Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout1995-11-07 HPC MINHERITAGE PRESERVATION COMMISSION Nov. 7, 1994 Present: Jeff Johnson, Jay Michels and Roger Tomten. Howard Lieberman arrived at 7:25 p.m. Others: Ann Terwedo, planning department Absent: Kathy Francis, Robert Kimbrel and Brent Peterson Mr. Johnson called the meeting to order at 7:05 p.m. No, SUP/V/94-61, Design review for a new retail structure and variance to the sign ordinance for placement of two signs east of Cub Foods and south of Curve Crest Blvd. in the BP-C, Business Park - Commercial District. Jim Kellison, applicant. Mr. Kellison appeared representing Andy Kass of Sutler's Liquor, who has a purchase agreement on two lots, a 45,552 square -foot site, where he is proposing to construct a 6,050 square -foot liquor store. Regarding the need for a variance to the sign ordinance, Ms. Terwedo noted that two signs are proposed, a 6'x'7'x3' freestanding sign adjacent to the drive and a sign in the entry way gable; one sign is allowed by ordinance. Both signs meet ordinance requirements individually, fit in well architecturally and are low in design in keeping with the design of the building. It also was noted that a precedent for allowing two signs in the area could be found in Brine's Meat Market. Most of the discussion centered on the roof element. Mr. Tomten said he would like to see the roof design carried all the way around the building. Mr. Kellison noted that to do so would involve considerable cost, and would be impractical if the building is expanded in the future. Mr. Kellison also noted that the trees and elevation of the site screen the roof details from view along the west, rear property line. Mr. Kellison said Mr. Kass had no objection to the nine recommended conditions of approval. Mr. Johnson moved approval with an added clarification that the color and materials used on the south and west portions of the building be consistent with the front of the building. Mr. Michels seconded the motion. Mr. Tomten suggested adding an additional condition of approval -- that the roof element be made continuous all the way around the building. Mr. Kellison again said that would be impractical and too costly. He noted that this proposal was consistent with the Stillwater Veterinary Clinic building which presents different views from the front and back of the structure. He also noted that major design elements of the building are complete and the traffic to the rear of the building will not be public traffic. Mr. Johnson's motion passed 3-1, with Mr. Johnson, Michels and Lieberman voting in favor and Mr. Tomten against. Case No. DR 4-1 . Design review for a facade alteration and signage for a facade creation at 330 N. Main in the Downtown Plan Area. Brent P. Thoreson, applicant. Mr. Thoreson appeared on his own behalf. He said he was led to believe that anything he did to enhance the building appearance would be a plus. If the request is denied, he said he would be back at "square 1." He likened the project to "making a silk purse of a pig's ear." Mr. Johnson said that as proposed, the design gives the building a cottage - type look, rather than an old store look. He suggested raising the awning/mansard and using transoms and bigger doors and windows to develop more of a storefront look. He noted that developing height and the vertical elements fits better with the scale of the building. The Thoresons agreed that the suggested design modifications might work. Mr. Johson moved to deny the plan, with the Thoresons to submit new design plans to Ann Terwedo and him for review. Mr. Michels seconded the motion; all in favor. Case No. SLIP/94.62. Design review for an outside storage area along with facade modifications for a retail store at 13900 N. 60th Street in the BP- C, Business Park, Commercial District. Anthony Weinand, applicant. Mr. Weinand appeared on his own behalf. Mr. Weinand said the building wi be used for display and sale of fireplaces and materials. About 10 fireplaces will be on display in the store. The facade of the main building will be stone and a gabled roof will be added. The building materials will be stored in the rear. The storage area will be enclosed in six-foot high fencing and possibly an additional two -feet of security wire. Mr. Johnson questioned plans for repair and landscaping of the parking lot and also lighting of the parking lot. Mr. Weinand said the lot would be repaired, bermed and landscaped. Mr. Johnson moved to approve the request with the five recommended conditions and a clarification of the curb and gutter standards for the parking lot. Mr. Michels second the motion; all in favor. fproy�i,l gf minUjes. The minutes of Oct. 3, 1994, were approved with three corrections. Soul tore project. Craig Campbell gave a brief presentation regarding his proposal to have sculpture exhibits on the lawn of the Stillwater Public Library. He currently is seeking grant money for the project and has talked with four artists who would be willing to have their work on display for a period of two months. He said the project was an educational endeavor that he hoped to build upon. There would be no permanent foundation for the exhibits. Commission members gave their enthusiastic support to the project. Other business. It was noted that Pat Qualey has resigned from the commission; it was agreed to present her with a plaque of appreciation for her service on the commission. Regarding Ms. Qualey's replacement, Mr. Johnson said he would like to have someone with more professional background. It was agreed that Todd Remington or Wayne Branham be contacting regarding their interest in appointment. Mr. Tomten gave a brief update on the.last Highway 36/bridge meeting. Jeff Johnson moved to adjourn the meeting at 9 p.m. Jay Michels seconded the motion; all in favor.