The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink About2001-07-02 HPC Packet• • IS THE BIRTHPLACE OF MINNESOTA HERITAGE PRESERVATION COMMISSION HERITAGE PRESERVATION MEETING NOTICE THE STILLWATER HERITAGE PRESERVATION COMMISSION WILL MEET MONDAY, JULY 2, 2001 700PM CITY COUNCIL CHAMBERS CITY HALL 216 NORTH FOURTH STREET AGENDA Approval of June 4, 2001 minutes 1 Case No DR/01-12 Continued from May 7, 2001 meeting Design review of exterior signage for First Union Securities located at 333 North Main Street Mike Lean, Tarus Sign Co , applicant 2 3 Case No DR/01-24 Design review of extenor sign for Marx Restaurant at 239 South Main Street Mark Hanson, applicant 4 Case No DR/01-25 Design review of an extenor sign at 223 South Main Street Dick and Jen Slachta, applicants 5 Case No DR/01-21 Design review of extenor signage and awnings at 402 South Main Street Steve Bremer, applicant 6 Case No DR/01-26 Design review of extenor sign for Greater Stillwater Chamber of Commerce at 201 South Main Street Patty Schachtner, applicant 7 Case No DR/01-27 Design review of exterior sign for Netasol at 126 South Second Street Matt Fuir, applicant 8 Case No DR/01-28 Design review of exterior sign for Cabin Fever at 503 North Main Street Perry Carlson, applicant Other Items a Revised Downtown Design Guidelines update CITY HALL 216 NORTH FOURTH STILLWATER, MINNESOTA 55082 PHONE 651-430-8800 J • • • City of Stillwater Hentage Preservation Commission June 4, 2001 Present Howard Lieberman, chair (7 35 p m ) Beth Diem, Phil Eastwood, Diane Hark, Jeff Johnson and Roger Tomten Others Planner Sue Fitzgerald Vice Chair Johnson called the meeting to order at 7 05 p m Approval of Minutes Mr Johnson noted the minutes of May 7, 2001, should be corrected to indicate that case No DR/01-11 was continued Mr Tomten, seconded by Mr Eastwood, moved approval of the May 7, 2001, minutes as corrected, motion passed unanimously Case No DR/01-17 Design review of site improvements and signage at Let There Be Light, 210 N Main St Mark Balay representing Steve Gnan, applicant Mr Balay and Mr Gnan were present Mr Balay reviewed the request which included the restoration of an existing wrought iron fence, both for decorative purposes and to control access to the site, the installation of benches, installation of four decorative street lights, non - illuminated, on the site, installation of an awning with a 1-1 pitch of a color yet to be determined, and placement of two business signs — one on the east side of the building and a free-standing clock/sign located on the east side of the building close to the sidewalk The building does have two street frontages which would allow the applicant to have two business signs, however, since both signs, as proposed, are located at the east elevation, a vanance would be required, and Mr Balay said the applicant intended to pursue a vanance from the Planning Commission for the clock sign and for a setback vanance as the clock sign will be closer than the allowable 15 feet Mr Tomten asked if the applicant had considered moving the clock to the corner position, Mr Balay responded that the location of the electncal conduit is a determining factor Members agreed the setback was not an issue due to the location in the downtown distnct During discussion, Mr Johnson suggested the signage issue could be resolved if the business name were removed from the clock and replaced with a symbol and verbiage representative of the business type Mr Gnan said he preferred to have the business name but was amenable to Mr Johnson's suggestion as a way of resolving the issue Mr Johnson moved approval with the additional condition that the clock sign have a graphic/symbol indicative of the business type, not the business name, that the four decorative street lamps not be lighted, that the awning color and bench style be reviewed by staff Mr Johnson noted in making the motion that the HPC determined the a graphic/symbol for the clock is not a sign by definition of the ordinance and that setback due to the location on Main Street and illumination is not an issue Ms Hark seconded the motion Motion passed 5-0, Mr Lieberman did not vote • • City of Stillwater Hentage Preservation Commission June 4, 2001 Mr Lieberman assumed the chairmanship at this point Case No DR/0-18 Design review of extenor mural for Northern Vineyards, 223 N Main St Robin Partch, applicant The mural artist, Lois Andrews, was present The mural would not contain any verbiage Mr Tomten, seconded by Mr Eastwood, moved approval with the additional condition that the mural contain no words or advertisement Motion passed unanimously Case No DR/01-01 Design review of revisions to the door width at Traditions, 311 S Main St Tom Brownson, applicant Mr Brownson explained the requested change to the previously approved 3' single door is due to difficulty accessing the elevator The request is to have a 6' wide, double door During discussion, Mr Johnson questioned whether there weren't other options to another opening on the building Ms Diem noted the rear elevation is on an alley with business loading docks, and she said she didn't think the request was inappropnate Mr Tomten said he had no problem with the double door if the masonry arch over the door matches the existing door arch Mr Tomten said the proposal for a freight -type access fits the building Mr Eastwood, seconded by Mr Lieberman, moved approval as conditioned, with the additional condition that the arch match the existing door Motion passed unanimously Case No DR/ 01-19 Design review of a freestanding sign for St Croix Lighting, 220 E Mulberry St Emmett Carolan, applicant Tony Lodge was present for the discussion Mr Lodge explained the request for a non - illuminated building sign and a freestanding sign, 2x3', which would e on a lantern post and illuminated by the lantern As requested, the freestanding sign would be closer to the property line than the required 15 foot setback Members expressed support for a vanance from the 15 foot setback requirement due to the setback of the building and lack of visibility from Main Street Dunng the discussion, members presented several alternatives for dealing with the issue of two business signs the wall sign could be removed and the window glass used for signage, there are two tenants in the building, so one tenant could be listed on the building sign and the other on the freestanding sign, the building sign could include a graphic and verbiage indicative of the business type, rather than the business name Ms Diem and Ms Hark noted that the site does have two street frontages and suggested that be a consideration in allowing two signs • • City of Stillwater Hentage Preservation Commission June 4, 2001 Mr Johnson made a motion indicating that the Heritage Preservation Commission finds the signage acceptable and recommend that the Planning Commission consider granting requested variances due to the setback of the building and the unique conditions of the site Ms Diem seconded the motion, motion passed unammously Mr Lodge asked about placing gooseneck, downht fixtures on the building It was noted that had already been approved in the initial design review Case No DR/01-20 Design review of exterior sign for Grand Games, 317 S Main St Mary Schmidt, applicant Ms Schmidt was present for the discussion She said she was considering changing the burgundy lettenng in Grand Games to gold lettenng with black outline The sign will be placed on an existing bracket Dunng the discussion, it was noted that the sign will be a bit shy of the required 8' height above the sidewalk Mr Johnson suggested making the sign letters a bit bigger and bolder and suggested that the applicant might want to consider having Just Grand Games on the extenor sign, with the other items the applicant was proposing — "games, toys, novelty and outdoor blasts" -- listed in window signage Ms Schmidt agreed with that suggestion Mr Lieberman moved approval of the Grand Games sign in gold lettenng with an outline, with the sign to be placed on an existing bracket, acknowledging there might be a slight encroachment into the required 8 feet height above the sidewalk Mr Johnson seconded the motion, motion passed unanimously Case No DR/01-21 Design review of extenor modifications at 402 S Main St Steve Bremer, applicant Mr Bremer was present and explained plans for restoration of the exterior of the building Mr Tomten asked if there was any indication of the condition of the stone underneath the stucco that is proposed to be removed from one of the buildings Mr Bremer said he doesn't think there will be a problem, he said the building will be refaced if need be Mr Bremer, who is the general contractor, owns the Wabasha Caves in St Paul and plans to do histoncal tours of the Brewery/caves Mr Johnson asked about plans for the existing shed building at the cave entrance Mr Bremer said the building likely will be removed and a tour office constructed, he said he will come back with those plans at a later time Mr Bremer said he has no fighting plans as yet and no sign plan until tenants have been secured for the retail/restaurant uses He said there would be no changes to the north elevation, other than perhaps new doors at the existing openings He also stated he is aware that he will need a trash enclosure, but a detailed plan for that has not been developed yet • i • City of Stillwater Hentage Preservation Commission June 4, 2001 Mr Johnson questioned the proposed bubble style awnings Mr Bremer said he thinks that style fits the window shape better, Mr Tomten suggested that bubble style awnings can be successful if the masonry opening is an arch Mr Johnson moved to give concept approval as conditioned, with the additional conditions that plans for lighting, signage, awning style, colors and cave entrance building plans come back to the Commission for review, and with the understanding that the bubble style awnings are not approved at this time and with the understanding that the existing yellow sign at the cave entrance be removed Mr Eastwood seconded the motion, motion passed unanimously Mr Lieberman turned the chairmanship of the meeting back to Mr Johnson Case No DR/01-22 Design review of an exterior entrance modification at 220 E Myrtle St Mark Balay, representing David Hurley Mr Balay reviewed the plans for a vestibule addition at the entrance to the stairway to the third floor residence The addition will be located at the site of the former loading dock for the old post office A slate roof on the addition will mimic the pnmary structure and the extenor will be of bnck, matching the main structure An existing dormer will be retained Mr Johnson noted the addition will not be visible from any street Ms Diem, seconded by Mr Tomten, moved approval as condition, motion passed unanimously Case No DR 01-23 Design review of 29-32 condominium project at 501 N Main St Jeff Wallis, applicant Mr Wallis and the project architect bnefly reviewed plans The building will include a minimum of three retail spaces, maximum of five, on the Main Street elevation The pnmary building material will be jumbo bnck, not EFIS as noted in the agenda packet, EFIS will be used as accent Mr Tomten suggested the applicant make the Main Street elevation more pedestrian -friendly, rather than using landscaping to separate the structure from the sidewalk Mr Lieberman suggested the applicant might want to consider cloth awnings over the retail spaces to soften the building up Mr Johnson noted the site is located in the flood plain and asked if meeting the 100- year flood elevation would create a problem, specifically if the access to the retail space needs to be at a higher elevation, Mr Wallis admitted that might create a problem for height of the structure, as the current plans already are at the maximum allowable height — 50 feet Mr Tomten asked about the tnangular space at the rear of the property Mr Wallis said it will be an open area for light recreational use, and perhaps a location for screened HVAC units Mr Tomten suggested it might be used for on -site drainage • • • City of Stillwater Heritage Preservation Commission June 4, 2001 Sample lighting fixtures were provided Mr Johnson pointed out that guidelines call for lighting to be non -point source, not visible from the street Mr Wallis said the they are not set on specific lighting styles There was some discussion of signage It was noted that an address sign centered on the building or a monument sign listing the address would be acceptable, not both There will be no window air conditioning units, furnace and air conditioning units will be inside of the units Mr Johnson suggested consideration be given to removing all roof -top units due to the structure's visibility from Pioneer Park, etc , with only sewer stack vents allowed on the roof Mr Tomten encouraged the applicants to coordinate landscaping plans with the buildings to the south and north and to think "creatively" regarding the use of landscaping for water retention Mr Tomten moved approval as conditioned, amending Condition No 14 to include language that security lighting be shielded and downht, with a plan submitted to the HPC for review, amending Condition No 15 to include a sign package for the entire building, and adding an additional condition that all lighting be sodium, rather than metal halide Mr Johnson suggested adding conditions that the only allowable roof -top equipment be plumbing stacks, that the applicant consider creating pedestnan space between the building and street, that the applicant coordinate landscaping with the property owners to the north and south, and correcting the agenda to indicate the pnmary building matenal is bnck with EFIS accent It was further suggested to add language that the lighting plan and any extenor modification be reviewed by the HPC, as well as staff Mr Eastwood seconded the motion, motion passed unanimously Other Items • Final draft of South Half Carh and Schulenberg Addition Architectural Survey — Mr Tomten, seconded by Mr Lieberman, moved to accept the final draft, motion passed unanimously • Discussion of grant for Churchill, Nelson & Slaughter Addition Architectural Survey — There was a brief discussion as to the reasoning behind the sequence of the surveys • Bndge update — Mr Tomten said the HPC should continue promoting the use of the $5 million to repair the lift bridge Mr Johnson agreed that the money is available for that purpose and needs to be used Ms Fitzgerald asked if members wished to send a letter to Council It was agreed some "behind the scenes" work would be more appropnate, but that the issue should be kept as an active discussion • Mr Lieberman said he had prepared the requested letter outlining the HPC's position on the nver park concept • Mr Johnson said he is working with and advising Sandy Hudson on her project Mr Eastwood, seconded by Mr Lieberman, moved to adjourn at 10 20 p m , all in favor Respectfully submitted, Sharon Baker Recording Secretary • • H P C APPLICATION REVIEW FORM CASE NO DR/01-12 Hentage Preservation Date July 2, 2001 Project Location 333 North Main Street Comprehensive Plan Distnct Central Business Distnct Zoning Distnct CBD Applicant's Name Mike Lean — Tarus Sign Co Type of Application Design Review Project Descnption Design review of an extenor sign Discussion Attached are the minutes from the May 7, 2001 HPC meeting It was suggested by the Commission that a complete sign package be submitted and the applicant and the owner of the building look at alternative options for the First Union Securities sign Submitted is a sign package They are still requesting design approval of the First Union Securities sign on the building They are also showing First Union Securities on the monument sign This would constitute two signs on for one street for one business One sign per business facing the street is permitted by the Sign Ordinance • Case Not 01 — 110. Date Filed 4 fl • 0 Receipt No Fee $25 00 DESIGN REVIEW APPLICATION FORM COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT DEPARTMENT CITY OF STILLWATER 216 NORTH FOURTH STREET STILLWATER, MN 55082 The applicant is responsible for the completeness and accuracy of all forms and supporting material submitted in connection with any application All supporting material (i e photos, sketches, etc) submitted with application becomes the property of the City of Stillwater PROPERTY IDENTIFICATION Address of Project -33 N • Mk t.7 Assessor's Parcel No • Zoning District CAMP Descnption of Project SLIP.) cff .� CfpAcCita- • "1 hereby state the foregoing statements and all data, information and evidence submitted herewith in all respects, to the best of my knowledge and belief, true and correct I further certify I will comply with the permit if it is granted and used " Property Owner vureAlc. Representative TOrIWS 151s ft, Co Mailing Address b tC"ia.P qr Mailing Address 9 2-(p ) Dt sr_ N.) . City State Zip �,,[' 1 LLk.014 C.. City State Zip GT. 'PAULI MfA E i Telephone No (o t • 4 t - `10i $ Telephone No LL - t i s g -13 -1 c1.- Signature Signature Mt Ke. I ,A H Revised September 16 1998 • • • 9 IP ('' i(6'1\ cs (5 g. L. o' P C V Ti,c, D-_, — (, f ,T_ 11 0 2 a 3 6 u; 5 (s% 7 ) N\ cp ' 2- 5 5 0 2 1 Y , v, (5, cs N k k _I- , --,(6? ,*y 4 o c .pa (_Z- 0 'J,\, P )?J\ c.-, o 0 3 Page 1 of 1 • • • -zgx�z - I Nc\-34e_ ek Dc,occ cpc, CSk \Atr\3 file //A \MVC-001F JPG 6/21/2001 Page 1 of 1 • ^-.r "^�'t-ter"` '?- ,a k • Ritiy� n x� • — " c\; -- 3 S rev-.1 \ 1; file //A \MVC-002F JPG 441 6/21/2001 Page 1 of 1 • • • 4;7114, , 01- - 6q/1LiS/1 ot\olcor(N7eAs\.--k- szcAsc - 1_ Cbc 1z-4.-k-kr\% e-Dr&eX ticsrN file //A \MVC-003F JPG 706e) _CI_ 6/21/2001 5.-N c3s(-) Page 1 of,1CZ • • Vakk-1,DuwA__ file /A\Sign guy\sign photos\Photos\WIP folder\signmedia2 nog 4/26/2001 Page 1 of 1 .0-k --o k.1_ T-0--ex- -cz,Dr-NrN ScD L)41--\ (A-Je_-+- CO CrVe-c- 0-e- (\AL.)b.ex-c-L ?__ vv\o--; %-- , file //A \MVC-004F JPG 6/21/2001 Page 1 of 1 • S, Vie, �,, -\kt, f\A- P file //A \MVC-005F JPG 6/21/2001 Page 1 of 1 • \ cNA(p_x- -C-c--cDr\f- Nr\kct A-0 0 e__c__V- PUS 1&\-,‘N-c \A ry\ L.) 1+z -\--e_cel\-\-- \r) L)- kt ke-\ o--c-A-05 44-Q- \--- k4 V\`1 A-- P IS S l 1f--, r\(\ ; ( e_6( U S-e_ , file //A \MVC-006F JPG 6/21/2001 • • City of Stillwater Heritage Preservation Commission May 7, 2001 Present Howard Lieberman, Chair Beth Diem, Phil Eastwood, Diane Hark, JeffJohnson and Roger Tomten Others Planner Sue Fitzgerald Absent Dean Miller Mr Lieberman called the meeting to order at 7 p m. Approval of minutes Mr Tomten, seconded by Mr Johnson, moved approval of the minutes of April 12, 2001, as presented, motion passed unanimously Case No DR/01-10 Design review of exterior signage for Noah's Ark at 116 S Mam St Mary Aldrich, apphcant Ms Aldrich was present She explamed that she does not plan to use navy blue as indicated m the packet The colors will be country red with a beige background There will be an ark m the center of the hand -carved sign. Mr Johnson, seconded by Mr Eastwood, moved approval as submitted and conditioned, motion passed unanimously Case No DR/01-11 Design review of sign package for the Desch Building, 333 N Mam St , Mike Lean, applicant Case No DR_01-12 Design review of exterior sign for First Umon Securities, 333 N Main St , Mike Lean Apphcant Mr Lean and another representative of the sign company were present The requested sign package proposed one non -lit sign on the southwest side of the building, with all other busmesses listed on an mtenor wall directory The requested buildmg sign for First Umon Secunties is a 12' x 12" non -illuminated sign. Mr Tomten noted there currently is a directory sign outside of the building between the parking lot and the sidewalk Mr Tomten, Mr Johnson and Mr Lieberman recalled that a previously approved sign package for the buildmg provided for one directory sign and no other tenant signs Ms Fitzgerald said she did not find any previously approved sign package m the records In the discussion, Ms Fitzgerald said that technically the proposed sign package is not complete because it does not mclude all existing signage Mr Tomten also pomted out that there is no buildmg entrance at the location of the requested First Union Securities sign. • • • City of Stillwater Heritage Preservation Comnussion May 7, 2001 Durmg the discussion, several members expressed a concem about the potential for requests for additional exterior signage by building tenants Mr Eastwood said it would be hard to deny the request considering other buildmgs m the area, citing Maple Island as an example Mr Eastwood also suggested the request is due to a changmg use — retail use — which should be recognized m considering the request Other members pomted out that changmg use could result m multiple requests for extenor signage m the future Mr Johnson suggested that the applicant and building owner consider better use of the monument sign and stronger buildmg identification on the wall near the front entrance Ms Diem said she would not object to a smaller sign over the side entrance, along with a monument sign. It also was noted the apphcant could make use of window signage After discussion, Mr Tomten made a motion to ask the owner and applicant to look other alternatives and return with a more complete sign package, one that includes all existing signs on the property, and to took at options that will both protect the architectural mtegrrty of the buildmg and be able to accommodate changmg uses m the future Mr Johnson seconded the motion, motion passed unanimously Mr Lieberman, seconded by Ms Hark, moved to table Case No DR/01-12 until the sign package is approved Motion passed unanimously Case No DR/01-13 Design review of exterior sign4ge for Hentage Embroidery at 1655 Market Dr Debbie Pierre, apphcant Ms 'ierre was present She said she was gomg to use maroon, rather than red as indicated m the packet, she further stated she was unhappy with the font used by the sign company She also provided a copy of a new logo which she said she would hke to mcorporate m the buildmg signage Mr Johnson suggested moving the signage closer to the entrance and perhaps mcorporatmg the H & E m the logo as the first letters of the signage Ms Pierre responded that moving the signage closer to the entrance would reduce its visibility due to the curve of the roadway Mr Johnson also suggested gettmg nd of the box around the logo as proposed Mr Eastwood moved approval as presented, with any changes, such as font style, to be reviewed by staff as long as the signage meets guidelines Ms Fitzgerald noted she would need to see the final product, mcludmg dimension. Motion died for lack of a second Mr Tomten moved to approve a sign of mdividual illuminated neon channel letters, with the letters to be 24" high and the logo 36" high, the sign is to be maroon with gray background and located m the middle of the front wall, centered over the two window bays, the apphcant is to submit final drawmgs, dimensions, color sample and font to staff for review Ms Diem seconded the motion, motion passed unanimously • • H P C APPLICATION REVIEW FORM CASE NO DR/01-24 Hentage Preservation Date July 2, 2001 Project Location 239 South Main Street Comprehensive Plan Distnct Central Business Distnct Zoning Distnct CBD Applicant's Name Mark Hanson Type of Application Design Review Project Descnption Design review of an extenor sign Discussion The applicant is requesting design approval for a 3 ft by 6 ft sign for Marx Restaurant The background of the sign will be copper and the lettering will be stainless steel It will be lit with soft lighting shining toward the sign projecting from the wall There is an existing sign on the back of the building that will be re -used This sign will have a look similar to the Main Street sign Recommendation Approval as conditioned Conditions of Approval 1 No additional signage 2 All changes to the approved signage shall be reviewed and approved by the HPC Findings The request meets the intent of the Downtown Design Guidelines Attachments Application Form/Letter/Elevation Drawing • • • • gar796 CHECK # Case No Pri01-?S�. Date Filed (, )4, O` Receipt No 0 Fee $25 01 DESIGN REVIEW APPLICATION FORM COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT DEPARTMENT CITY OF STILLWATER 216 NORTH FOURTH STREET STILLWATER, MN 55082 The applicant is responsible for the completeness and accuracy of all forms and supporting material submitted m connection with any application All supporting material (i e photos, sketches, etc) submitted with application becomes the property of the City of Stillwater PROPERTY IDENTIFICATION Address of Project 77 Sc' (1"r 511 Assessor's Parcel No Zoning District L j3 D Descnption of Project Si h r r-e�// "I hereby state the foregoing statements and all data, information and evidence submitted herewith in all respects, to the best of my knowledge and belief, true and correct 1 further certify I will comply with the permit if it is granted and used " Property Owner VV/►arlc ga,,,fiv1/4./ Representative Mailing Address f f 11 04 di) ) (—r� Mailing Address City State Zip S7' c /A-Ar MA City State Zip Telephone No ( (5) 7 3O - I l l 1 r2 Telephone No 0 I/ 1 7‘41?-`- - - - - - - Signature Revised September 16 1998 Signature eyo-pose I Y\ aQ„__ SCrI • 1�,r'rns-v\SMnS 711JIN Si-€tT (6zkc-- V (Al2_0 .�1 Lt - Ccv ee r • Li n-h - &k r\1Q S S'r€€- L I kI t rchn sIrk n iw -S n c \royal Irn sNra0A 0jz1L reds `� \a'`� • can e\mgbi\.1 Sion be uSedL r • • H P C APPLICATION REVIEW FORM CASE NO DR/01-25 Hentage Preservation Date July 2, 2001 Project Location 223 South Main Street Comprehensive Plan Distnct Central Business Distnct Zoning Distnct CBD Applicant's Name Dick and Jen Slachta Type of Application Design Review Project Descnption Design review of an extenor sign for the Bndge View Gallery Discussion The request is for design approval of a banner installed at the second floor level above Outfitters on Main Street Banners are not permitted in the sign ordinance It is staffs recommendation that the design of the sign be approved and the Commission direct the applicant to have a wooden or some kind plastic sign created A projecting six square sign is permitted in this district The sign would have a blue background with white lettering It will be installed where the banner currently is placed with a metal/wrought iron bracket, see attached photo It will not be lit Conditions of Approval 1 Banner shall be removed and replaced with a sign matenal permitted in the sign ordinance by 9/2/01 2 No additional signage Recommendation Approval as conditioned Findings With the Conditions of Approval, the request meets the intent of the Downtown Design Guidelines Attachments Application Form/Photo 06/19/2001 09 56 4308810 CITY OF STILLWATER le .- 4 • • • PAGE 02 Case No DE,1 bl Date Filed ) b Receipt No - - - - Fee: $25.0 Drninii Iimumuu ,.l.R:PLui.44-e.is b-,,r,‘v, COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT DEPARTMENT �.aa t %AC DJiLA•VVA1L't( 216 NORTH FOURTH STREET STILLWATER, MN 55082 The applicant is responsible for the completeness and accuracy of all forms and supporting material submitted in connection with any application. MI supporting material (1 e photos, sketches, etc) submitted with application becomes the property of the City of Stillwater PROPERTY IDENTIFICATION Address of Project 5 f um z4 ISM% Assessor's Parcel No Zoning District Description of Project _ 6 Jx of /3egwt L c7 (Mir/7 Af,t,L6L - je-14)- "1 hereby state the foregoing statements and ell date, Information and evidence submitted herewith in all respects, to the best of my knowledge end belief, true and correct, 1 further certify I will comply with the permit if f Is granted and used " Property Owner __1 kt4- ,�, j� 2 Representative .— T Mailing Address ;‘)--3 fliLi t Mailing Address City State Zip �-�G L- j) vY ► City State Zip Telephone No % 686 f 47/el 1 Telephone No Signature 9-Rd Revised September 16, 1998 /B/'Signature i • • • H P C APPLICATION REVIEW FORM CASE NO DR/01-21 Hentage Preservation Date July 2, 2001 Project Location 402 South Main Street Comprehensive Plan Distnct Central Business Distnct Zoning Distract CBD Applicant's Name Steve Bremer Type of Application Design Review Project Descnption Design review of an extenor sign and awnings Discussion The applicant is bringing in a sign for the coffee shop for HPC's approval They also have some alternative solutions for the awnings that were presented to the HPC at the June 4, 2001 meeting , • • • Case N of --at Date Filed 13 . Z- O Receipt No Fee 5 OC DESIGN REVIEW APPLICATION FORM COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT DEPARTMENT CITY OF STILLWATER 216 NORTH FOURTH STREET STILLWATER, MN 55082 The applicant is responsible for the completeness and accuracy of all forms and supporting material submitted in connection with any application All supporting material (i e photos, sketches, etc) submitted with application becomes the property of the City of Stillwater Address of Project Li) D Zoning Distnct C 7 c PROPERTY IDENTIFICATION C -I- II \kr L4 Assessor's Parcel No . 0 -SOD 0 L/ I C)Oi a Descnption of Project R (4,, , k „-,,,, ii Tcc ,A P �T)t, , r N. r` ftL r,.,A (r g C L.,.l e 1 r TC- "I hereby state the foregoing statements and all data, information and evidence submitted herewith in all respects, to the best of my knowledge and belief, true and correct I further certify 1 will comply with the permit if it is granted and used " Property Owner LU\ 0 ....' Mailing Address 11 ( X S rr 1-..S1 City State Zip 5}11 \ .,, LA-tr- ('A 0 5 5 (''' Telephone No (.PE I - LIS 9 - 359S Revised September 16, 1998 Representative A-e..L/ Ti—,re Mailing Address , \S Wc, k'-)c y Le ,...S4 City State Zip.._7\ (` r _ I ' Lii ti Telephone No (r z)' )Li — 3 IS Signature i • • • H P C APPLICATION REVIEW FORM CASE NO DR/01-26 Hentage Preservation Date July 2, 2001 Project Location 201 South Main Street Comprehensive Plan Distnct Central Business District Zoning Distnct CBD Applicant's Name Patty Schachtner, repsenting the Greater Stillwater Chamber of Commerce Type of Application Design Review Project Descnption Design review of exterior signage Discussion The request is for design review and approval of an extenor sign for the Greater Stillwater Chamber of Commerce It will be a 2 foot by 3 foot projecting sign, located near the northwest corner of Loome Antiquarian Booksellers building The building is on the southeast side of Main Street and Chestnut Street It will be at least 8 feet from the bottom of the sign to the sidewalk The sign will not be lit It will have mauve lettering on a white background, mounted on a simple black tubular steel bracket Conditions of Approval 1 No additional signage 2 All changes to the approved sign be reviewed and approved by the Heritage Preservation commission Recommendation Approval as conditioned Findings The request meets the intent of the Downtown Design Guidelines Attachments Application Form/Elevation Drawing JUN-15-01 02 40 PM CHAMBER1OFICOMMERCE 6124394035 P 02 06,15/2001 09 40 4208018 CITY CF STILLWq—ER FAC,� 0c _ Csse No, Date Filed 1 0 • • • Raaeipt No Fee: $25.00 DESIGN REVIEW APPLICATION FORM COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT DEPARTMENT c1TY OF STILLWATER 316 NORTH FOURTH STREET STA,LWATER, MN 55082 The applicant is responsible for the completeness and accuracy dell forms and supporting nsaterill submitted b eonrsecdon with any application All supporting material A e photos, sketches, etc.) submitted with application becomes the property of the City of Stillwater Ads of Pali cot PROPERTY IDENTIFICATION Assessor's Parcel No _ . Zoning District Description of Project U a-1/ •I hereby state the foregoing statements end a date, Information and evidence submlfted herewith in eA mapeete, to the best of my knowledge end belief, true end correct 1 further certify l will comply with the permit if f le granted and used • Property► Owner Mailing Address City state Zip Telephone No Liinigure Prlae t 8wptember 16, 1988 Representative I Zae. `t ` Melling Address SO Y. 5/ Ce city state zip 51 1 pin/ L Telephone No "V3 —5 66/ sistutt62Tehier.te___ Y JUN-15-01 02 40 PM CHAMBERIOF1COMMERCE 6124394035 P 03 • • • ftftft*a.„ is Lin.....•••=s-00-06 '1 I It i • • • te gu• d 4 .A. cil 1 21 4 n .41 41 le . r o " i a N In 3 -st •• "NI 3 Z .2 tri 21 'r a .gnu faM c� b0 d S£01P6£4ZT9 30N3WWOOTdOT2138WHH3 Wd Tb LO Te-ST -Nff • • 6124394/335 Greater Stillwater Ch • mbar of Commerce 201 South Main Street • • • H P C APPLICATION REVIEW FORM CASE NO DR/01-27 Hentage Preservation Date July 2, 2001 Project Location 126 South Main Street Comprehensive Plan Distnct Central Business District Zoning Distnct CBD Applicant's Name Matt Fuir, representing Netasol Type of Application Design Review Project Descnption Design review of an exterior sign Discussion The applicant is requesting design approval of a 3 foot by 8 foot wooden sign for a computer networks business, Netasol The sign will have blue lettering for "Netasol" and black lettering for "Networks" with a gold strip, all on a white background One sign is permitted by the sign ordinance The attached drawing shows two signs, one on the parapet and one at the door entrance The door entrance sign will have to be removed, the address will stay Conditions of Approval 1 No additional signage is allowed 2 Revisions to the approved sign shall be reviewed and approved by the Heritage Preservation Commission 3 Recommendation Approval as conditioned Findings The request meets the intent of the Downtown Design Guidelines Attachments Application Form/Sign Illustration • r Case No t" 71, Date Filed Receipt No SO 9 41 Fee $25 0( DESIGN REVIEW APPLICATION FORM COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT DEPARTMENT CITY OF STILLWATER 216 NORTH FOURTH STREET STILLWATER, MN 55082 The applicant is responsible for the completeness and accuracy of all forms and supporting material submitted in connection with any application All supporting material (i e photos, sketches, etc) submitted with application becomes the property of the City of Stillwater PROPERTY IDENTIFICATION I Z 6 S OL., k IN c�� 5}r c-1 Assessor's Parcel No • Zomng Distnct CB p Descnption of Project N� • Address of Project "I hereby state the foregoing statements and all data, information and evidence submitted herewith in all respects, to the best of my knowledge and belief, true and correct I further certify I will comply with the permit if it is granted and used " Property Owner Al c yi,L 1n20 A JiJ 4 6411Yglaepresentative Mailmg Address I (fi CAS+ elthS+ri 4-- S l- City State Zip . Ii (1 Wk kf . !h N S.SDB r_ Telephone No t$ t- — G/ 3 — y6 ZZ- Signature Revised September 16, 1998 Mailmg Address / Z 6 SD o f 5c7/ Sir` City State Zip ( i 614 k; t /1% Telephone No 6 Ss - 7 7.S Signature A Netasol Networks, Inc. 126 South Second Street Stillwater, MN 55082 • • Netasol Building Sign Netas®I 12S S 2ea Street • • H P C APPLICATION REVIEW FORM CASE NO DR/01-28 Hentage Preservation Date July 2, 2001 Project Location 503 North Main Street Comprehensive Plan Distnct Central Business District Zoning Distract CBD Applicant's Name Perry Carlson Type of Application Design Review Project Descnption Design review of extenor signage for Carlson's Fine Woodworking Discussion The applicant is requesting design approval of a 2 foot by 20 foot hand carved sign The lettering would be wooden, in earth tone colors, on a background that would be rough saw cedar The sign will be installed in the same place as the existing sign It will not be lit Conditions of Approval 1 No additional signage 2 All revisions to approved sign shall be reviewed and approved by the Heritage Preservation Commission Recommendation Approval as conditioned Findings The request meets the intent of the Downtown Design Guidelines Attachments Application Form/Sign Drawing • Case No Date Filed Receipt No Fee* $25 00 DESIGN REVIEW APPLICATION FORM COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT DEPARTMENT CITY OF STILLWATER 216 NORTH FOURTH STREET STILLWATER, MN 55082 The applicant is responsible for the completeness and accuracy of all forms and supporting material submitted in connection with any application All supporting material (i e photos, sketches, etc) submitted with application becomes the property of the City of Stillwater PROPERTY IDENTIFICATION Address of Project S 03 rrNo_ o N S-'s Assessor's Parcel No • Zoning District Descnption of Project • "I hereby state the foregoing statements and all data, information and evidence submitted herewith in all respects, to the best of my knowledge and belief, true and correct I further certify I will comply with the permit if it is granted and used " Property Owner P 1-1 Mailing Address City State Zip Telephone No Signature Revised September 16, 1998 Representative P-Pv-r' Cc&.cLSO rf..) Mailing Address5S V % `- -4-5e & h-3tetz DR 411 City State Zip Nork O4.,145, AAA). 5-S12-1 Telephone No (,\i - D O2 -1'"1 TS Signature L i • • BEFORE a Joseph -Wolf -Brewery 402 South Main Street —Stillwater, Minnesota 55082- - THE BREMERS St Paul, Minnesota Developer May 25 2001 r "9 WCL ASSOCIATES INC Architecture Interior PROPOSED BUILDING ELEVATION - SOUTH MAIN STREET 11111111 1111- I E.11 , 17 im-"" t ta•-• ' - v,„-;-;.; fit • . r • 6,1:1 74-. iifirl:.1111'.1'.;:7--1111F:77.-41::::1`....„!. :1.;• : : Jr • 17", .7/f' . . • 4.z „, „ „ , s .. ;;;;;`-id.: 1 , Lc74. w 4 ,1. ^Aga; _ •e: - . • 01,4' ! , AFTER ""• off': • • ASS BEFORE 4 Joseph Wolf Brevvery , 402 South Main Street ` J —Stillwater, Minnesota 55082- - THE BREMERS St Paul, Minnesota Developer May 25 2001 L. A WCL ASSOCIATES INC Architecture Interior *--,: s }w s Y� r;. tL < .v .. 'fir a.� t ? *4' - i_. �.., �y "` ''-� '. to 'h".✓ '�3�Li. ,- .,^' f; r . .k - h { .r-y+ ,,� 'Fri+ . ",.,. '.ram may_ • '.61' , r...f; Y• "�- { 5"� ti�'rr m !`l+g �, E 4+WS. der Wyry t43:t3p„r3� r. 1Y~a.J1` - Y PROPOSED BUILDING ELEVATION AFTER OEM • General Notes 1 The entire architectural modification puts emphasis on the restoration of the design and materials of the original building facades It will remove the present inconsistent elements 2 The exterior building size, height or dimension will not be changed 3 Exterior trash area or mechanical equipments will not be visible from the street 4 Outdoor food service activities (approximately forty seats) will only be available before it gets dark Therefore, no new lighting will be added 5 Landscape will not be changed Potting flowers will be arranged outdoor as needed to complement the outdoor activities in the summer 6 Parking or pedestrian circulations will stay as existing No change will be made 7 All storefront windows are transparent • 8 Door and window frames will be wood or bronze -tone aluminum • Joseph -wolf-Brewery` 402 South Main Street Stillwater, Minnesota 55082-- - THE BREMERS St Paul, Minnesota Developer May 25 2001 POD LJ WCL ASSOCIATES INC Architecture Interior 4 9 - 'ltyC Y 6 ':''{ 1' rc'�''4 ��r� v- d� PSG 11 '''' �_ v,-.:-....-s..._--..-iet- ::: -I,-;a:,,.--7'ff_:-!,7:::---ii:c :er..,, ,.' r: ' il,r -4,0,00-11 g es " " PhD da A �' r ^`ta'� -� J-"A 'lam •.• .� .,l Metal arch railing Stone trim and railing column will match existing stone material Proposed awnings will successfully complement the architectural arch shape They will also add shade and color to the building Storefront restoration will return the facade to its original character by uncovering existing stonework Red brick will match existing brick on building to south This facade will be restored to its original stone character Simulated clay tile will be used as cap material for the parapets -Individual signage will be complementary to the overall design No signage will be internally illuminated General Notes 1 The entire architectural modification puts emphasis on the restoration of the design and materials of the original building facades It will remove the present inconsistent elements 2 The exterior building size, height or dimension will not be changed 3 Exterior trash area or mechanical equipments will not be visible from the street 4 Outdoor food service activities (approximately forty seats) will only be available before it gets dark Therefore, no new lighting will be added 5 Landscape will not be changed Potting flowers will be arranged outdoor as needed to complement the outdoor activities in the summer 6 Parking or pedestrian circulations will stay as existing No change will be made 7 All storefront windows are transparent 8 Door and window frames will be wood or bronze -tone aluminum Joseph -Wolf Brewery` , 402 South Main Street ti -Stillwater, Minnesota 55082- r THE BREMERS St Paul, Minnesota Developer May 25 2001 L. WCL ASSOCIATES INC Architecture Interior Partial existing deteriorating stone wall will be removed New metal arch railing and stone railing column will match those on the South Main Street facade Stone looking stucco will be used on the majority of this facade Stone arch entrance will match those on the South Main Street facade i!. Pedestrian -friendly pavement will serve as the walkway between the apartment entrances and the parking lot Metal arch railing and stone railing column will match those on the South Main Street facade Awnings will match those on the South Main Street facade tor I-- .▪ .-• �r �- - I, 1, Proposed patio will serve for the — private apartment Planters near the apartments will enhance the living quality PICTURES OF • JOSEPH WOLF BREWERY SITE 1, 1^ Joseph-Wolt-Breivery`, , , -_, , --_-, , 402 South Main Street ---Stillwater::MinneSota 55082- --- THE BREMERS St Paul, Minnesota Developer May 25 2001 WCL ASSOCIATES INC Architecture Interior t — ,• • "`""',••• I ',-- •-r •••• F r- ,S ".0.1 •ira'Kr.,2•X142;1-- I' '1 ••• f 3 r.---.4-4111111 7;. - • --4*r f7' .2„ tkli• 7L4-:-.:"4:711-41:..11:',..,,,l,---.:71 4.11;::::-+-C,'.-14'1.° ,r..e4z,,,..4,, ,,,:v.„4.,,,:..tpi71:e., 7.--7:17.--;.., .:::::::::7.:: redr,4-1r 10..:-it.t.t.- L.:A.4'i C-4s ..::,.„541 .__%s't 4,'4elt-'4'641--6:.141,-,--TI., .1/ -,71.--,Rc" -v—,,,i-; .,'•4,, - —. „ - m, '-."' ''- 1?..'17..'1, Y.- ,...' ..-..' -*.:,' '',- -.'-vi'' '''. ,.. ' -e• ---•-• ..,g‘ -`',K-,- - oik - .., ---.--C: ' N. ...,i ..4, '......."-'' X /WL A., ''--.4,71,71t1"".1,1571c-, te4 .'"',..- "--- 1 ''' ",- 1,"i ,''' "' A '-' -}C k.'," -.-, ri-.,_--..,,T.,, -r--,.. A 5_v-__.-.1.•?t, 74' , ' • : t ' ' ' ' ' = • e littL'';tti :- : 1 -1 - - - - : : ,t7...:. f•-i ,.;' ' -In:=':.? .7' r:-:V,....z____._2— n',!Z : . -.”-r•••-71.,, -,- - sr,--,, - ' :.., , 05. - -,•,3",..-.-,6a...-, .0... --...-2.-•=f. ,..5.'•"'"---'' - •-.4 7.. _ . ,.... , .., ....f..,-,.... •-•'' — l'",. .- - ..- PICTURES OF * JOSEPH WOLF BREWERY SITE • • Joseph-WolfBrewe r _ 402 South Main Street Minnesota 55082- - - THE BREMERS St Paul, Minnesota Developer May 25 2001 WCL ASSOCIATES INC Architecture Interior -2- r zr ry_ r , Atigff c.411 PICTURES OF • SURROUNDING BUILDINGS Joseph -Wolf Brewery 402 South Main Street —Stillwater, Minnesota 55082-- THE BREMERS St Paul, Minnesota Developer May 25 2001 WCL ASSOCIATES INC Architecture Interior -e,, yy �F A,-, i 1 h , .a p t. �, ' c C, � _ ! > i axe ';ilie _ '� !_.taco. J :..q....7,-F......1,17LiT::,....-"iiilt,, �Y . s i E s u s�.,�� ,...,-- ..n,,,,b.1,74,... , ::, .::,:,-;:isi,,,E.- ,..”-- - , :: __,.,,_ , t --.-4„,,- 47'emu ...• — -+'T { a S aA L_ y "'",„- " J� r - r ,4z •fir_.- a L " f 9 F y, 4, k.- L ri,1.,, 4k ry L•: _ +' 5 ` - . .`f s \"`` ;LA., t '� J" �,...5 "" R Y'Pia; wcn '� ems-. '� L' ..''Fj.. ,a�irr•�.- %'-3�h,� f",,a7 {�_u i. e*�i'.1,r,s y.3.� .,'1:ri�`' ,��^'.. • •>:.r.• :,?:..'3�in� • • • Joseph Wolf Brewer, RENOVATION DESCRIPTION AREA 1 RETAIL 1 332 SF 2 RESTAURANT 5 244 SF 3 WINE AND CHEESE SPIRIT 1 244 SF 4 GRUMPY STEVE'S COFFEE 1 196 SF 5 CAVES AND RELATED SPACES 6 000 SF 6 OFFICE 2nd Floor 600 SF 7 OFFICE 2nd Floor 1 190 SF 8 APARTMENTS (2) 1 281 SF 9 STUDIO APARTMENT (1) 480 SF 10 ONE BEDROOM APARTMENTS (3) 1 728 SF 11 TWO BEDROOM APARTMENTS (3) 2 592 SF 12 LOFT APARTMENT (2) 1 480 SF 13 TWO LEVEL APARTMENT (1) 1 365 SF PROJECT TOTAL AREA 25 732 SF y '= f S} F� J y"j --..- M _, • First Floor Plan Scale None Mezzanine Area THE BREMERS St Paul Minnesota L A Joseph Wolf Brewery WCL ASSOCIATES INC Developer Stillwater, Minnesota Architecture Interiors • Joseph WbWRrewery.=w RENOVATION DESCRIPTION AREA 1 RETAIL 1 332 SF 2 RESTAURANT 5 244 SF 3 WINE AND CHEESE SPIRIT 1 244 SF 4 GRUMPY STEVE'S COFFEE 1 196 SF 5 CAVES AND RELATED SPACES 6,000 SF 6 OFFICE 2nd Floor 600 SF 7 OFFICE 2nd Floor 1 190 SF 8 APARTMENTS (2) 1 281 SF 9 STUDIO APARTMENT (1) 480 SF 10 ONE BEDROOM APARTMENTS (3) 1 728 SF 11 TWO BEDROOM APARTMENTS (3) 2 592 SF 12 LOFT APARTMENT (2) 1,480 SF 13 TWO LEVEL APARTMENT (1) 1 365 SF PROJECT TOTAL AREA 25 732 SF Second Floor Plan Scale None THE BREMERS St Paul Minnesota Joseph Wolf Brewery WCL ASSOCIATES INC Developer Stillwater, Minnesota Architecture Interiors • --:Tosersh i Volf Brewer RENOVATION DESCRIPTION AREA 1 RETAIL 1 332 SF 2 RESTAURANT 5 244 SF 3 WINE AND CHEESE SPIRIT 1 244 SF 4 GRUMPY STEVE S COFFEE 1 196 SF 5 CAVES AND RELATED SPACES 6 000 SF 6 OFFICE 2nd Floor 600 SF 7 OFFICE 2nd Floor 1 190 SF 8 APARTMENTS (2) 1 281 SF 9 STUDIO APARTMENT (1) 480 SF 10 ONE BEDROOM APARTMENTS (3) 1 728 SF 11 TWO BEDROOM APARTMENTS (3) 2 592 SF 12 LOFT APARTMENT (2) 1 480 SF 13 TWO LEVEL APARTMENT (1) 1,365 SF PROJECT TOTAL AREA 25,732 SF Third Floor Plan Scale None THE BREMERS St Paul Minnesota C A Joseph Wolf Brewery WCL ASSOCIATES INC Developer Stillwater, Minnesota Archltecture Interiors