Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout2001-12-03 HPC Packet• • i I .1 twat i{AM2.�YveyL ;::fY�`r' and THE BIRTHPLACE OF MINNESOTA HERITAGE PRESERVATION COMMISSION HERITAGE PRESERVATION MEETING NOTICE THE STILLWATER HERITAGE PRESERVATION COMMISSION WILL MEET MONDAY, DECEMBER 3, 2001 700PM CITY COUNCIL CHAMBERS CITY HALL 216 NORTH FOURTH STREET AGENDA Approval of November 5, 2001 minutes 1 Case No DR/01-41 Design review of building addition and signage for Bethany Evangelical Covenant Church at 6490 Stillwater Blvd Bruce Caulfield — Busch Caulfield Architects, Inc , representing applicant 2 Case No DR/01-42 Design review of an awning for McGarry -Kearney Agency, Inc and Marx Cafe located at 243 South Main Street Monica and Rob McGarry, applicants 3 Case No DR/01-43 Design review of extenor modifications for the old "Gazette" building located at 102 South Second Street Mark Balay- Balay Architects, representing applicant 4 Case No DR/01-44 Design review of signage for St Croix Vision located in the River Heights Mall Chnstopher Leaf — Sign -A -Rama, representing applicant 5 Case No DR/01-45 Design review of signage for Firstar US Bank Loren Lorenzen — Universal Sign, representing applicant 6 Case DR/01-46 Design review of roof top unit for WR Medical Electronics Co located at 123 North Second Street Jeanne Anderson, applicant Other items a Discussion of Temtonal Pnson Plans b Review of Public Works Building (tabled at 11/5/01 meeting) c "Christmas Party" CITY HALL 216 NORTH FOURTH STILLWATER MINNESOTA 55082 PHONE 651-430-8800 4 • • • City of Stillwater Hentage Preservation Commission November 5, 2001 Present Howard Lieberman, Chairperson, Beth Diem, Diane Hark, Jeff Johnson, Brent Peterson and Roger Tomten Others Planner Sue Fitzgerald Absent Phil Eastwood Mr Lieberman called the meeting to order at 7 p m Approval of minutes Mr Johnson, seconded by Ms Hark, moved approval of the minutes of Oct 1, 2001, as presented, motion passed unanimously Case No PUD/DR/01-27 Design review of Public Works building located on Boutwell Avenue North Wayne Branum representing SALA Architects Inc Wayne Branum was present He noted the intent of the design is to reflect an agnculture/lumbenng vernacular Public meetings were held to alleviate concerns about the building's location in a residential area The design fits the character of the area and neighborhood, he said, noting that a lot of landscaping is involved He stated that not much has deviated from the onginal design plans The major change is in the roofing materials, which now will be asphalt shingles rather than metal, as onginally planned Because revised plans were not available for members after initial discussion, it was decided to table the discussion until the December meeting when current plans would be available Members pointed out that the HPC is interested in matenals, landscaping, lighting and signage plans, and equipment locations Mr Lieberman made the potion to table the case Mr Tomten seconded the motion, motion passed unanimously Case No V/DR/01-37 Design review of extenor modifications at 214 S Main St Mark Balay representing Lynskey Properties Mr Balay provided samples of the proposed wood siding and colors, terra cotta for one store front and green shades for the other The tnm work would remain black, he said The main concern expressed was the location of the sign band Mr Tomten asked about the possibility of using the old sign band Mr Balay noted the columns stop below the old sign band and would have to come up to hit beneath an 8 inch roof Mr Balay also noted that the request does not include the Kmitsch Girls sign While not ideal, members noted the proposal doesn't do anything detnmental to the integrity of the building to allow for future restoration efforts Mr Johnson moved approval as submitted, including the matenals and colors, with the Kmitsch Girls sign to come back before the HPC and 1 0 • • • City of Stillwater Hentage Preservation Commission November 5, 2001 any window replacements to come back before the HPC Mr Tomten seconded the motion, motion passed unanimously Mr Balay asked if any Commission member would be willing to work with a promotional article on the restored street clock at Let There Be Light Mr Lieberman volunteered Case No DR/01-38 Design review of signage for Jiffy Lube at 1274 Market Dr Bruce Cardinal, Arrow Sign Co representing Commers Automotive II Ltd Present were Bruce Cardinal and Jim Schathauser Mr Johnson and Mr Tomten both expressed a concern about the proposed 4' height of the lettenng Mr Tomten noted at 4 feet, there is not enough room to get all the signage on the bnck and the signage overlaps the transition of the building Mr Johnson asked if there was any height restnction for signage along County Road 5 Ms Fitzgerald noted in the Marketplace development there is a 2 foot height restriction, existing signs outside Marketplace are 3 feet, Ms Fitzgerald also pointed out that Ace Hardware got a vanance for the size of the letter A Mr Johnson moved to approve the request as submitted and conditioned with the additional condition that the lettenng not exceed 36 inches in height on both the front and rear elevations and that the total square footage not exceed the allowable square footage according to ordinance Mr Peterson seconded the motion, motion passed unanimously Case No V/DR/01-52 Revised design review of retail/residential building located at 501 N Main Street Jeff Wallis, applicant Present were Jeff Wallis, architect William Prach and Jeffrey McDonnell of Landform The major revisions include the additional of retail space along the entire length of the front elevation, an increase in height of the building due to flood plain issues, and placement of mechamcals on the roof A variance will be sought from the Planning Commission for the height of the building Other revisions were enumerated in a communication from Landform included in the agenda packet Mr Wallis explained that the mechanicals were moved to the roof due to space issues within the residential units, as well as flood plain issues The intent is to screen the roof top units, and Mr Wallis said he was open to input regarding color of the roof accents Mr Tomten suggested making the front of the building more accessible to pedestnan traffic, such as through informal paths • • City of Stillwater Hentage Preservation Commission November 5, 2001 Dunng discussion of lighting, Mr Peterson noted that the City is in the process of installing histonc style lamp fixtures on Main Street, Mr Wallis said the developers would be open to looking at incorporating that style in their plans Regarding lighting of the building, Mr Lieberman said the plans seems to include a lot of up -wash lighting, and rather than accent the vertical element of the building, he suggested lighting could be used to create a sense at the street level There was discussion about the possibility of having awmngs for the storefronts Mr Wallis said awmngs are not planned at this time, since it is unknown who the tenants will be In discussing landscaping, Mr Tomten expressed a concern about the use of spruce trees due to their height at matunty Mr Johnson asked about landscaping between this project and the Desch building, Mr Wallis said the developers have contacted Mr Desch and Mr Desch had indicated a willingness to talk with them regarding plans Ms Hark expressed a concern with the proposal for the use of hanging signs for the retail spaces, suggesting that the signage looked cluttered Mr Tomten moved approval as conditioned with the additional conditions that the extenor lighting match the city's histonc pedestnan pole lighting and the parking lot lights match the city lots, that a type of pedestnan plaza be created in the front of the building to create easy pedestnan access from Highway 95, approving the signage as proposed, allowing tenants to choose between a wall or projecting sign, that the applicant consider an alternative to the proposed tier of spruce between the parking lot and Main Street, the extenor building lighting be onented to the first floor and not up on the building, and that the roof unit screening color pick up the building tnm or roof color Mr Peterson seconded the motion Mr Johnson suggested adding a condition that the windows be the same as submitted — casement with clear glass Mr Tomten and Mr Peterson accepted that amendment to the motion Amended motion passed unanimously Case No DR/01-39 Design review of an accessory building at 423 N Owens St Mick Lynskey, applicant Mr Lynskey was present Mr Tomten expressed a concern that the proposed building does not match the existing structure in roof pitch, fascia/tnm detail, window shapes etc Mr Lynskey noted that the slope of the land makes the accessory structure higher than the existing structure, also, he noted the existing structure has different roof pitches and little architectural continuity Mr Lynskey also noted that tittle of the new building will be visible from Owens Street Mr Tomten and Mr Johnson both suggested alternative, neither of which were acceptable to Mr Lynskey either due to cost factors or to difficulties with the site J • • • City of Stillwater Heritage Preservation Commission November 5, 2001 Mr Lieberman concluded the discussion by noting that it did not appear the proposal could meet the ordinance requirements without some changes and suggested the Mr Lynskey return at the December meeting with some additional ideas Mr Lieberman, seconded by Ms Hark, moved to continue the case until the December meeting, motion passed unanimously Case No V/DR/01-55 Revised design review of a four -unit housing structure on Olive Street, between Second and Third streets Jerry Runk, representing Don Nolde Mr Runk was present While the plans have been revised, the footpnnt of the structure is slightly smaller, he noted Ms Diem said the requested spiral staircase in not allowable per fire code Mr Runk responded that the staircase is a 9" winding staircase, not a spiral, and he said there will still be a need for a stairway due to code issues Mr Johnson questioned the use of the ball design element on the extenor Mr Tomten also questioned the scale of the balcony supports Mr Johnson moved approval as conditioned with the additional condition that the ball design element be eliminated, refemng the spiral staircase issue to the building official Mr Tomten seconded the motion adding the condition that the balcony columns be reduced in size, perhaps to Just a steel column It also was suggested that the applicant look at landscaping on Olive Street Motion passed unanimously Case No DR/01-40 Design review of extenor modifications for Belle Pogue Furniture and Accessones Kim Salmela, applicant The applicant was not present Mr Lieberman moved to deny the requested light figure Mr Johnson questioned why the requested awning covered Just the door and not the full storefront Mr Lieberman moved to table the awning Mr Johnson seconded the motion, motion passed unanimously Other business Mark Balay and Bob Anderson appeared regarding requested changes to the Andiamo ticket office Mr Balay bnefly reviewed changes made subsequent to the October meeting Regarding the HPC's request to reduce the number of light fixtures, Mr Balay said that due to code regulations, an additional fixture had to be placed on the west elevation Also, subsequent to the discussion at the October HPC meeting, a shed roof was added to the north elevation Mr Balay said his client is requesting an additional change — installation of two additional windows on the east elevation in order to see the docks/boats from the office Bob Anderson stated that the windows are needed in order to be able to work out of the office 4 i • • City of Stillwater Hentage Preservation Commission November 5, 2001 Mr Johnson noted the windows that were installed on the east elevation are half the size of the windows onginally proposed He suggested it looks awkward to have the smaller windows and then add two other windows in between Mr Johnson also said the building looks "remudeled", and it is not even complete Mr Lieberman suggested that the building doesn't do justice to the Andiamo's value to the community There was a bnef discussion of a stop work order that had been issued by the building official It was noted that the building permit was issued on the plans approved by the Hentage Preservation Commission and what is being built is not what was approved by the HPC Mr Lieberman cautioned against further discussion since a legal issue is involved Mr Balay said the issue at hand is the request for the two additional windows on the east elevation Mr Johnson noted the HPC had worked with the applicant regarding changes on the north elevation with the expectation that those were the only design changes that would be made Mr Lieberman said the east elevation does not reflect what was approved at the last meeting and moved to deny the request for the additional windows Mr Johnson seconded the motion, motion passed unanimously Mr Lieberman stated he would like Mr Harvey to appear before the Commission for approval of his sign Ms Fitzgerald said he has sent a letter to Marathon Oil regarding the lighting of the gas canopies at Tom Thumb The meeting was adjourned at 11 20 p m Respectfully submitted Sharon Baker, Recording Secretary • • • H P C APPLICATION REVIEW FORM CASE NO DR/01-41 Hentage Preservation Date December 3, 2001 Project Location 6490 Stillwater Blvd Comprehensive Plan Distnct Single Family Residential Zoning Distnct RA Applicant's Name Bruce Caulfield — Busch Caulfield Architects representing Bethany Evangelical Church Type of Application Design Review Project Descnption Design review of a building addition and signage for Bethany Evangelical Church Discussion The applicant is requesting design review for a building addition and new signage to replace the existing sign The addition would be on the southeastern side of the existing building Bethany Covenant Church is in the process of upgrading the exterior facade of the existing building (approved by the Commission at the October 1 2001 HPC meeting) The materials and the architecture of the addition will match the new materials and the architecture of the existing building The materials will consist of cultured stone at the base of the walls Tan color for the main surface with brown tnm There will be no new exterior lighting The proposed sign will replace the existing sign The new internally lit sign will be in harmony with the materials on the building It will be 15'-4" wide, 8'-15/6" high Conditions of Approval 1 All utilities shall be completely screened from public view 2 A lighting plan showing the fixture type, height, location and exterior lighting intensity shall be submitted with building permit plans for Planning Director approval All lighting shall be directed away from the street and adjacent properties Light sources shall be shielded from direct view and protected form damage by vehicles 3 Building lighting be contained to over entryways 4 Parking lot lighting shall be on one "shoebox" fixture pole 5 All landscaping shall be installed before utility release or final project inspection No project shall be phased unless approval is granted by the Planning Commission 4. • • 6 All trees required to remain on site, as indicated on the plans, shall be protected by fencing or other necessary measures shall be taken to prevent damage during construction activity 11 No roof equipment shall be visible to the general public 12 All gutters, downspouts, flashings, etc shall be painted to match the color of the adjacent surface 13 Construction projects shall conform to the City's Noise ordinance Construction dunng the dry season shall mitigate excess dust problems 14 A sign permit shall be required for all project signs 15 Grading and drainage plan to be approved by City Engineer before building permits are issued 16 Sign package to be approved by the Heritage Preservation Commission, including directional signs 17 Exterior lighting plan to be reviewed and approved by the Hentage Preservation Commission 18 All security lights on building shall be downlit 19 A sign permit is required for signage 20 All exterior modifications to the approved plan are to be reviewed by Community Development Director Recommendation Approval as conditioned Findings The request meets the intent of Attachments Application Form/Letter from Applicant/Photos/Site Plan/Elevation Drawings r • Case No fl (bl-9- Date Filed Receipt No Fee $25 00 DESIGN REVIEW APPLICATION FORM COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT DEPARTMENT CITY OF STILLWATER 216 NORTH FOURTH STREET STILLWATER, MN 55082 The applicant is responsible for the completeness and accuracy of all forms and supporting material submitted in connection with any application All supporting material (i e photos, sketches, etc) submitted with application becomes the property of the City of Stillwater • Address of Project Zoning Distnct PROPERTY IDENTIFICATION (v 490 4T- X2 ?w r7 Descnption of Project Assessor's Parcel No rt-I -1-( - Vi61- 1 l_LK 4L CoVNt-r-fr- e-1402 4 tl_v) ',,Icitil A-t-0 APO Ir1ol-1 "1 hereby state the foregoing statements and all data, information and evidence submitted herewith in all respects, to the best of my knowledge and belief, true and correct I further certify I will comply with the permit if it is granted and used " Property Owner 1J�TI- A'J.`(c -c 4/4+-4T 64 422-kepresentative *Z4.10- CAA--1 L7 Mailing Address 4490 �r(LLU\/l¢7EfZ SL1DQ Mailing Address 240Z Ol-t I V 12�r11- AVE- w � '' I Tr_ 5d1 City State Zip LL uvilrE12 1 MI --I 55082 1.(a..--,City State Zip T M4 '55I ! 4 Telephone No 4-121 1441 Telephone No LO i ip4 S CP/07 5 • Signature Signature P U}� Revised September 16 1998 • BUSCH CAULFIELD •ARCHITECTS, Community Development Department City of Stillwater 216 North Fourth Street Stillwater, MN 55082 November 19, 2001 Bethany Covenant Chuich is in the process of upgrading the exterior appearance of their existing Church They are also planning to replace their existing sign with materials similar to the new exterior materials on the Church The sign will be located in the same location as the existing sign An addition to the building is also being planned The materials and massing of the addition will match the new materials on the existing church We are submitting for review of the signage and addition to the building Materials Base of Walls Cultured Stone Pro -Fit Ledgestone Color Mojave MainWall Area EIFS Color #1 #110 Van Dyke Trim at Roof and Windows EIFS Color #2 #393 Chocolate Fizz Roof Composition Shingles Certainteed Landmark Series Color — Heather Blend Thai c you, Bruce Caulfield 2402 UNIVERSITY AVENUE WEST SUITE 501 651 645 6675 FAX 651 645 8071 SAINT PAUL MINNESOTA 55114 1701 • • • 8'-5' 21.92° �, ' i� Bethany Evangelical •, ' i• Covenant Church 1'VORSHIP SERVICES SUNDAY9:30-10:30 NDAY SCHOOL. 10:00 - 11:00 PASTOR SIGN LIGHTING: INTERNAL LAMPING, HORIZONTALLY LIT WITH (5) 8' LAMPS OR INDUSTRY STANDARD SIGN FRAME: EXTRUDED ALUMINUM CHANNEL 15-4" • • H P C APPLICATION REVIEW FORM CASE NO DR/01-42 Hentage Preservation Date December 3, 2001 Project Location 243 South Main Street Comprehensive Plan Distnct Central Business District Zoning Distnct CBD Applicant's Name Mark Hanson Type of Application Design Review Project Descnption Design review of an awning Discussion The request is for design approval of an awning for the building at 243 South Main Street The building houses two businesses, the future Marx Cafe and McGarry -Kearney Agency The applicant will bring a revised drawing of the canopy to the meeting illustrating both the proposed canopy and signage The color of the awning will be determined by the time of the meeting Tnm on the building will be painted dark brown or copper Recommendation Approval as conditioned Conditions of Approval 1 Awning will not be lit 2 No additional signage 3 Structural elements of the awning shall be at least eight feet above the sidewalk 4 The awning valance shall be at least seven feet above the sidewalk 5 Fixed awnings shall have a minimum one by one pitch Findings The request meets the intent of the Downtown Design Guidelines Attachments Application Form/Photo Nov 26 01 12 55p McGarr -Kearney Rgency 651-439-6350 11/09/2004 14 52 4388818 CITY OF STILLWATER PAGE 02 p 2 Case No sot 4)-4-z Date Piled ,�J_? /, O / Receipt No • DESIGN REVIEW APPLICATION FORM COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT DEPARTMENT CITY OF STILLWATER 216 NORTH FOURTH STREET STILLWATER, MN 55082 Fee. $25.00 The applicant k responsible for the completeness and accuracy of all forms and suppordng material submitted in connection %Mh any application A11 supporting material (i.e. photos, sketches, etc ) submitted with application becomes the property of the City of Stillwater Address of Project Zoning District PROPERTY IDENTIFICATION -) r- Assessor's ?excel No Deacnption of Project 1 hereby state the foregoing statements and ail data, information and evidence submitted herewith In all respects, to the best of my knowledge and belief, true end connect I further certify I will comply with the permg f It Is granted and used " Prvpeity owner'Kt*,1 I'VtOi lit Representative WAL/" k u A t3 cs A2 l Marling Address�01�lj2. 4) W ��1 Mailing Address Z [ S ,`f]ll i tiYl City State Zip c Lai Y fl �ci F city state Zip Sit ((vM2" nor co(-S7, Telephone No ? - Telephone No C, 1- 4 2iq 3 T 7 `1 Signature Signature Revised September 16, 1998 • Page 1 of 1 0 A KY RI d Al (612) 722 2731 Not to Scale - Facsimil $ file //C \Documents and Settings\SFrtzgerald\Local Settmgs\Tempo \McGarryRendenng jp 11/20/2001 Page 1 ot A (612) 722-2731 Not to Scale - Facsi mil file://C: \Documents and Settings\ SFitzgerald\Local Settings\Tempo...\McGarryRenderingjp 11/20/2001 Nov 26 01 12 55p 4 McGarr -Kearney Rgere 651-439-6350 p 1 • • MCGARRY-KEARNEY AGENCY, INC 243 S MAIN STREET STILLWATER,MN 55082 (651)439-6345 Fax (651)439-6350 EMAIL info@mcgarry-keameyagcncy com FAX MEMO 11/26/2001 To CITY OF STILLWATER At'n SUE F Fax Number 430-8810 From Rob McGarry Re AWNING Number of pages (including coier page) 2 Comments SUE INCLUDED IN THIS TRANSMISSION IS DESIGN REVIEW APPLICATION FORM FOR YOUR FILE AS PER OUR CONVERSATIONS, WE HAVE NOT DECIDED ON FINAL AWNING PLAN FROM TWO PROPOSALS PLEASE ALSO NOTE TRIM ON BUILDING FRONT WILL BE PAINTED WE HAVE NOT DECIDED ON FINAL COLOR BUT I SUSPECT IT WILL BE DARK BROWN, OR COPPER IF YOU REQUIRE ADDITIONAL INFORMATION, PLEASE DO NOT HESITATE TO CALL ME THANKS FOR YOUR HELP ROB MCGARRY • H P C APPLICATION REVIEW FORM CASE NO DR/01-43 Hentage Preservation Date December 3, 2001 Project Location 102 South Second Street Comprehensive Plan Distnct Central Business District Zoning Distnct CBD Applicant's Name Mark Balay-Balay Architects, representing John Harvey Type of Application Design Review Project Descnption Design review of exterior modifications of the Gazette Building Discussion\ The request is for design approval of exterior modifications to the Gazette Building Modifications will consist of an extension of the deck on the west side of the building, the addition of a block wall and steps, a deck and garden courts The existing deck will remain with a few alterations, new hand -railings will be installed to meet code All wood will be natural in color The new wall will be constructed with paver blocks, and the decks will be paver brick A door will replace an existing window on the southwest side on the building There will be fixed forest green awnings on the front and back of the building The applicant will bring a cut of the proposed lighting for the court and the building to the meeting for review and approval Conditions of Approval 1 Construction projects shall conform to the City's Noise ordinance 2 A sign permit shall be required for all project signs 3 Sign package to be approved by the Hentage Preservation Commission 4 A sign permit is required for signage 5 Exterior lighting plan to be reviewed and approved by the Hentage Preservation Commission 6 All security lights on building shall be downlit 7 Awning will not be lit 8 Structural elements of the awning shall be at least eight feet above the sidewalk 9 The awning valance shall be at least seven feet above the sidewalk 10 Fixed awnings shall have a minimum one by one pitch 11 All exterior modifications to the approved plan are to be reviewed by the Community Development Director • • • Recommendation Approval as conditioned Findings The request meets the intent of the Downtown Design Guidelines Attachments Application Form/Letter/Site and Elevation Drawings/Photos • • • Mark S Balay, AIA S t i I ( w a t e r M i n n e s o t o 110 East Myrtle Street State 100 Stillwater Minnesota 55082 (651) 430-3312 11/21/01 Ms Sue Fitzgerald /City of Stillwater 214 N Fourth St Stillwater, MN 55082 Dear Sue Michael E Balay AIA Indian a p o 1 1 s I n d i a n a 6801 Lake Plaza Dnve State C 305 Indzanapolzs Indiana 46220 (317) 845 9402 Enclosed are the submittal matenals for 102 S Second St ,the Gazette Building, site modifications We are applying for review of proposed improvements as shown on these documents, and our completed application This submittal currently does not include any awnings or signage We would like to hold the possibility open to bnng additional items to the meeting I believe we have successfully avoided the need for a vanance, by keeping all new construction outside the 15ft front yard The side yard is 0 on this side and 20 on the parking lot side Don't hesitate calling if you have any questions or require additional information Sincerely, ark S Balay cc John Hary enc Case No Date Filed Fee Paid Receipt No PLANNING ADMINISTRATION FORM ACTION REQUESTED Fees COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT DEPARTMENT _Special/Conditional Use Permit $50/200 CITY OF STILLWATER _Vanance $70/200 216 NORTH FOURTH STREET _Resubdivision $100 STILLWATER, MN 55082 _Subdivision* $100+50/lot Comprehensive Plan Amendment* $500 Zoning Amendment* $300 Planning Unit Development * $500 Certificate of Compliance Design Review *An escrow fee is also required to the costs of attorney and eng►neenng fees (see attached) The applicant is responsible for the completeness and accuracy of all forms and supporting matenal submitted in connection with any application All supportng matenal (► e , photos, sketches, etc) submitted with application becomes the property of the City of Stillwater A site plan is required with applications PROPERTY IDENTIFICATION 2 // Address of Project 1O S ; S =c _013 0 Assessors Parcel No (GEO Code) Zoning Distnct V7 Description of Project Ii ) A- Da_ -Rain (/ i "I hereby state the foregoing statements and all data, information and evidence submitted herewith in all respects, to file best of my knowledge and belief, true and correct I further certify I will comply with file • nn►t if it is granted and used " ,, I ,, Property Owner �r s ��� Representative 1- S i , df rc. Mailing Address `J a i. Mailing Address I I (`-) i� 1 t--iLepr�t 1 City - State - Zip � -city State - Zip <-,11il.LA..26.,--rr t;`-t k s c.% Telephone No%S 1 , phone No Signature Signature Lot Size (dimensions) Land Area Height of Buildings Stories Pnncipal �� SITE A D PROJECT DESCRIPTION Total Building floo Existing Feet Proposed v ' GS Paved Impervious Area square feet square feet square feet square feet f1 \f ummrnQAACnr AJf1T f1FCTpnv D1 AMADP PRAA 1 nn 77 7nnn Case No Date Filed Fee Paid Receipt No �, 1/,� Accessory No of off-street parkng spaces r v � n \ 11IANmCf1GWCfYI WIT nrCTPf1V\PI ANAPP FPU I nn 97 9nnn NiYR11S1' W51HVMI9Ns or riok:yAr?airriKstpF/cKs t02 5 s22J75t AJZ/z1/o2 PCK xr3JoH � Nw'ro�017E rfFl VS • la k VI / • • r ,25..gid 1 l 1Th- ► 1 1 1 II 7 i rx(q, vfk) dk r-XINSIoN NPV\/ WCKS I -17A-k I IJco _..c)i CK 5rf-PKYAW 0 � SiAl Est II402 5, sgoH V 51, i i/2i7/6i. k • 441C)',14 s „ A .., S. sr Atk " t‘•if 3 5- '5 5- c 4 ) 5 f H P C APPLICATION REVIEW FORM CASE NO DR/01-44 Hentage Preservation Date December 3, 2001 Project Location River Heights Mall Comprehensive Plan Distnct Business Park Commercial Zoning Distnct BP-C Applicant's Name Christopher Leaf -Sign -A -Rama, representing Anne Jeske, St Croix Vision Center Type of Application Design Review Project Descnption Design review of signage Discussion The applicant is requesting design approval of the 10" and 18" channel letters signage for the St Croix Vision Center The letters will be red with black trim in bronze aluminum cans The applicant will need to seek a vanance from the Planning Commission for the two lines of lettering The sign program for River Heights Mall allows for one row of signage Recommendation Approval as conditioned Conditions of Approval 1 No additional signage 2 All revisions to approved sign plan shall be reviewed and approved by the Community Development Director Findings The request meets the intent of the West Business Park Design Guidelines Attachments Application Form/Photo/Elevation Drawing • rRN CB RI OARn ELL, E NC (HRI111 01 1' 56/ST 15 54,N0 35Ei152r: 3 P 2/2 .. . • vie u „�j FR( NO 6123731733 rzvv 0r b'rIIJJIA—EP Nov i 5 2001 02 13Pri P2 "rKiE 03 Case No DE-/01 — } Date Filed .l 1- 7,1 s t Receipt No Z' Fee: $25 00 DESIGN REVIEW APPLICATION FORM COMMUNITY OLVILO M rtx IMPARTMENT cfTY o?faILLwATER 216 NORTH FOCUS Mtn ST ILWAt , boor S The applknafi is respons bk far the coupletentes end scct raeq of ell forms 004 supporting material e4btotiind Lm tvastedioh with um topplientlut All &Qppordng meterW (1.e. photos` ekedta, etc.) submitted with appikatks bees the prop arty of the City of sdfwnW PRONLTITY !ENTIPICATIOW Address of Project.] BD ,2r/1-E2 4 e ied- Astaseac'e Perae1 No zoatag Dintrut _ Descnpttaa of Protect (/ tt itL ( r��� " /h eP6v J l l 1 hereby state the farego1rrg statements end el! doe lntorrrmflan and evidence submitted herewith In ell respects, to the best of my knowredg+e end Walt f, true and comae 1 furthercettlfy 1 WO comply nvitl+ the penal Alt rs granted and used. gi ver a �rr 1 / � CO Gp R..►c�•.Gr� �1 i < 5 j-_sseotittfVmA1/41AMaims Sl<e- 5wk- 7 a --„` A't!J it�c ddreee"e but Sou._ 2daltagAdttesA Set_rk_? city Stara zip Ai.., _.L _s wth,' _ sios city stage zip 6S Telephoto No. 9 S Z — `I Z V —c.{ Si RoVioPti ,6eptembor f d 1996 • Stye • • Ink 1 .1 3 r 41 I i ' •.,' , ,4 ' 11 , k .4, i4 J 'd '4, 1k i kf 1 .kk i a 1 q 1 / f' •`. 4, 1 3. 3. 4.4 - r4' .3 I 3 3 3 I 344. 4144 .( • • • Specification - Channel letters illuminated by HYPERION R-Lite System, UHB red color - Red plexiglas faces, black trim, 1; - ze aluminum cans - Installation and city sign permit are not included • • • • H P C APPLICATION REVIEW FORM CASE NO DR/01-45 Hentage Preservation Date December 3, 2001 Project Location 213 East Chestnut Street Comprehensive Plan Distnct Central Business District Zoning Distnct CBD Applicant's Name Loren Lorenzen -Universal Signs, Inc , representing Firstar/US Bank Type of Application Design Review Project Descnption Design review for exterior signage Discussion The request is for design approval of four signs Firstar Bank and US Bank have merged and are located in the original Firstar Bank building The proposed signs will replace the existing Firstar signs All dimensions and source of illumination remain the same Colors used are blue, green and red Three signs have a white background and the pylon sign has a dark background Recommendation Approval as conditioned Conditions of Approval 1 No additional signage Attachments Application Form/Photos OF = T T' F,E ti_ • • Case No L bi -4 Date Filed LA Z.l O ( Receipt No DESIGN REVIEW APPLICATION FORM COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT DEPARTMENT CITY OF STILLWATER 216 NORTH FOURTH STREET STILLWATER, MN 55082 • Fee $25 00 The applicant is responsible for the completeness and accuracy of all forms and supporting material submitted in connection with any application All supporting material (i e photos, sketches, etc) submitted with application becomes the property of the City of Stillwater PROPERTY IDENTIFICATION Address of Project eD3 (I)-100 Assessor's Parcel No I f Zoning Distract Description of Project ayvo t'rS %n�l+� 0 rXicirs "I hereby state the foregoing statements and all data, Information and evidence submitted herewith in all respects, to the best of my knowledge and belief true and correct I further certify I will comply with the permit If It Is granted and used " Property Owner )%�� �Q'2 Au S &1" Mailing Address �43 e C h.toS/ith, City State Zip 'Z- Ill e � �1�, /yam 55D8'2 Telephone No (057 25/ 2 YO0 Signatur Revised September 16 1998 Representative 0/P1 N evsN Sri 1 c Mailing Address /03-) City State Zip 5t 1,DA,01 /viol s's JO 1 Telephone No 65-! - Os-- 6 2-Z-3 Signature • • 18" • 1,1u PROPOSED BLUE ACRYLIC REPLACEMENT FACES SCALE 1/2" = 1' 74" Ot/f MC SIGN CO.IPANY 35280 LAKELAND BLVD EASTLAKE OHIO 44095 PH 440-953-2280 FAX 440 953 2285 (2) REQ'D 14"O A LOGO HT BLUE BACKGROUND TO MATCH PMS# 2748 EXISTING PROPOSED 10" • (2) REQ'D /A\I-1 N\FA 1 WHITE VINYL APPLIED FIRST SURFACE TO FIRSTAR PANEL rt lir RED PMS 193 OT10E PRINTS ARETHEEXCLUSIVE PROPERTYOF'THE MC SIGN COMPANY'ANYUV•AUTHORIZED USE ORDIFl1CA11ONWLLRESULTNA$1000.00CHARGE 0MCSGNC0..19 117 bank T E SHOWN M US BANK #MN030 8/13/01 �q #MN030 0108 13 53 HS • • 17-1/2" 6-1 /4"I OA MC SIGN COMPANY 35280 LAKELAND BLVD EASTLAKE OHIO 44095 PH 440 953-2280 FAX 440 953 2285 PROPOSED WHITE ALUMINUM REPLACEMENT FACE SCALE 3/4" = 1' 68" *FIRSTAR embank EXISTING 7" 0 A PROPOSED L RFD r RED PMS 193 OTICE'PRiffS4.T.HEEICUJSIIEPROPp70FiTHE MC SIGN asir*ANY UN-161011:11.i4OR OUPLICATION iN1118:11T IN 41000.00 CHOiGE:igit S01 C00; [1:0 bank #MN030 T E SHOWN M US BANK 8/13/01 #MN030 0108 13 54 HS • F 48" 8-3/41 O 311 BLACK COPY 2-1/2" BLACK COPY PROPOSED WHITE ALUMINUM REPLACEMENT FACE SCALE 1/2" = 1' 96" *FIRSTAR (tO bank PRIVATE PARKING NO PARKING EXCEPT FOR CUSTOMERS OF FIRSTAR AND USBANK UNAUTHORIZED VEHICLES WILL BE TOWED AT OWNERS EXPENSE THIS RAMP IS CLOSED & LOCKED AT 6 00 PM REMAINING VEHICLES WILL BE TOWED R0 y i,, PRIVATE PARKING' .�,10 ARKIIGEXCEPT FOR CUSTOMERS 0FFIRSTAR l OpAOTHORIZEO VEHICLES WILL OE s, OWED AT OWNERS EXPENSE SRAW IS CLOSED & LOCKED ATM PM ,y EMAIWNC VEHICLES WILL RE TOWED MC SIGN COMPANY 35280 LAKELAND BLVD EASTLAKE OHIO 44095 PH 440 953 2280 FAX 440 953 2285 EXISTING 1,10"O A ��,l�:�•',ti:S.i,er..,.•......,_ - band #FRSTAR CEE3 PRIVATE PARKING NO PARKING EXCEPT FOR CUSTOMERS OF FIRSTAR AND USBANKWILL BETOWED AT OWNERS EXPENSE THIS EMAINI G VEHICLES WILLCUMED BE AT 6 00 P� BE TOWED PROPOSED 5LL n RED l PMS 193 I OTICEP1NTSNEll ECUlSWEPROPERIYOF'EIEMCSIGN_COMPANY'1MVYUN.AW}� ZEDUSEORDIFUCA11g viiiSUTINAPOOR CHARGE �MCSIGNCa1 a bank T E SHOWN M US BANK #MN030 8/13/01 #MN030 0108 13 51 HS • • 24" 2" OA± 1-1/2" BLACK COPY 1-1/4" BLACK COPY 2-5/8" BLACK ARROW MC SIGN COSIPANY 35280 LAKELAND BLVD EASTLAKE OHIO 44095 PH 440 953-2280 FAX 440-953-2285 24" *FIRSTAR CEO bank CUSTOMER PARKING ONLY NO OVERNIGHT PARKING VIOLATORS WILL BE TOWED AT OWNERS EXPENSE Immo* EXISTING CM bank #MN030 PROPOSED WHITE ALUMINUM REPLACEMENT FACE 2-1/2" 0 A SCALE 1/2" = 1' *FIRSTAR / ©bank CUSTOMER PARKING ONLY NO OVERNIGHT PARKING V10ATTORS ` OWNERS EXPENSE L BE TOWED PROPOSED ANY .AUTHI' DUS ORD 'll ATION TE SHOWN M US BANK FEE Pr , BUJ_ P ti RED PMS 193 TNA 11,i,1 it CHART ... . #MN030 0108 13 52 HS 4 P r • s • H P C APPLICATION REVIEW FORM CASE NO DR/01-46 Hentage Preservation Date December 3, 2001 Project Location 123 North Second Street Comprehensive Plan Distnct Central Business District Zoning Distnct CBD Applicant's Name Jeanne Anderson, representing WR Medical Electronics Co Type of Application Design Review Project Descnption Design review of roof top unit placement Discussion The applicant is requesting design review of the placement of a roof top air conditioning unit Approval was given this summer to place one air conditioning unit on the roof, since they have found another one is needed The unit would be back 20 feet from the front and side It's about two feet high and not visible from the street Recommendation Approval as conditioned Conditions of Approval 1 All revisions to the approved plan shall be reviewed and approved by the Community Development Director Findings The request meets the intent of the Downtown Design Guidelines Attachments Application Form/Site Drawing/Elevation Drawing • • • Case No Date Filed Receipt No DESIGN REVIEW APPLICATION FORM COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT DEPARTMENT CITY OF STILLWATER 216 NORTH FOURTH STREET STILLWATER, MN 55082 Fee $2500 The applicant is responsible for the completeness and accuracy of all forms and supporting material submitted in connection with any application All supporting material (i e photos, sketches, etc) submitted with application becomes the property of the City of Stillwater PROPERTY IDENTIFICATION Address of Project I . , .i',GO p — Assessor's Parcel No Zoning Distract G$ D Descnption of Project jpi Tbr j s t..r l D t) "I hereby state the foregoing statements and all data, information and evidence submitted herewith in all respects, to the best of my knowledge and belief, true and correct I further certify 1 will comply with the permit if it is granted and used " Property Owner Mailmg Address City State Zip Telephone No •Signature Representative-ANWIE, ANItee,6,C11,3 Mailing Address 123 I•3 at-�',cb 1•3 12 7t City State Zip L`t'L,) All 2 Telephone No 4SCD R 9-,s---1 Signature Revised September 16 1998 11/19/2001 15 58 4309930 WR MEDICAL PAGE 01 • • • 123 NORTH SECOND STREET • STILLWATER, MN 55082 5047 USA • From ‘ra l�-'l �' �i A-A,FeR 607V To FAX No Company Address Special instructions or message P/R 9/A3o - Sy6 9- 6kr rr r 6-ne 474 3o - ./ o PHONE 651 430 1200 • MAIN FAX 651-439 9733 Legal and Regulator, Department Direct FAX 651 430 8449 E-mail jma@wrmed com Web www wrmed com P Date RE orV gCOS / 1 Al 2A.0 S7- C� ry S, 1At4. a7A) N/VZ&,7 c>7/1 7C '_ / Qb or S / 67cC r 'l-7 c oz.) e D cz{771,/ A(Or /7/2G/ i r° /5 cA'Cra /9' 3//27/ / 47 ,4 A-Pcyesc 7'V( ' T (ex lli2Z4,76 401 ") 5 01- - T"><h9 r cw / L 5 6" rI) A /74 c iri 71f/s A'/cj 4 /c. 61—/ i /T iv _z- � � JVG2c e„) 5� 1' 9 v 77 & -' ,f% /7 (7 U `,7t 5*7)/� r7:;6/L//r> 47: K7 j /,C t g I°/L (1 N2 771E (z sen\hxjkarru 05 rev 1/37r0 Total number of pages Including this page 0- 11/26/2001 09 46 4303930 WR MEDICAL PAGE 02 Seezay.k si- • • FroAt o; 8,.t11' 1.,3 N, .?.146 $ f Rac-; Tap 'Jat.w 48 • • WR MEDICAL 11 / 18; 2001 a • t M 2 3'r.-^waS Nor [P C*►S A. JIIR COOLED CONDENSER DA/ eew,c `_ v a .re _ViVort-11-41-413I.e ;v frsat • BICB ISSUED FOR APPROVAL DATE ISSUED ton/of BY C. ere D 12P RO RFD AS NOTED 0 APPROVED AS ISSLTDD APPROVED BY DATE APPROVED i s 4.24 ACRES PLAY AREA/ \ \ \ PHASE 3 PARKING \ \ \ 42 SPACES 49=0* - - 00 #1 / / / >/ // /, /, // // EXISTING BUI I G /// /,/ / REPLACE EXISTING SIGN / / / / _&/ / 4 41 00 0ti / / �o v� ® /.4ftEir c, / Jv / ®/ Q7/ / / • WEST ELEVATION 11111111111111111011 EAST ELEVATION SOUTH ELEVATION NORTH ELEVATION NEW COMPOSITION SHINGLES WITH r OF ICE AND WATER BARRER AT AU. ROOF ECGES AND VALLEYS YAW EASMO MIX pauses rani =TIMM RITE NOERI NEW pm mum mum mum miumniammi ■ ISM-uINIuuMII a•�rvcv-aa -v�v�w vi�•a. a��nvvsa•a•a�r -�- _v1TF1Iij1i NEW EIFS COLOR #1 EIFS COLOR #2 mill11111T „v. \\\‘ CULTURED STONE WITH WATERTAB E a,• NO COMPOSITION SHINGLES NORTH ELEVATION EAST ELEVATION