMMENDATIONS 1 AND 2 -SHOULD BE CAREFULLY PLANNED TO MAINTAIN THE OPEN SPACE CHARACTER OF THE VICINITY SET BY LOWELL PARK. THIS COULD IN PART BE ACCOMPLISHED BY THE CAREFUL SAVING OF THE TREES IN THE AREAS. WE ARE CONFIDENT THAT THIS CAN BE DONE AND STILL PROVIDE ADEQUATE PARKING. THE PARK SHOULD BE UTILIZED AS A VISUAL AND PHYSICAL LINK BETWEEN THE PARKING AREAS AND DOWNTOWN. 3. IMPROVE FOR PARKING THE SOUTHEAST CORNER OF EAST MYRTLE AND NORTH SECOND, INCLUDING THE SIMONET WAREHOUSE. IT IS RECOMMENDED THAT A TWO LEVEL RAMP BE CONSTRUCTED AT THIS SITE AND THAT THE EXISTING SERVICE STATION BE INCLUDED AS A SERVICE FACILITY AND BE ENCOURAGED TO PARTICI- PATE IN THE PROGRAM. -BECAUSE OF THE COMMERCIAL POTENTIAL AVAILABLE HERE, THE PROVISION OF THIS PARKING FACILITY COULD WELL BE A PRIVATE VENTURE. A RAMP AT THIS SITE WOULD ACCOMMODATE 100 CARS. IT WOULD BE WITHIN THE DOWNTOWN RING ROAD AND IN A KEY LOCATION TO SERVE THAT PART OF DOWNTOWN NORTH OF CHESTNUT. 4. IMPROVE FOR PARKING THE NORTHWEST CORNER OF EAST OLIVE AND SOUTH SECOND. THIS AREA WOULD PROVIDE 100 PARKING SPACES ON TERRACED LEVELS AND WOULD 1.1 SERVE, ALTHOUGH JUST OUTSIDE THE -PROPOSED RING ROAD, PRIMARILY THE SOUTH PART OF DOWNTOWN. TABLE I SUMMARY OF NUMBERS OF ADDITIONAL PARKING SPACES PROVIDED THROUGH IMMEDIATE RECOMMENDATIONS RECOMMENDATION No. OF PARKING SPACES 1 NORTH OF LOWELL PARK 300 2 SOUTH OF LOWELL PARK 50 3 EAST MYRTLE AND NORTH SECOND 100 4 EAST OLIVE AND SOUTH SECOND 100 TOTAL 550 THE PROVISION OF THE ABOVE RECOMMENDATIONS WOULD MEET THE IMMEDIATE DEMAND FOR PARKING IN DOWNTOWN STILLWATER -- A TOTAL OF 550 ADDITIONAL SPACES AT ADEQUATE STANDARDS. THIS AMOUNT OF SPACES EXCEEDS THE CURRENT ESTIMATED DEMAND BY 50. THIS FACT ADDS SOME FLEXIBILITY IN THE PROGRAM BY PERMITTING THE SCALING DOWN OF CERTAIN FACILITIES-3 IF DEEMED DESIRABLE. THERE ARE, HOWEVER, OTHER CONSIDERATIONS THAT SHOULD RECEIVE ATTENTION AS PART OF IMMEDIATE RECOMMENDATIONS. THESE CONSIDERATIONS ARE: 1. VACATION OF A 24 FOOT STRIP OF LOWELL PARK ALONG ITS WESTERN BOUNDARY SOUTH OF CHESTNUT. THE AMOUNT OF USEABLE PARK SPACE TAKEN THROUGH THIS VACATION COULD EASILY BE MADE UP BY CLOSING THE ROADWAY ALONG THE EASTERN EDGE OF THE PARK AND EXTENDING THE PARK ACROSS THE CLOSED STREET TO THE LAKE FRONT. a THE ADDITIONAL 24 FEET GAINED ALONG THE EASTERN EDGE COULD BE IMPROVED FOR MORE ADEQUATE PARKING AS PART OF THE IMMEDIATE PROGRAM. IT WOULD PROVIDE 50 SPACES SOUTH OF CHESTNUT. AS THE RING ROAD AND IMPROVED BRIDGE ACCESS BECOMES A REALITY, THIS LAND WOULD DE USED FOR THE PRO- VISION OF ADEQUATE RIGHT-OF-WAY. THE PARKING WOULD THEN BE MOVED AS PART OF THE LONG-RANGE) CONTINUING PROGRAM. THE VACATION OF THIS AREA WILL BE A NECESSITY IN PROVIDING THE SOUTHEASTERN SEGMENT OF THE RING ROAD. THEREFORE, IF IT IS TO BE UTILIZED FOR PARKING, IT MUST DE DEVELOPED IMMEDIATELY TO JUSTIFY THE EXPENSE INVOLVED IN PREPARING IT FOR PARKING BEFORE THE RING ROAD IS BUILT. 2. THE DEVELOPMENT OF THE AREA NORTH OF NELSON AND BETWEEN WATER STREET AND THE RAILROAD FOR PARKING. THIS AREA WOULD ACCOMMODATE 130 CARS AND WOULD SERVE THE PURPOSE OF ELIMINATING THE NEED FOR THE SPUR TRACK CUR- RENTLY'SERVING THE AREA. THIS AREA ALSO SERVES THE IMPORTANT FUNCTION OF PROVIDING A SPACE FOR PARKING DISPLACED BY THE RING ROAD. 3. THAT THE AREA TO THE NORTH AND SOUTH OF THE NEW HOOLEY SUPERMARKET COULD BE USED FOR PARKING (THE AREA TO THE NORTH UNDOUBTEDLY WILL BED ESPECIALLY AFTER THE RING ROAD BECOMES A REALITY). .THIS WOULD PROVIDE 130 SPACES. THERE IS A QUESTION, HOWEVER, WHETHER THIS PARKING SHOULD BE PROVIDED AT PUBLIC EXPENSE BECAUSE IT WOULD MOST ASSUREDLY BE USED ALMOST EXCLUSIVELY FOR SUPERMARKET PARKING. THESE SPACES CANNOT BE ENTIRELY COUNTED IN MEETING CURRENT DEMAND BECAUSE OF THE PECULIAR REQUIREMENTS OF A SUPER- MARKET. THOSE SPACES ABOVE SUPERMARKET REQUIREMENTS, IF THERE ARE ANY AND.IF THE PRIVATE OWNERSHIP SO ALLOWS, COULD BE USED FOR MEETING CURRENT GENERAL DEMAND. 10. THESE ADDITIONAL CONSIDERATIONS ARE PRESENTED AS POSSIBLE ALTERNATIVES TO THE IMMCDIAIE RCCOMMCNDATIONS PRESENTED ABOVE. THIS GIVES MORC FLCXIBILITY IN MEETING YOUR PARKING PRO-BLEM AND REALIZING THE 11414EDIATE OBJECTIVC OF 500 ADDITIONAL PARKING SPACES. THEY ALSO PROVIDE AN INDICATION OF THE NEXT STEPS THAT SHOULD BE TAKEN AS PART OF YOUR LONG-RANGE PROGRAM OF KEEPING ABREAST OF PARKING DEMAND AS IT INCREASES WITH ECONOMIC AND POPULATION GROWTH. V. LONG-RANGE RECOMMENDATIONS AFTER THE PROVISION OF 550 ADDITIONAL PARKING SPACES IN DOWNTOWN STILLWATER TO ADEQUATELY MEET IMMEDIATE DEMANDS, A PROGRAM SHOULD BE INITIATED TO CONTINUALLY KEEP ABREAST OF PARKING NEED. OUR ESTIMATES INDICATE THAT BY 1980 DOWNTOWN STILLWATER WILL NEED ANYWHERE FROM 2,000'TO 2>500 PARKING SPACES TO SERVE ITS CUSTOMERS AND VISITORS. THIS MEANS THAT FROM THE TIME IMMEDIATE DEMANDS ARE MET) AN ADDITIONAL 1,000 TO 1,500 SPACES WILL BE REQUIRED IN THE NEXT TWENTY YEARS DEPENDING ON THE RATE OF GROWTH OF STILLWATER'S ECONOMY. THIS NUMBER INCLUDES THE REPLACEMENT OF ON -STREET PARKING THAT SHOULD BE REMOVED AND PLACED INTO OFF-STREET FACL•LITIE7. ON -STREET PARKING, IN THE LONG RUN, SHOULD BE AT LEAST REMOVED FROM THE RING ROAD AND CHESTNUT STREET. IT IS ALSO A REAL POSSIBILITY THAT BY 1980 DOWNTOWN STILLWATER WILL BE IN A POSITION TO CLOSE CERTAIN STREETS AND ORIENT ITS BUSINESS ACTIVITY MORE TO THE PEDESTRIAN. IT WAS ASSUMED THAT SUCH ACTION WOULD DISPLACE 250 ON -STREET PARKING SPACES. THE REPLACEMENT OF THESE SPACES IS PROVIDED N THE ESTIMATED -1.000 TO 1.500 ADDITIONAL SPACES BY 1980. GENERALLY, APPROXIMATELY 1,100 ADDITIONAL SPACES CAN BE PROVIDED THROUGH THE FOL- LOWING PROGRAM, STAGED TO MEET DEMANDS OVER THE NEXT TWENTY YEARS: 1. EXPANSION OF THE NORTH SECOND AND EAST MYRTLE FACILITY TO TWO ADDITIONAL LEVELS PROVIDING 150 MORE SPACES. 2. CONSTRUCTION OF A THREE LEVEL RAMP AT SOUTH SECOND AND EAST OLIVE TO ACCOMMODATE AN ADDITIONAL 200 CARS. 3. THE PROVISION OF 130 MORE SPACES AS OUTLINED PREVIOUSLY FOR THE AREA NORTH OF NELSON STREET BETWEEN THE RAILROAD AND WATER STREET. THIS) OFF COURSE, ASSUMES THAT THIS AREA IS NOT PART OF THE IMMEDIATE PROGRAM. 4. THE AREA NORTH OF COMMERCIAL STREET AND BETWEEN MAIN AND SECOND CAN Arrnk,unnArr 190 rADC 5. THE AREA NORTH OF NELSON AND BETWEEN MAIN AND SECOND CAN ACCOMMODATE 100 CARS. 6. EXPANSION OF THE AREA NORTH OF LOWELL PARK TO ACCOMMODATE 200 AD- DITIONAL CARS. 7. EXPANSION OF THE AREA SOUTH OF LOWELL PARK TO ACCOMMODATE ZOO ADDITIONAL CARS. THE COMPLETION OF.SUCH A PROGRAM WOULD PROVIDE FOR THE MINIMUM PARKING REQUIRE- MENTS OF DOWNTOWN STILLWATER BY 1980. BECAUSE THE LONG-RANGE DEMAND IS INTEGRALLY RELATED TO THE LONG-RANGE GROWTH OF THE STILLWATER AREA, MORE DETAIL IN RELATION TO THE LONG-RANGE RECOMMENDATIONS CANNOT BE GIVEN AT THIS TIME. MORE DEF1141TE ANSWERS TO THE FUTURE DEVELOPMENT OF STILLWATER WILL BE GAINED THROUGH THE PHASE II PLANNING WORK CURRENTLY UNDERWAY BY YOUR PLANNING COMMISSION. THERE- FORE.9 WE RECOMMEND THAT THE PROVISION OF PARKING TO MEET YOUR LONG-RANGE DEMAND BE REFINED IN RELATION TO YOUR CONTINUING PLANNING PROGRAM. WE FEEL IT WOULD BE WELL TO CONSIDER THE UNDERTAKING OF A SPECIAL PLAN FOCUSED ON THE DOWNTOWN AREA OF STILLWATER. IN ADDITION TO THE PINPOINTING OF FUTURE PARKING AREAS AND NUMBERS OF SPACES, SUCH A PROJECT WOULD OUTLINE THE FUTURE AUTO- MOBILE AND PEDESTRIAN CIRCULATIONS NEW BUSINESS LOCATIONS AND DESIGN, A SHOPPER'S 12. MALL, AND PROVIDE A SCALE BY WHICH TO JUDGE THE NEED FOR ADDITIONAL RETAIL, OFFICE, COMMERCIAL AND OTHER DOWNTOWN USES. IN ADDITION.9 A CAREFULLY PURSUED PLAN FOR THE DOWNTOWN AREA WOULD PROVIDE THE BASIS FOR BUILDING AN URBAN RENEWAL PROGRAM AROUNC`THE NEEDS OF DOWNTOWN. THIS WOULD SERVE THE PURPOSE OF OBTAINING FINANCIAL ASSISTANCE IN PUBLICLY CLEARING DETERIORATED PROPERTY AND MAKING IT AVAILABLE FOR PUBLIC OR PRIVATE DEVELOPMENT - PARKING, NEW BUILDING SITES, ROADS, MALLS, ETC. VI. ADMINISTRATIVE CONSIDERATIONS ACHIEVING THE RECOMMENDATIONS OF THIS REPORT WILL REQUIRE ADMINISTRATIVE DECISIONS THAT CAN BEST BE MADE BY YOUR LOCAL CITIZENS AND OFFICIALS. HOWEVER., THERE ARE CERTAIN CONSIDERATIONS IN RELATION TO PARKING PROGRAM IMPLEMENTATION THAT MAY ASSIST YOU IN ARRIVING AT A MEANS OF ACHIEVEMENT. IN RELATION TO THIS) WE PRE- SENT THE FOLLOWING CONSIDERATIONS: 1. THE PARKING PROGRAM BE CONDUCTED WITHIN THE FRAMEWORK OF EXISTING GOVERNMENT. 2. THE IMMEDIATE RECOMMENDATIONS OF THE PARKING STUDY BE AOOE�TEDWITH REVISIONS AS FELT NECESSARY, BY THE PLANNING COMMISSION AND CITY COUNCIL AS THE PARKING PROGRAM FOR DOWNTOWN STILLWATER. 3. A COMMITTEE BE FORMED OF REPRESENTATIVES OF THE CITY COUNCIL, PLANNING COMMISSION AND THE BUSINESS COMMUNITY TO OUTLINE THE PROCEDURE TO FOLLOW IN ACHIEVING THE IMMEDIATE PROGRAM. THE CITY ATTORNEY WOULD BE A VALUABLE MEMBER OF THIS COMMITTEE. THIS COMMITTEE VOULD REPORT TO THE CITY COUNCIL ON NEEDED LEGISLATION TO IMPLEMENT PARKING NEEDS AND/OR DETERMINE THE BEST PROGRAM FOR PLAN ACHIEVEMENT IN LINE WITH THE PROGRAM AND GENERAL COMMUNITY SENTIMENT. THE COMMITTEE COULD WELL BE GUIDED IN 13. THEIR EFFORTS BY CAREFULLY REVIEWING THE WORK OF ST. CLOUD AND WILLMAR IN MEETING THEIR RESPECTIVE PARKING NEEDS. 4. BEGIN DET.,LED SITE LAYOUT OF LOTS AND PRELIMINARY ARCHITECTURAL DESIGN OF RAMP FACILITY WHILE IMPLE14ENTATION DETAILS ARE BEING WORKED OUT. TO BE EFFECTIVE PARKING AREAS MUST BE FUNCTIONALLY LAID OUT, ADEQUATELY MARKED, LIGI4TED AND LOCATED, WITH WELL DESIGNED DIRECTORY SIGNS. 5. THAT REVENUE OBTAINED FROM PARKING SOURCES BE RESERVED IN A SPECIAL PARKING FUND TO BE USED EXCLUSIVELY FOR PARKING PURPOSES. WE FEEL THAT THE PARKING PROBLEM IS A COMMUNITY WIDE PROBLEM AND THAT THE MONEY THE COMMUNITY SPENDS ON PARKING SHOULD BE USED TO MEET THEIR PARKING NEEDS. EXPERIENCE INDICATES THAT A PARKING PROGRAM IS NOT CHEAP. ACCORDING TO REPORTS, THE PARKING PROVIDED BY ST. CLOUD AS A RESULT OF THEIR PROGRAM AVERAGED $1,500 PER SPACE. A MUNICIPAL RAMP ABOUT TO BE BUILT IN WILLMAR (106 CAR CAPACITY) COST $653 PER SPACE, EXCLUSIVE OF LAND COST. (NCLUD`pG'LAND COST THE PRICE PER SPACE COULD WELL REACH OVER $1�000'. 14. VII. APPENDIX APPENDIX 1 DISCUSSION OF METHODS USED IN DETERMINING PARKING NEED THE FOLLOWING TABLES PROVIDE THE INFORMATION NECESSARY TO MAKE ESTIMATES OF DOWNTOWN STILLWATER'S PARKING REQUIREMENTS. AFTER THEIR PRESENTATION, THERE FOLLOWS A DISCUSSION OF THE VARIOUS METHODS USED TO DETERMINE PARKING REQUIRE- MENTS FOR STILLWATER'S DOWNTOWN AREA. TABLE 2 CURRENT PARKING SPACES WITHIN DOWNTOWN CORE AND FRAME, STILLWATER, MINNESOTA* CORE FRAME TOTAL STREET METERED 208 23 231 NOT METERED 123 143 266 OFF STREET 50 185 235 TOTAL 381 351 732 *BASED.ON ACTUAL COUNT CONDUCTED JUNE 1960 TABLE 3 SUMMARY OF DOWNTOWN CORE FLOOR AREA USE USE COMMERCIAL HEAVY COMMERCIAL OFFICE INSTITUTIONAL STORAGE -VACANT (BUILDINGS) RESIDENTIAL PARKING LAND WITHOUT BUILDINGS* STREETS AND ALLEYS INDUSTRIAL TOTAL AREA % TOTAL SQUARE FT.) 211,850 17.2 141,250 11.5 39,420 3.2 39,450 3.2 80,950 6.5 45,700 3.7 13,800 1.1 213,700 17.3 409,000 33.2 38,000 3.1 1,233,120 100.0 *DOES NOT MEAN TO INFER THAT THE LAND IS NOT USED, 1T MEANS ONLY THAT ON THIS AMOUNT OF LAND THERE ARE NO BUILDINGS. .A USED CAR LOT, FOR INSTANCE, HAS NO BUILDING BUT IS CERTAINLY BEING USED. i APPENDIX - 2 TA13LE 4 SUMMARY OF DOWNTOWN FRAME FLOOR•AREA USE USE COMMERCIAL HEAVY COMMERCIAL OFFICE INSTITUTIONAL STORAGE -VACANT (BUILDINGS) RESIDENTIAL PARKING LAND WITHOUT BUILDINGS* STREETS AND ALLEYS INDUSTRIAL TOTAL AREA % TOTAL (SQUARE FT.) 39,200 2.7 145,400 10.2 6,000 .4 39,050 2.7 17, 400.1 .2 38,100 ;_,2.7 50,600 3.5 824,850 57.8 265,000 18.6 2.700 .2 1,428,300 100.0 *INCLUDES PARK AND RAILROAD PROPERTY, AGAIN DOES NOT MEAN LAND IS NOT USED. TABLE 5 SUMMARY OF TOTAL DOWNTOWN FLOOR AREA USE USE COMMERCIAL HEAVY COMMERCIAL OFFICE INSTITUTIONAL STORAGE -VACANT RESIDENTIAL PARKING LAND WITHOUT BUILDINGS STREETS AND ALLEYS INDUSTRIAL TOTAL AREA % TOTAL SQUARE FT.) 251,050 9.5 286,650 10.8 45, 420 1.7 78,500 2.9 98,350 3.7 83,800 3.1 64,400 2.4 1,038,550 39.2 674,000 25.2 40,700 1.5 2,661,420 100.0 RATIO METHOD IN EMPLOYING THIS METHOD, THE FOLLOWING STEPS WERE TAKEN: w APPENDIX - 3 1. THE AUTOMOTIVE SAFETY FOUNDATION, AFTER EXHAUSTIVE STUDY, RECOMMENDS A RATIO OF ONE SQUARE FOOT OF PARKING TO ONE SQUARE FOOT OF PRIME DOWNTOWN COMMERCIAL USE. 2. THE ASSUMPTION IS MADE THAT FOR OFFICE AND HEAVY COMMERCIAL USES A RATIO OF ONE SQUARE FOOT OF PARKING TO TWO SQUARE FEET OF USE WOULD SUFFICE. THIS IS BECAUSE OFFICE AND HEAVY COMMERCIAL USES DO NOT HAVE AS MANY VISITORS AND ARE GENERALLY LESS INTENSIVE LAND USERS THAN REGULAR COM- MERCIAL USES. 3. THE ASSUMPTION IS MADE THAT BY SATISFYING THE ABOVE REQUIREMENTS, ALL PARKING NEEDS IN THE DOWNTOWN AREA WILL DE MET. THIS CAN BE DONE BECAUSE: THESE ARE THE PRIMARY USERS OF LAND IN THE DOWNTOWN AREA (32% OF ALL LAND IN THE CORE TAKEN AS A WHOLE) THEY GENERALLY REPRESENT USERS THAT MUST BE IN DOWNTOWN TO FUNCTION MOST EFFECTIVELY. PARKING DEMANDS OF OTHER USES ARE MINIMAL BECAUSE THEIR SPACE USE 'IS MINIMAL. IN MANY INSTANCES DEMAND OCCURS AT DIFFERENT PERIODS IN TIME (AS BETWEEN THEATRES AND OFFICES, FOR INSTANCE) AND THIS SAME SPACE COULD SATISFY TWO USES. 4. CURRENT PARKING NEED FOR CORE USES USE SQUARE FEET RATIO PARKING SQUARE FT.) COMMERCIAL 211,850 1:1 211,850 HEAVY COMMERCIAL 141,250 1:2 70,625 OFFICE 39,420 1:2 19.710 TOTAL NEED 302,185 THE BUREAU OF PUBLIC ROADS DIVISION OF RESEARCH RECOMMENDS 250 TO 300 SQUARE FEET PER CAR SPACE. APPLYING AN AVERAGE OF 275 SQUARE FEET PER SPACE TO THE TOTAL SQUARE FOOT NEED, A DEMAND OF 1,110 SPACES IS DETER- MINED. COMPARING THIS WITH AN ACTUAL COUNT OF PARKING SPACES IN THE DOWNTOWN CORE OF 381, A DEFICIT OF 729 SPACES IS NOTED. 1 AUTOMOTIVE SAFETY FOUNDATION, WHAT PARKING MEANS TO BUSINESS (WASHINGTON, D.C. THE FOUNDATION, 1955), P. 30. 2 DIVISION OF RESEARCH OF PUBLIC ROADS, PARKING GUIDE FOR CITIES (WASHINGTON, D.C. GOVERNMENT PRINTING OFFICE, 19561 P. 124. APPENDIX 4 5. BECAUSE LAND IS LESS INTENSIVELY USED IN THE FRAME, AND USES WITHIN THE FRAME ARE GETTING FARTHER AWAY FROM STILLWATER'S "100/0 CORNER", A RATIO OF ONE SQUARE FOOT OF PARKING TO TWO SQUARE FEET OF FLOOR AREA WAS ASSUMED. IN THE FRAME, THERE IS 270,450 SQUARE FEET OF FLOOR AREA THAT REQUIRES PARKING TOTAL, LESS: STREETS AND ALLEYS, LAND WITHOUT BUILDINGS, LAND ALREADY USED FOR PARKING, STORAGE - VACANT). APPLYING 275 SQUARE FEET PER PARKING SPACE TO ONE HALF THE AREA REQUIRING PARKING, A DEMAND OF 480 SPACES IS OBTAINED. COMPARING THIS WITH THE ACTUAL COUNT OF 351 SPACES IN THE FRAME AREA, A DEFICIT OF 129 SPACES IS NOTED. 6. TOTAL ESTIMATED PARKING DEMAND FOR DOWNTOWN STILLWATER IS APPROXIMATELY 850 MORE SPACES OR 234,000 MORE SQUARE FEET 7. ESTIMATED 1980 PARKING DEMAND FOR DOWNTOWN STILLWATER CURRENTLY, UNDER THE RATIO METHOD, STILLWATER NEEDS NEARLY 1600 PARKING SPACES TO SERVE A CITY POPULATION OF 8,300 PLUS AN UNDETERMINED NUMBER OF PEOPLE IN STILLWATER'S TRADING AREA. (732 EXISTING, 850 ESTIMATED ADDITIONAL). - ASSUMING THAT STILLWATER'S TRADE AREA GROWS AT THE SAME RATE AS STILLWATER., AND THAT THE CURRENT RATIO OF DOWNTOWN PARKING TO POPULATION REMAINS CONSTANT, A 1980 TOTAL PARKING DEMAND CAN BE DERIVED FROM FORECASTED POPULATION FIGURES. ALSO ASSUMES PRO- PORTIONATE INCREASE IN OTHER USES.) 1980 DEMAND UNDER "HIGH" POPULATION FORECAST INDICATES A NEED FOR 3250 SPACES. - 1980 DEMAND UNDER "LOW" POPULATION FORECAST INDICATES A NEED FOR 2760 SPACES. THIS INCLUDES TOTAL DEMAND, SO IT WOULD BE A COMBINATION OF ON AND OFF- STREET PARKING. AS PART OF THIS ANALYSIS IN DETERMINING THE PARKING REQUIREMENTS FOR STILLWATER, WE DIVIDED THE DOWNTOWN AREA INTO THE CORE AND FRAME. THIS WAS DONE IN EMPLOYING ONLY THE RATIO METHOD OF FORECASTING PARKING NEEDS. HOWEVER, BECAUSE OF THE PHYSICAL LIMITATIONS OF DOWNTOWN STILLWATER, THE RELATIVELY SHORT DISTANCE TO THE HEART OF THE AREA FROM ALL OTHER POINTS, AND THE RESULTS FROM THE OTHER METHODS USED IN FORECASTING PARKING REQUIREMENTS, THE CORE AND FRAME DIVISIONS WERE NOT USED AS A FRAMEWORK FOR PRESENTATION OF THIS REPORT. WE FELT THE ENTIRE DOWNTOWN AREA COULD BEST BE TREATED AS ONE UNIT FOR THE PURPOSE OF THIS REPORT. COMPARATIVE METHOD THE BUREAU OF PUBLIC ROADS CONDUCTED A SURVEY OF TH PARKING REQUIREMENTS OF CITIES THROUGHOUT THE NATION ON VARIOUS POPULATION GROUPS. II B^____i DD . , P . 25. APPENDIX -- 5 THEY FOUND THAT IN CITIES OF STILLWATER'S POPULATION GROUP (5,000 TO 10,4900) THERE EXISTED 797 TOTAL PARKING SPACES IN THE DOWNTOWN AREA. IN THE CITIES STUDIED, IT WAS RECOMMENDED THAT 70 ADDITIONAL PARKING SPACES DE PROVIDED, ON THE AVERAGE, TO MEET CURRENT DEMANDS. IN OTHER WORDS, THE CITIES STUDIED IN THE 5,000 TO 10,000 POPULATION CLASS REQUIRED AN AVERAGE OF 867 PARKING SPACES TO MEET CURRENT DEMAND. THIS HELPS POINT UP THE DEFICIENCY IN PARKING IN STILLWATER'S DOWNTOWN TODAY. WITH ONLY 732 SPACES AVAILAELE, STILLWATER, LAGS 135 SPACES OFF THE AVERAGE RE- QUIREMENT OF CITIES OF SIMILAR SITE. THIS REPRESENTS PARKING SPACES ONLY, AND DOES NOT HAVE ANY BEARING ON SUCH OTHER PROBLEMS AS LOCATION, ACCESSIBILITY, SIZE OF FACILITY, TYPE OF FACILITY, TRAFFIC FLOW, ETC. WHAT ABOUT FUTURE DEMANCT BY 1980 IT HAS BEEN ESTIMATED BY THE STILLWATER PLAN- NING COMMISSION THAT THE POPULATION OF STILLWATER WILL 9E AT LEAST 13,600 AND PERHAPS AS MUCH AS 16,900. THE BUREAU OF PUBLIC ROADS IN THEIR STUDY INDICATED THAT CITIES OF THIS SIZE DEMAND AROUND 1,850 PARKING SPACES IN THEIR DOWNTOWN AREAS. IN LAND ALONE, THIS WOULD REQUIRE 510,000 SQUARE FEET OF LAND OR NEARLY 12 ACRES. FUTURE DEMAND COULD ALSO BE SIMPLY VIEWED AS RATIO BETWEEN POPULATION AND PARKING SPACES. CONSIDERING THAT THE CURRENT POPULATION OF 8,300 REQUIRES 867 SPACES, A POPULATION OF 13,600 IN 1980 WOULD REQUIRE. 1,420 AND A POPULATION OF- 16,900 - 1,770. I [A il MUL 11f 11 hV I , D I a -- Z _.r�rypuN IF f y z z N A � y D U.r.I room '- E A T- MrRTLE �S7RE ET qJ�;aSia�l�i�u t CHESTNUT STRCET Y i I0 w n _ z = _ 0 L4 ,o BEET c NELSON - IIIIII011!utlCJifl!111'!I!IIII qrr STREET PARKIt4 'LIESED Oh STREET &R%1W. /''h-.(TERED A STREET YNh1Ai � EXISTING STQEE T } PARKING - DOWNTOWN CORE AND FRAME 1 Area LOTS - Auditorium Maple Island Reeds River ON STREET PARKING - Chestnut Commercial Main Myrtle Olive Second Union Water TOTALS PARKING SPACE SURVEY DEC.8,1978 THRU JAN.10, 1979 Total Empty' Spa-ces A.M. P ON. 254 518 264 240 373 133 103 191 88 424 804 380 51 92 41 44 66 22 341 538 197 83 153 70 23 34 111 221 350 129 8 19 11 13 28 15 1805 3166 1361 _ Avg. A.M. P.M. 21.2 20.3 20.0 10..2 8.6 6.8 35.3 29.2 4.3 3.2 3.7 1.8 28.4 15.2 6.9 5.4 2.1 1.2 18.4 9.9 0.7 1.0 1.2 1.4 150.4 104.7 Sw� :e.e. �••-t.•.: * Averages based on 25 time periods (except Union, Water, and Olive Streets which varied somewhat)- 12 A.M.'s - 13 P.M.'s Empty spaces refer to the number of available meters counted during the survey. PARKING METER SURVEY Friday, December 8, 1978 2:00 p.m. 5 empty spaces on Myrtle Street 3 empty spaces on Commerical Street 9 empty spaces on 2nd Street 12 empty spaces on Main Street 15 empty spaces in Maple Island L-)t 3 empty spaces in Reeds L-)t 22 empty spaces in River Lot 21 empty spaces in Auditorium L-)t 4 empty spaces on Chestnut Street 2 empty spaces on Union Alley 96 Total empty spaces Monday, December 11, 1978 9:30 a.m. 13 empty spaces in Auditorium Lot 6 empty spaces on Myrtle Street 2 empty spaces on Commercial Street 10 empty spaces on 2nd Street 36 empty spaces on Main Street 23 empty spaces in Maple Island Lot 6 empty spaces in Reeds Lot 36 empty spaces in River Lot 6 empty spaces on Chestnut Street 1 empty space in Union Alley 1 empty space on Olive Street 140 Total empty spaces Monday, December 11, 1978 2:00R_m_ 6 empty spaces 1 empty space 11 empty spaces 17 empty spaces 8 empty spaces 8 empty spaces 33 empty spaces 14 empty spaces 3 empty spaces 101 Total empty on, Myrtle Street n Commerical Street on 2nd Street on Main Street in Maple Island Lot in Reeds Lot in River Lot in Auditorium Lot on Chestnut Street spaces r -2- Monday, December 11_,_ 1978 3:30 p.m. 6 empty spaces 2 empty spaces 13 empty spaces 20 empty spaces 9 empty spaces 4 empty spaces 36 empty spaces 11 empty spaces 3 empty spaces 1 empty space 105 Total empty on Myrtle Street on Commercial Street on 2nd Street on Main Street in Maple Island Lot in Reeds Lot in River Lot in Auditorium Lot on Chestnut Street in Water Street spaces Tuesday, December 12,_1978 9:30 a.m. 7 empty spaces on Myrtle Street 5 empty spaces on Commerical Street 28 empty spaces on 2nd Street 37 empty spaces on Main Street 27 empty spaces in Maple Island Lot 15 empty spaces in Reeds Lot 39 empty spaces in River Lot 14 empty spaces in Auditorium Lot 5 empty spaces on Chestnut Street 5 empty spaces on Union Street 1 empty space on Olive Street 1 empty space on Water Street CTotal empty spaces Tuesday, December 12, 1978 3:15 p.m._ 6 empty spaces in Reeds Lot 34 empty spaces in River Lot 22 empty spaces on Main Street 8 empty spaces in Maple Island Lot 2 empty spaces on Water Street 7 empty spaces on Myrtle Street 21 empty spaces on 2nd Street 14 empty spaces in Auditorium Lot 1 empty space on Olive Street 5 empty spaces on Chestnut Street 1 empty space on Union Street 121 Total empty spaces ST I LLWA, ; C R s MI NKSOT'A LAND USE CHARACM I ST I CS GROSS POPULATION IeST1 MA'S'ES LAND DEMAV WHAT DOES STI LLWAT°ER WANT TO BE Z P THE FOR: Y HE S i I LLWA ER P6.NKWI NG AND ZONING COMMI SSI ON MWM,lI Y PLANNING &. DESI Gib ASSOCIATES INC 2635 Um VmSm AVENUE, Sr, PAUL 14 MO NNFSOTA LAND USE CHARACbT'ER 1 ST I CCS CXI STI NG LAND USE I NOT TUTI ONAL INDUSTRY CoMMERCF. SINGLE FAMILY MIULTI •f AM1 LY PARK PLAYGROUNDS STREETS RAILROADS COMMENTS PERCENTAGE Of DT.VELOPIcD LAND 6.8% 2.1% 2.3% 4a.2% 5.6% 1.2% 9.4% 32a2% 2.2% INSTITUTIONAL USES SEEM TO OCCUPY A HIGHER THAN AVERAGE PERCENTAGE OF DEVELOPED LAND AS COMPARED WITH OTHER CITIES. BEING THE COUNTY SEATS AND HAVING THE NUMBER OF CHURCHES AND SCHOOLS THAT STILLWATER HASy ALL CONTRIBUTES TO THIS PACTOR INDUSTRY AND COMMERCE ARE BOTH LOH. THE FoamcR IS BECAUSE OF THE RATHER LIMITED DEVRLOPMENT OF INDUSTRY AT THIS MOMENT. THE LATTER PERHAPS REFLECTS THE CROWDEDNESS OR LACK OF LAND IN THE CENTRAL BUSINESS AREAc IN THE SINGLE FAMILY MRSIDENTIAL USESR THERE REPRESENTS A NET OENRITY OV APPROXIMATELY FIVE DWELLING UNITS PER ACRE; IN MULTI -FAMILY USES THIRTEEN DWELLING UNITS PER ACRE. HE DENSITY SEEMS TO BE FAIRLY REASON— ABLE IN A TOWN SUCH AS STILLWATER.- PARKS AND PLAYGROUNDS INCLUDING THE 40LF COURSE TOTAL APPROXIMATELY ONE HUNDRED ACRES IN THE CITYe NOT INCLUDING THE FORTY-SIX ACRES OWNED SY STILLWATER ON THE WISCONSiN SIDE OF T"m ST. CROIX. WITH STILLWATER POSSESSING SCENIC ANC RECREATIONAL ADVANTAGES AND LACK OF EQUAL DIS— m auTTON OF PARK AND 'PLAYGROUND FACILITIESO THIS IS NOT ADEQUATE, STREETS OCCUPY 32.2% OF THE DEVELOPED ACRES. THIS 18 DEFINITELY EX- CESSiVE. THE STEEP TOPOGRAPHY HAS MADE SEVERAL PARTS OF THE CITY DIFFICULT TO SERVE WITH STREETS, THE EXCESSIVE STREET MILAGE IS UNDER- STANDABLE. m_zl LAND USE a L_KI STI NG ACRE4 4--or CI 1'V TOTAL I NSTI TUTI ONAL SS 3 INDUSTRY 20 1 COMMERCIAL 22 1 31 05 ACRES PARKING INCLUDED) SINGLE FAMILY 383 18 MULTI —FAMILY 34 1.5 "PARK 11 0.5 RECREATION (SPORTS) 90 4 ***VACANT 1,9204 53.5 *STREETS 308 13 WATER 82 3b5 RAILROAD 21 1 YO a AL 29 240 100 I14PROVED ONLY #' PARK I N WI SCONSI N a- 46 ACRES VACANT LAND ACH! FvED BY SUBTRACTING TOTAL OTHER USES FROM NSP TOTAL rOR CITY (305 SQUARr MILES) SUMMARY! DcvELOPEO AREA VACANT LAND USEABLE BLUFFS., SLOPTS AND RAVINES TOTAL DWEES_ I W U N I TS 1e1EIGHSORHOOD SINGLE N1 705 N2 416 NIS 504 N4 244 1,9869 ABOVE DOES NOT INCLUDE CDD 1,,056 15102 102 2�240 TT� 149 18' 97 19 46,5 49 4.5 100 VOTAI. 2.315 r-`TeOM A, 1950 POPULATION 0,F NEARLY 1 7' 1 % 1MAT STi LK-.f.,lT ..P HAS GROW!' ABOUT 1 +0 ABMIT ;?,,'?Cr:) ',QPDAY, F'.i:,Te:M01P.',G T,`,',2 . Litd!;4Fli': LRT'mFR fL%T0 TW1 'PLTiri12i`:p. u.Flo'i(r:'AVS i:''OR 5910 A—Nr, T IN! AP-,':e`•a'::. MA Tr'.�. L. Y l E r 000 AI € •tm ;e, t G9 : a L a0 1��1:;c)0 ��a�, �r` �� E :��. ';;., � �. a��.1��.. _.ab�� .� B 3960 OF N ARL Y 0008L ' 'tle—Alf I T 15 70DA 3' , ;, A .:a1+191 FI(a Tt-A s MA S N TA I NB I T"A CU'R Y NT NAR"' 1 ' T58`'= TOTAL WA 93�1 ,NGr?'ON COLCM "Y 1="CRC 1G1 A T I v°I . Wei, CONSIDER THE MKTROVOL I TAM PLANNING C�^epF�:l a`ii O!4-�i AEC'`'Nl' E�w� i 1 MA Te. - tKi WASHI WGTON COUNTY TO BE TV:'= MOST A"-• i A©LE AVA i 1_.ADLE a IT a AN G:- PC,.I ?4 -1 C OUT THAT TMe 1980 FORS :'OASTEIr F'%OPVLAT'!"ON �;,KGRT �J 1T L�1�oi�iE'P O.,P Z i fa;V ilGE��T POPULATION O 0JL� . Att "•! al)U STI L__WAV—v'X OF -?.AN WASHiNGTON COUN7V ''iTI L"LWAT ,i WA5f ,v'1 oGTON COUNTy 1890 zo s 0o3 1930 1940 of `3 3950 34.,544-* 7^A7411 22.' 17957 41 X95** 8, Ci00-'r ; 9 ..5 '1960 43,, 500+ 8i, 7 v-,+ 20.0 1970 "-)MU0+ l i ,� Goo++ 1980 84 0 3DQF 1950 c,�°N8Fis = ` MINNK30TA D`r";,PAATM' NT OF MRALTTUt, EST114ATES OF THE METPUPOL1 TAN PL.A1119 I NG. COMM0 351 0", +i Assume NG THAT: I , ]TI LLWA,T-50 I�1?TAI NS �CA3� IN 1niA 4M NGTd'N CfJINTY Gta•DIt4T';:, 2 o KPC ESTIMATES FOR WA N I NGTON 'C'-0r_ N T'.' AfRE THP MOST F %AL I STI C, AVAI LAl U:~ '; -4- LAND DEMAND Ac, PeRCE(ITAGC USED 12036 46,5%, VACANT 1 a 102 4(3 Wv VACANT UN)SEABLE 10_2_ Q •5E TOTAL ACRES 2s240 100.0% USEA®Le LAND VACANT 11100 ACRES 20 YEAR LAND OEMANO (IP ONLY INCREASED AT PRESENT RATE or GRowTm) RE9d OENTI AL 800 ACRES ( BASED ON: 2.8. D.0 /ACRE PRESENT: 5.5 D.U./ACRE] INSTITUTIONAL 65' ACRES INDUSTRIAL 20 ACRES C0MME1lC I AL 15 ACRES PARR/PLAY 40 ACRES STREETs 300 ACRES TWAL ACRES 1..240 EXPANDED USES? RECREATIONAL AND RELATED ACTIVITIES INDUSTRIAL EXPANSION COMMERCIAL EXPANSION - CBE) OR DECENTRALIZATION WHAT DOES STI LLWATER WANT TO BE ? STI LLWATEER IS ONE OF THS OLDEST TOWNS IN TWE STATE. AROUND THE TURN OF THE CENTURY WHEN THE LUP4BF,R INDUSTRY WAS AT i T5 fE'AM9 STILL WATER MAD APPROXIMATELY ZF000 lR!45l DENTSu IN TH'z YEARS THAT "OLL.OWE:D; A DRAMATIC, DECREASE I POPULATION 61AS ld!TNESSED. AROUND 19402 THE OFCLINE RzAcroso ITS DEPTH - i.,000 P'EOPLT a SLINGF, TFEN THI€RE HAS BEEN A h'IJDFRATs;: I NCb?EASI: TO THR PRESENT POPULATION OP' SOMEWHAT OSJI PE 8N000. 'i R 1 S 1 S DUE IN 1'AR T TO GENERAL GROWTH 0& THE TWIN CI TI f;S AREA AND IN PART TO TFX FACT THAT PERHAPS STI LLWATER HAS BEGUN TO FIND A NEW IDENTITY. SF�iil NIG NEW i NDtJSgStm AND/OR DEVI"LOP'I NG NA FURAL SC N1 C AND RECREATIONAL rACI LI TI E 5 DEF/ONSTRATEF, €-Ir ORTS STI LLWATER HAS TAKEN IN SFEARC', OP' TMI S IDENTITY. W6IAT 7NE dU'TUPE Or STI LLWATfER WILL BE DEPENDS UPON DECISIONS MADE' TODAY. STI LLWATER MAY DEVOTE ITS EFFORT ALO@tG 7"X—F ABOVE LI PBFS OR r I ND w' W REASONS FOR GROWTH. FOR CON5CI F-NTI OV$ AND ORDXALY PROG.E'aSsp IT IS IMPORTANT YOR STI LLWATER TO KNOW ITS OWN ASQETS AND fyRO3L>~14S5 AND TO DL'VELOP TH? ASSFTS AND ELIOINATE THE PROOL 19D. A GENERAL XXAMf NATION OF THESE ALTF.RNATI VE; DIRECTIONS OF GROWTH WILL OF 41ELPFUL. STI LLWA•iW S CASE AS A RF-CR ATI ONAL TOWN. StCAUSF Or NATURAL SCZNI C AND HI $TORT CAL ASSCTS. STI L.LIVATZR SHOWS GREAT POTENTIAL AL IN THE'•4 RESPF CT. tr:: ST. C`RO1 x RE of IS A FAL.ACE FOR SAIID'sRT AND PLEASURE BOATS IN TR^F SUNNER. �U'CORT SHOULD Bl; MAD?: TO HAI6 ' TI•a-" RIM t_V'e:N MOR ATTPACTlVz- FOR R'rCREATIONFL PURP'OSt:S, iO NAMr OUT A -%,wl F-SSE4TI AL STEPS.1 h . 0MIFNI NG Or THE CFANNIIL ON TRP, tl GHT BANK UND♦ Q THE I NTI".I2S"A'ETF B�^'1 DGI; WOULD PERMIT BOATS 00114G LND9,R THE Btii D(.;?' NOT TO DISTURB BER I DGIF TRAa I C 6 . 13L11 LOI NG NEW OR ENHANCING F.XI STI NQ REITAUIBAN73? AND OTI ER RrLATCZV P'AG1 LI T: I~S� > . Ri' TA i INI NG AND ":N,4Ahr--' NG L.ANDSCAF"'E :NIG Ai ONG 1X0. "Cf';N1 6 AEA AS 0,% BOT)i RIVKR BANKS f:1F°aELOP! NG OT€^.,CR ATTRACT':CJN�, IN T'47V, 0'-;'—%EA4;"N; o4O THAT T4F TRADE WI LL B YEA-R ROUND. A ---� A DORMITORY TOWN at& -,FULL ©OTl'.NTI AL IN TH1 5 REPsPFC7 F ROBADL';' ;AqN' T BE;e.N DFIl? ;LOP"'D<, Aie-i �.n TMl"v< Id .its 11R CQu%, IAYS A;Z� COlglxL�;Ti DA Tea TRA,B(EL TIMP. TWEErN 971L,L,S. AT4"IR SAND TMi C-5INTRAL Cl TI F..3 OV THE WTROVOd,l TAN cerA %ll i L BP. GREiATL';,' iRF tDUC-' D. !�R.A`?ft L.- LING TlMr MAY 6ti; RI;DIICI.D 'fO TMV VI CA N1TY 04' TWITNT'y P$1NU'PllS, As '!'�i;. ak:Ii,Dr,ii1,'r LAN 0 .ALSAI LA6Li '. I IN TKE C;Z'NT,SS`AL CI TV 0 1 H I Nd1, IMVFS. S T I LLWATER A- A 3ATS:'_1,i Tf=- TOWN :'• 0;1 HAV1 ,' NO OF TO O,'' b �'� 133Atti 1 aIN?%r:O7 HTE. SF.S'SURBc., 8FGA040il 1 T 3R -61:1 I,, RkSOURfF' O;r' VACANT.q BUtLDABL LANCI 2, RI cm MI STORI CAL BACKGROUND 3� COMR)MIINI TY I DI°NTI Tv 4 � SCENIC AND RF:CREATI OVAL FAGI LI TE ES 5. AVAILABLE UT1 LI TI FS SHOULD S'fI LLWATER DEMMI NE TO BBB A DORMITORY TOWNq THESE ASSETS 5HOU'LD Br iTRENGTHENED. STI LLWATFR AS AN INDUSTRIAL TOWN ACcORDI NG TO A NoRTHFiRN STATES POWER COMPANY SURVEYS THERE IS A NUMBER O� IMPORTANT MANUFACTURERS IN STI LLWATWER. TM K I R PRODUCTB RANGE FFOM SHOES TO OA3R'V PRODUCTS. TNEIR MARKET COVERAGE IS NATIONAL AS WELL AS REGIONAL., SOME30%OF THE T07AL EMPLOYMENT 13 ENGAGED IN MANUEACTL41I NG ACCORDING TO THE 1950 cmus. NOb9nwut,, NA$ STILLWATkR°S INDUSTRIAL POTENTIAL Ur,I-N E'ULL Y EXPLORED? HAVE THE PRESENT MOTOM AND RAIL TRANSFORTATI O94 FACI L I T! r'S IN STI LLWATER BEEN FULLY FXF'LORE07 CAN rPE Sir. CRt01 Y RI VEIZ BE AN ASSET IN SEEKING I NDU STRY7 (-Amc M1 Ssi SBI ppi NI VEit 19 REACHING ITS PEAK IN OX1 DI 81 NG THE METROPOLITAN INDUSTRIAL AND PF.S1 DF;NTI AL. WA;TF) n li THE PROXIMITY OF STI LLWATE;R TO ST. PAIL AND {III NNEAPOLI S AN ADVANTAGE OR DISADVANTAGE? .'HE MOST FUNDAMENTAL QV9STI ON O, ALL IS WHETHER STI LLWATEA WANTS ANV NEW INDUSTRY AI'TPR CONSI DELI NG ddVAT INDUSTRY MAY BRING TO STI LLWATER m- BOT'ai IN BENEFITS TS AND PROBLEMS. SUM§MARV3. THERE MAY BE OTHER ALTERNATIVE ROLES OR COMBINATIONS Or SEVERAL OF THE ABOVE ROLES STI LLWATER CAN PLAY. THE IMPORTANT THING 15 WHAT STILL%,SAT�tR GIANTS TO BE IN THE FUTURE. ST' LLWATER SHOULD THINK HARD HEPO&66'; REACPl NG A DECI `AI ONo 1THC CONSULTANT'S ROLE I$ MAINLY TO BRING ky.P THESE ALTERNATIVES AND AFI.r TO ANALY%Z EACR SO TRAT HE MAY ASSIST STI LLWATER IN REACHING THE BEST OFCI SI ONa rill w, ter i H F B H F L A C E O F M I H N E S 0 f A PARKING COMMISSION DATE: October 19, 2018 SUBJECT: Parking Study:1996 FROM: Bill Turnblad, Community Development Director The following study was completed in 1996. Sources: I ' Abe-WWY]M-uNf AIov U Iau �uu 4Z)U ow Feet City of ale, , Downtown Parking Survey Legend: Parking Commission District NParking District Boundary Public Parking Lots a Leased Public Parking Lots 80 Parking Spaces/Lot � 500 • 599 ® A00 - 499 Additional 300 - 399 Parking 200.299 Spaces 100 - 199 Needed 0-99 Parking Space Surplus Parking Survey Results rj N to C UU T Q a a E m a m <� o $` o m J y c u S E > 'n 5 a z' a. a' CL a 1 50 164 207 77 448 1015 -567 2 75 225 204 160 589 1111 -522 3 57 145 0 59 204 703 -499 4 1 64 58 17 139 163 -24 5 20 48 76 21 145 282 -137 6 0 _ 0 0 0 0 0 0 7 53 135 45 112 292 691 -399 8 14 - _M_J1 70 U2 . Total 270 1136 777 506 2419 4235 -1816 Available vs Requife4 Parking r.oa rood - AveJrhre Derlt,ng _ .. (�gt"wrR I Pat k•np 10, 4DJ n I M--- .. 0 Parking District Map Area 7L ... I ..;Naar City of Stillwater- Downtown Parking Survey (8129/96) Peikfeg District Business Name No. 1 I J Asch 413. 1 The Dock Cafe 425 Parking IBut;iness Spaces Sq Street Provided Footage E Nelson St. Brick Alley Z700 E Nelson SC 32 3,784 Parking Spaces Required 32 Parking Space Deficiency 0 1 Andiamo Boats 427 E Nelson St. 20 2,000 320 (300_)_ 1 1 SIG Packaging Technologies 201 South Main St. F 0 6,171 21 1 Seasons Tlque 2091 South Main St. 0 1,800 9 (9) 1 Apartment 211 South Main St. 0 1du 2 (2) 1 ThumbellnWs Fun Factory 21311South Main St. 0 2,227 11 01) 1 Sebastlan Joe's _ 215 South Main St. 0 2,400 12 12 1 Brines Restaurant/Bar 219 South Main St, 0 8,250 69 (69) 1 Saint Croix Outfitters Inc 223 South Main St. 0 10,000 50 50 1 Apartment 223 South Main St. 0 2du 4 4 1 Apartment 225 South Main St. 0 2du 4 4 1 Gaalaas Jewelry Stillwater Book Center 227 229 239 South Main St. 0 3,000 15 15 1 South Main St South Main St. 10 0 3.600 4du 18 B 1 Residence B 8 1 Silver Lake Restaurant � 241 South Main St. 6 3,160 26 2_0 1 Mc Garry -Kearney Agency 243 South Main St. 4 300 1 3 1 Midtown Mall 301 South Main St. 0 14,400 36 (36) 1 Noah's Ark 317 South Maln St. 0 529 3 (3) 1 Barbara Ann's Fudge Shoppe 317' South Main St. ate 1 0 566 3 3) 1 Fancy Nancy's, 317 South Main St. ste 2 0 864 _ 4 (4) 1 Busy Needle 317' South Maln St. ate 3 0 540 3 (3) 1 Daily Grind Express 317 South Main St. ste 4 0 633 3 (3)- (4) 1 Grand Games 317 ISouth Main St. ate 5 0 700 4 1 Jimmy Vees 317 South Main St- ate 8 0 300 2 (2) 1 Trumps Deluxe Bar & Grill 317 South Main St. upper 0 6,000 50 50 1 Traditions Quality Home Furnishings 321 South Main St. 0 6,000 15 05) 1 W.R Medical Electronics 321 South Main St. upper 0 6,000 ZO ZO 1 -1 1 lHarvest States Co-op Riverstdo Gallery Jem House of Blues & Cigar... 401 402 421 South Main St. SwA Main St South Main St (D?) 8 7 2 15,000 850 50 4 1 People Management Minnesota 421 South Main St (E2?) 2 1,025 3_ (1) 1 River Crossing Antiques River Valey Endodontis- 421 South Main St. (B?) 2 1,000 5 3) 1 421 South Main St. E7 1 600 2 1 1 _ Stillwater Area Chamber of Commerce 421 South Maln St. B1 2 950 3 _ 1) 1 St. Crobc Crafts & Gifts 421 South Main St. F1 2 780 4 2 1 Hope Adoption Services 421 South Main St_ste 40 (F?) 3 1.220 4 1 1 Miss Dona 421 South Main St_ ste 50 (B?j 2 900 5 ) 1 _ Sterling Interiors 421 South Main St. ate 50 (F1?) 3 1,380 7 (4 1 Stillwater Psychological Assoc. 421 South Main St.(A7?) 2 770 3 1 1 Esteben's 423 South Main St. A 14 6,431 54 (40) 1 Apartment 423 South Maln St. D1 1 1du _ 535 2 1) 1 E 4231 South Main St. E 1 2 (1) 1 McGulre Architects 4231 South Main St. E2 2 960 3 1) 0 1 Storage 423, South Main St. E2 1 700 1 1 _ Brick Alley Books 423 South Main St. R102 (A?) 3 1,160 6 (3) 1 _ Soaring Eagle 423 South Main St.(D2?) 1 621 3 2) 1 Stillwater Trolley 305 South Water St. 0 48 0 (0 1 Freight House Restaurant 305 South Water St. 33 8,000 67 (34 1 2 2 Vern's BarberlStylisl Slate Nallonal Guard Armory Peterson & Hudson LPA 228 107 116E South Water St, E Chestnut St. Chestnut St. unit 1 0 10 0 2 chairs 27,496 t,500 a 5 (6) T {b) 2 Shorty Cleaner/Launderer 121 E Chestnut St. 17 7,500 38 (21) 2 St. Croix Area United Way 200 E Chestnut St. ate 2 3 1,450 5 2 2 Firstar Bank of Minnesota 2131 E Chestnut St. 28 12,000 60 (32] 2 J. Barry Designs 221 E Chestnut St. 0 7 2 1Nearly New 2211 E Chestnut St. 0 810 4 4 Page 1 City of Stillwater - Downtown Parking Survey (8/29/96) Parking District Business Name No. Strut Parking Spaces Provided Business Sq. Footage Parking Spaces Required Parting Space Deficiency 2 2 2 2 I 2 2 Allstate Insurance 221 E Chestnut St. E Chestnut St. E Chestnut St. Chestnut St I E Chestnut SI. E Chestnut St. 0 240 1 (1) Birch Lake Imports Cameo Costumes Tailor Meld of Stillwaler Anna Lou's Hair Design R Cottage on the St. Croix 221 221 223 `E 225 229 0 0 0 I 0 0 240 425 I 900. 1 AD 1 2 5 (1) (2) (5) 2 Smitty's Barber Shop 235-1/2 E Chestnut St. 0 300 3 3) 2 Tatoos by Permanent Marks 235-1/2 E Chestnut St. 0 764 3 3 2 Gordon Iron & Metal Co 207 E Nelson St. 4 2.021 2 2 2 Katydids/stokes Jewelry 202 South Main St. 0 3,528 18 (18) 2 Your Treasure Island 204 South Main St. 0 320 _ 2 (2) 2- Past & Present A*Ues 2138 South Main St. 0 2 O�Lburne a Oold &Gems 210 South Main St. �0 1,954 10 00) 2 mttsch Giris & Toytown 214 South Main St. I '� 5i 000 25 �(24) 4 2 Dom in "Valley Crafts 216 South Main St. 0 2 Mad Capper Saloon & Eatery 224 South Main St. 2 2.484 21 (19) 2 Stillwater Antiques 226. South Main St. 0 2,300 12 (12) 2 St. Croix Antiquarian Booksellers/Coffee Shop 232: South Main St. ! 4 4.600 23 19) 2 American Gothic Antiques 236, South Main St. 0 7.400 37 2 John's Bar & Tavern 302' South Main St. 5 2,070 17 (12 2 Residence 3081 South Main St. 0 tdu 2 (2) 2 rem ay Sweet Shop 306, South Main St. 0 1,680 8 8) 2 Kelley Gallery Framing 310 South Main St. 0 2,640 13 (13) 2 Residence 312 South Main St. 0 1du 2 (2) 2 Madiba Restauraunt 312 South Main St 8 1,450 12 (4) 2 2 Ethel's Gallery Tupelo �Soulhern 324 South Main St. 1 595 3 2) 324 South Main St. 1 425 2 (1) 2 2 2 Charms Grand Theatre Rosteria 324 324 324 1 South Main St. South Main St. South: Main St. 1 1 1 1,368 111.18 1,915 7 16 (B] 18 2 Jazmine 324 South Main St. 1 857 4 (3) 2 Stillwater Chamber_ of Commerce 324 South Main St. 0 100 _ 0 0) 2 2 _ 2 Richards Wild River Smokehouse 324• South Main St. 1 636 3 (2) 324 South Main St. f 1 5,136 43 (42 Rain Clan 324 South Main St. 1 1,477 7 (6) 2 Art Decor 324 South Main St, ate 10 1 1.019 5 4) 2 BelaCosa 324 South Main St. ste 17 2 3,324 28 0j 2 Cottage 324 South Main St. ste 2 1 713 4 (3) 2 Be" McKee attorney 324 South Main St. ste 22 1 1.086 4 (3 2 D. Chell 324 South Main St. ate 24 1 292 1 0 2 Hiloo 324 South Main St. ste 27 0 100 0 f (0 2 HAF Equipment Inc 324 South Main St. Ste 290 1 1,375 5 (4 2 Macushle's Irish Shop 3241 South Main St. ste 5 1 797 4 (3) (4)- 2 lCustom Bronzeworks on the St. Croix__ Vtttorlo% Wolf Pass Gallery Second Street Store 324, South Main St. ste 9 1 1,041 5 _ 2 2 2 _ 402 402 233 South Maln St. South Main St. upper South Second St. 7 8 Q 10,230 1,000 85 5 (78) 6 (5) 2 Surya & Friends 233 South Second St. 0 1.000 5 (5 2 Andiamo Deli 301 South Second St. 0 2,000 17 (17 2 Andiamo Commissary 301 South Second St. 0 4,600 15 15 2 Andiamo Banquette Facilities 301 South Second St. 0 8.700 101 (101) Z lU S West Communications 302' South Second St. 14 12,760 39 (25) 2 Keister & Keister Insurance 2 St. Croix Valley AlanonSociety 2 1 James /Barbara Rosemilla 2 IStllwater Really _ 2 jMotorbooks International 202 206 220 South Third St. SouthThird.SL South Third St. 13 7 0 2,500 ? 480 8 2 5 7 (2) 222 South Thlyd St. 0� 500 1 2 2) 275 South Third St. 3 2.400 12 9 Page 2 City of Stillwater - Downtown Parking Survey (8/29196) Parking Business Parking Parking [Parking Spaces Sq 1 Spaces Space District Business Name_ No. Sheet LProvlded Footage Required Deficiency 2 Legal As6olance of Washington County 275 South Third St. 2 JWB Associates LTD 275 South Third St. 2 Thoemon Coen & Company LTD 275 South Third St. 2 iHarlan-Evens Inc I 2751South Third St.ste 20 1 14 1,850 6 a 2 Sharon L Buffington attny 275 South Third St.ste 20 2 Richard C likka attomey 275 South Third St.ste 20 2 j Midwest Lumber Association I 275I South Third State 30 0 I 1,400 I 5 (5) 2 People Management 275 South Third SLsie 30- 2 Eric Crandall, Attorney at Law 275 South Third Ste 205 0 600 2 2 Notde & Son 311 South Third St. 1 1,500 5 4 2 CUB Corporate Offices 421 South Third St. 60 44,000 147 8 3 Piper Jeffrey Cc 106 E Chestnut St, 14 6,766 23 9 3 _ Harvest Inn Water Music/The Blue Guitar 114 116 E Chestnut St. 3 1,600 13 (10) 3 E Chestnut St. 0 4,500 23 (23) 3 Kinsel's Liquor Store 118 E Chestnut St. 0 3,765 19 (19) 200 E Chestnut St. 20 4,000 13 7 3 Edina Really 3 FirstBank 200E Chestnut St. 23 11,500 58 3 The M Y X 220E Chestnut St. 0 1558_ 13 (13) 3 The New York Style Deri 224 E Chestnut St. 0 850 7 (7) 3 St. Croix Canis & Gifts 226 E Chesinut St. 0 7 3 European Hair Spa 228 E Chestnut St. 0 3 Extraordinary Journeys 228 1 E Chestnut St. Rm 1 0 650 2 M 3 J P Laskin Cc 308E Chestnut St. 0 900 3 3) 3 Optical Express 109 E Myrtle St. 10 2,700 14 4) 3 The Mind's Aye 221 E Myrtle St. 0 650 3 (3) 3 Loggers 2311 EMydieSt. 0 1,000 a (8] 3 EIkS Ledge NO 179 279. E Myrtle St. 0 Sp00 3 lCentral Bank 101 South Main St, - 5 8,000 40 (35j 3 Images of the Past & Present 102 South Main St. 0 1.100 6 (6)_ 3 Harold Kimmel & Associates 106i South Main St. 0 2,500 B 8) 3 The Main Cafe 108, South Main St. 0 1,500 13 (13 3 Tamarack Gallery & Framing 112, South Mein St. 1 1.300 3 (2 3 Clark J Watches 113 South Main St. 0 2,500 13 (13) 3 inter -State Lumber Co. 113 South Main St. 4 2,500 8 [8] 3 Masonic Temple 113 South Maih St. 0 6,000 0 3 Leo C. Neuman LTD. CPA 113 1 South Main St. 0 2,000 7 _ �St. PC 3 John's Home Corp. 11$ South Main St. 91 (9t) 3 David Carlsan CPA 413 South Malin St. 0 3 Silver Light Photography 116 South Maln St. 0 8W 4 (4 3 Eastern National Park and Monument Assoclatir 117 South Main St. 0 2,500 8 8 3 Lynskey Real Estate/Property 118 South Main St. 0 2,500 8 (a) 3 Lutheran Brotherhood 118• South Main St. 0 160 1 1 3 River City Antiques 119, South Main St. 0 2700 2,000 14 10 14) 3 jPetals & Primitives 124 South Main St. 0 (10) 3 Impressive Imprints 124. South Main St. ste 10 0 500 3 3) 3 _ Country Char Antiques 124 South Main St. ste 13 0 1,900 10 10) River Valley Clock Shop 0 500 3 (3) 3 124 South Main St. ste 5 3 Nelson's Card Connection 124 South Main St. ste 6 0 250 1 (1) 3 Nearly New 124 South Main St. ste 8 0 1,900 10 00) 3 St. Croix Designs 125 South Main St. 0 3.000 10 (10) 3 MR Griffin Insurance 126 South Main St.. 0 700 2 (2) 3 Jan St, Ores Dance Studio 129, South Main St. 0 2,000 7 ) 3 Diamonds on Main 129-12 South Main St. 0 600 3 3 3 Creative Art Supplies 129-12 South Main St. 0 468 2 (2) 3 Vacant (formerly Joel's Bakery) 131 South Main St. 0 5,930 30 (30) 3 Saint Croix Rexall Drug Co/Hallmark 132! South Main St. 0 5,000 25 25) 3 Stillwater Evenin Gazette _ 102 South Second St. 20 8.425 26 6) Page 3 City of Stillwater - Downtown Parking Survey (8/29/96) Parking Business Parking Parking Parking Spaces Sq. Spaces Space District Business Name No. Street Provided Footage Required Deficiency 3 Meerkats 124 South Second St. 2 T400 2 0 3 SfilWater Title 124 South Second St. 2 300 1 1 3 J R Transmission & General Repair 124 124 South Second St. 6 2,500 6 17 0 (1) 3 1 Holsten Law Office South Second St. 16 5,000 3 IThe Courier News 1261 South Second St. 0 2,000 6 (6) 3 Amsriran Legion Building 101 South Third St. 0 7;50Q, . 3 1 Traditional Healing Arts Center I 151 South Third St. 2 ` [ 1,500 3 Elert & Associates 140 South Third St. 9 4,000 13f (4) 3 Adethetica ISO South Third St. 0 0 3 Oul's Stillwater Outdoor Power Equipment 150 South Third St. 6 2,000 10 (4) _ 3 Reflections 150 South Third St. 6 1,200 6 0 4 Lumber Baron's Hotelllhe Old Br ue/Queen Vir 101 Soulh Water St. 64 163 (99) 5 Old post office Shops 220 E Myrtle St. 0 9,995 50 ($Qy 5 Mark S. Balay Jeanne Anderson & Associates Inc 226• E Myrtle St. 228 E Myrtle St. 1 1 736 1,084 2 4 1} (3 5 5 R.J. Steichen & Co. 226 E Myrtle St. 3 2,640 9 (a} 5 Oneof a IQnd Anllques 102 North Main St. 0 1,700 9 (9) i 5 F1na Gas & Convenience 103 North Main St. 6 2, 110 13 (7) 5 Jartwa Suelow & Associates F 104 North Main St. 0 1,400 5 5 Tozer Foundation Inc 104 North Main St. 0 1,400 5 5 Ranetm Law Offices 104 North Main St, 0 1,900 6 (6) 5 WiMN AM 1220 _- 104 North Main St, 0 1,000 3 (3) 5 Savories _ 108 North Main St. 0 1,800 15 5 Cat Balbu's_ 112 North Main St. 0 4,200 35 (35 5 Gabrielle 114 North Main St. 0 5 5 _Residence_ 118 North Main St. 0 2 (2) 5 Main Street Anllques 118 North Main St. 0 r2,OOO 8 (B) 5 Capiz Galleries Limited R L Schneider, dentist 120 North Main St. 126 North Main St. 0 0 g 10 i (10) 5 5 ivwall Inn 102 North Second SL 37 7,000 B5 - 5 Voyageur Press Inc 123 North Second St 0 1,400 4- 4) 5� 5 WR Medical EfecimnicCo 123 North Second St 1,400 5 (5] 7 FNe Q, aid Sprfnkiar Service 212 Commercial SL _0 0 3,212 - _ 7 Glass Service Co _ _ _ 220 Commercial St. Qi 3,000 3 (3) 7 Valiant Inc 222 Comm mlal $t 0 576 2 _ 7 Hi -Tech Signs Inc 222 Commercial V. 0 1_200 1 3 7 Larryk Floor Coverings Marathon _ 260 1^ Mulberry SL 0 3,000 15 i5} 7 Aftermarket Service 260 E Mulbwry St. 0 1.= 5 7 Moore Sales Co 260 E Mulberry St. 0 896 3 i ($} 7 Vacant 210 North Main St. 5 1,50Q 8 7 Wrap and Ship 212 North Main St. 6 1,500 8 7 Stillwater Bock and Statfonery 212, North Main SL 0 {2) 7 Valley Auto Supply_ _ Associated Eye Physicians & Surgeons Craupride Opticrens nS 21 8• North Main St. 232 North Main St. e _ 25 1,500 5,000 5,Ot1p 25 25 (17) 7 7 w _ Johnny's TV 232 North Main St, INorth 25-C. 500 3 23 7 7 _ MrAbe Point Antiques 242 Main St. 13 3,375 8 5 7 Rich's Health Shop 27CI North Main St. 6 16000 C14) 7 _ More Ardiques 304 North Main St. _ 0 850 (4} 7 Appel Associates 312 North Main St. 0 7,414 37 7 _ Communication Techrm;og312 aecturalAnliques 312 North Main St. North Main SL 0 5 3,200 1,382 17- 5 - 0 7 7 - [CO-8011daled I Wood SpedatNes ad Efeganee 316 North Main St. North Main SL 0 0 1,800 2,980 9 15 7 7 eson's Craft Connection 324 North Main St 330 NortMaln SL y 0 0 330 330 22) 2 7 nal Woodworks 360 North Main St. 0 27 13 of Enl" htenment ppe s} ��ni nr rr new e. (13) c,UW - (10) Page 4 City of Stillwater- Downtown Parking Survey (8/29/96) Parking District I Business Name No. Street Parking Spaces Provided Business Sq. Footage Parking Spaces Required Parking Space Deficiency 7 In House 370- North Main St. rear 0 2,000 10 (10 7 Chuan-Lo Martial Arts 402: North Main St. 0 7 Grafiks 402: North Main St. 0 7 7 Northern Vineyards Winery 402: North Main St. 0 3,000 15 15 7 Moffat David 402! North Main St. 0 3,000 10 10) 7 The Supreme Bean 402: North Main St. 0 1,100 9 (9) 7 Harding Design Studio 402; North Main St. 0 2,400 8 (8) 7 Hedron Inc 402 North Main St. 0 1,660 5 (5) 7 Stillwater Framing Company 402 North Main St. 0 900 5 (5) 7 Stillwaters Trading Post 402! North Mein St. 0 800 4 4) 7 Studio B 402: North Main St- 0 1,500 3 3) 7 North End Coney Island 402 North Main St. 0 100 1 0) T 7 7 7 T IGlasspectecle Hall Kelly Inc 201 Stillwater Chuan Lo MITI Antiques 402 402 402 410 410 North Main St North Maln St. North Main.Sl. NoM Main St. North Main St. 0 0 D 0 7D0 80D 18,000 4 90 (4) p 90) 7 Lonnie Loveness, Inc, 450 North Main St. 0 3,715 12 12 7 Vacant 45CI North Main St. 0 6,735 0 0 7 West Publishing Co 201 North Second St. 12 12.500 42 (30) 7 Residence 212 North Second St. 29 96du 96 (67) 7 Brian L Bunce dentist 225 North Second St. 0 864 4 (4) 7 CS Communication Specialty _ StilMster Dental Laboratories 225I North Second St. 0 800 3 (3) 7 225 North Second St. 0 360 2 (2) 7 7' 7 St Croix Recreation Company Inc R"rt*n:Afcado.(Erice . Bliss Plumbing 8 Heating 2251 225. 225 North Second St North Second St. North Second St. p :D - ;; 1 450 -211 4= p 13 (12) 7 Washington County Historical Society 602! North Main St. 0 3.400 11 (11) 8 Pappy's on the River 422! 1 E Mulbeny St. 0 1,950 16 (16) 8 Mulberry Point Yacht Club 422; E Mulberry St. 0 157siips 39 -9i 8 StilkvaterYecht Club/storage 422' E Mulberry St. 53 160s 26 27 8 StiltwaterYacht Club Sales/Rerttal 422: E Mulberry St. 10 2,000 10 0 8 StIllwaterYacht Club repair 422: 1 E Mulberry St. 5 5.000 5 0 8 8 Student Assurance Services Behavioral Health Services _ 333 333. North Main St. North Main St. 42 28 6,425 2,834 21 14 21 14 8 Datalog inc, 333• North Main St- 14 2,20p 7 7 8 Magnussen Law Finn 333• North Main St. 9 1,400 5 4 8 Stillwater Dental Clinic 3331 333 North Main St. North Main St. 23 2.340 1,361 12 5 11 q 8 The Sand Creek Group LTD 8 DDmino'g Pizza 8 Sieves Repair_ 8 The Minnesota Zephyr TOTALS 501 501 601 North Main St. North Main St. North Main St. _9_ 12 30 120 1136 2,200 1,500 7,800 18 6 86 3697 (8 24 34 2761 Page 5 .4 LIVW ter H E / I N T H r L A C a M I N N k S 0 1 A PARKING COMMISSION DATE: October 19, 2018 SUBJECT: 2010 parking inventory FROM: Bill Turnblad, Community Development Director The following inventory was completed in 2010. r %l water H F 9� N f H P l A l: ! O F h1 I H H F S 0 1 A TO: File DATE: June 20, 2006 Updated February 17, 2010 RE: Downtown Parking Inventory PREPARED BY: Bill Turnblad, Community Development Director A preliminary inventory of parking in the downtown Stillwater area has been completed. The parking spots were primarily counted from aerial photography, though some field verification also was conducted. A. Public parking lots* Lot Lot Name Dist. # Spaces" HC Notes 1 South Main Street Lot 1 102 4 Pay lot - $5, all day 2 River Lot 1 106 4 Pay lot - $3, all day 3 Chestnut Street Lot 1 36 2 Free lot — 3 hr limit 4 Bridge Lot 4 47 1 2 Free lot-4 hr limit 5 Mulberry Point Lot 4 40 2 Free lot — 4 hr limit 6 Maple Island Lot 5 69 2 Free lot — 3 hr limit 7 Water Street Lot 8 117 2 Free lot — 4 hr limit; 50 spaces reserved for River Market customers 8 Railroad Lot 6 50 2 Free lot — all day 9 North Main Street Lot 8 84 1 Free lot — all day 10 Mulberry/Second Street Lot 7 15 0 Free lot — all day 11 Municipal Parking Ramp 7 248 6 Pay lot; various rates 12 Olive/Second Street Lot 2 45 2 Free lot — 4 hr limit 13 UBC lot 2 99 4 Free lot — 4 hr limit 14 Riverview Lot (Cub) 2 158 6 Free lot (only during non - business hours) 15 Mulberry Street Lot 7 28 0 Free lot (only during non - business hours) TOTALS IL,244 39 * Unverified info from www.stillwaterparking.com ** Not including Handicapped (HQ spaces CBD Parking Inventory February 17, 2010 Page 6 of 6 CBD Parking Inventory February 17, 2010 Page 2 of 6 B. Marked on -street parking spaces (unmarked on -street parking spaces not included, i.e Water St. north of Myrtle, Third Street except between Chestnut and Myrtle, Olive between 3`d and 2nd, and Chestnut between 3`d and 2°d). Lot Lot Name Dist. # Spaces" HC Notes 1 Water St., nose -in parking, between Chestnut & Nelson Nelson St. east of Main 1 38 2 1 8 3 Main St. between Nelson & Chestnut 1 12 3 Main St. between Nelson & Chestnut 2 13 4 Nelson St. between Main and the river 1 11 5 Main St. between Chestnut & Mvrtle 3 8 6 M rtle St. between Main & Water 3 2 7 Water St. between Myrtle & Chestnut 3 5 7 Water St. between Myrtle & Chestnut 4 12 8 Main St. between Commercial & Myrtle 5 3 9 Main St. between Commercial & Mulberry 7 13 9 Main St. between Commercial & Myrtle 8 12 10 10 N. Main St. between Mulberry & Terra Springs 7 40 39 N. Main St. between Mulberry & Terra Srins 8 11 Chestnut St. between Main & 2nd 2 8 11 Chestnut St. between Main & 2n6 3 7 12 Union Street between Chestnut & Myrtle 3 18 13 2n1 St. between Chestnut & Myrtle 3 12 14 2nd St. between Myrtle & Commercial 5 8 15 Commercial St. between 2"d & Main 5 5 15 Commercial St. between 2n1 & Main 7 6 16 South Main St. between Nelson & Andiamo, west side 1 26 17 South Main St. south of Nelson, east side 1 47 2 tour busspots 18 2"d St. between Commercial & Mulberry 7 33 19 Nelson St. between Main & 2" 2 8 20 Myrtle St. between Main & 3`d 5 4 1 20 Myrtle St. between Main & 3'd 3 5 21 V St. between Chestnut & Myrtle 3 12 22 2nd St. between Chestnut & Olive 2 12 23 2nd St. between Olive & Nelson 2 16 24 Olive St. between 2"d & Main 2 17 25 Nelson Alley between 2"d & Main 2 7 TOTALS 467 1 CBD Parking Inventory February 17, 2010 Page 3 of 6 C. Unmarked on -street parking. This table represents an estimate of the number of possible parking spots based upon lineal footage of available space divided by 22 feet. Location Dist. # Spaces HC _' Notes Water St. north of Myrtle, east side 4 12 Water St. north of Myrtle, east side 8 11 Water St. north of Myrtle, west side 5 2 Water St. north of Myrtle, west side 4 8 3rd Street except between Chestnut and Myrtle, west side 2 22 3rd Street except between Chestnut and Myrtle, west side 7 15 3rd Street except between Chestnut and Myrtle, east side 3rd Street except between Chestnut and Myrtle, east side 3rd Street except between Chestnut and Myrtle, east side 2 3 7 22 7 16 Olive St between 3`d and 2nd north side 2 12 Olive St between 3`d and 2n1 south side 2 6 Chestnut St between 3`d and 2nd north side 3 8 Chestnut St between 3`d and 2nd south side 2 7 TOTAL 148 CBD Parking Inventory February 17, 2010 Page 4 of 6 D. Private (non-residential) parking lots. This category includes lots that are private and either dedicated to employees, clients, or members. Some of these may be posted to exclude general public parking. This category also includes both lots that are private but allow their retail customers to park, and lots at government buildings. Lot # Private lot name _ St. Croix Preparatory Academy parking lot Post office rear lot Dist. # Spaces* HC notes 1 7 111 9 2 NA 35 4 Associated Eye Care Block 7 66 Public allowed to use after business hours 5 Maple Island hardware store lot 8 23 6 Mills on Main retail parking (underground) 7 55 7 Desch Building south lot 8 27 Not including underground parking 8 Desch Building north lot 8 78 Not including underground parking 9 Minnesota Zephyr south lot 8 48 2 10 Minnesota Zephyr north lot 8 42 1 11 Stillwater Yacht Club 8 108 12 Old Post Office 7 8 14 Water Board lot NA 6 15 City Hall parking lot (excluding squad carspots) NA 69 1 16 Post office front lot NA 8 1 17 Victorian Building, et. al. 3 21 18 Gazette Building lot 3 39 19 Washington Federal ramp 3 37 Not including lower level 20 Reeds Building 1 6 21 Freight House lot 1 32 2 22 Stone's Restaurant 2 10 23 Cub Foods lot 2 56 2 24 Brick Alley/Commander lot 1 47 1 25 Dock Cafe lot 1 30 1 26 Old public works building NA 26 27 Vacant lot adjacent to Marx Restaurant 1 6 28 Water Street Inn 4 60 29 Historic Courthouse lot NA 31 2 30 Armory lots 2 12 31 Shor 's 2 21 32 Grumpy Steve's west lot 2 15 33 Qwest 2 11 34 Whitey's 2 8 35 Alley 2 6 TOTAL 1,158 124 * not including handicapped spaces NA for each private lot that is outside of the Downtown Parking District CBD Parking Inventory February 17, 2010 Page 5 of 6 SUMMARY This inventory finds a total of 3,107 parking spaces in the Stillwater Central Business District. This is up 252 spaces since 2006. ■ 1,925 of the spaces are available to the public (1,309 in public parking lots; 616 on -street) • 1,429 of the public spaces are free (813 free in lots;; 616 free on -street) • Therefore, 74.3% of all public parking downtown is free. • 1,182 spaces are available in private/semi-private commercial parking lots (includes 24 handicapped spaces). This does not include private residential parking spaces and parking lots. l4 O J-) G N G O O N 4J JJ ul T3 C O a w u u 0 U 1 u A i~ a +) O is c x u ro Q. O H A C W Fl jnn r r I I � LINDEN C ! 1 v r rn f m � � f � I MULBERRY I � t I I I ❑ 4� E F { re C6�'e-tr'. ALEl G I r-1 ! CHESTNUT �o _ A oI �W n 3 1i ' F N & � M , w r• y,r o %E:.SC." I kL, "`.CY f r N i 1 L 5 R f ,L I � N u iw S 5 1 1 ��TO Twin Citise (U x U x ro N (0 C C C �4 �' (a ro - I� 04 ¢' N � 4 N Q) 4J 4J U) m 0 C O w ^ W ro 1� City of tr' Ater Conununity Development DepartmenL Unmarked on -street Pariing N O +j G N G 0 0 41 CN 3 TS G 0 R, fN N N i4 O � U N f X X � N F ro F: G I I +j X X (a ro (ac a x a � + + ro N N U +J -P m U A C O O W El i To Twi-iti- k.x i i a er V. Xd r, 1` 15 & 30 Minute On-street parking spaces 1 n { fiN � 44 A` sotP F3F E"1 �9 VA 4. ' t g' S�"�T 1t� �� " •i � � �� .�,�'.1''• � phi ' � � .��'� � ,:+ 15 minute space ., �, - lti,• 30 minute space l � t FIE B r m fH►LACE 01 PARKING COMMISSION DATE: October 19, 2018 SUBJECT: 2015 car count FROM: Bill Turnblad, Community Development Director The following car count was taken in July of 2015. WE a, E c � o U 0 n M I• Ln L. !� 0 � I .N N Ln � r+ w 0 0000 rn 0 d w rn E Om N +1 C ++ \ \ N M U Ln »O •M m �• J Ln 00 N v m N v H M 0 00 G Dl a-i , CO rn r" rlti rl cr Q ri d' M n Ch N O LD M O rn C \ N p 3 T ri a I U O Ln .�0 -S rj Cr,, r- wn Ln a Lr, ^i - W a% r. am 0 00 0 N M. w rn nN --i --I In r-L "T d C* . -" zr CS , Ln a rM-I r11 ++ ti 0 r^I O U ccjX In 4T ti in - .n C' 00 Ln -r Ln Ln i� N Ln W O c ri G n rr7 N ^ ^i r+ M •� e7• n'? k-; C7 a' L.o Ln E O d 0 N N a+ U 0 _- Ln O ul 'ti3 4D Ln 0 14 WJ :^� Ln r. �o N LD c c-I i%7 rV r-I :r r`j Lin LD E_ ON n N lD C ++ p N r\I 7 T ri N U O Ln ri O1 ri Ln M '.iD r'7 co 00 ,.n ri O cr a -I 01 ri N w e N ri Q .-I .-I N r-1 '-I r-1 N ri a -I Ln KT r- N 0 N r- \o 7 ? ri C11 U 0 Ln a,T' Ln n O L11 ri Ln Ln 00 Ln m o DJ rl 'r7 o'S rn r,r rn '7 -el! r1 Ln rf 0 O1 O r1 00 N O m U Ln Ln �o M cF N r: M O O N�-ct N N w e aj ri Ln M N r; Ct N M ri M r rn DO E Lco ++ \ 0 O- 7 ? u o u 00 M cn ^ wW Ln 0 00 Ln rn 00 rn Ill r,-4 co ra cn 00 rn N ri r1 I-, rn � 0O N ri � M N 0 Q to 1-1 N ai U >. � a � a M Ex U C N M Ln w I, -0 Mo ri N m [t Ln w r, Ln Ln M O 00 c-I ri ri ri rl i r ri r-I J M 01 O O. M H 0 4- � 4-- go 0 o c l71 � Ol O Ln O Ln N LL. n Ln N O fill f H E B I H I H F L A C E O F M I N N f 5 0 1 A PARKING COMMISSION DATE: October 19, 2018 SUBJECT: 2017 parking study FROM: Bill Turnblad, Community Development Director The following study was produced in 2017 from 2016 data. l 1water THE BIRTHPLACE OF MINNESOTA TO: Downtown Parking Commission FROM: Erik Olson -Williams, Zoning Administrator/Assistant Planner DATE: May 18, 2017 RE: Downtown Parking Study Introduction & Background: City staff recently completed a survey of land uses and parking needs in the Downtown area. A similar survey was conducted in 1996, but little research has been done since. Given increasing demand for parking Downtown, this most recent study was undertaken in an effort to clarify the amount of additional parking needed and identify possible methods of increasing parking capacity. The survey uses data from 2016, so it provides a look at how parking demand has changed over the past 20 years. 1996 Parking Study: The 1996 parking study was used as a model for the 2016 survey. It utilized a detailed inventory of Downtown land uses to calculate the number of spaces required by the Zoning Ordinance for each property Downtown,. That data was then organized by parking district. The study compared the required number to the number of existing parking spaces to determine each district's parking deficit or surplus. A summarized version of the results of the 1996 survey can be found below. The complete dataset used in the 1996 study can be found in Appendix A. Parking Survey Results N' G 0 7 r Q.10 S Oi yO, ° a c} W a z a a c a a 1 50 164 207 77 "8 1015 •567 2 75 225 204 160 589 1111 -522 3 57 145 0 59 204 703 A99 4 1 64 58 17 139 163. -2.4 5 20 48 76 21 145 282 -137 6 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 7 53 135 45 112 292 691 •399 8 14 , 355_ t07_.6Q ._W2 270 352. Total 270 1136 777 506 2419 4235 -1816 Avatlable vs Regvir1ed Pafkinq 1 A.vadah:r Pa4ng.' at.�r § 4 c 7 A r"�1�f�'�1 �1�111ly1 Above: summarized results of the 1996 parking survey. Downtown Parking Study May 18, 2017 Page 2 k August 29, 1996 ,A150 0 15U 300 450 800 mmm Feet fit} of p �L Downtown Parking Survey Legend 1 aar ,ng pgmm"W DAM NPalkrg cis 16A tipm" 0 P mit Palm! Lo16 0 Lbe/9®P11W PbIkWg to" 90 Parlmg Spmxmtot 500 - 599 IN 400-499 Aqd el 3OG-399 Parking 2GO - 200 SpNes 100.1" NeedW v-99 PBrklrlg 5pdC6 Surp"m Parking Survey Results L 7 pp RR t 1 SO IG4 207 77 "0 IOIS AV' x t:. 4.1 :04 10 lr71+ o I 1 -!.27 3 57 145 0 59 2CA 7113 490 4 1 6-1 SO IT 129 163 •26 9 20 4i1 78 21 145 282 •1 i7 6 0 C C 4 Q A 4 t 53 ta4 46 1r7 m 491 '-&B 8. 14_766-1.0? 00'.4t22 a3t Vol* .77+6 1136 7i3 603419 4235 .}aW- Ay&bbn vs !mend Pa+" f� �1eu ..+red. p r • • 1 �►M ••➢ 6r6•H map A Itl a ti L Downtown Parking Study May 18, 2017 Page 3 2016 Parking Study: Over the past several months, Staff has compiled current parking data for the Downtown area, in order to create an updated version of the 1996 survey. The purpose of this updated survey is to understand parking needs downtown and to guide future expansion of the City's parking system. The 2016 study utilized the same methods and criteria as the 1996 survey, in order to create results which most directly reflect changes in the parking system. A summarized version of the results of this survey can be found below. The survey's full results can be found in Appendix B. Legend Parking Districts F-71 Parking Surplus Deficit IF 0-199 200-399 - 400-599 _ 600+ 64 ­ 36 2016 Available vs. Required Parking Parking district October, 2016 Deficit 1600 1996 2016 1400 1 -567 -630 1200 2 -522 -454 Um 1000 3 -499 -625 a Ln Soo 4 -24 -85 -2 5 -137 -271 600 Q 6 0 17 400 7 -399 3 ' 200 , ' 8 332 476 . , o 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 Total -1816 -1569 Parking District m Available 0 Required Downtown Parking Study May 18, 2017 Page 4 Parking Available Required 1996 & 2016 Available vs. Required Parking, by district District 2016 2016 1600 1 530 1160 1400 2 620 1074 CU 1200 3 198 823 a 1000 4 131 216 800 5 139 410 Y 600 6 50 33 400 III7 III ■ 200 I moll oil� 8 791 3 05 0 _.. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 Total 3866 5436 Parking District ■Available - 1996 ! Required - 1996 9 Available - 2016 a Required - 2016 Conclusions: Percent Increase, 1996-2016, by District 450 400 350 300 250 200 150 100 so 0 — - -50 Available Required M1 n2 03 84 05 06 07 08 ■Total Parking District The 2016 study shows that the total available spaces grew at a higher rate than the total required spaces between 1996 and 2016. Total available parking grew by approximately 59.8% (2,419 spaces to 3,866 spaces), while total required parking increased by only 28.3% (4,235 spaces to 5,436 spaces). This results in a decrease of 13.6% (1,816 spaces to 1,569 spaces) in the total parking deficit. Districts 6, 7, and 8 currently have a sufficient number of parking spots available, but there is still a significant deficit of available parking spaces in Districts 1, 2, and 3. District 1 has 530 of its required 1160 spaces, which puts it at only 45.7% of its required number of spaces, District 2 has 620 of 1074 (57.7%), and District 3 has 198 of 823 (24.1 %). Downtown Parking Study May 18, 2017 Page 5 Future parking facilities should be located to create maximum relief for the districts with the most significant deficit. The results of this study suggest that a new municipal parking ramp or other parking facility would be most effective if located in Districts 1, 2, or 3. ,Due to the nature of the City Zoning Ordinance's parking requirements, not all required spaces will be in demand at a given time, so it is expected that the parking deficits found in these studies are slightly exaggerated. Appendix A: City of Stillwater- Downtown Parking Survey (8/29/96) Parking { District Business Name 1 PJ Asch 1 The Dock Cafe No. I 413. 425E f�lrlfiRg Business Perking Spn¢ Sq Spaces Street Provided Footage Required E Nelson St. Brick Alley 2,700 Nelson St. 32 3.784 Parking Space Deficiency 0 1 Andlamo Boats 427 E Nelson St. 20 2,000 _32 320 (300) 1 SIG Packaging Technologies 201 South Main St. 0 6,171 21 21 1 Seasons Tlque 209 South Main St. _ 0 1,800 9 (9 1 Apartment 211 South Main St. 0 1du 2 (2) 1 Thumbelinia's Fun Factory 213 South Main St. 0 2,227 11 11) 1 Sebastian Joe's 215 South Main St. 0 2,400 12 (12 1 Brines Restaurant/Bar 219 South Main St. 0 8,250 69 (69) 1 _ Saint Croix Outfitters Inc 223 South Main St. 0 10.000 50 50 1 Apartment 223 South Main St. 0 2du 4 1 _ Apartment 225 South Main St. 0 2du 4 4 1 Gaalaas Jewelry Stillwater Book Center 227 South Main St. 0 3.000 15 (15) 1 229, South Main St 10 3.600 18 (8) (8) 1 Residence 239, South Main St. 0 4du 8 1 _ Silver Lake Restaurant 241 South Main St. 6 3,160 26 (n 1 Mc Garry-Keemey Agency 243 South Main St. 4 300 1 3 1 _ Midtown Mall 301 South Main St. 0 14,400 _ 36 36) 1 Noah's Ark T 317' South Mein St. 0 529 3 (3) 1 Barbara Ann's Fudge Shoppe 317 South Main St. ste 1 0 566 3 3) 1 Fancy Nancy's 317 South Main St. ste 2 0 864 4 4) f 1 Busy Needle 317 South Main St. ste 3 0 540 3 (3) 1 Daily Grind Express 317 317 South Main St. ste 4 0 633 _3 (3� 1 Grand Games South Main St. ste 5 0 700 4 (4 1 r1 Jimmy V_ees 317 South Main St. ste 8 0 300 _ 2 (2) 1 Trumps Deluxe Bar & Grill 317 South Main St. upper 0 6,000 50 (50) 1 Traditions Quality Home Furnishings 321 South Main St. 0 6,000 15 (15) 1 W.R Medical Electronics 321 South Main St. upper 0 6,000 20 20) 1 1 Harvest States Coop Riverside Galtery Jazzy House of Blues & Cigar ... 401 402 421 South Main St. S" Main St South Main St (07) 8 7 2 15,000 850 50 4 ({2) f 1 _ People Management Minnesota 421 South Main St (E2?) 2 1,025 3_ (1) 1 River Crossing Antiques 421 South Main St. (B?) 2 1,000 5 (3 1 1 River Valey Endodontis 421 South Main St. E7 1 600 2 1 _ Stillwater Area Chamber of Commerce 421 South Main St. 81 2 950 3 (1) 1 St. Croix Crafts & Gifts 421 South Main St.F1 2 780 4 (2) 1 Hope Adoption Services 421 South Main St_ ste 40 (F?) 3 1.220 4 (1) 1 IMiss Dona 421 South Main St. ste 50 (B?) 2 900 5 (3) 1 Sterling Interiors 421 South Main St. ate 50 F1?) 3 1,380 7 (4) 1 Stillwater Psychological Assoc. 421 South Main St.(A7?) 2 770 3 1 1 Esteben's 423, South Main St. A 14 6,431 54 (40) 1 Apartment 423 South Main St. D1 1 idu 2 1 1 E McGuire Architects 4231 South Main St. E 1 535 2 1 1 423 South Main St. E2 2 960 3 1 1 Storage 423 South Main St. E2 1 700 1 0 1 1 Brick Alley Books v Soaring Eagle 423 South Main St. R102 (A?) 3 1,160 6 (3) 423 South Main St.(D2?) 1 621 3 (2) 1 Stillwater Trolley 305 South Water St. 0 48 0 (0) 1 Freight House Restaurant 305 I South Water St. 33 8,000 67 (34) _ 1 2 2 Vern's BarberlStyllat State National Guard Armory Peterson & Hudson LPA 228 107 118 South Water St. E Chestnut St. E Chestnut St. unit 1 0 10 0. 2 choirs 27AN 1,500 a S (a) (fij 2 Shorty Cleaner/Launderer 121 E Chestnut St. 17 7,500 38 (21) 2 St, Croix Area United Way 20CI E Chestnut St. ste 2 3 1,450 5 (2 2 Firstar Bank of Minnesota 213 E Chestnut St. 26 12,000 60 Oz 2 J: Barry Designs 221 E Chestnut St. 0 ? 2 Nearly New 2211 E Chestnut St. 0 810 4 (4) Page 1 City of Stillwater - Downtown Parking Survey (8/29196) Parking District Business Name No. Street Parking Spaces Provided Business Sq. Footage Parking Spaces Required Panting Space Deficiency 2 Allstate Insurance Birch Lake Imports Cameo.Costumes Tabor Maid of Stillwater I Anna l.ou"s Hair Design R Cottage on the St. Croix 221 E Chestnut St, E Chestnut St. E Chestnut Si. Chestnut St. E Cheatn+n St. E Chestnut St. 0 240 1 (1) 2 2 2 2 2 221 221 2231E 225. 229 0 0' 0 ! 0.. 0 240 j 425 am. 1,000 1 2 I 5 (1) (2) (5) 2 Smitty's Barber Shop 235-1/2 E Chestnut St. 0 300 3 3) 2 Tatoos by Permanent Marks 235-1/2 E Chestnut St. 0 764 3 (3) 2 Gordon Iron & Metal Cc 207' E Nelson St. 4 2,021 2 2 2 Katydids/stokes Jewelry 202 South Main St. 0 3,528 is (18) 2 Your Treasure Island 204 I South Main St. 0 320 2 (2) 2 Past & Present Antiques 208 South Main St 0 2 iSherbur a's Gold & Gems 210 South Main St. �0 1.00 10 (10) 2 Kmboh Girls & Toytown 214 South Main St. j 1 5,000 25 (24) "2 Down In the Valley Cfflft 216 South Main St. 0 2 Mad Capper Saloon & Eatery 224 South Main St. 2 2,484 21 (19) 2 Stillwater Antiques 226 South Main St. 0 2,300 12 (12) 2 St. Croix Antiquarian Booksellers/Coffee Shop 232 South Main St. 4 4,600 23 (19) 2 American Gothic Antiques 236. South Main St. 0 7,400 37 (37) 2 John's Bar & Tavern 302: South Main St. 5 2,070 17 (1?)- 2 _ Residence 308i South Main St 0 1du 2 2) 2 Tremblays Sweet Shop 308, South Main St. 0 1,680 8 (8 2 Kelley Gallery Framing 3101 South Main St. 0 2,640 13 (13 2 2 Residence Madiba Restauraunt Y 312 South Main St. 0 1du 2 (2) 312 South Main St 8 1,450 12 (4) 2 2 Ethel's Gallery Tupelo 324 South Main St. 1 595 3 2) 324 South Main St. 1 425 2 (1) 2 2 2 Southem Charms Grand Theatre Rostetia 1 I 324 324 324 South Main St. South Main St. 1 South Main St, 1 1 1 1.368 1,1,18 1,915 7 16 1 2 2 Jazmine South Main St. South Main St. 1 857 4 (3 Stillwater Chamber of Commerce 100 0 (0) 2 2 2 2 Richards Wild River Smokehouse Rain Clan Art Decor 1324 _ ----0 South Main St. 1_ 1 636 5,136 3 43 (2) South Maln St. (42) South Main St. 1 1.477 7(6) South Main St. ste 10 1 1,019 5 (4) 2 BelaCosa 324 _ South Main St. ste 17 2 3,324 28 (26 2 1 Cottage 324 South Main St. ste 2 1 713 4 (3 2 Barry McKee attorney 324 South Maln St. ste 22 1 1.086 4 (3 2 D. Chell 324 South Maln St. ste 24 1 292 1 0 2 Hiloo 324 South Main St. ste 27 0 100 0 (0) 2 HAF Equipment Inc 324 South Main St. Ste 290 1 1,375 5 (4 2 2 Maeushle's Irish Shop 324 South Main St. ste 5 South Main St. ste 9_ 1 1 797 1,041 4 3) (4) Custom Bronzeworks on the St. Croix 324 5 2 2. 2 VAtorio's Wolf. Pass Gallery Second Street Store 402 402 233 South Maln St. South Main St. upper South Second St. 7 6 0 102W I 1,000 85 5 (TS) 6 (5) 2 Surya & Friends 233 South Second St. 0 1,000 5 (5) 2 Andlamo Deli 301 South Second St. 0 2,000 17 17) 2 Andiamo Commissary 301 South Second St. 0 4,600 15 15 2 Andlamo 12S ette Facilities U S West Communications 301 _ 302 South Second St. 0 8,700 101 (101 2 South Second St. 14 12,760 39 25) 2 Keister & Keister Insurance 2 St. Crogc Valley Alanon Society 2 jJamea lBarbara Rosamtlla 202 South Third St. 13 2,500 S 208 SWh Third St. 7 7 220 SoA Third St. 0 480 2 5 7 2 IStillwater Really 2221 South Third St. 0 500 2 2) 2 1 Motorbooks International 275 South Third St. 3 2,400 12 9 Page 2 City of Stillwater- Downtown Parking Survey (8/29/96) Parking District Business Name_ No. LParking s Street d Business Panting Parking Sq. Spaces Space Footage Required Deficiency 2 Legal Asslslance of Waahfngtan County 275 South Third M. . 2 JW8 Associates LTD 275 South Third St, 2 Theerson Coen & Company LTD VS. South Third St, 2 Harlan -Evans [no l 2751South Third St.ste20 14 j 1,850 I 6 ! 8 2 Sharon L Bufhngton.allny 275 South Third Si.sle 20 - 2 pRichard C Itkka attorney 275 South Third St.sta 20 2 I Midwest Lumber Association f 2751 South Third St.ste 30 I ❑ f 1,400 5 I (5) 2 Peeple Management 275 South Third St.sta 30 2 Eric Crandall, Attorney at Law 275 South Third Ste 205 0 500 2 (2) 2 Nolde & Son 311 South Third St. 1 1,500 5 4 2 CUB Corporate Offices 421 South Third St, 60 44,000 147 87) 3 Piper Jeffrey Cc 106 E Chestnut St. 14 6,766 23 9) 3 Harvest Inn Water Music/The Blue Guitar J y 114 E Chestnut St. 3 1,600 13 (10) 3 116 E Chestnut St. 0 4,500 23 23) 3 Kinselt Liquor Store 118 E Chestnut St. 0 3.765 19 19) 3 Edina Realty 200 E Chestnut St, 20 4,000 13 7 3 FlrstBank 200 E Chestnut St. 23 11,500 58 35 3 The M Y X 220 E Chestnut St. 0 1.558 13 (13) 3 The New York Style Deft 224 E Chestnut SL 0 850 7 m 3 01. Cmk Pords & Oft 226 E Chestnut St ❑ 7 3 European Hale Spa -me E Chestnut St. 0 3 Extraordinary Journeys 2M E Chestnut St. Rea 1 0 am 2 3 J P Laskin Co 308 E Chestnut St. 0 900 3 3) 3 Optical Express 109, E Myrtle St. 10 2,700 14 (4) 3 The Mind's Aye 221 E Myrtle St. 0 650 3 (3) 3 Loggers 231 EMyrtlaSt. 0 1.000 8 (a) 3 Etks Lodge No 179 V9. E My* St, 0 S,000 3 Central Bank 101 South Main St. 5 8,000 40 (36) 3 Images of the Past & Present 102 South Main St. 0 1.100 6 8 (6) 8) 3 Harold Kimmel & Associates 106; South Main St. 0 2,500 3 The Main Cafe 108 South Main St. 0 1,500 13 13 3 Tamarack Gall& Framing 112 South Main St. 1 1.300 3 (2) _ 3 Clark J Watches 113 South Main St. 0 2,500 13 03) 3 Inter -&tale Lumbef Co- 113 South Main St. 0 2,500 8 (8) 3 MasonlcTemple 113 South Main St. 0 5,000 0 3 Leo C. Neuman LTD. CPA 113 South Main St. 0 2,000 7 3 St. John's Home Corp. 113 South Main St. 0 27.1 91+ (91) 3' DavidCartsen CPA 113 South Main St: 0 3 I Silver Licht Photography I 116ISouth Main St. 0 800 4 (4) 3 Eastern National Park and Monument Assoclatic 117 South Main St. 0 2,500 8 (8) 3 Lynskey Real EstatelProperty 118 South Main St. 0 2,500 8 (8) 3 Lutheran Brotherhood 118. South Main St. 0 160 1 1 3 River City Antiques 1191 South Main St. 0 2700 14 (14 3 Petals & Primitives 124 South Main St. 0 2,000 - (10) 3 Impressive Imprints 124 South Main St. ste 10 0 500 3 3 3 _ Country Charm Antiques 124 South Main St. ste 13 0 0 1,900 10 10) 3 River Valley Clock Shop 124 South Main St, ste 5 500 3 (3) 3 Nelson's Card Connection 124 South Main St, ste 6 0 250 1 (1) 3 Nearly New 124 South Main St. ste 8 0 1,9W 10 10 St. Croix Designs 125 South Main St. 0 3,000 10 10) —3 3 M R Griffin Insurance 126 South Main St. 0 700 2 2) 3 Jan St, Ores Dance Studio 129- South Main St. 0 2,000 7 (7 Diamonds on Main 129-1/2 South Main St. 0 600 3 (3 _3 3 Creative Art Supplies 129-12 South Main St. 0 468 2 (2) 3 Vacant formerly Joel's Bakery) 131 South Main St. 0 5,930 30 (30) 3 Saint Croix Rexall Drug Co/Hallmark 132 South Main St, 0 5,000 25 25) _ 3 1 Stillwater Evenin Gazette 1 1021 South Second St. 20 8.425 26 6 Page 3 City of Stillwater - Downtown Parking Survey (8/29/96) Parking Business Parking Parking Parking Spaces Sq. Spaces Space District Business Name No. Street Provided Footage R ulred Deficiency 3 _ Meerkats 124 South Second St. 2 400 2 0 3 Stillwater Title 124 South Second St. - 2 300 1 1 3 J R Transmission & General Repair 124 South Second St. 6 2,500 6 0 3 Holsten Law Office 124 South Second St. 16 5,000 17 0) 3 ;The Courier News I 126 South Second St. T 0 2,000 g (a) 3 American Legion 501ding 101. South Third 61. D 700' 3 ITradirional Healing Arts Center 1161South Third St. 2 1,500 (6) 3 Elert & Associates ` 140 SaWh Third St. 9 4,000 -_$ 13 (4) 3 Atethouce 1150 South Third St. 0 0 3 oafs Stillwater Outdoor Power Equipment 15D SpWh Third St. 6 2,000 10 (4) 3 Reflections 150- South Third St. 6 1.200 6 0 4 Lumber Baron's HoteV_the Old Brogue/Queen Vic, 101 South Water St. 64 163 (99) 5 Old post office Shops 220, E Myrtle St. 0 9,995 50 50) 5 Mark S. Balay 2261 E Myrtle St. 1 736 2 1) 5 Jeanne Anderson & Associates Inc 226. E Myrtle St. 1 1,084 4 (3) 5 R.J. Steichen & Co. 226. E Myrtle St. 3 _ 2,640 9 (6) 5 One of a IQnd Antiques 102 North Main St. 0 1,700 9 9) 5 Fine Gas & Convenience James Buelow & Associates 103• North Main St. 6 2,610 13 fn 5 104 North Main St. 0 1,400 5 5 Tomr Foundation Inc 104 North Main St. _ 0 1,400 5 (6) 5 Ranum Law Offices 104 North Main St._ 0 1,900 6 (6) 5 WIMIN AM 1220 1�O�4NorthMain St. 0 1,000 3 ($) _5Savories 1North Maln St. 0 1,800 15 (15) Cal Bellows 1North Main St. 0 4,200 35i 5 Gabrielle 114 North Main St. 0 1,440 5 {$} 5 Residence 110 North Main St. 0 1du 2 {zj 5 Main Street Arrliques 1181 North Main St. 0 1,512 8 ($} 5 Cal* Galleries Limited 120 North Main St. 0 1,700 g (g 5 R L Schneider, dentist f� 1261 North Main St. 0 2,000 10 �a 5 Lowell Inn _ 1021 North Second St. 37 7,000 B5 (48 5 Voyageur Press Inc -123 North Second St 0 1,400 4 {) 5 WR Medical Electronic Ca 123 North Second St_ 0 1,400 5 {5 7 Fire -Guard Sprinkler Service 212CommercialSt. 0 3,212 3 7 Glass Sennce Cc, _ _ _ 220 Commercial St _ 0 3,000 3 (3) {3] 7 Valiantlnc u� 222 Commercial St 0 576 2 7- HI -Tech Signs Inc _ 222 Commercial St. 0 1,200 1 (1) 7 Lany's Floor Coverings 260 E Mulperry St, 0 3,000 15 7 _ _ Marathon Aftermarket Service Moore Sales Co 260 E Mulberry St 26D E Muth" St. 0 896 15} 7 7 Waaard 210 North Main St, 5 1,500 3 e (3) 7 pa Wrap and Ship _ 212 North Main St. 6 1.500 8 7 StN water Book and Station �y 212 North Main St. D (2) 7 Valley Auto Supply Assodafed 6 Ph iclana & Su � ��_-_ 2161 North Main St. -. - 232: North Main St. 8 25 1,900 5,000 a 25 (g) - (17 7 7 Croktslde D Iclans 232, North Main St. -25- C 5,000 500 25 0 7 Johnny'a TV 242 North Main St. , 13 3,375 3 8 23 7 Mulberry Point Antiques 270 North g _ Main St, 6 16,000 80 7 RlatNaHealth Sh Shop - 304 North Main St. � {i 7 T More Antiques Appel Associates 312 North Main St. 312 North Maln St. 0 0 850 7,414 4 37 (4) 7 7 Consolidated Communication Teehnologlea 312 North Main St. 0 3,200 11 11) 7 - fuchilecluralRntiques _ 316 North Main St. 5 0 1,382 5 0 7 H & I Wood Special;ies -- 318 North Main St 0 1,800 9 � 7 - Carved Elegance - 324 North Main St. 0 2,980 15 7 _» Thoreson'a Craft Connection 330, North Maln St. 2 7 Original Woodworks 360 North Malin St. 0 0 2 2) 7 `- 5h of Enli htenment 370 11 North Main St. 0 2,600 2 non 13 ,,, (13) , Page 4 City of Stillwater- Downtown Parking Survey (8/29/96) Parking District Business Name No. Street Parking Spaces Provided Business Sq. Footage Parking Spaces Required Parking Space Deficiency 7 In House 370 North Main St. rear 0 2,000 10 (101 7 Chuan-Lo Martial Arts 402 North Main St. 0 7 Grailiks 402 North Main St. 0 ? 7 Northern Vineyards Winery 402 North Main St. 0 3,000 1 15 (15) 7 Moffat David 402 North Main St, 0 3,000 10 (10) 7 The Supreme Bean 402 North Main St. 0 1,100 9 (9 7 Harding Design Studio 402 North Main St. 0 2.400 8 (8 7 Hedron Inc 402 North Main St. 0 1,660 5 (5) 7 Stillwater Framing Company 402: North Main St. 0 900 5 7 Stillwaters Trading Post 402' North Main St. 0 800 4 4 7I Studio B 402' North Main St. 0 1.500 3 3 7 INorth End Coney Island 402: North Main St. 0 100 1 (1) 7 7 -7 7. 7 jGlasspecta6,, Ball Kelly Inc 201 Stillwater Chuan Lo Mill Antiques 402 402 402`North 416 410 North Main St. Worth Mafn Si. Mofn St. North Main Sr- North Main St. 0 0 0- tl 700 e0D IS,= 4 90 (4) 0. 90) 7 Lonnie Loveness, Inc. 45D North Main St. 0 3,715 12 12) 7 Vacant 450I North Main St. 0 6,735 0 0 7 West Publishing Co 201 North Second SL 12 12,500 42 30 7 Residence 212 North Second St. 29 96du 96 (67) 7 Brian L Bunce dentist 225 North Second St. 0 864 4 4) 7 7 CS Communication Specialty Stillwater Dental Laboratories 225 North Second St. 0 800 3 (3) 225 North Second St. 0 360 2 (2) T 7 7 St Croix Recreation Company Inc RiveRown Arcade ❑mrce Bliss Plumbing & Healing 225 M. 225 North Second St North Second SI, North Second St. 0 0 1 450 20 4,000 2 13 (2) (72) 7 Washington County Historical Society 602: North Main St. 0 3,400 11 (11) 6 Pappy's on the River _ _ 422: E Mulbeny St, 0 1,950 16 (16) 8 Mulberry Point Yacht Club 422 E Mulberry St. 0 157slips 39 _ (39) 8 StilhwaterYacht Club/storage 422' E Mulberry St. 53 160s 26 27 8 StillwaterYacht Club Sales/Rental 422, E Mulberry St. 10 2,000 10 0 8 StillwaterYacht Club repair 422 E Mulberry St. 5 5,000 5 0 8 Student Assurance Services 333 North Main St, 42 6,425 21 21 8 Behavioral Health Services 3331 North Main St. 28 2,634 14 14 B Datalog inc, 333 North Main St, 14 2,200 7 7 8 Magnussen Law Firm 3331 North Main St. 9 1,400 5 4 8 StilMrater Dental Clinic 3331 North Main St. 23 2,340 12 11 8 The Sand Creek Group LTD 333, North Main St. 9 1,361 5 4 8 Domino's Pizza 501 North Main St. 12 2.200 18 8 Steve's Repair 501 North Main St. 30 1,500 6 24 8 IThe Minnesota Zephyr 601 North Main St. 120 7,800 86 34 TOTALS 11136 3897 (2761] Page 6 Appendix B: Parking Business No. Street Use District Name I Tin Bins 413 E Nelson St Dining The Dock 425 E Nelson St Dining Cafe 1 Mara Mi 201 South Main St Retail Life is 1 209 South Main St Retail Good Multi -Family I Apartment 211 South Main St Residential Capture I Salon & 213 South Main St Beauty Parlor Studio The Green I 215 South Main St Dining Room Brines 1 Restaurant 219 South Main St Dining /Bar Furniture & l Simonet 223 South Main St Appliance Stores Multi -Family 1 Apartment 223 South Main St Residential Multi -Family 1 Apartment 223 South Main St Residential Gaalaas I 227 South Main St Retail Jewelry I 45 229 South Main St Retail Degrees LoLo South Main I American 233 Dining St Kitchen Haf South Main I 233 Office Architects St. Multi -Family 1 Residence 239 South Main St Residential Marx I Fusion 241 South Main St Dining Bistro Midtown Furniture & I Antique 301 South Main St Appliance Mall Stores 1 Pet Store 317 South Main St Retail Parking Units (If Parking Parking Spaces Applicable Spaces Space Provided Fo Footage ) Required Deficiency 0 2700 23 (23) 32 3784 32 0 0 6171 31 (31) 0 1800 9 (9) 0 3000 1 2 (2) 0 2500 8 24 (24) 0 3300 28 (28) 0 8250 69 (69) 0 10000 25 (25) 0 3500 2 3 (3) 0 3500 2 3 (3) 0 3000 15 (15) 10 3600 18 (8) 0 1920 16 (16) 0 1920 6 (6) 0 4500 4 6 (6) 6 3160 26 (20) 0 14400 36 (36) 0 900 5 (5) Barbara 1 Ann's 317 South Main St Retail 0 500 3 (3) Fudge Shoppe Swedish 1 317 South Main St Retail 0 900 5 (5) P 1 Vacant 317 South Main St Retail/Vacant 0 1500 8 (8) Retail Basement 317 South Main St Storage 0 6800 7 (7) Storage Coffee 317 South Main St Dining 0 700 6 (6) o P SouthMein St 1 Rafters 317 Dining 0 6500 54 (54) Upper 1 Alfresco 321 South Main St Retail 0 6500 33 (33) SouthMein St 1 IdeaLink 321 Office 0 2060 7 (7) Upper Vacant South Main 321 Vacant Office 0 4440 15 (15) Office St. Upper Stillwater Farm Store South Main 1 401 Storage 0 3050 3 (3) W arehous St. e Stillwater l 401 South Main St Retail 8 2010 10 (2) Farm Store Joseph South Main 1 Wolf 402-410 Hotel 7 20000 40 40 (33) St Hotel Joseph South Main I Wolf 402-410 Dining 0 5500 23 (23) St Restaurant Brick South Main 1 Alley 421-423 Retail 10 4365 22 (12) St Retail Brick South Main 1 Alley 421-423 Storage 10 700 1 9 t Storage Brick South Main I Alley 421-423 Office 10 11542 38 (28) t Office Smalley's South Main i Carribean 421 Dining 9 4649 39 (30) St BBQ Brick Alley South Main Multi -Family I 423 9 608 l 2 8 Residentia l St. Residential St. Croix South Main l Boat & 525 Unspecified Packet Stillwater South Water t 305 Entertainment Trolley St Freight South Water 1 House 305 Dining St Restaurant Vern's South Water I Barber/Sty 228 Beauty Parlor St list District Sub - Total 1996 Total 2 Armory 107 E Chestnut St Storage Storage Armory 2 Gymnasiu 107 E Chestnut St Health Club in Armory 2 Office 107 E Chestnut St Office Space City E Chestnut St 2 118 Retail Sliquors unit 1 Shorty 2 Cleaner/La 121 E Chestnut St Laundry underer St. Croix Area E Chestnut St 2 200 Office United unit 2 Way 2 US Bank 213 E Chestnut St Bank 2 Paint Your 221 E Chestnut St Retail Own 2 Buttercrea 223 E Chestnut St Retail in Bakery 2 A'Salonna 225 E Chestnut St Beauty Parlor Office 2 227 E Chestnut St. Office Space E. Chestnut Multi -Family 2 Apartment 227 St. Residential A 2 Spacious 229 E Chestnut St Retail Place 30 2000 400 (370) 0 48 0 0 32 8000 67 (35) 0 950 2 6 (6) 173 175227 60 1160 (988) 1015 (528) 0 9000 9 (9) 0 5496 55 (55) 10 13000 43 (33) 0 1500 8 (8) 18 7500 38 (20) 3 1450 5 (2) 28 12000 60 (32) 0 1290 6 (6) 0 425 2 (2) 0 950 3 9 (9) 0 3500 12 (12) 0 2500 1 2 (2) 0 1000 5 (5) Tattoos by 2 ZBod & 235 E Chestnut St Beauty Parlor Y Piercing Teddy 2 207 E Nelson St Park Bear Park 2 Art n' Soul 202 South Main St Retail 2 Britta's 204 South Main St Retail Stillwater 2 Olive Oil 208 South Main St Retail Co. Sherburne' 2 s Gold & 210 South Main St Retail Gems Spice & South Main 2 212 Retail Tea Co. St. Loft at South Main 2 214 Private Club Studio J St. Upper South Main St 2 Studio J 214 Gallery Lower 2 Fun Sisters 216 South Main St Retail Mad Capper 2 224 South Main St Dining Saloon & Eatery South Main Multi -Family 2 Residence 224 St. Residential My Sister's 2 226 South Main St Retail Cottage St. Croix Antiquaria 2 n 232 South Main St Retail Bookseller s American 2 Gothic 236 South Main St Retail Antiques 2 Whitey's 302 South Main St Dining South Main Multi -Family 2 Residence 302 St. Residential Multi -Family 2 Residence 308 South Main St Residential Tremblays 2 Sweet 308 South Main St Retail Shop Gallery 2 3Ten Fine 310 South Main St Art Gallery Art 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 Oj 1064 31000 3528 320 825 1950 1250 5000 5000 2000 2484 2 6 0 18 2 4 10 6 42 10 10 21 0 850 1 2 0 2300 12 (6) 0 (18) (2) (4) (10) (6) (42) (9) (10) (19) (2) (12) 4 4600 23 (19) 0 7400 37 (37) 5 2070 17 (12) 0 2250 4 6 (6) 0 1500 1 2 (2) 2 1680 8 (6) 1 2640 5 (4) Multi -Family 2 Residence 312 South Main St Residential Nacho 2 312 South Main St Dining Mama's Cooks of 2 Crocus 324 South Main St Retail Hill 2 Tilted Tiki 324 South Main St Dining Design 2 324 South Main St Retail Ideation 2 Vacant 324 South Main St Vacant Retail Retail Sawdust 2 324 South Main St Retail Savvy Galeria 2 324 South Main St Gallery Saro 2 Angela 324 South Main St Beauty Parlor Rucinski NSudios 2 324 South Main St Retail Studios St 2 Lion's 324 South Main St Dining Tavern Lion's South Main 2 Tavern 324 Office St Office Vacant South Main 2 324 Vacant Retail Retail Mama's South Main 2 324 Retail Happy St Ste 10 Cooks of Crocus South Main 2 324 Storage Hill St Ste 17 Storage Sawdust South Main 2 Savvy 324 Storage St Ste 2 Storage Vacant South Main 2 324 Vacant Retail Retail St Ste 22 Thomas South Main 2 324 Office Corbett St Ste 24 Reclamati South Main 2 324 Office on St Ste 27 Advent South Main 2 324 Office Films St Ste 290 William South Main 2 324 Office White St Ste 5 Patrice South Main 2 324 Office Goetzke St Ste 9 Dave South Main 2 Magnuson 324 Office St Law Firm 0 2400 3 5 (5) 0 1450 12 (12) 0 3324 17 (17) 0 2342 20 (20) 0 797 4 (4) 0 740 4 (4) 0 525 3 (3) 0 930 2 (2) 0 353 2 6 (6) 0 770 4 (4) 0 5136 43 (43) 0 857 3 (3) 0 927 5 (5) 0 1754 9 (9) 0 100 0 (0) 0 100 0 (0) 0 1981 10 (10) 0 183 1 (1) 0 300 1 (1) 0 225 1 (1) 0 450 2 (2) 0 383 l (1) 0 1086 4 (4) Kathleen South Main 2 324 Office Feil St. CD South Main 2 Systems of 324 Office St. Paul Vacant South Main 2 324 Office Office St. Retail South Second 2 233 Retail Space St Retail South Second 2 233 Retail Space St Grand South Second 2 301 Catering Catering St Grand South Second 2 301 Dining Pizza St Grand SouthSecond 2 Banquet 301 Private Club St Hall Century South Second 2 302 Office Link St Thrivent South Third 2 202 Office Financial St Apartment South Third Multi -Family 2 202 s St. Residential St. Croix Valley South Third 2 208 Unspecified Alanon St Society James/Bar South Third 2 bara 220 Office St Rosamilia Avante South Third 2 222 Beauty Parlor Salon St Office South Third 2 Space (10 275 Office St units) South Third Multi -Family 2 Residence 311 St. Residential South Third Single -Family 2 Residence 315 St. Residential CUB & South Third 2 Leased 421 Office St Office District Sub - Total 1996 Total Vacant E. Chestnut 3 106 Office Office St. 0 313 0 418 0 750 0 1000 0 1000 0 2000 0 4600 0 8700 9 21276 13 2500 0 9000 9 3800 6 i 480 1 500 3 21 10303 4 2600 2 2 2650 l 60 44000 194 282325 29 14 6766 3 (3) 5 (5) 5 (5) 10 (10) 38 (38) 73 (73) 71 (62) 8 5 9 (9) 10 (1) 147 (87) 1074 (880) 1111 (517) 23 (9) Vacant E. Chestnut 3 114 Office Office St. Compass E. Chestnut Medical 3 Center for 116 St. Office/Clinic Healing Peterson, Hudson, & E. Chestnut 3 118 Office Potthoff, St. Unit 2 LTD Office E. Chestnut 3 118 Office Space St. Unit 3 Office E. Chestnut 3 200 Office Space St. E. Chestnut 3 Restaurant 200 St.Dining Retail E. Chestnut 3 200 Retail Space St. E. Chestnut 3 Enchante 220 Retail Apartment E. Chestnut Multi -Family 3 222 s St. Residential Urban E. Chestnut 3 226 Retail Violet St. Office E. Chestnut 3 226 Office Space St. Four E. Chestnut 3 Office 228 Office St. Rm. 1 Spaces E. Chestnut Multi -Family 3 Apartment 308 St. Upper Residential The E. Chestnut 3 Wedge 308 Retail St and Wheel Office 3 109 E. Myrtle St. Office Space Office 3 221 E. Myrtle St. Office Space No -Neck 3 231 E. Myrtle St. Dining Tony's Office 3 279 E. Myrtle St. Office Space Stillwater South Main 3 101 Retail Antiques St. Black South Main 3 Letter 102 Retail Books St. Croix South Main 3 Home 106 Office St Loans 3 1600 5 (2) 0 4500 23 (23) 0 1882 6 (6) 0 1882 6 (6) 20 9525 32 (12) 23 4250 35 (12) 0 4250 21 (21) 0 2408 12 (12) 0 1825 2 3 (3) 0 850 4 (4) 0 850 3 (3) 0 4000 13 (13) 0 1000 1 2 (2) 0 1000 5 (5) 10 2700 9 1 0 1500 5 (5) 0 1000 8 (8) 0 5000 17 (17) 5 8000 40 (35) 0 1100 6 (6) 0 2500 8 (8) The Main South Main 3 108 Dining Cafe St. Apartment South Main Multi -Family 3 110 s St. Residential Tamarack South Main 3 Gallery & 112 Gallery t Framing Retail South Main 3 113 Retail Space St. Office South Main 3 113 Office Space St. Masonic South Main 3 113 Private Club Temple St Quickfirc South Main 3 116 Dining Pizza St. Lynskey Real South Main 3 118 Office Estate Pro St. perty Lutheran South Main 3 Brotherho 118 Office t od SoutStMain 3 Kids Oasis 120 Retail Gammy & South Main 3 124 Retail Gumpy's St. Cherry South Main 3 125 Dining Berry St. South Main Multi -Family 3 Apartment 125 St. Upper Residential T-Shirt South Main 3 126 Retail Factory St. Kathe South Main 3 129 Retail Wohlfahrt St. Boutique South Main 3 Collaborat 129-1/2 Retail t ions Creative South Main 3 Art 129-1/2 Retail Supplies t Leo's Malt South Main 3 131 Dining Shop St. SoutStMain 3 Ziggy's 132 Dining Gazette South Second 3 102 Office Building St. SouthS�econd 3 Domacin 102 Dining 0 1500 13 (13) 5 8600 2 3 2 1 1300 3 (2) 0 9500 48 (48) 0 9500 32 (32) 0 9500 32 (32) 0 800 7 (7) 0 2500 8 (8) 0 160 l (1) 0 3500 18 (18) 0 3500 18 (18) 0 3000 25 (25) 0 3050 1 2 (2) 0 2400 12 (12) 0 2000 10 (10) 0 2400 12 (12) 0 468 2 (2) 0 5930 49 (49) 0 5000 42 (42) 10 5550 19 (9) 10 3200 27 (17) Craft South Second 3 124 Dining 14 8200 68 (54) Distillery St. American South Third 3 Legion 101 Dining 2 7500 63 (61) St Building Apartment South Third Multi -Family 3 101 2 2500 2 3 (1) s St. Upper Residential Elert & South Third 3 140 Office 10 4000 13 (3) Associates St. Del's Stillwater South Third 3 Outdoor 150 Office 7 2000 7 0 St Power Equipment Reflection South 3 150 Office 7 1200 4 3 s t District Sub- 143 177146 8 823 (680) Total 1996 703 (499) Total Charlie's South Water 4 101 Dining 32 21000 175 (143) Pub St. Water South Water 4 101 Hotel 32 29000 41 41 (9) Street Inn St. District Sub- 64 50000 41 216 (152) Total 1996 163 (7) Total 5 Gartner 220 E. Myrtle St. Office 8 9995 33 (25) Studio Mark S. 5 226 E. Myrtle St. Office t 736 2 (1) Balay Jeanne Anderson 5 & 226 E. Myrtle St. Office 1 1084 4 (3) Associates Inc. R.J. 5 Steichen & 226 E. Myrtle St. Office 0 2640 9 (9) Co. Forget Me North Main 5 102 Retail 0 1700 9 (9) Not St. Gulf Gas North Main 5 103 Service Station 21 2125 13 8 Station St. James North Main 5 Buelow & 104 Office St Associates Tozer North Main 5 Foundatio 104 Office St n Inc. Ranum North Main 5 Law 104 Office St Offices WIMN North Main 5 104 Office AM 1220 St. Osaka North Main 5 108 Dining Sushi St. North Main 5 Pub 112 112 Dining Pub 112 North Main 5 Event 112 Private Club St Space Purefex North Main 5 114 Beauty Parlor Salon St. North Main Multi -Family 5 Apartment 114 St. Upper Residential North Main Multi -Family 5 Residence 118 St. Upper Residential River North Main 5 118 Retail Jeans St. North Main Multi -Family 5 Residence 118 1/2 St. Upper Residential Capiz North Main 5 Galleries 120 Retail St Limited Camy North Main 5 124 Retail Couture St. North Main Multi -Family 5 Residence 126 St. Upper Residential Modernro North Main 5 126 Retail ots St. NorthSt. Second 5 Lowell Inn 102 Hotel Lowell Inn North Second 5 102 Dining Restaurant St. J Event North Second 5 123 Private Club Center St. JX Event North Second 5 123 Office Center St. 5 JX Event 123 North Second Dining Center St. JX Event North Second 5 123 Storage g Center St. 0 1400 5 (5) 0 1400 5 (5) 0 1900 6 (6) 0 1000 3 (3) 0 1800 15 (15) 0 4200 35 (35) 0 4200 35 (35) 0 1440 6 18 (18) 0 2150 1 2 (2) 0 1500 1 2 (2) 0 1512 8 (8) 0 1700 1 2 (2) 0 1700 9 (9) 0 500 3 (3) 0 1600 3 5 (5) 0 2000 10 (10) 0 16000 35 35 (35) 0 7000 29 (29) 0 14000 5 (5) 0 14000 47 (47) 0 7000 58 (58) 0 7000 7 (7) District Sub- 31 113282 47 410 (379) Total 1996 282 (137) Total 6 PD Dining 0 4000 33 (33) Pappy's District Sub- 0 4000 33 (33) Total 1996 0 0 0 0 Total Larry's Furniture & Commercial 7 Floor 212 Appliance 0 3212 8 (8) St Coverings Stores Ce Commercial 7 220 Manufacturing 0 2675 8 (8) Press General Commercial 7 Construed 222 Office 0 576 2 (2) St on Inc. Healthier Commercial 7 with 222 Office 0 1200 4 (4) t Heather Let There North Main 7 204 Retail 1 1550 8 (7) Be Light St. NortStMain 7 Candyland 212 Retail 3 1500 8 (5) Office NorthMainOffice 7 212 3 1500 5 (2) Space Valley North Main 7 217 Retail 0 1950 10 (10) Bookseller St. Barber North Main 7 218 Beauty Parlor 4 2200 1 3 1 Shop St. Images of North Main 7 218 Gallery 4 5000 10 (6) the Past St. Merrill North Main 7 219 Office 0 7600 25 (25) Lynch St. River North Main 7 221 Retail 0 7875 39 (39) Market St. River North Main 7 Market 221 Office 0 7875 26 (26) t Office Northern North Main 7 223 Dining 4 3075 26 (22) Vineyards St. Maple North Main 7 Island 225 Dining 31 6625 55 (24) St Brewing Office North Main 7 232 Office 25 5500 18 7 S ace P St. Johnny's North Main 7 242 Retail 13 3375 17 (4) TV St. 7 Morgan 270 North Main Office 5 8000 27 (22) Stanley St. Bluestone North Main 7 Physician 270 Office 5 8000 27 (22) t Services Stillwater 7 Mills 350 North Main Office 75 23000 77 (2) Commerci St. al Stillwater Mills North Main Multi -Family 7 350 262 52275 98 l47 115 Residentia 1 St. Residential Staples North Main 7 402 Retail 0 25600 128 (128) Mill Retail St. Staples North Main 7 Mill 402 Office 0 25600 85 (85) St Office Mill North Main 7 410 Retail 0 18000 90 (90) Antiques St. Ofce NorthMainOffice 7 450 0 12000 40 (40) Pace 7 Office 201 North Second Office 12 12500 42 (30) Pace North Second Multi -Family 7 Residence 212 29 92400 96 144 (115) St. Residential Office North Second 7 217 Office 0 1975 7 (7) Space Brian L. North Second Medical 7 Bunce 225 0 864 4 (4) St. Office/Clinic dentist Office North Second 7 225 Office 0 5630 19 (19) Sp ace St. Washingto n County North Main Museum/Galle 7 602 6 3400 11 (5) Historical St. ry Society 610 Terra North Main 7 Springs 610 Office 86 6788 23 63 St Office 610 Terra Springs North Main Multi -Family 7 6l0 85 32300 14 21 64 Residentia I St. Residential 620 Terra North Main Multi -Family 7 620 85 71900 42 63 22 Springs St. Residential 630 Terra North Main Multi -Family 7 630 85 287600 46 69 16 Springs St. Residential 640 Terra North Main Multi -Family 7 640 85 69000 36 54 31 Springs St. Residential 650 Terra North Main Multi -Family 7 650 85 345000 37 56 30 Springs St. Residential District Sub- 993 1165120 370 1404 (411) Total 1996 691 (398) Total 8 Pappy's on 422 E. Mulberry Dining 0 1950 16 (16) the River St. Mulberry 8 Point 422 E. Mulberry Marina 0 157 52 (52) Yacht St. Club Stillwater 9 Yacht 422 E. Mulberry Marina 53 160 53 (0) Club/stora St. ge Stillwater Yacht E. Mulberry 8 Club 422 Office 10 2000 7 3 St Sales/Rent al Stillwater Service & Yacht E. Mulberry 8 422 Maintenance 5 3500 1 1 4 Club St. Center repair Office North Main 8 333 Office 106 6425 21 85 SpaceSt North Main Multi -Family 8 The Lofts 501 132 66 99 33 St. Residential NorthtMain 8 Vacant 601 Dining 120 7800 65 34 District Sub- 426 22058 1 315 90 Total 1996 270 332 Total GRAN D 1598 1963100 5088 (3490) TOTAL S 1996 TOTAL 4235 (1776) S _F� 1 K P`p0e0<Pat #1# Lot 12 Lot 10 �p Lot 13 St w all �hetnut $t Lot 14 pktua St Lot . 11 IV Lot Lot 6 5 Nctson �`11eY $ t Tyelsdn Lot 1 $ate %, Lot cP 4 pine 5t ate Public Parking Lots Downtown Stillwater 2019 Legend City Parking Lot City Parking Ramp Permit parking ONLY r Trailhead Parking ® Crosby Ramp - 2nd St level public Private parking until 6 PM - Bus, RV, Trailers Bus loading/unloading - Bus parking Lots where Monthly Permits are Valid Business Permit Valid* DT Resident Permit Valid ** I * Allows vehicle in lot longer than the posted limit (but not overnight) ** Allows Downtown Resident to park overnight Free parking lot (year round) Pay parking lot (Free Nov 1 -Apr 30) J Lot available to public after office hours Public restroom ® Numbers in circles = hour limits for free parking lots On -street parking is tree, but limited to three hours unless posted for less Downtown Parking Commission April 2019 Pioneer 9301 1® 9 I 0 Lot 12 '.1 Lot 11 l' Lot 1 D *71 6b Lot 9 d F _ 1 Lot Sa lilt 7 Loc tl A� Lot 5 1 � m F of pp 4 J4 �1 1 Lot f $ � J \2. Mto ou"51 1��11 s1 �,���• 1 K°le°r' \ l 1t ddY Bear ParK �. ��r Lot �e _ Lot 15 111111 , ie lllll' r ti ,11111111j1- -- . t 't . r11U1`Yr®: Lot 17 r'1 ` 1 (SjIlwat.ceir �- a 9,M".n- o• m N w I %o Public Parking Downtown Stillwater 2019 Legend Downtown Parking District City Parking Lot - City Parking Ramp Y Public - upper level (Crosby Hotel) Trailhead Parking (Lot 12) O J Private parking only (Lot 8a) Permit parking only (Lot 12) Trailers & large vehicles (Lot 12) - On -street handicapped 15 minute parking limit - 30 minute parking limit Y a _ Valet Loading/unloading - Bus loading/unloading - Bus parking Monthly Permits cc > * Business Permit Valid m E * DT Resident Permit Valid (allows overnight parking) >1 0 Free parking (year round) m a Pay parking (free Nov1-Apr 30) 0 Free after office hours LL Numbers in circles = hour limits on free parking Lot 1 (pay lot)(free Nov 1 - Apr 30) - 98 spaces Lot 2 (pay lot)(free Nov 1 - Apr 30) - 84 spaces Lot 3 (free lot - 3 hr) -- 33 spaces Lot 4 (free lot - 4 hr) -- 29 spaces Lot 5 (free lot - 4 hr) -- 7 spaces Lot 6 (free lot - 3 hr) -- 16 spaces Lot 7 (free lot - 3 hr) -- 16 spaces Lot 8a ("private" *) -- 51 spaces Lot 8b (free lot - 4 hr) - 75 spaces Lot 9 (free lot - 4 hr) -- 30 spaces Lot 10 (free all day; overnight by permit) - 48 spaces iLot 11 (free all day; overnight by permit) - 45 spaces Lot 12 (part free all day; no overnight here) - 78 spaces (part permit only; overnight allowed here) - 23 spaces Lot 13 (free lot - 4 hr) - 13 spaces Lot 14 (free lot - 4 hr) - 47 spaces Lot 15 (free lot - 4 hr) - 97 spaces Lot 16 (free after hrs) - 60 spaces Lot 17 (free after hrs) - 75 spaces Lot 18 (free lot - 24 hr) - 22 spaces Public Ramp (pay) -- 248 spaces Public level, Crosby (pay) 52 spaces J * Free public lot after 6 PM 1,247 off-street parking spaces: 1,206 general public 41 handicapped spaces 468 marked on -street spaces: 416 general public 18 handicapped spaces 14 15 minute spaces 7 30 minute spaces 19 Loading spaces 239 unmarked on -street spaces (Includes 91 on 2nd St no, of Mulberry) 1,954 total public spaces 1,451 free public spaces (74,3 % ) Map W d.Ccd By ;gnvnurM•Y Da ek,4_n I flap; lu Qan+'daNn Purr<Ing Comn.�ssvn April 1, 2019 T 36 46 36 42 13 � 5 P�Oneet patK Cl 1 Lot f 66 6 1 ' �2 Lot tvliil`� c`Y`• _ 8 E] Lot \ r 13 Lot 1 Lot 8a 14 5 Lot 10 E l Lot 7 �. . 5 CpA' Lot 6V, , 4 O Lnt _ 3 d Lot 16 Lot 2 o1�ye 5�13 Lot iI INater N Residential Parking Downtown District Downtown Residential Units On -site parking? Yes No Number of units noted on map City Parking Lot . City Parking Ramp Private parking ONLY * Overnight permits available 15 minute parking limit .30 minute parking limit - Loading/unloading Bus loading/unloading - Bus parking On -street handicapped Free parking Pay parking O Free parking after office hours Lot 1 (hourly) -- 98 spaces Lot 2 (hourly) -- 84 spaces Lot 3 (hourly) -- 33 spaces Lot 4 (hourly) -- 29 spaces Lot 5 (hourly) -- 7 spaces Lot 6 (hourly) -- 16 spaces Lot 7 (hourly) -- 16 spaces Lot 8a ("private") - 51 spaces Lot 8b (hourly) -- 75 spaces Lot 9 (hourly) -- 30 spaces Lot 10 (hourly) -- 48 spaces Lot 11 (hourly) -- 45 spaces Lot 12 (24 hr) -- 101 spaces Lot 13 (3 hr) -- 23 spaces Lot 14 (24 hr) -- 8 spaces Lot 15 (4 hr) -- 13 spaces Lot 16 (4 hr) -- 47 spaces Lot 17 (4 hr) -- 97 spaces Lot 18 -- 60 spaces Lot 19 -- 75 spaces Lot 20 (24 hr) -- 22 spaces Ramp (hourly) - 248 spaces Total = 1,226 spaces 468 marked on -street parking spaces 148 unmarked on -street parking spaces 1,842 total public spaces 1,412 free spaces 76.7% of spaces free 1 Lot `Te�yy:Beat Pa 17 Lot18 2 0. Lot St r 1 1 1 of 19 Map Produced 1, Stillwater Parking Commission 11/4/14 Draft I Discussion Draft r r r- .0 Ilwater Lot 10 , Lot 11 Residential Parking Downtown Core 98 - � ram, � � � Downtown Residential Units On -site parking? Yes �D - No } St s 1 8b Number of units noted on map ` Lot — ' 9 City Parking Lot 1 ' - City Parking Ramp Lot 0 Private parking ONLY 13 Lot * Overnight permits available 8a -- Lot f' 15 minute parking limit 1 I 14 1 .30 minute parking limit Loading/unloading 1. Lot 7 . Bus loading/unloading . Bus parking .On -street handicapped Free parking Pay parking +� 0 Free parking y ^ after office hours Lot 1 (hourly) -- 98 spaces Lot 6 1 Lot 2 (hourly) -- 84 spaces Lot 3 (hourly) -- 33 spaces l Lot 4 (hourly) -- 29 spaces lti Lot 5 (hourly) -- 7 spaces t p Lot 6 (hourly) -- 16 spaces !Z Lot 7 (hourly) -- 16 spaces 1 = �' Lot 8a ("private") - 51 spaces Lot 8b (hourly) -- 75 spaces 0 Lot 9 (hourly) -- 30 spaces - iiLot < Lot 10 (hourly) -- 48 spaces 4 Lot 11 (hourly) -- 45 spaces MyA_ f Lot 12 (24 hr) -- 101 spaces Lot 13 (3 hr) -- 23 spaces . " Lot 14 (24 hr) -- 8 spaces y Lot 15 (4 hr) -- 13 spaces Lot 16 (4 hr) -- 47 spaces Lot 17 (4 hr) -- 97 spaces ` Lot 18 -- 60 spaces Lot 19 -- 75 spaces Lot 20 (24 hr) -- 22 spaces Ramp (hourly) - 248 spaces ! 1 1 Total = 1,226 spaces ' �_r 468 marked on -street parking spaces tst . - 148 unmarked on -street parking spaces Lot 1,842 total public spaces 3 1,412 free spaces 1 76.7% of spaces free j y 1 r Map produced by 1 Stillwater Parking Commission . '1 1 L 'I1/9/t_ - Lot 16 �1 l fit'1 Lot 2 AA 13 1 eddy � Lot ' � 17 �_ Discussion Draft Lot 1 3646 l1 ct 36 er Y ►' l 42 Municipal Parking 13 Downtown Stillwater Proposed for 2015 Legend P\ooeel patK Lo 12 City Parking Lot City Parking Ramp ® Private parking ONLY ® Trailhead Parking 16 66 Monthly permits 1 `* Day use permit * 24/7 DT resident permit r 15 minute parking limit 30 minute parking limit 4� Loading/unloading a Bus loading/unloading Lot 10 - Bus parking l - On -street handicapped - Lot 11 Downtown Residential Units \ 1 On -site parking? Q \ • _ f� Yes _— - - No i Lot Y Number of units in black �S - ~ Lot ® Parking Mitigation j 9 i Lot 1 Number of spaces in blue ' \ — - ` \ 13 18 Lot Free parking Lot 8a y Pay parking ' 14 , 6 , O Free parking ' 96 `y Lot 7 — after office hours ' Approved, — '1 \ not yet built. Lot 1 (pay lot) -- 98 spaces Lot Lot 2 (pay lot) -- 84 spaces Lot 3 (pay lot) -- 33 spaces 5 Lot 6 �'� '[ Lot 4 (pay lot) 29 spaces Lot 5 (pay lot) 7 spaces Lot 6 (pay lot) -- 16 spaces Lot 7 (pay lot) -- 16 spaces Lot 15 Lot 8a ("private")_ 51 spaces Lot 8b (pay lot) 75 spaces My��eSt • p 0� Lot 9 (pay lot) -- 30 spaces ro fly 4 �A Lot 10 (pay lot) -- 48 spaces r 1 6 Lot 11 (pay lot) -- 45 spaces + 0� �: Lot 12 (free - 24 hr) -- 101 spaces `. Lot 13 (free - 3 hr) -- 23 spaces I'A 2 l �•, r Lot 14 (free - 24 hr) -- 8 spaces Lot 15 (free - 4 hr) -- 13 spaces Lot 16 (free - 4 hr) -- 47 spaces 0G Lot 17 (free - 4 hr) -- 97 spaces Lot _ � Lot 18 -- 60 spaces 3 ': - `, Lot 19 -- 75 spaces ti _ _ d Lot 20 (free - 24 hr) -- 22 spaces 10 Ramp (pay lot) -- 248 spaces Lot 16 Lot Total = 1,226 spaces 1 Q"eVy 468 marked on -street parking spaces 0 1 148 unmarked on -street parking spaces 1,842 total public spaces r,� 1,412 free spaces 13 �--} \76.7% of spaces free 90hvRm p n pm�eb by 4 Lot $j y � ge tL°t Discussion Draft jk\,"Lot 18 Lot 20 l` �n � 1 • Pyre st-- ��u Lot- 19