Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout2008-08-04 HPC Packet water Heritage Preservation Commission Notice of Meeting Monday, August 4, 2008 The regular meeting will begin at 7 p.m., Monday, August 4, 2008, in the Council Chambers of Stillwater City Hall, 216 North Fourth Street. AGENDA 1. CALL TO ORDER 2. APPROVAL OF July 7, 2008 MINUTES 3. PUBLIC HEARINGS 3.01 Case No. DEM/08-37. A demolition request for a single, detached garage located at 921 South 5th Street in the RB, Two Family Residential District. Mark and Kristine Olson, applicants. 3.02 Case No. DEM/08-38. A demolition request for a garage located at 502 West Laurel Street in the RB, Two Family Residential District. Robert and Nora Hahn, applicants. 3.03 Case No. DEM/08-39. A demolition request for garage located at 1104 5th St So in the RB, Two Family Residential District. Kevin Riley, representing, Stephen and Beverly Diemler, applicant. 4. NEW BUSINESS 5. DESIGN REVIEWS 5.01 Case No. DR/08-40. Design review for fac;ade renovation, window replacement, new entry and walk-up window located at 132 South Main Street in the CBD, Central Business District. Mark S. Balay Architects, applicant. 6. OTHER BUSINESS 6.01 Heirloom Home Program update and review 6.02 Demolition Ordinance Review 6.03 Update on Municipal Parking Ramp 7. ADJOURN City of Stillwater Heritage Preservation Commission Monday, July 7,2008 Present: Phil Eastwood, Gayle Hudak, Jeff Johnson, Roger Tomten and Scott Zahren Staff present: Planner Mike Pogge Vice Chair Johnson called the meeting to order at 7 p.m. Approval of minutes: Mr. Zahren, seconded by Mr. Eastwood, moved approval of the minutes of June 2, 2008. Motion passed unanimously. PUBLIC HEARINGS Case No. DR/08-35. Design review for new construction in the Neighborhood Conservation District located at 1221 N Broadway Street in the RB, Two Family Residential District. Sala Architects, representing Steven and Jessica Meletiou, applicant. Tim Old of SALA Architects was present; he noted that a three-dimensional model of the site was available, as well as color studies that were not in the original application packet. It was noted the site is currently a vacant lot. Mr. Johnson pointed out the intent of the Conservation District was established primarily to provide uniformity to infills in historic neighborhoods so the infill structure continues to support the historic community in respect to massing, scaling and design. Mr. Johnson noted that this site is somewhat unique in that it is located on the east side of Broadway where there are no historic homes; the homes that are there have been built in the last 40 years or so, as opposed to the west side of the street where there are several older homes. Mr. Johnson asked the architect about plans to address the slope of the site. Mr. Old stated there is quite a bit of change in the slope of the site due to the condition of the quarry. The house itself, he said, sits pretty much up on the street level, with the walkout located on an existing shelf that lies below that, so the house nestles into the existing topography. Mr. Old noted there is a 30-foot setback from the bluffline as required; he said retaining walls will be minimal. Mr. Johnson pointed out that due to the topography there will be minimal impact on the view from the street. Mr. Johnson asked if the applicant was aware of the suggested conditions of approval, specifically the submission of a tree removal plan. Mr. Johnson opened the public hearing. A realtor with Caldwell, Banker, Burnet, who has the house next door listed, asked about the setback from the bluff. Mr. Pogge noted in the discussion at the table that the required setback from the bluff in this area is 30 feet, not 40 feet as this is not in the St. Croix River overlay district, and reaffirmed the 30 foot setback. There was a question about an existing house and driveway. It was noted the current owner is building a driveway to serve the new lot. No other comments were received, and the hearing was closed. Mr. Eastwood moved to approve as conditioned, with the additional condition that final colors and materials be submitted to staff for approval and that a tree removal plan for the entire site be submitted to staff for approval as well. Mr. Zahren seconded the motion. Mr. Tomten said he thought the applicants had done a good job of following the guidelines and that the design fits well with the natural grades of the site. Motion passed unanimously. 1 City of Stillwater Heritage Preservation Commission Monday, July 7,2008 DESIGN REVIEWS Case No. DR/08-31. Design review for the installation of a new sign for Paws and Claws Daycare located at 1900 Tower Drive in the BP-O, Business Park Office District. Daniel Lodge, applicant. The applicant was not present. In the staff report, it was noted the proposed sign meets the code/ordinance requirements. Mr. Zahren, seconded by Mr. Eastwood, moved approval as submitted and conditioned. Motion passed unanimously. Case No. DR/08-32. Design review of a store faQade located at 108 South Main Street in the CBD, Central Business District. Dan Roettger, representing Mike Lynskey, applicant. Dan Roettger was present. Mr. Johnson reviewed the proposed changes, which include removal of the brick veneer and aluminum-framed windows and bringing the front elevation out flush with the front of the building. There was discussion about the proposal for a take-out opening in the south window. Mr. Johnson said he thought it looked somewhat awkward to have the window cut up on a storefront where there would normally be a rhythm of windows; he also referred to staff's concern about traffic with the relatively narrow sidewalk. Mr. Tomten suggested the possibility of doing gliding windows that open right to the sidewalk and said he was somewhat bothered by trying to put in a small operating window with a wooden frame breaking up the larger window opening. Mr. Roettger suggested running horizontal boards all away across and centering the opening. Mr. Tomten asked if the window could be full width; Mr. Roettger stated they could special order the window. Mr. Johnson pointed out in the historical photo, there were two large windows and a larger entryway, so the front elevation was almost broken into thirds. Using that perspective, Mr. Johnson suggested there could be a wider entryway, which would provide some opportunity to have the service window open into the entry rather than out on the sidewalk front, or perhaps have a double-door entry with one of the doors serving as the service window. Mr. Roettger agreed that Mr. Johnson's concept could be workable. Several members pointed out that concept might affect the interior functions. Mr. Zahren questioned having the entrance and service window/door functions in that close a proximity. Mr. Johnson suggested another possibility would be to have the service window as proposed in the application look more like a door, narrower and all the way to the ground, rather than a display window. Mr. Tomten noted that the door concept could change the symmetry of the kick plate, as well as the window openings. Mr. Johnson pointed out that the entryway could be shifted slightly to restore the symmetry. Shifting the entryway could also impact the interior functions, it was noted. Mr. Zahren asked if there was any way to make the service window less obtrusive; Mr. Johnson suggested using a bronze aluminum glazing around the window opening rather than wood columns/framing as proposed. Mr. Tomten said he liked the wood panels below and wood framing between the four major panes to accentuate the wood verticals and minimize the steel framing, the operational part of the service window bay. Mr. Johnson asked about the main entry door; Mr. Roettger said it would be the same as the Main Street Square, bronze colored; Mr. Johnson said the use of the wider frame is preferred to provide a more traditional look. Mr. Johnson asked about colors; Mr. Roettger said staff preferred colors to match the adjacent building to the south. The awning will remain unchanged, it was noted. Mr. Tomten moved to approve the application as conditioned with the additional conditions: any of the divided lights in the service window bay be held to as minimal a width as possible; that 2 City of Stillwater Heritage Preservation Commission Monday, July 7,2008 the vertical elements dividing the five storefront bays continue to be the dominant vertical element on the storefront; that the applicant submit production drawings to staff for review before going ahead with the manufacturing of storefront windows; that the door frames should pick up on the historical proportion of a full light door and the heads and styles be of at least a 6" dimension and the bottom rail 1 0-12"; and that color samples be provided to staff for review. Mr. Johnson clarified that the kick panels and other elements of the building to the south will be carried through on this storefront. Mr. Zahren seconded the motion; motion passed unanimously. Case No. DR/08-33. Design review of a store faQade located at 14480 60th Street North in the BP-C, Business Park Commercial District. Tim Keenan, applicant. Luke Riley, Riley Construction, was present representing the applicant. Mr. Riley briefly explained proposed changes to the mansard/roof; he said two new windows may be added, but no other changes to the windows are planned at this time. On a question by Mr. Johnson, Mr. Riley stated he was not sure of the building owner's signage plans. Mr. Johnson asked about the columns; Mr. Riley stated those are actually roof drains that will be copper color to match the mansard, spaced to appear as an architectural element. Mr. Johnson moved to approve as submitted and conditioned. Ms. Hudak seconded the motion. Mr. Tomten asked about lighting. Mr. Riley stated when the parking lot was resurfaced, proper lighting was installed; he said they plan to install recessed can lights underneath the mansard, canopy entrance and school gable. Mr. Johnson stated his motion stood with the clarification that there will be recessed lighting under the mansard. Motion passed unanimously. Case No. DR/08-34. Design review of a sign located at 901 3rd St S. in the RB, Two Family Residential District. Mark Weyer, applicant. The applicant was present. Mr. Eastwood asked about colors. Mr. Weyer stated the windows are basically white, with red brick on the building, along with green and an off-white trim around the green part of the roof. He said the original plans for the signage called for a white background with green lettering; he said another option would be an off-white/antique white. Mr. Johnson pointed out there is space along side of the door that might allow the signage to be stacked, more like a professional building would have, rather than up on the parapet. Mr. Johnson said he thought the proposed placement was a bit awkward; he suggested the signage should be closer to the door, more of identification at the door, noting the building does carry an address which is the primary locator. Mr. Weyer said he would be OK with a corner location. Mr. Eastwood suggested sliding the signage over on the parapet so it is above the entrance. Mr. Weyer said he chose the proposed location because that is where the previous sign was located, and the color is different. Mr. Zahren agreed it seems to make more sense to move the signage over as suggested by Mr. Eastwood. Mr. Johnson said if the signage is placed above the entry, it should be no wider than an existing masonry line on the building or it would appear clumsy at that location, too. Mr. Johnson moved to approve the sign color of antique white background with green lettering and a green band to separate the individual signs from each other, with the signage to be placed on the masonry directly above the door on the Churchill elevation, confined within the vertical line of the masonry of the door opening below, or placed between the door opening and 3 City of Stillwater Heritage Preservation Commission Monday, July 7,2008 the first window on the Churchill Street side. Mr. Eastwood seconded the motion. Mr. Johnson clarified there will be no lighting. Motion passed unanimously. Case No. DR/08-36. Design review of signage for the building located at 232 N. Main Street in the CBD, Central Business District. Dana Daniels and Jan Dornself, applicant. The applicants were present. Mr. Eastwood pointed out the address is 232 North Main Street, not South Main Street, as indicated in the agenda packet. Mr. Johnson noted the proposal involves using existing post and rebuilding the sign frame. Mr. Johnson clarified there would be no lighting, other than the existing ground lights. Mr. Tomten pointed out that the existing light fixture throws a wide beam and suggested adding a side shield to narrow the beam and hide the light source. Mr. Johnson suggested another possibility for lighting would be to have a projecting arm above the sign frame. It was noted the building will not house retail space; it will serve as a design studi%ffice. Mr. Johnson stated if the applicant has some different lighting ideas, plans could be brought back to the HPC or reviewed by staff. Mr. Johnson moved to approve the sign as submitted with repair to the box frame and lighting utilizing the existing ground lighting, provided shields are added to the fixtures, or replacing the ground lighting with projecting arms from the top of the sign box, with details presented to staff for review and approval. Mr. Zahren seconded the motion. Mr. Tomten suggested that perhaps small LED lights could be installed and concealed within the top cap of the sign itself. Motion passed unanimously. OTHER BUSINESS Mr. Pogge stated that historically there was a plaque on the flag pole in Lowell Park. He said the intent was to replicate the plaque. Using a sculpted Lions Club head, the cost of a new plaque would be about $3,000, without a sculpted head, the cost would be about $800, he said. He said the City and Lions Club would split the cost, based on the $800 cost. Mr. Pogge said the question to the HPC is whether to contribute $1,500 of HPC funds to replicate the plaque. He said verbiage would be added to indicate this is not the original plaque, otherwise the original will be replicated as much as possible. It was noted the $1,500, part of a lawsuit settlement, can be used basically for preservation purposes. It was agreed to have Mr. Pogge obtain more information, and also contact the Lions Club regarding additional cost participation. Mr. Tomten raised the issue of the lights at the Shirt Factory and asked that the wattage be confirmed or the owners be contacted about utilizing different bulbs. Ms. Hudak, seconded by Mr. Tomten, moved to adjourn at 8:35 p.m. Respectfully submitted, Sharon Baker Recording Secretary 4 Heritage Preservation Commission DATE: CASE NO.: 08-37 July 31, 2008 APPLICANT: Mark and Kristine Olson REQUEST: Demolition Permit for a garage LOCATION: 921 5th St N HPC PUBLIC HEARING DATE: August 4,2008 PREPARED BY: Michel Pogge, City Planner~~ BACKGROUND Mark and Kristine Olson, property owners of 921 5th St N, are requesting a demolition permit for an existing garage on their property. The exact age of the garage could not be determined and a building permit for the structure was not on file at the City office; however, the property owner believes that the garage is older than 50 years of age. After reviewing the structure, style, and condition of the structure it leads staff to conclude that the garage is more than 50 years old. Since the garage appears to be over 50 years old, it is by definition considered to have potential historic significance. Consequently, the Heritage "" ._~ Preservation Conmlission is required to review the demolition request. This site is in the Conservation Design District; however, since the main structure is not being removed a new garage would not be subject to the infill design criteria. SPECIFIC REQUEST The applicant requests approval of a permit to demolish the existing garage. 921 5th St N Olson Garage Demolition Permit Page 2 EVALUATION OF REQUEST Chapter 34, Section 34-4 of the City Code states that "if buildings or structures are determined by the community development director to be historic or potentially historic, the application must be sent to the [heritage preservation] commission for review... Buildings or structures determined nonhistoric must be referred to the building official for issuance of a demolition permit." A "nonhistoric structure or building" is defined by Chapter 34, Section 34-2 as a structure or building less than 50 years old... Since the age of the structure could not be determined it is assumed that the garage is over 50 years old; therefore, it is of potential historic significance and requires review by the Heritage Preservation Commission. Section 34-5 of the City Code lists nine items which must be considered prior to approval of a demolition permit by the Commission. (1) A map showing the location of the building or structure to be demolished on its property and with reference to neighborhood properties; This information is included in the attached application. (2) A legal description of property and owner of record; The legal description of the property was included in the application. (3) Photographs of all building elevations; Photos from various angles are included in the packet. (4) A description of the building or structure or portion of building or structure to be demolished; The existing garage is an approximately 17' by 20' garage. The applicant has indicated in the cover letter that the entire garage structure is proposed to be demolished. (5) The reason for the proposed demolition and data supporting the reason, including, where applicable, data sufficient to establish any economic justification for demolition; The applicant stated in the cover letter that" our contractor does not believe that it is economically feasible to rehabilitate the garage". However, no bid for renovating the garage was included in the application material. The applicant states in their application that the structure is unusable and could pose a safety hazard if it is not replaced. (6) Proposed plans and schedule for reuse of the property on which the building or structure to be demolished is located; The applicant has indicated that they wish to build a two stall garage with attic storage. No plans were submitted for the new garage. 921 5th St N Olson Garage Demolition Pennit Page 3 (7) Relation of demolition and future site use to the comprehensive plan and zoning requirements; The current comprehensive plan land use designation for the property is Single Family Small Lot and is zoned RB, two-family residential. Once the current garage is demolished the proposed garage would be required to meet all of the current requirements of the zoning code. This site is in the Conservation Design District; however, since the main structure is not being removed a new garage would not be subject to the infill design criteria. (8) A description of alternatives to the demolition; The applicant has provided no alternatives to demolition. Staff would offer that restoration of a structure is always an alternative to demolition. (9) Evidence that the building or structure has been advertised for sale for restoration or reuse and that sale for restoration or reuse is not economically feasible. The applicant has indicated that they have advertised the garage in the Stillwater Gazette on July 10, 11, and 14, 2008. A copy of the ad proof has been included in your packet. AL TERNATIVES The Heritage Preservation Commission has the following options: 1. Approve the demolition permit as presented. 2. Deny the demolition permit if the applicant has not proved the necessity for demolishing the garage or if the Commission believes there are alternates to demolishing the garage. 3. Continue the public hearing until the September 3, 2008 Commission meeting. The 60 day decision deadline for the request is September 16, 2008. RECOMMENDATION Review and take action on the request. attachment: Application and supporting documents from the applicant Heritage Preservation Commission Demolition Request Permit Demolition Permit No. Fee $100* Receipt No. Address of Project: ?1../ ~lt S.I,'tl~-Jh Parcel No.: J?-.O:O 2- D21UoSCf Lot OJ3 Block c.t) 8 Subdivision ~taf{t;s & IlI:s APPlicant:~ (f()~'(}t.. 0$0>'1 Address: On J :Jh ')j. U.' ~d/W';t-lwrelePhone No.: ~5/.J~'30 -/;J,.oj +6J ~ ) , - Owner if different than Applicant: Address: Telephone No. Type of Structure: S''jl, dJ.tl(ch,,J 0',)l S' Age of Structure: .~,. )f.s~ondition of Structure: Intended Use of Site after Demolition :J::>olll.b k.. J dt -I'tchtJ 0 ~t.... 4bU- 1//(# ( Date -:7 ff/ a" Signature of Owner Date *After Heritage Preservation approval, there is a 10-day appeal period. Once the la-day appeal period has ended, the applicant will receive a design review permit which must be signed and submitted to the City to obtain the required building permits. A building permit must be obtained with the City of Stillwater Building Department. The fee for the building permit is based on the valuation of the demolition project. Office Use Only HPC Review Date: o Approved o Denied City Planner/Community Development Director Date July 15, 2008 City of Stillwater Heritage Preservation Commission 216 Fourth Street North Stillwater. MN 55082 Dear Members of the Heritage Preservation Commission: This letter is a request to tear down and replace our single, detached garage with a double, detached garage. We are uncertain of the year the garage was built due to a lack of permit information but believe that it is over fifty years old. We have been unable to locate any information on the previous ovvners or the builder of the garage. "rhe garage is located on our property at 921 5th Street North in Stillwater. 'rhe legal description is as follo\\s: the West 100 feet of the South Y2 of Lot 3 and the West 100 feet of Lot 4, Block 8, Staples and May's Addition in Stillwater. Washington County, Minnesota (parcel number 28(3020210054). Mark and Kristine Olson are the owners of record. It is a single car, detached garage with wood siding. There are numerous cracks and holes in the foundation and the wood near the foundation is beginning to rot. The entire structure is leaning to the north. Our contractor does not believe that it is economically feasible to rehabilitate the garage. We would like to replace it with a two car detached garage with an attic storage area in the same location on our property. The garage was advertised for sale in the Stillwater Gaz&tfe on luly1 Oth, 11 th and 14th. The advertisement did not generate any response. We h~V:~attached a map showing the location of our property and gatage, photographs of:~~ gar:age, the garage order for the new garage, and evidence of the advertisement. We feel that our garage in its current state is unusable and could pose a safety hazard if it is not replaced. Please feel free to contact us at 651-430-120 I if have any further questions. J?krL 1Z2ttA- Mark Olson ArcIMS Viewer u: 924 9ZO. 302 ~. I , I Tl]l~it~~Qf.J~fe1.mrc,JiiM~~ llJO o l() m Q It) 2"14 o II) .... (I) Q Q II) II) .... .... J / lOti httn:/ /www.datafinder.org/website/DF_WashingtonCounty/Parcels/MapFrame.htm Page 1 of 1 64.6, lfU I " '. '....N~ 64.4 1lO6 7/18/2008 STILLWATER GAZETTE AD INSERTION ORDER Salesperson: CINDY LEHMANN Printed at 07/08/08 13:54 ------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Acct#: 286574 KRISTINE OLSON 921 5TH ST. N. STILLWATER MN 55082 Contact: NATALIE COLEMAN Phone: (651)430-1201 Fax#: Email: Ad#: 851040 Start: 07/09/08 Times Ord: 3 STD 1.00 X Rate: COP1 Class: 3260 MISC. FOR SALE Descript: DETACHED 1 CAR GARAGE, $5 Given by: ***************************** Created: clehm 07/08/08 13:51 Last Changed: clehm 07/08/08 13:53 Status: N Stop: Times 3.00 07/14/08 Run: * * * * Words: 9 Agency: ------------------------------------------------------------------------------- PUB ZONE ED TP START INS STOP S2 SV 97 S 07/10,11,14 WIKI A 94 S 07/09 SMTWTFS ---------------------------------------~--------------------------------------- Detached 1 car Garage, $500, upick up, 651-430-1201 FIRST LANDMARK BUILDERS, INC. 255 E. ROSELAWN AVE.. SUITE 48 MAPLEWOOO, MINNESOTA 55117 (651) 699~3135 eFAX(651) 699-9740 GARAGE ORDER CONTRACT /.'i. ) ~' ,!. J ~;,: ".~'\,: ii, ~"~.),,. Ot.l;/f2"c, - '. ~ e:' . / .... /. . -,,~ .'" ~ '1 LANDMARK BUILDERS, INC. Job 1':10. '~,l' (j. ' 11.,,,, '. P, Purchaser I! i, /l,\'\ ,/. ' ___ f ,~< . /""', 'l' I). t Address'll;' l 11'f7} /'}l-' "), ,',' '~'kJ\"" , f. . '" >-,,-tl~'I\ '\/".. ~n.~""",~: _ /.---;;""', f f:--) ,.Zip Code''') ,~, Y.,,' .'..,..-.; Deliver to City Zip Code 1. Size of ,Garage I.'st, ", #',1,...',.0," , ~,'i.;.,.t,,~ o ,Detached o Match Ridge , 0 .Attached o Drop Ridge Roof Style ~Gable '0 Reverse Gable , OHip o Fllit Roof Pitch fV'Ai, , .j-' ; ",.7 "/. f)('" ,J'.. ~'_ 4. Wall Sheathing: Soffit & Fascia " O.OneEnd ,0,., Wood,' . (painted by. ow. ner) , ..11,'" (~ ",O\\Two En.d"s . 'i- f' , ,Je" Aluminum OColor.J:f~-'J\(,~_f~ ',," '. . " , : - " :.,'. .,' :'..' :.... . -,: . -", " .;.. ~. -. "-", '. -. - . '. ,." O..CheCk ~ous~f': .c~lortomj~Ch hOUl;ea~ c1ose,asP()ssible Rafters ~x.". -..".",./;' ...." 't" ,'. .'., 'O..c. q~olor LIt ..K.~ ,,\-,/L1'" '. A 'L.(\'.,'I ~~~-~ Wall' Tie spacingibl~~},,.~:,~t'~~?,,,,....O.C. o Fibergliss ..\i\ Other' ' , , Manufactur!lQ Trusses't! C.C. F\Waferboard [J 1/2'Graylite 0 25/32" aildrite 0 1/2" Plywood 0 None, Studs O.C. t., "I,i 0 S'd' M t h H [)'d Donlt Match House ' :1.... _ ."' , I lrig - a c ,ouse ,ling - . ,.' . .. EkPpsu're .' o One End othEi1ds Thli exposure shown above may o 1/2 Wall g"fiul! Wall vilry,so that all rows have equal o Otlier 1 exposure when applied. , ",.I) l' L;-:t": Rake Overhang o Other ,2. Roof Sheathing Eav,e [) Plywood . Overhang r-"Waferboard , 3. Seal Down ROl.lf Shingles ' and 15 Ib Felt: o Asphalt .1\. 1:./ o Ribbed Steel (Wh - Br) ~Iass , o FluSh ,~:: 9\Rais d ~te~~ P;\I~~leBr) o Insulated o i' .! , ",.} "l Cl Notlnsulated -' " 7. Service Doorand 0 Pre-hung. Steel 0 Qw;U)tity 0 Alum. w~ap. 1, .l~ j/ , " Windows )'l.pre-hung Steel Panel ^ Quantity t ,~WOOd trim Windows: Quantity !l}~'Uri" ~" .). ,., '.. '., Painted by owner 0 Pre-hung Wood 0 'Quantity g;(2'8"03'0.~1 " · . "J:.Y,<1 Slyl4 ,.;_,~$';"':lJ;>'v.t.,t"-::1 8. CemenlSlab with TWOFootAPronq{~lncluded 9\concreteReinforcing 0 Patio sq. ft. . -'-'''' Ground Preparation "'.)1]llnc,uded o SodRemovel . . d By Purchaser. ". . :' , 0 Sidewalk sq. It For Slab Build Up 0 NotlncJuded 9. Excavation & Dirt ;1t(,lncluded BlockS:-;! /ii~t1 ' . !l,pcj/f'/" ~ Damp prooling: ,f~Landmark Backfill: ...~lncIUded Removal: 0 Not Included ,i il (!;~~'j /112'4"':" '0'" 0 -Purchaser ,0 Purchaser' 10. 42" Fr()st 0 Included 0 Type ~,.,,,.,,,' jil.. Concrete Driveway: sq. fl. . ;'/f{'. (', Permit by:~andniark Clean-up by: ".D,a, n. dmark -~...~- .. FootingS: 0 Not Included 0, Lill. FI. 0 Asphalt sq. fl. 0 Purchaser 0 Purchaser 11. Door Operator: pt,Yes 0 No ~. .~~uantity '" I ,.~4/2 Horsepower with 2 Tri}nsmitters " [)~,t~,er .-1"" ". 5i'/'t-' 12. Electric Wiring: . 9i(Y as 0 No' '. '. ...Standard Package .lncludes:.1' Li9ht;;1 SWitch~,:t Outlet. '.1 ,GFI outlet"lfJtJol(;("};)):'~!lj{ Deluxe, Package Includes: ~andard Package above plus 3-way switch, Double Flootllight 2Stake Survey ~,lncludedO Not inCluded o Extras: , 5. Type SidingcJf ,- Gabie End Siding Front Wall Siding Siding Corners o Wood 6. overhea. dboorSize/. "'"7.'."".' 4--- Quantity / If ,x ' OPv.c Stop n Alum. wrap o Squared Ope ing o . Mitered Comers o ,Arched Opening Wood trim Overhead Door Header: J~" Double 2 x 12 o Laminated Beam q 13. Removals:~ 6y Landmark~l~ i\rt:t ;;.9 , IJ . . f! OtherWork .~,. ...' \y, ',,- . I U ...":.t,)' . i'U . "J' . . '1,1 I r, /',~", u..t, ',; i,,?;,d'l,1l'Y;v'i. ' Ii l.,' ," f\ f!, ,~ lfhf\,,, Ce'\i'~' D ", o By Owner d'baymentto b.emadeas folio : )'\ ." r " , . j! ,iil>f/ '. . 's' "i ~ -'r~A... /l~.~ J.~ . ,-i, /' ,f/it' .,/ Il ..'....'. ,:'~';":.f' '.r? ""1''' l~,( ( /' t"~,~...". We have received a copy of this agreement .,' " .' . Contract Amount I~/l? tJ,.f:t-Z) , fl. r.>,,,,,,";r~../;> ~ Down Payment I (), v V. ("< Balance Due / t '/ ;1:'? {l /;;l " )' .. "urchaser's Signature x.: ' :;0 - Purchaser Signature ' tT-r .oI{\ ,Q, Sales Consultant 3y Residential Contractor Licensed By The State Of Minnesota. License #0001992. . .. . .. . . ~ I LANDMARK BUILDERS, INC. 651-699-3135 WORK ORDER /'C'/-11? I <, ,~ '-1 HOME PHON~!'" "f :' 0 - I .~-;, I ! $"" . '. , ~. Permit by L " /''''' JOB ADDRESS c} ~:~ , .,;~,.t f\l I 1/-", r\ Legal Description :. tt:i ,', Lot ~"-l;; "ij Blk BLDG CODE AREA ,.(;/,L ,'.\..tl'71 .:y.,/~ Add'n n CONTRACT DATE ~. I '//1) Y'SIZE llf.:l (', SALESMAN l.' j....,\1 0...... Value / ( . Type Const. FOR OFFICE USE ONLY SLAB: . Ii:t. By First Landmark t . I"\. . o By Owner Approx. .... .. ..... . I ,~. Din l~) '"",,' 2-STARTING POINTS ONLY I \ 1 i . S. p.L. :7- . . . - . . ....... s.s.p.L. ... .... ....... . R.p.L. t'.' '" . ., .! . ~ .",. Alley . ., '" ~ ~ House '7 '" -~ [\ .' ........ .' '.. .... . .....tti' F. Street '. .... ^ I V V J 1\, ... ........ Other . ! ...... '1 ...... . '.' ..... ftl Square With \' t ;::.i L ; t. ~! , . o Sod Rem. - By . ... .... ...... .. .. lJ A.B.U. . ~~ ~ (11l18l Grade Point ..... . .... . o Conduit . . : . .... L .... . ....... .'. .. . .... (!I. Blocks: 0 By Owner ClBy FlM . .... '. . ..... .... .... '.' ...... o Wtr. proof: 0 By Own.l!I By FLM . . . o Backfill: 0 By Owner ~ FLM . "'I., f) ..... .. I '# "1' .... '\ '" ..... ....... .... l}1 Maintain 8' Total Wall Heig t y :1". . .....,.., " P........ :;t;~ v~ ~, . Including Blocks OR .... .' .. 10 Mai"'''" 8' W'" ""'gh' on . {\) ....~ it, II 'I ,\. i'~lfP... , "...~ .... . , . Top of Blocks __,. . I . . , , , . '. Block Size (Top course) r~ ;?i;\/;',......! ... . .......... .:...........,.... I 08" 11.6" 0 4" r )", . . 2~::t i .~. ff v~, . . .. I ~all Height other than 8" ..... ': " .... . ....... . o Frame with full wall height . . . .. ... ...... sold OR c.tN\A'. :.JJA' .. " ..... '.' ..' . o Cut studs as required for .' ' . OHD clearance ',,",,"'J ....... : ' : '4 tJP1'7~r ..... [lO.H. Dr Offset ~S.D. Location '. , Windows I : . . ........... . I . D Attached Garage Roof Tie-in . ... . .'. Drawn on attached pictures I , ... ... .... Existing garage: NoD . .... D Detached 0 Attached Yes g) .... Size of existing: x ... Existing garage will be: . . . . . o Left as is . . ..... o Converted to L.S. - By Owner '.' GI,Removed by: 0 Owner O':~LM I '" Junk Must Be Removed By Owner I .' o Specify removals by Landmark , Owner - trees, bushes, etc. I . . o Show approx. distance garage to . ~J~~ '. . . house and all property lines .. Stakes visible - DYes DNo Survey available - 0 Yes ONo .. o Special instructions from owner: U< ~ .... . OFair \ :;,,/,/ , ...0 Poor I. , . . ," . ...........J. PURCHASER'S INITIALS: DIRECTION fI' n NAME it J 4,: k! BUS. PHONE: (' t\ ()-1:~:L(J"7'- Heritage Preservation Commission DATE: July 31, 2008 APPLICANT: Robert and Nora Hahn REQUEST: CASE NO.: 08-38 Demolition Permit for a garage LOCATION: 502 Laurel St W HPC PUBLIC HEARING DATE: August 4,2008 PREPARED BY: Michel Pogge, City Planner~~ BACKGROUND Robert and Nora Hahn, property owners of 502 Laurel St W, are requesting a demolition permit for an existing garage on their property. The property owner believes that the garage was built in the 1950' s and is over 50 years of age. A building permit for the structure was not on file at the City office. After reviewing the structure, style, and condition of the structure it leads staff to conclude that the garage is more than 50 years old. Since the garage appears to be over 50 years old, it is by definition considered to have potential historic significance. Consequently, the Heritage Preservation Conmlission is required to review the demolition request. This site is in the Conservation Design District; however, since the main structure is not being removed a new garage would not be subject to the infill design criteria. SPECIFIC REQUEST The applicant requests approval of a permit to demolish the existing garage. 502 Laurel St W Hahn Garage Demolition Permit Page 2 EVALUATION OF REQUEST Chapter 34, Section 34-4 of the City Code states that "if buildings or structures are determined by the community development director to be historic or potentially historic, the application must be sent to the [heritage preservation] commission for review... Buildings or structures determined nonhistoric must be referred to the building official for issuance of a demolition permit." A "nonhistoric structure or building" is defined by Chapter 34, Section 34-2 as a structure or building less than 50 years old... Since the age of the structure could not be determined it is assumed that the garage is over 50 years old; therefore, it is of potential historic significance and requires review by the Heritage Preservation Commission. Section 34-5 of the City Code lists nine items which must be considered prior to approval of a demolition permit by the Commission. (1) A map showing the location of the building or structure to be demolished on its property and with reference to neighborhood properties; This information is included in the attached application. (2) A legal description of property and owner of record; The legal description of the property was included in the application. (3) Photographs of all building elevations; Photos from various angles are included in the packet. (4) A description of the building or structure or portion of building or structure to be demolished; The applicant has indicated in the cover letter that the entire garage structure is proposed to be demolished. (5) The reason for the proposed demolition and data supporting the reason, including, where applicable, data sufficient to establish any economic justification for demolition; The applicant has included a quote from Nile's Construction related to the cost to renovate the garage. It is estimated it will cost $28,102.50 to restore this structure. (6) Proposed plans and schedule for reuse of the property on which the building or structure to be demolished is located; The applicant has indicated that they wish to build a two stall garage with attic storage, similar in design to what exists on the site today. 502 Laurel St W Hahn Garage Demolition Permit Page 3 (7) Relation of demolition and future site use to the comprehensive plan and zoning requirements; The current comprehensive plan land use designation for the property is Single Family Small Lot and is zoned RB, two-family residential. Once the current garage is demolished the proposed garage would be required to meet all of the current requirements of the zoning code. This site is in the Conservation Design District; however, since the main structure is not being removed a new garage would not be subject to the infill design criteria. (8) A description of alternatives to the demolition; The applicant has provided two alternatives to demolition. First, it could be renovated, which they believe would be too costly. Second, it could be reused elsewhere in the community, which they have advertised for. (9) Evidence that the building or structure has been advertised for sale for restoration or reuse and that sale for restoration or reuse is not economically feasible. The applicant has indicated that tJzey have advertised the garage in the Star Tribune. A copy of the ad has been included in your packet. ALTERNATIVES The Heritage Preservation Commission has the following options: 1. Approve the demolition permit as presented. 2. Deny the demolition permit if the applicant has not proved the necessity for demolishing the garage or if the Commission believes there are alternates to demolishing the garage. 3. Continue the public hearing until the September 3, 2008 Commission meeting. The 60 day decision deadline for the request is September 16, 2008. RECOMMENDATION Review and take action on the request. attachment: Application and supporting documents from the applicant July 16, 2008 City of Stillwater Heritage Preservation Commission 216 Forth Street North Stillwater, MN 55082 Dear Members of the Heritage Preservation Commission: We are applying for demolition of our existing garage to be replaced by a new one. The existing garage is located on the North West comer of our lot and is adjacent to our neighbors' garage. (We own both the East Half oflot 45, all of lot 46, block 2, Sabin's addition and lot 1, b10ck2 Sabin's Addition excepting the Northerly 119 feet) The garage was originally built prior to 1950's and has been poorly added on several times since. The wooden structure sits on a cement slab that has heaved up and caved in severa11ocations. The wood is rotten throughout, roof is unsafe to walk on and has large holes in it and the windows are missing and there is no way to put up a garage door. The garage had been used for keeping dogs and has damage from the dogs. Currently, it is nonfunctional as a garage and we would like to use the space for a functional garage. Section 34-5.1 a. We have attached a map showing the location of the garage on the property b. We have attached the legal description c. We have attached photos of the existing garage d. The garage is a detached single car with a small shed off to the side with limited storage space e. The garage is in great disrepair and living in an older home with limited space we need extra storage. f. We have attached drawings of the new garage, basically keeping with the same style of the old garage, but providing for two cars and a storage space in the roof area. g. The property is zoned single family and will remain single family. h. Two alternatives to demolition have been researched, first having it restored, which we have found too costly for not providing us with a minimum of two car stalls (we have attached the bid for this), and we advertised the garage to be moved off site, which we received no takers (we attached the add from the Star Tribune). 1. We have attached the advertisement that ran in the Star Tribune J. Not required for out buildings Basically the garage is an unsafe shack that decreases the value of our and our neighbor's properties. We would like to replace it with a new garage keeping in the style of the home and existing garage. We have put a lot of time and money in the restoration of our home and feel the new garage would complete the property. Please allow us to move forward with this project. Sincerely, 0k [~ Robert and Nora Hahn 502 West Laurel Street Stillwater, MN 55082 ~ o o c:i ;;; Snd^l:lnS Jq 'w'd lO:~ \8 900l '()c I;lUl1r panOJd [fi I- u..G ~ Os: >- ~ ~ <rj ~ g~~ ~ ~ ~8~ m 'i:f fb~8 (I) ~ a:e~ ~ $.: 0(:1- ~ !JJ a: ~~~ n. ~ ~ ~~~ ~ p {.!) f::: ::s;; 0 iU C; f2 :s CI) Li... Q: !.LJ 0 a:~~~ ~ ~ :::: a:. ~ ~ 0 u.. 8~~ 0:: fh ~ ~~~ fi? 0:: ~ 4.. n: i:3 tJ.J lli ~iE~ ~~ 8 ~ i~~ ~~ ~ ~ i ~~~ (J)~ .:t ~ (I)~ ~~ Cl ?: ~ !a~o ~~ ~ ~ -.. ~ ~~ ~~ ~ ~ ~ ~8e ~~ e g 8 ~:i!~ rEm :5 8 ~ (I) Q ~ 0... a: a.. ~ ~ ~~~ ~~ ~ ~ d w ~ I~ ~ h :5 a=ffi l: ~ ~$: ! 0: 815 ... ffi ~ ~~ ~ ~~:: ~ g ~ ~~:: n ~ @~.. . ~ g In::e ~ ~ (3 ;;; 6 i= ~ ,~.I15 +-+-+ ~+-~ l.L o B~ ~~ " -Jc ~~ EEPfff ::J[; az UQ > ~1~1 ~L~--1 ~ j fJ I ~ a ~ N ~r~1 o a ~ L~-1 rn ~ ~ C'\l ~ ~ ---0- g ro I~I L~-1 [ I, r-;, L~-1 w ~ J!! :c 0 ('? ?- ft .c a:: u .5 0 W z: -1 <: () w II w U) a: ::J 00 ~z~ ~~~>- <:u.:I<f;l:I: ::3:~(3 cccz>- ~~~:;::l~ &3frl&3~~ ~~~~g o.a.a.Q~ ~~~~~ 000::2:0... @ S Ci l- r5 i~~ ~~ 0:<: "'=t~ fuo . 0 ~3 C) rx: ~ rLJ ~~ ~m ~i ]~ d9 ~ n.:~ E~ ~~ :2 g ~ ~~ ~~ 1i1~ ~-2 .rg ~ ~ ~ ,~ ~~i28~ ~ S~ e t g ~~~~~ ;!:~~~~ 'Fol1ll No. 5-M - WARRANTY DEED Indivldual(s} to Joint Teuanls t- or:::-'rr: .of" COUNTY RECOROEI\ WASIHlH::TQH COUN'TY FILED ON Jd \8 q 03 MI '96 DOC._~.1.Q::;~3 . CIHDY IJ:Q:'~kNH ~~R No delillquent taxes and ~r entered; Certificate of Real Estate Value (./)filed ( )not required ~ficateofReal Esta, te Value No. ~ ~€M.l1Lt1, n ,19~ ~l U..cLJhli'J ,/""'" fr __7' ~""" A..... byr-ta cJv 11 l41. ) QL ~ Deputy STATE DEBD TAX DUEHBREON: $ 433.95 Date: November 27th $19.50 ,19 95 (reserved for recording data) FOR VALUABLE CONSIDERATION, A Tom Rehn also known as A Thom~~ Rehn. Singl , Grantor(s), hereby convey(s) and warrant(s) to (marital slams) Robert C. Hahn and Nora D. Hahn tenants, real property in Washinqton , Grantee(s) , as joint County, Minnesota, described as follows: The East Half of Lot 45 and all of Lot 46, Block 2, Sabin's Addition to the City of Stillwater. IIOgO Records of Washington County The seller certifies that the seller does not know of any wells on the described property. (if more spal>> is needed, contillllC 011 back) together with all hereditaments and appurteDllDCeS belonging thereto, subject to the following exceptions: STATE OF MINNESOTA .____._..___. ___0 _~___ ..-_ 27-oec-95 WASH ItlGTOH CCUl TV No. 2S6<ID ~ tax herotal of $433.95 Paid "" Con_rvation <P,un.:t "':;;,. 'I73H $5.00 Paid RlH. STAFFa<D, 'AlJdi~ifli""'rllRx ._1Il1A1l\I.UH } 5S. COUNTY OF Ramsey The foregoing instr\lIl1l:llt was acknowledged before me this 27th day of by A. TomRehn also known as A. Thomas Rehn, ,19 95. NotmaJ lIla1np or seal (or ~ tltl~ or rank) I Grantor(s). I Cll a. :t-JJr- Signa1urc of penon talcin& acknowledgment ............. po....... If ..... I~ tG'~ alAD A. FEn J . ...iif' NOTARY PUBtJC.MIHHESOTA I ~~ WASHINGTON COUHTY . , ~ My Comm. Expires Jan. 3t. 2lllIO f ~.....~.............~. .-.~,....,.~_.........-. Tax Stalem~1a for the real ~IOperty de.cdbed in tblt in!t1ument should be ....t 10 (Includ~ name and address of Grantee): Firstar Home Mortgage Corp Loan No. 0867051 This InoIlumelll was drafted by (name and addreas): First Security Title 4525 White Bear Parkway White Bear Lake, MN 55110 Grantees: Robert C. Hahn Nora D. Hahn 502 Laurel Street West Stillwater, MN 55082 95-17888 1l8569w ~-7- ~ ,-..Jlf.-1:~..19.::.M.= OUIT_CLMMP.!';~...J1iJJ!l~_YDiform C..Q!!m.l!!JC.J!!&.)}lanksi!ill.!~lL.. Miller-Davis_Co.. St...Paul. MN , . 1 I Individual(s) 10 loilll Tenants 3104132 I I 111111111111 I I I I i I I }) Office of the County Recorder Washington County. MN Cerllfted Died andlor recorded on: 2000/05/15 4:17:00 PM 3104132 DEED TAX DUE: $ 1. 6 5 Date: May 2. 2000 I~ . '\. .'~~~ ", ;) (reserved ror =1lIIIIg Wi"') Clndv l(aOlm..n C,un~ "'conler (marital status) Robert C. Hahn and Nora D. Hahn Michael J. Raleigh and Barbara Raleigh, I I. , Grantor(s), i ,Grantees, I County, Minnesota, described as follows: I FOR VALUABLE CONSIDERATION, husband and wife hereby convey(s) and quitclaim(s) to as joint tenants, real property in Washington Lot 1, Block 2, Sabin's Addition to Stillwater, excepting the Northerly 119 feet thereof, according to th~ plat thereof on file and of record in the office of the County Recorder, Washington County, Minnesota. "The total consideration for this transfer of property is $500.00 together with all hereditaments and appurtenances. or Ie s s . " Check box if applicable: IXkThe Seller certifies that the seller does not know of any wells on the described real property. [] A well disclosure certificate accompanies this document. [] I am familiar with the property described in this instrument and I certify that the status and number of wells on the described real property have not changed since the last previously filed well disclosure certificate. WASHINGTON COUNTY "."-. ..ADA_ 1!i~1: r~ SDY%CIlS AIm 1lL-=no.I Receipt No.: 132584 0511512000 Deed lax hereon of $1.65 Paid 4; 1/ ~ MN COI1SefV3lion Fund M.S. 473H $5.00 Paid . 11, Virginia R. Erdahl . Aucitor- Treasurer by: c.Jv1cKenzie .' a;~ ~ e i:t . STATE OF MINNESOTA COUNTY OF WASHINGTON }". I"". uuu_u.uu......u...u_. e. ...... ~~~~~.;;,.~~;;.., NOTAIlVl'\.WJC.IolINNE IIY CCMMISSION EXPlIlE81-3_ .V'('"NJ'~"'^ ~.,^VN^""N.w *'...YN....,...y. ~~TUR~:f!~OAL I -I _ Grantor(s) ' , I by Thlis instrument was acknowledged before me on fY\ A.-1 ?, .~ (. Jc..)c) Michael J. Raleigh and Barbara Ra\eigh, husband~~d wife, NorAIUAL STAMP OK SllAL (OR OTBEIt 11TLE OR RANK) Check here if pan or all of the land is Registered (Torrens) 0 Edward W. Simonet, Jr. Attorney. at Law 522 S. 4th Street P. O. Box 16 Stillwater, MN 55082 A.R.N. 101229 (651) 439-5787 Tax StatemenlS for the real property described in this insllUlllenl should be sent to (include oame and address of Grantee): Robert C. and Nora D.Hahn 502 W. Laurel Street ~ Stillwater, MN 55082 ~CJ' mlS Lll,j'STRlTl\otE."O' WAS DRAFTED BY (NAME AND ADDRESS); . . L.._..._.._......._...__...____._..__..._..._......._.__.....-.--...-.-----........-..............----.--__---i c ~l /' .. &;;J ~ ~ .'{ i~ _' ~ir~ ~~~. ~'. v'; --- .~ -.~ .... . ....------ .....:<I} FROM : NILES~CONSTUCTION CO. FAX NO. 6514303269 Jul. 17 2008 12:50PM Pi e NILE'S CONSTRUCTION CO 507 6th Street North Bayport, MN 55003 Lic: # MN ID 20165748 WI #966982 (651)-430-3269 Estimate For: July 17, 2008 Bob and Nora Hahn 502 Laurel St. N. Stillwater, MN 55082 (651)-439-3454 File Name: HAHNREST Quantity Units Work Description Unit Price Total Price 1 . PLANS &SPECS 1. 00 Ea This is an e~timate to restore exist- ing garage. 2. PERMITS 1.00 Ea TO the City of Stillwater. 3 . DUMPSTER 1.00 Ea Haul debris to dumpster. 4 . FOUNDATION 1.00 Ea Allowance of $1500.00 to jack up garage to level and set new found- ation as needed. 5. CONCRETE 633.00 SF Pour 4" of concrete floor in garage. FRX NO. 6514303269 Jul. 17 2008 12:50PM P2 FROM NILES_CONSTUCTION CO. Job For: File Name: HAHNREST PAGE 2 Quantity Units Work Description Unit Price Total Price 6 . FRAMING 1.00 Ea Repair rotten wood and replace plates install new roof sheathing with osb sheathing. 7. WINDOWS/DOORS 2.00 Ea 3.00 Ea Install new 36" exterior entry door. Install new 32x60 double hung window. 8. ELECTRICAL 1.00 Ea Allowance of $1500.00 for electrical work. 9 . ROOFING 12.00 Sq 12.00 Sq Install new felt, ice & water and shingles. Remove 2 layers asphalt roof & dump 10. SIDING 1. 00 Ea Repair siding and replace siding that does not match original siding. 11. FASCIA/SOFFIT {continued} FROM NILES_CONSTUCTION CO. FAX NO. 6514303269 Jul. 17 2008 12:50PM P3 Job For: File Name: HAHNREST PAGE 3 Quantity Units Work Description Unit Price Total Price 11. FASCIA/SOFFIT (cont.) 155.00 LF Install new 1x6 and 1x3 fascia boards around garage. 12. PAINTING 1.00 Ea Allowance of $2000.00 for painting exterior walls and trim. 13. MISCELLANEOUS 1.00 Ea 1.00 Ea Allowance of $3000.00 for materials to complete this job. Install a new 10lx71 garage door with a 1/2 hp garage door opener with 2 remotes. 14. PAYMENT SCHEDULE 1.00 Ea 1.00 Ea 25% @ start, 25% @ roofing, 25% @ painting and balance at completion. All change orders if needed would be payable at time of change order. 15 . ACCEPTANCE OF PROPOSAL 1.00 Ea (contimied) This is a good faith estimate to provide all materials and labor as described in this document. Any other work for unseen problems or demanded FROM : NILES_CONSTUCTION CO. FAX NO. 6514303269 Jul. 17 2008 12:51PM P4 Job For: File Name: HAHNREST PAGB 4 Quantity Units Work Description Unit Price Total Price 15. ACCEPTANCE OF PROPOSAL (cont.) 1.00 Ea by a building official would be perf- ormed at an extra charge. Thank You To make this document a contract please sign and date at the XIS. Contactor X Homeowners X X NILE'S CONSTRUCTION COMPANY MN BUILDERS LICENSE NO.20165748 WISCONSIN LICENSE NO. 966982 16. NOTICB TO OWNER "(a) ANY PERSO~ OR COMPANY SUPPLYING LABOR OR MAT$RIALS FOR THIS IMPROVE- MENT TO YOUR PROPERTY MAY FILE A LIEN AGAINST YOUR PROPERTY IF THAT PERSON OR COMPANY IS NOT PAID FOR THE CONTRIBUTIONS. (B) UNDER MINNESOTA LAW I YOU HAVE THE RIGHT TO PAY PERSONS WHO SUPPLIED LABOR OR MATERIALS FOR THIS IMPROVE- MENT DIRECTLY AND DEDUCT THIS AMOUNT FROM OUR CONTRACT PRICE, OR WITHHOLD THE AMO'(fflTS DUE FROM US UNTIL 120 DAYS AFTER COMPLETION OF THE IMPROVE- MENT UNLESS WE GIVE YOU A LIEN WAIVER SIGNED BY PERSONS WHO SUPPLIED ANY ANY LABOR OR MATERIAL FOR THE IMPROVE MENT AND WHO GAVE YOU TIMELY NOTICE." FROM : NILES_CONSTUCTION CO. FAX NO. 6514303269 Jul. 17 2008 12:51PM P5 Job For: File Name: HAHNREST PAGE 5 Quantity Units Work Description Unit Price Total Price GRAND SUBTOTALS Labor: Materials: ~O,612.84 17,489.66 GRAND TOTAL 28,102.50 ...... r1 1) r= I~ ~ v.> ~~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ .~ tll f;; ~ ~ ~ 111 Sb II! 1 I I 1 J i!!l ~~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 1 u; ah jl~ I 1) 1 M MW IT ~~~~%~==~E::a,.~~:o!~$:~~~:=~S::u.5s~~AND :=S06s.~~s:r~~~-=~~..=w~~~~:..~~~~~~~~VftR'YA\.l..~L..NO~UGMJUMIINr.S ~~>; ~f.~ tl~i !~I il =.NC6~ ~.. ,-$ ~-.- M ~IUIS~ =::-or e.~. ~~9~: ~=~~=.s~: MEi'(6R-1:le;.st4NSe'R:.YlC6 -r--- ' STDRAc1&ROOM "..... D T6L6; (1ft) ~~3U3 =-;:-- C$tUN'1 fie14H'r. S FAAd""')~".O+~~:: __-- '" Ri~i 11- Id E @ h III IUI i~li;;11111 ;11 11;;11 I ~ 1;1 I~sll ~ I ~~I Idll r ~ I I II Ri~111 ~, lei E I h III II~I I ~ III ~~ ~~ R 111111I1 I ~ I ~BI I I ; , , , , , -I '. , . /' / , , , , "" ,/ , , -' , " " , . , , l~_____, " / !../ , , ....________________, I I' '" ~~~-a%~=~~~~_=:~~~=~~===u5-~~~ ~~~=r:.,~R.DOR.~-=~~~~~~~~o:='.:'t.~~~T1'R.&l'W.Lw..,-AU..~~~~ma ~ ~ )>; I! ~ ~ t I 4. ~ &~ i ~ w i te :-101......... 1! -_.- M M6'(6R.~a5k:1N SR.V1CC D TSt.&, (no) 051-- 3US S """>1-.1"""00+"" " . ~~ ~~ M.l1O c.o. Aa..crHORJZ.f>l)'Io: 1:I&.sCR.n"T10NOFc.HAN 6 A/,.L.ltl4If'I"Sus.... 040-11-<< 1. HAftN SUMNAT6S'rAfRS. MAKE ST'O'RAG& ROOM .'.... c.eIUNIC:1: tt6tc:j..".-. 'J.Hbl94-1!::JNnl:9Q ..,..., W00lt9~S S?Pr'W ~V.J.S 9J.\t"Nwns I#fV+I \I4fO ~ NOUdnltOS'9<l : . <t9:7RiOH..U1V 'f# BO-n--J(J ~fiUI.bnI.,.,.... .0""0) !U~-.-,IUDN~ "","".*" c-l 'XV, e>nE',(gc (Baa) "'oaJ. 3'OIA'lSS N~IS'9<1 ~W S <1 W ......... ~ 9'ON9~S"'!nI s:.~ ~J h Z I ~ ~ ~ '"' i I ~ ~ zt'j ~ i i ~ h~ ! <l: a '"' ~~QN>;"~W.,.,v~TMIS'~~~~~~~":~~~~~~~~~~~r=~Tw~~ QHV~~~-==a~~--==~~:~~~-==:;=~~~=:~~~ r------ I I I I I I I ---------l I I I (\ I, 3. Ii .1 V ,-- ---- I ~ I ! d ---, S" r"r::!i I _..J I I I I I I I I I __-.J , /lIIIdfAllP.lf./ i ~ ~- - T!- '.iii, r ,I, I ( II ~::::r,,_ L'~ ! l,JI: -. , , , , , L________ _ ~m.,l L~~ I . ~ ~ ~ ~~ o I<< ~ ~ ~l ~ 18 ----WL pz:l ~ ~ ~ ----DlIL ~ r - - - - - - - - t-, , , ~ ~ , ;~ , , , , I , ,- - _-:"""1 ~Q r- " , " v.l " , rmOOwM 1 " ~ " , " " , L4~~ " :' , ./ ...1%....... " , _._uc.;- , " ~ Z " =-,-'- /ltllr..-'h\ ~ , II ' ~ z :' ,I. I! : , ...= :: II ~ ~ n z " II] . :: II ~ ~ ~ , ~ Z " , " I , -# ~ " ./2DlIOOIfaar iVDlUlI'IItlMw;:.,....- I Z :' -...... , , . ~ - - -. I " --;--- -,- , , " " , , " " , /lI:IUIONWIIOllII , " , ~.M"o.c.""- ~ , , ~ , , '-- =[ -"~ .... ~~~~%~=~::JR=~~~~Z~==~~3a==~~==:u.5s~~AAD ~AU.~s=r-:"'~F\.OOIL~-=~l:;:~=~~~~;::'~~~~~~.sfW.L.\IftlPJ'AU.M~AIC>1JL8)T1ItI(W..~NT.S ~ L In U ~ ~I R.6Sltlo5NC6 fOR: M Mn CoO. A~Z.~'" : ~ONOfettAN 6' i-I. ~ ~ ! i ........, o.ru-Dt' #%. - 6UMNATe srAfRS. MAf(.& t z 1~ M6"(6R. tl6SkiN S6R.V1C6 ST'ORA<16 ROOM ".... ~~ ~ D c.eIUN'1 fi6lG1fiT. i-I. ~ T5LFi: CUI'} 25}'-. S1.SS ~ Z~ j '/i~ ~-.- FA>O C06S.J,.,.,.-...,..,.. ~ W . S BOARDING BOX STALLS In & lighted outdoor arenas, pasture turnout, no charge trailer parking (geldings only). $300 per month. A MISTY MEAOOWS FARM OUf 22nd year. Delano 952-465-4430 5 YR DUN QH geld.15.2 ;k H, barrels, poles, trail. st Quick tearner. $4500 /bo Sharon 612-987-1521 or Iii Amanda 651-269-9147 ,~,,-=: l\1 ~Oh~~s~~~~t~~J~~u~~ ~~, t'i mid/rr tack, dress rm, side/rr _ r~mps, hay rack. drop down wndws $16,950 612-267-2545 )0 AOHA. gelding ,black, Im- presSive. 18 yrs otd, 15 H, Hx kn1g(,eOs~~~e, g~e1a_\~~7 !3~~S5 Web 10 1014 D2 03 06 13 16 19 26 HORSE HAY, timothy/or 36 chard grass/alfalfa mix, med sqs, Semi-In ad lots only. 320-795-2179 320-808-5723 ~2 ~A~~~W ~;.~ ~~0~~E5t~~: 44 no need to call 952-545-1626 .46 AQHA GELOING, excel horse ,~ ~O{5~~.a~~~~ig~7_3:Og or trail, '54 '56 '58 20' FEATHERLlTE stocK trailer, axe cond $8900 218-686-7755 I ~ Is. :01 ;.44 :F: 13. :0 FOR SALE PIGEONS: Good for eating Of training dogs. Many colors. 218-851-4677 Web 10 1031 20 BEEF COWS & CALVES, cows 1st third calvers, approx 2001bs, kn-ife cut, 320-760-5622 PASTURE CATTLE Angus-X heifers 475-650 fbs $525-$600. 763-972-2339 TEXAS LONG HORN COWS & HEIFERS; Reg p,urebred, top blood lines. 507-235-3467 Gi lEE DELI CATERING MARKET ght * ONLINE AUCTION * BOB'S SUPER VALU '+ 6001 167th Ave Ramsey s COMPLETE LIQUIDATION 16<- Quality Name Brand Equip Deli Cabinets, AltoShaam Warmer ,Henny Penny 'iI Fryer & Warmer & Rotis- serie SS Wunde Roaster Oven Hobart Slicers, Mix- ers, Etc Beverage Air ,S Freezer, Wlln Coolers_& Freezer, Bakery Equip, Meat Cutting Equip Lots min of Coolers & Display 5N Cases, Tables & Chrs, etc 18. Toyota Gas Forklift, Lozier Shelving, Cardboard Baler E"'l TOO MUCH TO LIST! View Pies Bid Online NOW m K .~IO .eorn 16<- , 16<- 763-479-3000 Lic #27-57 leck Restaurant Auctioneers ,aid, 6<- EXCAVATOR Surplus Eqp oE! * ONLINE AUCTION "* , Sav;3:ge, MN Location -~ '00 Ford F550 Dump Truck Mack Dsl Midliner Flatbed l+ Wacker Roller. Morbark iiii wd Chipper, Trailers incl Iii Office, Travel, Flatbeds. Bldg Supp '00 Chev Flat- bed. '00 Ford F150 4x4 Crew Cab. Nomad Electric Scooters, Pontoon. Dock .01< Sections, Plow Trucks & Just Too Much To List! ..270 View Pics Bid Online NOW ..273 ..276 K .~ID .com lted ..279 ...282 ...285 763-479-3000 Lic #27-57 I Equipment Specialists CEMENT CONTRACTOR I * ONLINE AUCTION * has CMU SURPLUS ASSETS pvt&. 02 Ford E450 Gargo Van lis. a 05 Ford E350 6.0Dsl Truck II the 96 Ford E350 6.0Dsl Truck f Der- '97 Ingersoll Rand VR90B ------------ Auctions . .. _.. li uidalions REAL ESTATE AUCTIONS * ONLINE BIDDING * Residential & Commercial Buildings & Building Lots (2) Mini-Storage Facilities Development Land & Lots PROPERTY AUCTIONS View Pics Bid Online NOW K .~ID .com 763-479-8888 Lic #27-57 K-BIO Realty Maple Plain Jenna Nepper, BROKER REPAIRABLE CARS * ONLINE AUCTION * DAD'S AUTO Hugo, MN StormlHail Damaged Cars 96 Honda Acc, 89 Volvo 94 Mazda MX3, 98 Dodge Caravan & MANY MORE! Several Sets of Used Tires Lots of CD Players, ETC. View Pics Bid Online NOW K .~ID.com 763-479-3000 Lic 024714 Selling To A Worlo Market SPECIALTY VEHICLES * ONLINE AUCTION * 47 American LaFrance Fire Truck V-12 Eng, 5K Act Mi Open Cab, Hyd Ladder Trk 01 Dynasty Motorhome wI Cummins OSI, Slide-Outs, 560. HP Bucket Roadster Cust HD Sportster 1200 View Pics' Bid Online NOW K .~ID .com 763-479-3000 Lic #27-57 SOLUTION PROVIDERS SHAKOPEE High School * ONLINE AUCTION * Storage Sheds Playhses Crafted By Shop Students 24' Wells Cargo Encl Trlr View Pies Bid Online NOW * WE PURCHASE * Limited.edition art print/framed & sculpture. Please leave detailed message Art liquidators 612-245-0015 Clothing & Furs MEN & WOMEN'S vintage clothing, shoes, hats, hat boxes & more. 320-632-6765 COIN SALE JULY 6 Osseo American Legion 260 4th Ave SE 608-723-4917 * I BUY BEANIE BABIES * All styles, cash paid. This Sat/Sun from 12-5pm I'll be at .'1 Sold it" store- 6819 1/2 York Ave, Edina. www.b.uyingbeans.com ** 630-837-9965 ** GOLD/SILVER 28 YEAR HIGH CASH PAID $S TOP DOLLARS Diamonds 1 CT + Scrap Gold/ Coins, Silver/Silver Building Supplies GRANITE COUNTER TOPS ON SALE! Choice of 6 colors @ $35 per sq ft includes installation. COME IN FOR A fREE ESTIMA TIE Free SS sink w/ 50 sf purchase Flooring & Back Splash nle also Available FOR DETAILS Coon Rapids: 763-862-0888 Showroom Hrs:. Man-Sat 9-6 pm Closed Sunday SEMI LOAD BLACK PLASTIC WINDOW & door shins, 1000 assorted new light fixtures. $3-$300 each, 5000 interj'Qr 'pre-finished mahogany door frames. make offer. 507-831- 2651 Windom, !\/IN 36 X 20 Steel Mezzanine with 12 f,t. Extei1sion~ 2 Sets of Steps. 30 Light Poles. Hobart Commercial ,Dishwasher with 20 ft. Tables. Call (612) 521-9492 with any inquiries *** STONE SALE '*** Make offers. Unique stone from buildings & roads of the past. Many bri(:k pavers. 3940 Washington Av N. Mpls 55412 651-641'1234 www.historicstone.com BOULOERS \ Stockpiles in Shakopee & Scandia. GOT ROCK 507-822-2167 www.gotrtJck4u.com GRAVEL PIT BOULDERS Very colorful, shoreline rock. Ornamental decor stone. De- livery only; Install avaiL 20 yrs established.- Visa I MstrCrd accepted! 612-282-9609 RUSTIC BARNWOOD Planks, Boards, Beams, Paneling, Flooring. Rough or Planed. Beautiful Grain, +1- -100yrs Old. 100% reclaimed612.481.9916 DESIGNER LAMINATED Flooring. Must' sell $.55'sq ft. 30% thicker! 2,740 sQ,ft available. 763-421':"'2164 FLOORING 2,145 sq ft. Solid Brazilian Cherry. $'1.75/sq ft. . Will separate. 763-533_1309 GARAGE ** FREE' ** For restoration orreuse; You pick up. Stillwater location. 651-439-3454 BARN,34'x30' all wood. reasonable offer, needs repair/paint. 218-722-2451 WOOD FLOORING High qual ityat low pri~e 952-448-6566 www.surfacingsolution.com SINGLE GARAGE W/ LOFT (unfinished). Needs. repair, resonable offer. 218-722-2451 . Firewood * 100 % RED OAK * Clean & Dry. 4:xB'xI6" @ $130. 4'x4'x8' @ $390. (Slabwood Now Avail - Great for FIREPIT!) Daily Deliveries. 2 Free Boxes Kindling w/each Order! Serving the Metro Area, * 612-325-2323 * Handicapped I " Medical Equipment WHEELCHAIR PRIDE JAZZY 1122 5 Spd, Tilt. great cond tuned up to sell. 3 1/2 yrs old. Asking $1875, 952-888-7017 Web 10 1057 1995 FORD E150 w/newer rear load pwr wheelchair lift, rear ht/AC, 7 pass, perfect, $3950. ** 612-267-2545 * JOHN DEERE, STlHL & * LAWN BOY SALES AND SERVICE Garceaus 651-483-0292 www.garceaus.com JDLAWN TRACTERS USED 40 in stockl Open 7 days a week. Open Sun 9-2. 4 miles Waf 494 on Bass Lake Road. 763-420-3584 JD-XRX95 R. eng., riding ~~d'ee;: ~~bO.bt~j~8~~~31~~ttl * ONLINE AUCTION * Precision DeSign Surplu.s Pettibone C8000 Oil Road Forklift w/Cab, Port. Air Compressors, Press Wash ~~~~I~~~J'~;J~d~~~dJ~g View Pies Bid Online NOW K .~ID.com 763-479-3000 Lic #27-57 Online Equip Auctioneers SANDBLASTING EQUIPMENT _ _ includes truck. compressor, 2 pots and 200 ft of hose. $15,000507-323-4507 PORTABLE storage units 7x7x16. Steel"frame w/wood floor. $20oo/ea. 15 yd dump- sters $1500-$2000/ea 952-943-9053 lincoln 60HP molar cheap!!! 320-968-6480 11&I Business Equipment ';'$;;' ~<<:, STORE FIXTURES Large quantity of clothing racks. hangars,_body forms , and mannequins, glass cubes and shelves. book and video racks, track lights, safes, cash draw~r, jewelry props and jewelry shQ,-,,!cases, checkout counters, 3 tier tables, stack- ing tables, folding banquet tables; shopping carts and baSkets, back room storage shelving, purse and belt racks, warehouse carts, rolling step ladders and much more ACCENT STORE FIXTURES 612-379-2788 800-546-9558 .434 Lakeside, Minneapolis MN,55405 www.storefixturesused.com LEASE Return Copiers * ONLINE AUCTION * 11 TO CHOOSE FROM Optics Cleaned by Tech Some Color Copiers Inspect Daily & Operate View Pies Bid Online NOW , K .!IO .com 763-479-3000 Lie #27-57 Qu'ality Online Auctioneers 7360 KONICA COPIER. 73' pages per minute, 4000 page feeder, business & legal, high end machine. excellent quality $4800. 952-451-7307 Computer Equipment & Software DELL P3 & P4 desktops. keyboard, mouse & speakers Starting @ $89. 763-228-8000 ~eb 10 8398 FOR INTERNET ACCESS ANO SERVICES SEE CLASSIFICATION 7 INTERNET COMMUNICATIONS QUALITY used file cabs, 60 vert. $20-$70. 150 lateral $25-$180. Chairs (25) $30/ea. 2 coni tables $200/ea. 25% off. Delivery available *651-503-5341 * Restaurant Equipment ~ Appliances Used AIR COND/DEHUMIDFIER RECONDITIONED AND. NEW APPLIANCE DEPOT ~e'~i~~~~~~e~~~R~o~~ Financing Available www.ap~liancedepot.com . 651-454-5995 DRYER, STOVE, WASHER Fridge, $75/each Delivery avail 651-464-6727 DRYERS / WASHERS-RBLT $125 & Up, Stoves & Fridges Also Available. 760 Payne Ave SI. Paul * * 651-172-2195' ~ -' ~"'::~<"' ~~~~~;::;: ~ <-,' FUr~isliings::::~W_- M ESS steR .net j I : ! j Famous Maker Mallresses 5~%.~0% Off! We carry 4 of the top 10 mattress brands. ~~;n~~i~~,U;;'% Rt~f3~ I www.mattressmonster.net l 952-270-6619 \' RESS ste~ .ne\ * Clearance Mattress Sale * '. Queen Mattresses-: \ $79 .' 952-270-66ess I. teRI .net! I King Euro Pillow Top List Price $2600 Monster Approved Price: $499 952"-270-6619 HESS steR .net ************** FANTASTIC BEDS Twin Sets ...............$129 Full Sets...... ......$139 Qn Sets... ....$149 King Sets..................$249 763-464-8557 CommonCentsfurniture.Com ************** Queen Pillow Top Mallress Famous Name Brand $299 763-464-8557 CommonCentsFurnlture.Cor:n ************** King Pillow Top Mallress Famous Name Brand $399 763-464-8557 CommonCentsFurniture.C.om ************** ^_ 1..___00..... r Heritage Preservation Commission Demolition Request Permit Demolition Permit No. Fee $100* Address of Project: 50L\,U.lA.0r<L\ ~+ Parcel No.:'2l5 . 030. <.o.Z4.u 0 Ih..Lot- L1Sl~t) Subdivision ~'o; f\'~ ~c\a.+-;~ Lot 4\.." Block '7 - Applicant: ~ ckr-\- ~ ~ow-a.. ~ aht') , Address:602 L0. Le""....ve...\6-t. Telephone No.:~q- "3"16<-1 Owner if different than Applicant: Address: ". Telephone No. Type of Structure: b~r~ ~fL Age of Structure: ) S> "~dition of Structure: ~r Intended Use of Site after Demolition: ~~ .e. ?~c~- I J I~ 10 i' Signature of Applicant Date ?Jft.~ I ([0 (OJ Signature of Owner Date *After review and approval of the demolition permit request with the Heritage Preservation Commission, a building permit must be obtained with the Qty of Stillwater Building Department. The fee for the building permit is based on the valuation of the demolition project. Office Use Only HPC Review Date: o Approved o Denied . City Planner/Community Development Director Date 4'1. Heritage Preservation Commission DATE: July 31, 2008 APPLICANT: Stephen and Beverly Diemler REQUEST: Demolition Permit for a garage LOCATION: 1104 5th St S CASE NO.: 08-39 HPC PUBLIC HEARING DATE: August 4,2008 PREPARED BY: Michel Pogge, City Plann#~ BACKGROUND Stephen and Beverly Diemler, property owners of 1104 5th St S, are requesting a demolition permit for an existing garage on their property. A building permit for the structure was not on file at the City office. In a report completed by Don Empson of Empson Archives, the garage is judged to be built between 1910 and 1930. Since the garage appears to be over 50 years old, it is by definition considered to have potential historic significance. Consequently, the Heritage Preservation Conmlission is required to review the demolition request. This site is in the Conservation Design District; however, since the main structure is not being removed a new garage would not be subject to the infill design criteria. SPECIFIC REQUEST The applicant requests approval of a pernlit to demolish the existing garage. 1104 5th St S Diemler Garage Demolition Permit Page 2 EVALUATION OF REQUEST Chapter 34, Section 34-4 of the City Code states that"if buildings or structures are determined by the community development director to be historic or potentially historic, the application must be sent to the [heritage preservation] commission for review... Buildings or structures determined nonhistoric must be referred to the building official for issuance of a demolition permit." A "nonhistoric structure or building" is defined by Chapter 34, Section 34-2 as a structure or building less than 50 years old... Since the age of the structure could not be determined it is assumed that the garage is over 50 years old; therefore, it is of potential historic significance and requires review by the Heritage Preservation Commission. Section 34-5 of the City Code lists nine items which must be considered prior to approval of a demolition permit by the Commission. (1) A map showing the location of the building or structure to be demolished on its property and with reference to neighborhood properties; This information is included in the attached application. (2) A legal description of property and owner of record; The legal description of the property was included in the application. (3) Photographs of all building elevations; Photos from various angles are included in the packet. (4) A description of the building or structure or portion of building or structure to be demolished; The applicant has indicated in the cover letter that the entire garage structure is proposed to be demolished. (5) The reason for the proposed demolition and data supporting the reason, including, where applicable, data sufficient to establish any economic justification for demolition; The applicant has included a quote from Rybog Construction related to the cost to renovate the garage. It is estimated it will cost $67,437.00 to restore this structure. Staff does not wish to dispute Rybog Construction qualifications; however, a quote of$67,437.00 to renovate this garage seems to be out of line with previous garage restoration quotes. (6) Proposed plans and schedule for reuse of the property on which the building or structure to be demolished is located; The applicant has indicated that they wish to build a two stall garage similar in design and size to what exists on the site today. In addition to the garage, the property owners wish to connect the home and garage with a new breeze way. 1104 5th 8t 8 Diemler Garage Demolition Permit Page 3 (7) Relation of demolition and future site use to the comprehensive plan and zoning requirements; The current comprehensive plan land use designation for the property is Single Family Small Lot and is zoned RB, two-family residential. Once the current garage is demolished the proposed garage would be required to meet all of the current requirements of the zoning code. This site is in the Conservation Design District; however, since the main structure is not being removed a new garage would not be subject to the infill design criteria. (8) A description of alternatives to the demolition; The applicant has provided no alternatives to demolition. Staff would offer that restoration of a structure is always an alternative to demolition. (9) Evidence that the building or structure has been advertised for sale for restoration or reuse and that sale for restoration or reuse is not economically feasible. The applicant has indicated that they have advertised the garage in the Stillwater Gazette on July 22 and 29,2008. A copy of the ad proof has been included in your packet. The applicant retained the services of Don Empson of Empson Archives to review the structure. A copy of that report is included in your packet. AL TERNA TIVES The Heritage Preservation Commission has the following options: 1. Approve the demolition permit as presented. 2. Deny the demolition permit if the applicant has not proved the necessity for demolishing the garage or if the Commission believes there are alternates to demolishing the garage. 3. Continue the public hearing until the September 3, 2008 Commission meeting. The 60 day decision deadline for the request is September 16, 2008. RECOMMENDATION Review and take action on the request. attachment: Application and supporting documents from the applicant Heritage Preservation Commission Demolition Request Permit Demolition Permit NO.pem 16<3'~/ :t:ft- J~~ Address of Project: II 0'-+ S'"IJ:L S-y-: :5 I ';.~ 030 Ol.oI'3Oo5' Parcel No. :33 O~D ;;l.() 1 '3 ODS3 f6 Lot J Block d-- f SubdivisionMA R SH $ ~b t'i I "l/ -orJ Applicant: (<..Y.80h- Co^,~-r-R.UL-rl ON Address: gS, 0 ~OtJT~\/JLL ,-R.N ITelephone No.: tosJ. ~-cJ-+7CJ J-A~. ~l>,M;.J. 550~ Owner if different than Applicant: '$T6P~ ~ lSE..v'f::~Y ~ I ~~ Address:~ ~ ~T. ~ . Type of Structure: b-v4-1<A6-f- Telephone No. te:c>/. '-f~ - ~ oQR Age of Structure: '1 Condition of Structure: ~ AJl:r J I\J o,.J ',f:>~~ Intended Use of Site after Demolition:_B{JI~ ;.J1f..iN &~~. ( Signature of Applicant ~cLJ~ 711~/o€ Date Signature of Owner 7-/<)~oy Date *After review and approval of the demolition permit request with the Heritage Preservation Commission, a building permit must be obtained with the City of Stillwater Building Department. The fee for the building permit is based on the valuation of the demolition project. Office Use Only HPC Review Date: o Approved o Denied City Planner/Community Development Director Date t ClTY ()~ 5.-, ~ H-t:~l"'~ ~~~ 0,..] Co....w. t$l t>J d-Ilp~~~ N~ 'STI~A,W~ ~d- Il,s/os '~~R. ~B\tRS. ({) ~ -nt~ l.-\: ' ~ ..C-, TH-lS ~ \S 4: ~uesr- FoR. 6-f:MOl-t:'"\10N of- ov~ b4RA:~ ~ (),.J ~ , JJo~t+w~-r Ce~ o? oJR t>Po-t=>~Y 4"""\ l(o+5~S, , L-o--r-I , ~LOC~;L O~ "uJ}~H-6 Ab~ r-r-/oAl . Ou~ f>A-,Q..~L i:t~ t4R..€:.', 33 030 02Dl'?>o05.;l~ 33 cv30 ~l3oo~ WJ..l t W {../-A\I~ B~ CoM.8/^-1~ !Al J4 SvPp.ofZl1~ k~ ~~~ ~I\A kJA.sH'~N Cov~ .L.4-r-.st> ~S. A-s PfR. Co,..)\I(d<.SA--rIDN '-Vm4 hON,4L-b tSu~f i-r~ s,-,e.u6;r~ Is iN ~ e>vt:ft- S-o ~~ oL-bs l Bvr A.,...- -r-l4-t SAM.t -n Mi I-Io~ S ,..YO if 1~1LlCAL- -S\ G::NI FI CA-J~ . -ro ~t J'o.-1'=-I~o.e~ A-,.J~ ~..,.....~~ o~ S~ b S~~ \50 rJO"'\ ~;JO~lCA-L-L..o/ ~t8~ i Wf. )4A.v'- fNrUoStfb AL.o~ W\-n4 -n-Il~ ~~,- A~ .sWoWI,.Jb- J-o~oJ-J ()f- ~,~ ~~l A Cev~ ~ bt..?u...\~IOrJ tPf' ~~W ~l::> 19u~ eWNtB.6H-I~l ~s o~ ~\JA-'1Io^'Si b~h1D,JS ef ~c~ru~ ~ ~ b0vtoJ-tSH-tb l~ "tJ~ bq~t S~Ot=trl;Jb- ~A ~/VL f)v{<.. Co^",~JbR STA11f.f&~ ~)JO.M.'6IN~SlB~L...tTY o~ ~AtRJN& ~~V6iVR~ As"TO ~ BJIL!::::4A1b- ~ ~Mt.. ~ 19;:' :;OV;J~ ~vc:tL>R~ I LAJt- ~() ~ flPPL-<(,"'tr- ~~ v4 V,4A.JAIJ(t ~ Bt- ABLl '"'TO f<e- Wllb l~ -6AMf -ryti M~ ~12f er~v~ w\-\ICK \/J.~ WA,.rr"11) ~ 0\16, · W~ f-t-tl \/(z,. N 0'1~ I iJl,.- (2) LYr 1""""'-":~ ) ~~ of=- WLAU JJb- ,l~ IS -5~c..--r0~ W\"'rt* ff,.J~ -SA~ -rYf>~ o?- -5-r-P-~RJf.. W+\\c+l 5a..t.+t..L. ~ --r~ SA~ (,""vrf>R..'~ A,..s~ l,.J~rTY E)~ -rf.U:- N~'&H-eo~ ~$\bN. SJ~~LV, {1w~~ ,$cG.hAlJ frUPEfev 6.[( -450 ~6('f7 P YeI II' },-/;-;. A.wz~ 7-'7 <' T~~I cbv{~ .. .' ". llirI" ........ . .. 0', ;':(,:. .,<,.," -. ", .,"..-. : ~':'" .....:... ........ ...."..:.:.:...... ." ..'....:<.. ..........,..;:':... ...>tJ........... ..........:.:.. .' .'., \ a"""""'S" . '."'..........:.g. .' '0'" "0"''''> ',""' . . " . . . . . .' , . . . - -' . '," . . ,'. ."." . . . , . . ., . ' . .::.:....Z::'.";'~(:";,;,:'(S'::...'......:...... .'C{" .""t:.."" . .... . ,~,::"(),~",,,,,,,,,,,. V ~, . . ... .J..,:. .'~~"j LAND RECORDS 14949 62ND STREET NORTH * PO BOX 6 * STILLWATER, MN 55082-0006 FAX: 430-6178 * PHONE: 430-6170 RECB'ED JUL 1.4 Z008 ASSIEBS~JlENT Combining Real Estate Parcels into One Tax Parcel: ~ .I1'be. . r{l '1-^V' . u kf ~~ld11 Under MN Statute 272.46, owners of contiguous property, which has' exactly the same owners listed for the property and meets certain other conditions, may combine the parcels into one tax statement. To be combined, the following conditions must be met: The parcels must have exactly the same (identical) ownership. Parcels may only be combined with contiguous' (bordering) parcels in the same ownership. Application will not be processed until all current year taxes are paid in full. All parcels must be taxed the same (city, township, TIF, EDA, Green Acres, etc.) All Special Assessments should be paid on all parcels or the city/town would need to recertify those special assessments for the new parcels. CAUTION Parcels that have been combined cannot be divided again without local municipality approval. If location is in a township, Washington County Land Management Office must also approve. . .~ . Combined property tax will be reflected on the next year's statement Owner (Applicant) Name: Jte~ E"y\ Address:~ 5th st. S . S+fdlA')~\'~ Mf\J ~t\d&~tl 1)<2 V\-\-l ev Phone Number: bY f-Lf.3 9 -'l oq~ Parcels to be combined: 33 030 33 030 ~() \'300 S d.... cQ() 1300 $3 Signature: Pw~ - Date: 7-/y-oR Washington County does not discriminae on the basis of race, color, national origin, sex, religion, age, and handicapped status in employment or the provision of sel1iic,es. . . r'.' Receipt#: 42893 3653519 11111111111111 WAR $46.00 CRY Filed No Delinquent Taxes Transfer Entered Certified Filed and/or recorded on: 7/23/2007 3:15 PM 3653519 Return to: ATTORNEY'S TITLE OF BAYPORT 363 5TH AVE N BAYPORT MN 55003 Office of the County Recorder Property Records & Taxpayer Services Washington County, MN Kevin J Corbid, County Recorder (Top 3 inches reserved for recording data) ~~ 0/30 <JC'> \~ no F)d.-; Minnesota Uniform Conveyancing Blanks Form 10.1.5 (2006) WARRANTY DEED Individual(s) to Joint Tenants DEED TAX DUE: $ DATE: November20,2003 (monthldaylyear) FOR VALUABLE CONSIDERATION, Donald W. T. Wessel and Deanne M. T. Wessel, husband and wife (insert name and marital status of each Grantor) , ("Grantor"), hereby conveys and warrants to Stephen Diemler and Beverly Diemler, husband and wife (insert name of each Grantee) , ("Grantee"), as joint tenants, real property in Washington County, Minnesota, legally described as follows: Lot One (1) and the North Sixteen and Two-thirds (N 16 2/3) feet of Lot Two (2), Block Two (2), Marsh's Addition to Stillwater. Check here if a/l or part of the described real property is Registered (Torrens) 0 together with all hereditaments and appurtenances belonging thereto, subject to the following exceptions: Check applicable box: . The Seller certifies that the Seller does not know of any wells on the described real property. o A well disclosure certificate accompanies this ~ document. o I am familiar with the property described in this instrument and I certify that the status and number of wells on the described real property have not changed since the last previously filed well disclosure certificate, Grantor 8~~ W/~ rJQ4'~-~ ~ooald W. T. W.".I <----> , . ~../I,/.~ (signature) Deanne M. T. Wessel Page 1 of2 , Page 2 of 2 Minnesota Uniform Conveyancing Blanks Form 10.1,5 State of Minnesota, County of Washington This instrument was acknowledged before me on Donald W. T. Wessel and Deanne M. T. Wessel, 6 7, by (inserl name and marital status of each Grantor) (Seal, if any) LISA A. STEINKE Notary Public Minnesota My CommiSSIon Expires January 31,2012 THIS INSTRUMENT WAS DRAFTED BY: (inserl name and address) Dwight P. Cummins CUMMINS LAW OFFICE, P.A. 363 5th Avenue North Bayport. MN 55003 651-430-2630 I_~ a..~ me (and Rank): My commission expires: (month/day/year) TAX STATEMENTS FOR THE REAL PROPERTY DESCRIBED IN THIS INSTRUMENT SHOULD BE SENT TO: (inserl name and address of Grantee to whom tax statements should be sent) Stephen Diemler and Beverly Diemler 1104 South 5th Street Stillwater, MN 55082 ~ EMPSONS.COM DON@EMPSONS.COM P. O. Box 791 STILLWATER. MN 55082 (651)351-0172 FAX: (651) 430-2051 Elnpson Archives July 18, 2008 TO: Beverly & Stephen Diemler 1104 Fifth Street South Stillwater, MN 55082 Marsh's Addition, Block 2, Lot 1 Report on Garage The garage structure, in the northwest corner of the lot, measures approximately 26 feet by 22 feet. The one-and-one-half story structure presently has two car bays with an exterior hatch to the upper level on the south side. There are four six-pane-over-six-pane windows in the garage; the building has car siding. The construction lumber is not full dimension. Considering the type of siding, the style of windows, the hatch to the upper level, I would judge the building to have been built somewhere between 1910 and 1930. The 1924 Sanborn Atlas indicates a building of approximately the same dimensions and the same height, in the same location (as the present building) on the lot. Attached to the (garage) structure were several small one-story structures that have since been removed. On the Sanborn map, there is no indication the building was a garage in 1924, which would have been marked with an "N' (auto). There is no building permit for the structure. I can find no justification that the building (garage) would be eligible for the National Register of Historic Places, nor can I find that it has any unique historical significance to Stillwater. Donald Empson Kathleen Vadnais EMPSONS.COM DON@EMPSONS.COM Elllpson Archives ~} ;~. -~---~ ~:" ~-'l_.~ __' r-... '" '<-, [8 -.----------~:cl.,-.~ '1- E:?...J ~~ . .. . . j ...:: I jj >4800NVH'M >~ " <So- ~ ~ ...... f..rl hj '\i '" ,. -- ""<>1" \,.__J <:,. . ; _____~_d ~ ;-,'{o .~. ---l ~ .... ,j,-' ! )( "-'- ---"1 i I j I P. O. Box 791 STILLWATER. MN 55082 (651) 351-0172 FAX: (651) 430-2051 f~~r..[ ']] fb ." J. _ _,' {; " ~ <r ~ --s.- ~ t-:= (}) 1:1 .... to . (.f) " l _____ '" F:l t~ -.rJ <.f) '1- -, t ~ '. v: 1 f\~ v__~ PARC~L#'S: 33 ~ 33 t-Ol ~ { M.A-R.S# S 0'- oc..L l( ~ 030 0'30 ~l A-b /),-., ON R22W Rl\ W RlOW Vicinity Map o c 35 I Scale in Fool TluattrawinQiilherewllolBcompi!B!iOn llIIdfl!PIl!ductionofW.dlecordsll5lhey apPlNlin\{ariclUf,WashlngIGIlCOun!Voffooes Tl>edrilwintsflOUldbl'llMIdtorlelefeooe pUIllOse5~~~ISNII ,espon5iblelOlilOYIr\eCCVl'- SoufGe:WUI\iflOIonCOYnlVsuron!yOI'sOII\l;e Phone 1651jfJ0.687S P.,.,el RIll tlased on ~<<lO WOrmetioll (:Ulf8nI\tw'oUQh:....w3t.2Oll8 MapDJinled:July1..1OO8 Proposal Submitted To: COMPLETE GENERAL CONTRACTORS KITCHENS. BATHS. FAMILY ROOMS REHAB & RENOVATION WORK FREE ESTIMATES Proposal No. O~7JS"'ol f> f\6-E:. I orl Dak 7}15" o~ , Work To Be Performed At: ork Phone: Phone: Co O.crz:::> All material is guaranteed to be as specified, and the above work to be performed in accordance with the drawings and specifications submitted for above work and completed in a substantial workmanlike manner for the sum of Dollars ($S,aoD,~ ) With payments to be made as follows:--'.J.J~ Al Cc:,AA-t>~""'J eN 0 F- ~~'\/'AL. ACCEPTANCE OF PROPOSAL The above prices, specifications and conditions are satisfactory and are hereby accepted. the work as specified. Payment will be made as outlined above. Signature Any alteration or deviation from above specifications involving extra costs, will be executed only upon written orders, and will become an extra charge over and above the estimate. All agreements contingent upon strikes, accidents or delays beyond our control. Owner to carry fire, tornado and other necessary insurance upon above work. Workman's Compensation and Public Liability Insurance on above work to be taken out by Rybog Construction. We reserve the right to Lien and will supply release of Liens. Date: 7-1S-~lJ? RYBOG CONSTRUCTION NOTE- THIS PROPOSAL MAY BE WITHDRAWN BY US IF NOT ACCEPTED WITHIN ~AYS. You are authorized to do Signature IF ACCEPTED, PLEASE SIGN AND REMIT WHITE COPY. (PLEASE KEEP YELLOW COpy FOR REFERENCE) STILLWATER GAZETTE AD INSERTION ORDER Salesperson: CINDY LEHMANN Printed at 07/22/08 10:17 ------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Acct#: 285406 BEV A. DIEMBER 1104 5TH ST. S. STILLWATER MN 55082 Contact: JERRY HARVIEUX Phone: (651)439-9098 Fax#: Email: Ad#: 854534 Start: 07/22/08 Times Ord: 3 STD 1.00 X Ra te : COPC Class: 3260 MISC. FOR SALE Descript: ANTQ GARAGE FOR SALE, $5, Given by: ***************************** Created: jrobb 07/22/08 10:12 Last Changed: jrobb 07/22/08 10:16 Status: N Stop: Times 3.00 08/05/08 Run: * * * * Words: 6 Agency: ------------------------------------------------------------------------------- PUB ZONE ED TP START INS STOP S2 SV 97 S 07/22,29 08/05 SMTWTFS Antq Garage for sale, $5,000/BO, 651-439-9098 v .~ ~..-:,:{... . ::!;;~~ ~< '. -:"'~-"~''''-~ ..- I' '~','1"..7,", ,'" ...., :'..' '/"', '. '.~ 4 :, ft? \\. 0"; ',.. ~'. . J' ~~~'~';~"'fl..,..,.' I' '. ~~" '\lY';.. .,., .... ~,>,,<~,~;:;~~ .'Tt;; ~;:",. ,.: 'S' ~ti'~ ,- .' \ YBOG .._~ 8510 DEMONTREVILLE TRAIL LAKE ELMO, MN 55042 651-269-2479 OR 612-747-4159 MN Llc # 20422135 Proposal Submitted To: COMPLETE GENERAL CONTRACTORS KITCHENS. BATHS. FAMILY ROOMS REHAB & RENOVATION WORK FREE ESTIMATES Proposal No. D<i?7 15-0 ',).. f'~ J~l Dite 7//5 0<6 Work To Be Performed At: Date of Plans: Architect: We hereby propose to furnish the materials and perform the labor necessary for J. , / I" ... t: 1 t I All material is guaranteed to be as specified, and the above work to be performed in accordance with the drawings and specifications submitted for above work and completed in a substantial workmanlike manner for the sum of /.; . . . ' e' ^.' . ", Dollars ($(P7.1-f9 7,00 ) With payments t be made as follows: ,) ,)y;t.J;J. .2 t' 1>t.b\~ s.> A..t'/l-\.j~~7S to ," I'). .1" J ../. ,', ,.c- . ") c; ... ..... t,'~ Cl Any alteration or deviation from above specifications involving extra costs, will be executed only upon written orders, and will become an extra charge over and above the estimate. All agreements contingent upon strikes, accidents or delays beyond our control. Owner to carry tire, tornado and other necessary insurance upon above work. Workman's Compensation and Public Liability Insurance on above work to be taken out by Rybog Construction. We reserve the right to Lien and will supply release of Liens. ~ RVBOG CONSTRUCTION NOTE- THIS PROPOSAL MAY BE WITHDRAWN BY US IF NOT ACCEPTED WITHIN ~~J DAYS. ACCEPTANCE OF PROPOSAL The above prices, specifications and conditions are satisfactory and are hereby accepted. You are authorized to do the work. as.spec..ified. Payment will be made as outlined above. . ..M (. .... '. .". ~; Date. 7//4 c~ slgnal/!-- 1.)-<---.1{. ~- Signature IF ACCEPTED, PLEASE SIGN AND REMIT WHITE COPY. (PLEASE KEEP YELLOW COpy FOR REFERENCE) Oversized Drawing out for Scanning A copy of this drawing may be viewed in the Community Development Department at the Stillwater City Hall during normal business hours orMNt,'EOIl ') Heritage Preservation Commission DATE: July 31, 2008 CASE NO.: 08-40 APPLICANT: Mark Balay REQUEST: Concept Design Review of Store Front Changes to the St Croix Drug Building at 132 Main St S LOCATION: 132 Main St S COMPREHENSIVE PLAN DISTRICT: CC - Community Commercial ZONING: CBD - Central Business District HPC DATE: August 4,2008 REVIEWERS: Community Dev. Director PREPARED BY, Michel Pogge, City Planner tt4 DISCUSSION The applicant is requesting a discussion on proposed changes to the St Croix Drug building. This includes: 1. Selective explorative demolition under the existing stucco fa<;ade in order to discover the condition of the limestone to determine what is required to restore the original limestone building fa<;ade. 2. Explore the existing window to determine original sizes and masonry openings. 3. Discus and review a proposed store front for the new first floor tenant Dairy Queen. STAFF RECOMMENDATION Review and discuss the plans, provide feedback to the applicant, and consider approving a request to conduct selective explorative demolition on the building. attachments: Applicant's Form, letter from the applicant, and site photos. . DESIGN REVIEW APPUCATION FORM use nul Date Filed: & Receipt No..: Fee: $25.00 COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT DEPARTMENT CITY OF STILLWATER 216 NORTH FOURTH STREET STIllWATER, MN 55082 The applicant is responsible for the completeness and accuracy of all forms and supporting material submitted In connection with any application. All supporting material (i.e. photos, sketches, etc.) submitted with application becomes the property of the City of Stillwater. Photos, sketches and a letter of intent is required. Fourteen (tA) copies of all supporting materials are required. All following Information is required . PROPERTY IDENTIfICA nON Address of projectJ 04 S~l'Assessors Parcel No. Zoning Dlstrict~ Description of Project in detail L-ou o-J W 11JJ:tJ~ "J hereby state the foregoing statements nd all data, information and evidence submitted herewith In al/ respects, to the best of my knowledge and belie!, to be true and COITed. 1 further csrtify 1 will comply with the permit if It is grantl!d and used" If representative Is not property owner, then property owner's signature is reouired. Property Owner ~ Ifl ~ J {)UI; (lj Representatlve yu...~S . ~ '-1 ~ Mailing Address / tJ/tj 5:. r/;ffELC,y .s;:Maillng Address \, c:; -:f.\ ~S"\. Oty State Zip (1;((bl1iE III /Y;U .Jr::s&1'pOty State Zip :n SSOt1, Telephone No. t..J"/- Y-7f' - ;J Y// Telephone No. to ~ 1-1 &;7- 203S /) ../-' Signature (/;;;';77) /---v----;?) i;:k-c~/t:~:-(/ i!<ReqUired) ______=c:~ H:\mcnamalCl\Shella\2005\deslgn revieW pennit.wpd cf, '. "'. -...... July 13, 2005 ]..::E:f1f120f"" ~S, ~ exP~I/OJ.-.J ~l:5nt1lT-n.;..0 'E t' "L- ~I L '-0 GJ -r'-(. Michel Pogge From: Sent: To: Cc: Subject: mark balay [mark@balayarchitects.com] Wednesday, July 16, 2008 12:46 AM Michel Pogge sales@stillwaterdairyqueen.com; 'Greg Gartner'; kkoerner@Gartnerstudios.com Dairy Queen Submittals Mike, SUP/ Variance Submittal All the issues are the same as the last submittal except that this walk up window will have stacking space for 8 which stays on the property. We will accomplish this by enlarging the exterior vestibule that already exists on the corner. I will have illustrations of this for you next Wed., upon my return, as we discussed. The numbers you requested are on the second page of the app lication which will be submitted this week. Design Review There are several distinct categories of mini-projects in rehabilitating the exterior fac;ade of this building: 1) There is a second building/ storefront which was conglomerated onto this building. It was formerly the Hall mark card shop. 2) The condition of the original limestone underneath the stucco is reported to be very poor by the current and longtime owner We will bring in a masonry restoration specialist to start dealing with this. It is the wish of the new owner To uncover and restore the original limestone fac;ade materials. 3) The Roof Parapet and Fac;ade top have had a cover over with stucco and we have to do investigation to see exactly where we are starting from. The new owner wishes to recreate the original parapet and resotre the "historical" signage that was part of that parapet. 4) The existing windows do not represent in height was the original windows did. Our intent is to update thises windows But we must do investigative demolition to determine our options. The new owner wishes to return the windows to their original masonry opening size. 5) The immediate need is a re-work of the Main St. storefront and corner recessed entry to accomadate the new first floor tenant Dairy Queen. The new owners goal is to get the Dariy Queen open as soon as possible, so the interior finish-out and new storefront! walk-up window/ entry will be commenced before the complete exterior fac;ade work/ rehabilitation is finalized in terms of design and construction phasing. We are asking the HPC for approval to begin selective and investigative demolition on the exterior for purposes of creating and submitting a follow-up plan to them in a second session. We are asking the HPC for approval of the geometry, and materials of the storefront renovation which is an expansion of the existing recessed opening by deepening it to 16 ft. and squaring it off. We intend to remove all of the lower, and modern brick, remove the existing Rexal drug company signage and raise the awning up to a higher level. The new storefront windows and doors will be limestone wainscot with a black anodized storefront system. The details of this Replacement storefront will have to be adjusted based upon investigative demolition. We ask that staff be allowed to judge and approve these adjusted details knowing that they, may also opt to say that the changes are to involved and need to be resolved with the full committee. We plan to have a second submittal to the HPC at the next monthly meeting in Sept. which will wrap up all the finalized design from our investigative demolition, into a full package for exterior fac;ade renovations. 1 Don't hesitate calling if you have any questions or require additional information. Sincerely, Mark S. Balay Cell # 651-967-2085 2 SIDE\,!"\L K [ ] O[r COD 0- Ul pi I 0 ]0 DO DO D - [ [ )) L CODD - ~=€ .L [ )) [ )) - I 01 ~ 0 a co ]) ([]=D I co ~ co D n n n COr=D ([ D ([] hNC In ~ n = CODU co D co D IGID ~ I W i I LJ FREEZER Mens - ClI1.ER ~ ~ ~ I ~ - I I I 'WOf"lE'ns ~C TtRAGE I I I UN ;} 1//-- i 2 d I I I o : .., ..-: \\ l\~ - ~ ~. ..~-.'...;-- ."~ . ~~~;.~ .=.....~~ ~~- -. ~~-- .. :;..~ -- -~ ..... ~~.~ ~-=~~ -~~ Chestnut Street, Stillwater, looking west with horse drawn vehicles and a streetcar. A photographer is on the right. Photographer: John Runk (1878-1964) Photograph Collection 1912 Location no. Runk 333 Negative no. Runk333 .-. ~/:::;- ,\.r' .~1 '\\ \ r~\ "\\ '\\ ..~ - . ,.Ii.1 ~.- "f , ~ Corner of Chestnut and Main Streets, showing primarily the St. Croix Drug Store. Photographer: John Runk (1878-1964) Photograph Collection 1913 Location no. Runk 346 Negative no. Runk346 p;, Streetcar on Chestnut Street, Stillwater. Photographer: John Runk (1878-1964) Photograph Collection 1932 Location no. Runk 388 Negative no. Runk388 ... ~ 1.1 ~~~~~ . . . East Chestnut Street looking west, Stillwater. Photographer: John Runk (1878-1964) Photograph Collection 6/1934 Location no. Runk 396 Negative no. Runk396 ~ "-I.? t--":' ~. ~-...~-; __..<t.,. u"", .. ~ - .. 3 ,'JI' .. iii '"- ~~ '" St. Croix Drug Company, Stillwater. Photographer: John Runk (1878-1964) Photograph Collection 6/4/1934 Location no. Runk 577 Negative no. Runk577 j 1"- -r--- m DI East Chestnut Street looking east, Stillwater. Photographer: John Runk (1878-1964) Photograph Collection 6/5/1934 Location no. Runk 392 Negative no. Runk392 n 11- Jr;, --.....- g ~~ . , th Stillwater. k'ng nor 1 . Street 100 I ) South Main k (1878-1964 h . John Run Photograp er. . 6/5/1934 Ph Collection Photogra Runk 400 Location no. Negative no. ~""'!""""" Runk400 ..:.. c':' ..~~+;-:rj;~~~.F;,;,'~-::p;. ~-?-'. -,. ~ St. Croix Drug, Main and Myrtle, Stillwater. Photographer: John Runk (1878-1964) Photograph Collection ca. 1950 Location no. Runk 660 Negative no. Runk660 , March 24, 2008 March 24, 2008 March 24, 2008 @--1 ~~ From: maps.live.com Photo from approximately December 2007 From: maps.live.com Photo from approximately December 2007 From: maps.live.com Photo from approximately December 2007 "lIwat ':J (I f M INN Memo Community Development Department To: From: Heritage Preservation Commission Michel Pogge, City Planner ~<r Thursday, July 31, 2008 Heirloom Home Project Date: Re: Message: Attached please find the final drafts of the property write-up for year one of the heirloom home project. This set of drafts completes the first year of the project. Please review this and have comments ready at your August 4th meeting. Greg Mathis from The 106th Group will be at the meeting to review and answer any questions you may have on them. Staff has sent out the RFP for year two of the Heirloom Home project. Proposals are due back to the City on August 8th. I would ask that the commission again this year appoint a subcommittee to review the proposals prior to your September 3rd meeting. It is my hope that the Commission will recommend a consultant to the City Council at your September meeting. Thanks, Mike From the desk of... Michel Pogge, AICP . City Planner' City of Stillwater' 216 N. 4th Street. Stillwater, MN 55082 651.430-8822 . Fax: 651.430-8810 . email: mpogge@ci.stillwater.mn.us City of Stillwater HPC -- HHLS Website -- Property Information lof2 . Home . Properties . About the Program . Rehabilitation . Search Property Infonnation Printer-friendly Version Staples, Llewellyn, House Stillwater HPC 7/31/2008 Parcel Identification Number (PIN): 2103020430045 Site Address: 1214 1st St N Construction Date: 1894 Builder: Architect: Architectural Style: Vernacular N aritive: This vernacular house was built circa 1894 for Llewellyn Staples, the son of Josiah and Lydia E. Staples and nephew of Stillwater lumber baron Isaac Staples. According to the 1894-1895 city directory, Llewellyn Staples was a clerk with the Schulenburg and Boeckeler Lumber Company. Later, he moved on to become the manager of the Staples-Atlee Saw Mill Company and the manager of the Campbell, Irvine Company general store. Mr. Staples only lived in this house for ten years, moving to a larger home as his career blossomed. The one-and-a-half-story, frame house has a limestone foundation, masonite siding, one-over-one double-hung City of Stillwater HPC -- HHLS Website -- Property Information 20f2 windows, and a cross gable roof. The house retains its metal roof, a type of roof that was popular in Stillwater at the turn of the twentieth century. The one-story, hipped-roof porch on the southeast corner of the house appears to have been enclosed circa 1920, based on its three-over-one double-hung windows. A one-story, gable-roofed rear addition was also added around this time. It also has a metal roof. An unusual, one-story, concrete block garage with a flat roofwas constructed south of the house circa 1970. ~1,w1 I IP>I I ~~ )" lIt :, j:;;;:;1 . St cror--,- e. E I ;JIDi~ve: I!D D. [J 0 z .. :; .~ . .stJllw.a~:eli' .Ave E 5 jj ve~ -D~D DaD I~ 'I j~cto '0 0 D~ II I ~ Afi.~l St W A~pBn st E l ~ J~D~D ~~r ~N l \ J O~Dg: ~ m~ 1.1 \, \"1 tb~.OfY 5C ~< M?P da~ '~2008 Tele Iftl?s- Te I I~ vf Vs? City of Stillwater HPC -- HHLS Website -- Property Information lof2 . Home . Properties . About the Program . Rehabilitation . Search Propeliy Infonnation Printer- friendly Version Mahoney, James M. and Maggie, House Stillwater HPC 6/1/2008 Parcel Identification Number (PIN): 3303020110019 Site Address: 709 1 st St S Construction Date: 1870 Builder: Architect: Architectural Style: Folk Victorian N aritive: This vernacular house was constructed circa 1870 for James M. and Maggie Mahoney. The 1887 city directory indicates that James M. Mahoney was a plasterer and Maggie was employed as a milliner at 225 East Chestnut Street. According to the 1890-1891 city directory, Maggie and Mary Mahoney were the primary residents of the house. By 1890, Maggie was employed as a clerk at Samuel Mathews and Company. Maggie Mahoney lived in the one-and-a-half-story, frame house on this property for City of Stillwater HPC -- HHLS Website -- Property Information 20f2 over twenty years. The house has clapboard siding with corner boards, a front gable roof with overhanging eaves, and a tall brick chimney rear the ridgeline. The defining features of this Folk Victorian house include its tall and narrow one-over-one double-hung windows; one-story, rectangular bay windows on the north and south elevations; and full-width front porch with a mansard roof, turned spindles, and decorative brackets that was added sometime in the 1890s. The Folk Victorian style that was popular in the United States in the late nineteenth century features details that are evocative of the Italianate and Queen Anne styles. A one-story, gable-roof addition on the rear elevation was constructed circa 1905. The addition rests on wood posts and is faced in clapboard siding. The one-story, front-gabled, clapboard-sided garage is located adjacent to the house was built in 1982. ~I \~ '~'.J ... t~1 O~e}l.D'\N~, ~ .... ~~'.0~... 91.. . ..' _ 'L t:. ~ ~ )~ . ~~D\ ~, 5\J1L\N.~'roIr'.Q....U. ....~.. '. ~..... @,..'''' W "000 \ 'r eo\ \.N ..... ~ ~cso5:j d.y \ '~\ ] Wilr~rcl StE <Q> "\ '. ~D [J D~U~ ~~~" , J:hiJI Sto - ~ChUd"Dro.i1l S'D~ ~ ~ 9S \ .' N ~ ~\ ~I @) ~. ~-~ \~.'" (!JJ- 00 0 D @ 00 =retb ,I l~n rl E BurtinglQfi Sf 8l1lrli.nglon $t 'E j ~l U L.~M;~J.aialt)fclO~ fele]A/Ia51- er~~of Use ~ City of Stillwater HPC -- HHLS Website -- Property Information lof2 . Home . Properties . About the Progralll . Rehabilitation . Search Property Infonnation Printer- friendly Version Doyle, Stephen and Mary Ann, House S till water HPC 6/1/2008 Parcel Identification Number (PIN): 3303020110018 Site Address: 711 1st St S Construction Date: 1871 Builder: Architect: Architectural Style: Folk Victorian Naritive: In 1871, Stephen and Mary Ann Doyle had this house built. Doyle, a riverman, took out a $208 mortgage from Hersey, Bean & Brown, a sawmill and lumber company, to partially pay for construction costs. The Doyle's resided in this house with their three children and Mary Anne's mother until 1880. A deed was never recorded for the Doyle's property and Fayette Marsh reclaimed the property around 1874 and sold the house to William Stein (Donald Empson, The East Half of the Churchill, Nelson & Slaughter Addition Residential Area, 2003 :32). Stein, who owned a jewelry store at 108 South Main Street, owned the house through the mid-1880s. This one-and-a-half-story, Folk Victorian house features clapboard siding, one-over-one double-hung windows, and a front gable roofwith City of Stillwater HPC -- HHLS Website -- Property Information 20f2 decorative shingles in the gable. In addition to the full-width front porch, there is a one-story rectangular bay window with a mansard roof on the south elevation. The house features details evocative of the Queen Anne style, including the full-width porch with a mansard roof and the decorative woodwork in the front gable. Based on the style of these elements, they were most likely added after the building's original construction, possibly around 1890. Over time, the front and rear porches have been enclosed as screen porches. ~\ ~D~\tJ ~ ~ ~~~ \. ~ 'L~ ~ ~j,> (/'I ""IIi: S D tiC Ot \ ~'" \ de~\J~ ,\~ \", J~D [jrdo(J~ ~:~ \ ]:hi'lIStC'" r----'. ~ Ch.tJ.'iDcllm$t~.~ ~ .~'.'I' .:~.- '9"5:,,."..'1.\ .~I I\J en ~:!;( .~' ~ ...::J . ~ ~ ., ~I @ ~ (I}-~ \...." mL W DO @ l~n '~I =:1:t~t~9 8v,rlington 5t E ~ ~ I l~p~al@~8 ~Af,~- e~~Of Use ~ City of Stillwater HPC -- HHLS Website -- Property Information lof2 . Home . Properties . About the Program . Rehabilitation . Search Property Infonnation Printer- friendly Version Miller, John and Elizabeth, House Stillwater HPC 6/1/2008 Parcel Identification Number (PIN): 3303020110017 Site Address: 717 1 st St S Construction Date: 1885 Builder: Architect: Architectural Style: Queen Anne Naritive: The original owners of this elegant, two-and-a-half-story Queen Anne style residence were John L. and Elizabeth Miller, who built the house circa 1885. Miller was a carpenter and house mover, who likely built the house in the Italianate style. In 1890, after John's death, Elizabeth sold the house and moved in with her son Benjamin S. Miller at 615 South Broadway Street. In 1911, this house was damaged by a large fire which cost an estimated $2,51 4.92 (Donald Empson, The East Half of the City of Stillwater HPC -- HHLS Website -- Property Information 20f2 Churchill, Nelson & Slaughter Addition Residential Area, Empson 2003:33). It was during this time that the house was reportedly renovated from an Italianate box to its present Queen Anne form. Today, the house rests on its original limestone foundation and has clapboard siding, a steeply pitched, irregularly shaped cross gable roof with a front facing gable, and a brick chimney centered on the ridgeline. The asymmetrical fa9ade, wraparound porch and the two-story polygonal bay on the side elevation are all characteristics of the Queen Anne style. The house also features one-light fixed leaded glass windows and tall and narrow one-over-one double-hung windows with bracketed wood lintels. The classical columns on the front porch are exclusive to the Free Classic subtype of the Queen Anne style. From 1917 to 1929, Frank H. Welch resided in the house. Welch owned the F.M. Welch Printing Company which was located at 224 South Main Street. His company published of the Stillwater Messenger. In the late 1920s, Welch was the manager of the St. Croix Poster Advertising Company and the Acme Poster Advertising Company. In 1930, the Welch's moved to St. Cloud. Ernest Schad owned the house in the 1940s and 1950s. More recently, a one-story, gable-roofed addition with screen porch that respects the design, scale, and materials of the house was added to the rear of the house. Offset to the side and rear of the house is a large, modern, one-and-a-half-story, clapboard sided garage with a side gable roof that features a front gable dormer with paired one-over-one windows that is reminiscent of a carriage house. ~lj- ~.~ .' ~ ,~......... I o~'5,h,'~,' ,\~ ,t,.' . ,,'E:., . ',' ~~~~'",~, )y'~ ~~sO ~ ....~ ~aOt. l ~', ~~~e G~,,~~ \"~, o -. t~ \ , J~D [ VJl/i'~rclD5t \'-Y.u:'1, ~. ,\'\ ;;; ~ ~ :---.~ \ J:hi:U St[J ----' _Qhl UIlJ'cll.iH s;or. ~ ~ i '@\ ~I ,,~' ~,~ ~ '\'\ ~L@~~ .' D~D~ . '~ J~D- [J, ~:Q:J;J . 8~rlinnlon St E, \\ ~ n ~l 0 D [J l~ .~___,_ ~OL~.~~~ifft~~~~felej~~laSf er 1 of Use ~' '~ City of Stillwater HPC -- HHLS Website -- Property Information lof2 . Home . Properties . About the Program . Rehabilitation . Search Property Infonnation Printer- friendly Version Vernacular House 106 Group 10/1/2007 Parcel Identification Number (PIN): 3303020140090 Site Address: 1340 1 st St S Construction Date: 1878 Builder: Architect: Architectural Style: Vernacular N aritive: This two-story, vernacular dwelling with a T-shaped plan was constructed circa 1878 in Churchill's Addition to Stillwater. The house is set on a rock-faced, cut stone foundation and features clapboard siding with corner boards, narrow, one-over-one double-hung sash windows, and a cross gable roof. The house has a number of Queen Anne details such as a wrap-around front porch, diamond-shaped wood shingles in the gable ends, and decorative bargeb oards in the eaves. The hipped-roof porch has Tuscan columns, which is a common variation of Queen Anne architecture, which is more commonly associated with turned spindles. A one-story bay with decorative brackets under its eaves is located on the north elevation and a modern one-story addition City of Stillwater HPC -- HHLS Website -- Property Information 20f2 is located behind the house. The first known inhabitants of this residence were Edwin J. and Minnie Larson, who lived in the house in the 1930s. During these years Edwin was employed in the trucking business. By 1942, Andrew J. Berquist, an estimator, and his wife Marie L. Berquist were residing in this home. J!U LJ;L@JUlJ~L!-~ 1 'JJV DooD ~ ==rctb 0 D D .~ . lJaD~LrD Bwrl~r.9!~n 51l~ Marsh St Wro 5. MS!'!lh $1 E D D~ J~D D D;ooD~llli; li[l[] ts IOrJ~m;SIWI 65th StN~ 1 CtN . . . '! cl' 64111 51 IN li~iew i ~ !I I~I 'm'slet'J 18, ~ !,'i J_~I ~. z ~t. ~ ~ . . 133rd $t t~ .:... . '6:3.rd St iN C~nd SlrNr~ap a~~?8~td~IeI~t1~r~ City of Stillwater HPC -- HHLS Website -- Property Information lof2 . Home . Properties . About the Program . Rehabilitation . Search Propeliy Infonnation Printer- friendly Version Roney , John, House Stillwater HPC 6/1/2008 Stillwater HPC 6/1/2008 Parcel Identification Number (PIN): 2803020440015 Site Address: 663 2nd St S Construction Date: 1870 City of Stillwater HPC -- HHLS Website -- Property Information 20f2 Builder: Roney., John Architect: Architectural Style: Folk Victorian Naritive: This ornate, Folk Victorian house was built on Stillwater's South Hill circa 1870 by a local carpenter named John Roney. According to the 1887 city directory, John and Nathan Roney were listed as the residents of this house. By 1894, lumberman Herbert Roney; Adda B. Carpenter, a teacher at Lincoln School; Mary Roney, also a teacher; Mathew Roney, a laborer; Norman Roney, a clerk; Saide Roney, a stenographer at H.H. Gillen; and 1. Alfred Roney were also living in the house. By 1910, only John Roney and his wife resided in the house. According to the 1930-1931 city directory, John' s widow, Clara, was still living in the house and remained in the house for many years after John's death. By 1956, Russell W. Chidester owned the property. The one-and-a-half-story, frame building has a limestone foundation, one-over-one double-hung windows, clapboard siding, and a gable roof. The original portion of the house is the front gable section on the left. The one-story, flat roof front porch with decorative wood work on the front of the original house and a one-and-a-half-story, side gable addition on the south elevation were constructed circa 1885 based on historical maps. The house features three exterior brick chimneys; one is located on the north and east elevations of the original building and one on the south elevation of the addition. Gable wall dormers are located on the north elevation of the original house and on the east and west elevations of the addition. According to historical maps the full-width front porch on the side gable addition was added circa 1900 and the rear screen porch was added circa 1905. The gable front and wing form, the turned columns and the decorative spindlework and scroll cut ornamentation on the porches are common features of Folk Victorian architecture. According to historical maps, between 1910 and 1924, the current one-and-a-half-story carriage house was constructed to replace a two-story, hipped-roof carriage house. The current frame structure is faced in clapboard siding and covered by a front gable roof. It features double-leaf wood doors, a six-light wood window, and a hipped-roof addition on the west elevation. Q?~\ ~~~~1JQ'1~ - ~~ W~(j'I D'ifJ ----' I . S\. ,..)- '- . I , ~ ,.t:;;........ .\N " <f! ~.. irr:J oa~D5'L& I~ ~~ ~ a (D C.D itSI .1.Jl r-r 'L 'E:. tD ~ ...... (fI ~~"i'o0 $ . -", :.::.. (f.I ~ n .Q ~ t'v;t8 ~ ~~ . ~ ~ fJl., \ ~ \ G~~\~~b ~~'~\ , "tl'~J 0 - -- u , \ '.., ] D~D 0 jrdD~ ,~L ~>\ 'CJh.urchlll St ~Ch~i""-III' St r: !!D~..(IJ '\~. Joo[J C~II ~- NlJ D~ ~ t( ~ ~ 9=. , a. ~:E .. ~ J~~@.~ ~!:lU \ >tlll}. H8ncoel\; 5t E n l n~n ~p ~m~..~ Atla~rli. r. . . ~e City of Stillwater HPC -- HHLS Website -- Property Information lof2 . Home . Properties . About the Program . Rehabilitation . Search Property Infonnation Printer-friendly Version Lammers, Nathan & Lizzie, House Stillwater HPC 7/31/2008 Stillwater HPC 7/31/2008 Parcel Identification Number (PIN): 2103020430011 Site Address: 1106 2nd St N Construction Date: 1882 City of Stillwater HPC -- HHLS Website -- Property Information 20f2 Builder: Architect: Architectural Style: Italianate N aritive: This fine example of a two-story, Italianate style house was constructed circa 1882. The frame residence has a limestone foundation, clapboard siding with corner boards, and a hipped roof with a prominent brick chimney at the ridge. Its low-pitched roof with widely overhanging eaves with decorative brackets, tall and narrow windows with decorative wood surrounds, and full-width front porch with chamfered columns are characteristics of the Italianate style that was popular in the United States in the mid- to late nineteenth century. There is a two-story, hipped roof, rear ell with a one-story enclosed porch on its south elevation. These features are present in a 1922 John Runk photo, which indicate they were added before this time. A two-story, hipped-roof addition located on the north elevation is set back from the front elevation. This house was built in 1882 for Nathan D. and Lizzie Lammers. The 1894-1895 city directory, lists Nathan D. and Lizzie Lammers as the primary residents. Lewis and Catherine Biele were listed as a borders. Mr. Lammers was employed as the store manager at Schulenburg & Boeckeler Lumber Company. According to the 1906 city directory Lammers owned Lammers & Company, a grocery store located at 106 North Main Street which he operated with his brothers George A. and Albert J. Lammers. By 1930, Axel R. and Anna Holmberg were the primary residents. Mr. Holmberg was the manager of the Stillwater Market Company located at 211 North Water Street. According to the 1956 city directory, Raymond H. Carlberg resided in the house. "::'U~I g Il~\ ~il Moore Sll ~k~/' II l =:J~I -] SI c~le ~ ~CrDix_Ave Vj ~D 0 D D =;~11 Ave~~iD~~'~D#'a"leli A"'Oe_E . t~ ~IJ ;lY~. ~. ] L wJ~nssto 000;1 ! ~ A~~Jllj;t W ~~ -Sl E l .@. Jr. D;D~D J IN E~ ,I J~. 'DZ~0D'~ :a. gl ; ~ ~ ; ~~ ]D[~rDi ~~ '-~ J Mrple St I/L~s:Kfa1. dfta ~2QO~ e'lp Atlas - :"'lCo,o.' )Q.I1.i:I,.:; ... 'I City of Stillwater HPC -- HHLS Website -- Property Information lof2 . Home . Properties . About the Program . Rehabilitation . Search Property Infonnation Printer- friendly Version Dailey, Lawson, House Stillwater HPC 6/1/2008 Parcel Identification Number (PIN): 3303020110035 Site Address: 704 2nd St S Construction Date: 1877 Builder: Architect: Architectural Style: Italianate Naritive: This Italianate style house was built circa 1877 for Lawson Dailey. The two-story, frame dwelling rests on a limestone foundation, is sheathed with clapboard siding with corner boards, and is covered by a truncated hipped roof with flared eaves. Its low-pitched roof with widely overhanging eaves, decorative brackets, and tall and narrow two-over-two arched windows are characteristics of the Italianate style. A two-story, hipped roof wing was located behind the house and featured a one-story porch. City of Stillwater HPC -- HHLS Website -- Property Information 20f2 At some point in time, possibly in the 1920s, second story, sleeping porches were added above the front and side porches, and the first floor of the porch was enclosed with 12-light windows. Lawson Dailey, the original owner of the house, worked as a planer in one of Stillwater's mills and as a fence builder. The 1894-1895 city directory, lists Dailey as the primary resident and Frederick Doe, a clerk at A.K. Doe, as a border and Christine Nelson as a servant. In 1901, Dailey filed for a permit to add a one-and-a-half-story, $150 addition. Later that year, he applied for a permit to build a two-story, $450 "stove store and shop" that was located on the rear of the lot, facing Willard Street. The addition to the house connected it to the store. A historical map from 1904 identifies the addition to the house as a two-story horse barn and shows the two-story stove and tin shop with second story storage. Neither of these structures remains. The 1906-07 city directory confirms that Dailey was selling ranges out of his home. Mr. Dailey passed away on June 5, 1915, at the age of 62. Dailey's wife, Hattie, and their children Bertram and Ella continued to live in this house for many years. The stove business that Mr. Dailey operated was renamed the Mrs. L.W. Stove Works after Lawson's death and continued to sell, rent, and repair stoves. In more recent times, the house has been converted for two- family use and a modern, two-stall garage now stands where the store was located. , ' \ ~~~ -. \ \,\--'''' <-'",' "J ~e~\ \ ~ .~I, j< ~D;;s.l ~ ~. I; ~.':~~. ,~ (D (.D~. it;} w,',' .' I'!.LQ'.," , '.~~, '~;;..ii) s'tO.'.~ ~,', "\, J' , ,(f.I %' ". '0' ",.\ \ 'oj" , . ,.' \]oJ (JTI " ,..J .z ,a6 . ~ 'iJI,"'+ . 1'\,(1.85\,-0, ",~Q ~,:a" "~,"" @,',,",\ ~U 5:r\N Q~ (Q. ~'" , .' ~,!, f4.\~~" M" ""r]'! ..(1} ." . ~ ~ .'. \ aId St W . . - W ~ 51 E " ". '., ] \DuD!D [ ]uD~te ~ ~ ]~DooD C' ~I ~~D D~ ~ fi I ~ ~ g: ',' 0.. ,;i:5 ~ ~ ~L@ .~oo-v- ock St Vv . ,I ~ncocr-.:, $t E 0 D [ Illmn I =.J D D' ~ lV1ab d~tar&~~~~rre.!A\I::JS~nTR!~~ ~_ L..-. ,L..:..=J J I I L r- l . City of Stillwater HPC -- HHLS Website -- Property Information lof2 . Home . Properties . About the Program . Rehabilitation . Search Property Infonnation Printer- friendly Version Kalinoff, Demeter and Alice, House Stillwater HPC 6/1/2008 Parcel Identification Number (PIN): 3303020110037 Site Address: 712 2nd St S Construction Date: 1913 Builder: Linner., Frank Architect: Architectural Style: Colonial Revival Naritive: This stately house was built in 1913 for Dr. Demeter and Alice Kalinoff and replaced a circa 1870s house that was built on this lot for Fred Pennington, part owner of the Sauntry, Pennington & Co. Constructed by Frank Linner & Co. for an estimated cost of $5,000, the present two-and-a-half-story, frame residence features a rock-faced, concrete block foundation; one-over-one double-hung windows; clapboard siding; a full-width front porch; and a flared hip roof with prominent lower cross gables on the City of Stillwater HPC -- HHLS Website -- Property Information 20f2 front and side elevations. The house features a mixture of Victorian, Colonial Revival, and Craftsman details that were popular styles when the house was built. The massive brick chimney with corbeled cap and polygonal bay on the south elevation reflect Victorian influences. The wide eaves with decorative brackets, the semi-circular window in the front gable, and Classical piers resting on concrete block piers on the front porch are all Colonial Revival details. The tapered piers on the porch reflect a Craftsman style influence. An early, two-story, hipped roof addition was added to the rear of the house and respects the design, scale, and materials of the original building. As mentioned above, Dr. Demeter and Alice Kalinoffwere the first owners of this home. According to the 1917 city directory, Demeter Kalinoffwas a physician and surgeon with an office located at 308 East Chestnut Street. Mr. and Mrs. Kalinoffraised four children in this house-Frederick, Helen, Naidena, and Vacil. After Demeter Kalinoff's death in the early 1950s, his wife, Alice, and their children continued to live in this house. In more recent times, a new, three-car garage with a hip roof has been constructed behind the house. ~e~r::J lJt~"~~ C!;r. ~ (f! ~, .t;"j o~~ .J\ ~ _ ,-4" '{~~ ~ ~ ~ o;,L 0-, (f.I .... ~~v;:. ID ',g:.On\ '^~o '5\O~ ~ ~. ! (J) ~l-JI 0 ~ \; , IS \N "';I' ..::J ~ \ ~ ~ ~~"e~Q 12 a! ~,'~ '\ \\ W 5\\1< ~ (~ \ \ \ \ ~a\"~O ..~ w U ' ", rOD~D [j J D~ . ] \DI~JOhurcD.hi'lI Stc 1[5 ~chUlrDro.m S'O' ~ f ~ (,I} ; I ,. ~ fp < ~.~ ~ @ 2 . . .~-~~ ockSIW 00 . . =retb 0 D [ l nt:r1n l ,E Bl,Jr1'ing~(Jn .s.t 8uflin::\" tOii $t E ~ ,." ~] n-- ~ ~ap d~~I~~18 Tyll Atl~S~ City of Stillwater HPC -- HHLS Website -- Property Information lof2 . Home . Properties . About the Program . Rehabilitation . Search Property Infonnation Printer- friendly Version Glaspie-Dwyer House Stillwater HPC 6/1/2008 Parcel Identification Number (PIN): 3303020110040 Site Address: 806 2nd St S Construction Date: 1890 Builder: Architect: Architectural Style: Queen Anne N aritive: In 1889, local real estate dealers John and Katherine Glaspie purchased the lots on which this house and the adjacent house at 808 South Second Street are located from the Stillwater Construction and Furnishing Company. They sold the portion of the lots where 806 now stands to Ellen and James W. Dwyer in 1891, and the existing house was constructed for the Glaspie's or Dwyer's between 1889 and 1891. According to the 1894-1895 city directory, James W. Dwyer was a sawyer at the S1. Croix City of Stillwater HPC -- HHLS Website -- Property Information 20f2 Lumber Company. By the turn of the twentieth century, Jewett W. and Rebecca R. Wheeler were residing in the house. When Rebecca R. Wheeler was widowed in 1904, she sold the property to Arthur Day and William F. Kenneman. According to the 1904-1905 city directory, Kenneman had moved to Frazee, Minnesota, but Mr. Day remained in the house. Day, a civil engineer, lived in the house until he moved to Duluth in 1908. One will note that this house and the one at 808 South Second Street were built according to the same plan. This interesting one-and-a-half-story, Queen Anne cottage has a limestone foundation, clapboard siding one-over-one double-hung windows, and gable-on-hip roof with a corbelled brick chimney on the ridgeline. The second story balcony, the diagonal siding in the gables, the elliptical sunburst over the front window, and the projected lower cross gable bay on the north elevation are all features of the Queen Anne style that was popular in the United States in the late nineteenth century. A one-story, front gable rear addition that respects the design, scale, and materials of the original building likely dates from the turn of the twentieth century. The portion of the porch that wraps around the side of the house and the dormer on the south elevation are later additions. The garage that is located behind the house was built around 1990 and features a clipped gable roof, also known as ajerkinhead roof. I ~D....'~'. t\. '!. ~ . .~~ (J) -'!lU. " '.... '. %.W.. ?\I\O 5\O..~. ~ \~ 't!;; ,U'" ,,~ ',. t: '\ .~ \~ ~l ,SQ",\N ~a., '. . .0. ~.t. 2... @~ ........ ),..Ii r'(Le - ~ , "0"9.. \~ ~U~\J_G ~ rOD~D [JD~ . ]~DiDStC~'L@ J~osrJ! ~-~~ ~_sJ W 00 r- =retb 0 D [ D~D ~JaD;OonO 8mT1onSIE M:)fSWPc!lf.!'dalf @2CID8b~,blIIB's ~ r!~ -C ,--, r-" 1 r LI --, r- .,_~- ~ .... City of Stillwater HPC -- HHLS Website -- Property Information lof2 . HOlne . Properties . About the Program . Rehabilitation . Search Property Infonnation Printer- friendly Version Glaspie-Grace House S till water HPC 6/1/2008 Parcel Identification Number (PIN): 3303020110041 Site Address: 808 2nd St S Construction Date: 1890 Builder: Architect: Architectural Style: Queen Anne Naritive: In 1889, local real estate dealers John and Katherine Glaspie purchased the lots on which this house and the adjacent house at 806 South Second Street are located from the Stillwater Construction and Furnishing Company. Mr. and Mrs. Glaspie had the existing Queen Anne style house constructed circa 1890 and sold it to Frank L. and Augusta Grace in 1891. At the same time, they sold the southern part of the lots, where the house at 806 South 2nd Street stands, to Ellen and James W. Dwyer. Mr. Grace, who according to the 1894-1895 city directory, owned F.L. Grace & Co., ajewelry store located at 220 South Main Street, lived in the house with his wife through the turn of the twentieth century. When it was built, this one-and-a-half-story, frame cottage, with its limestone City of Stillwater HPC -- HHLS Website -- Property Information 20f2 foundation, vinyl lap siding, one-over-one double-hung windows, and gable-on-hip roof with a corbelled brick chimney on the ridgeline, was mostly likely nearly identical to the house next door at 806 South 2nd Street. The second story balcony, the corbelled chimney, and the projected lower cross gable bay on the north elevation are all evocative of the original Queen Anne styling of the house. Queen Anne was popular in the United States in the late nineteenth century. This house and the one next door are an excellent example of how two nearly identical house can evolve in different ways over time. ~~.,'" jif1.~...o'.~~." 5\D',.'...'i1",'~~.',' .... ?-:'.",\',."',,-'~~ I~ G' ~\ C.D~, \.~. % .~ ~ q.~~tJ ~ ~.~. p\{L".,50'~ ~a.. O~A tID..." (\ \ ,,' \}J ~\ \\!J, \ '\ :1 u ~O_ U~~ , . \'~" ]1;;1 r'doSt \N O.~OI [.' ~DStE ~ ... {J} ~ (n i~ ]"-.j\O(lJ ch,~rc[JhiJ"StD~" -qlh~rDehjll S'[]~ ! ~.~ g:,', R . ~ __ ~. ' .; ~I @--,-J~., " f,I}-'w;I-"---I cdStW m t: =roStb 0 D [ D~D JaO;[jonO 8UflD'nlon 5t E_ M3fSh. 1St W ,u, to' Mal'!ln ~t E; n r-lI I mil Ill(lap-d~rnJ@2@~.T1~~;.'~11~[- ~ City of Stillwater HPC -- HHLS Website -- Property Information lof2 . Home . Properties . About the Program . Rehabilitation . Search Property Infonnation Printer- friendly Version Marsh- Thayer House Stillwater HPC 6/1/2008 Parcel Identification Number (PIN): 3303020110042 Site Address: 814 2nd St S Construction Date: 1895 Builder: Architect: Architectural Style: Queen Anne N aritive: The existing house is not the first to stand on this property. The first house on this lot was built around 1874 for William McPherson. According to historical documentation, the existing two-and-a-half-story, Queen Anne style house was house was built between 1891 and 1898, and has been heavily modified over the years. According to the 1894-1895 city directory, Mary A. Marsh, widow of Michael, and Thomas A. Thayer resided in this house. Mr. Thayer, an agent for the Chicago, Milwaukee and St. Paul Railway, was responsible for many of the changes to the house. Between 1904 and 1910, the house was altered to reflect its present City of Stillwater HPC -- HHLS Website -- Property Information 20f2 form. The pedimented bays on the front and side elevations, the corner tower that is topped with an onion-shaped dome, and the two-story sleeping porch on the front of the house were all added during thi s period. Thayer added the front sleeping porch in 1909. Some of the remaining original features include the one-over-one double-hung windows, one-light wood windows in the gables, the hip roof, the two brick chimneys, and the projecting bay window on the south elevation. By the 1950s, the property was owned by Arnold A. Nippoldt and Mrs. Mary Jahress. After 1956, a small, one-story shed roof addition was added to the southwest corner of the house that wraps around the rear elevation. Later changes include the covering of the original stone foundation with a concrete parge coat, and the original siding has been replaced with masonite siding. Aside from the turret on the house, perhaps the most interesting features of this property is the garage, which appears to have been built in the late 1920s. The garage is unusual in that it is constructed of alternating coursed of smooth and rock-faced bands of concrete block that provide a rich amount of detailing and character that is not usually found on a garage. ~., ~~, O~""',D'" \~ffiU",., i~~,~' "~.~~~~~,',,',",,, 'LflG ,.- . S'LO' I;;. ~- W r--r' , , . (fl. ~~'i'\~ -' ...., , ~' 9} ,(J) ';" '\ ,', ':f .' " \J'J (JQ, " ~ ~ ,3:6 '\ '\ (\ \ 5\~ ~~. . ' -1U~O_ U~, . . \~~ jlsrclo' StW D D [- , ~rclDst E;..... '. \, ~ :;'.} , 6f "~,. ~ 1~1~~\ ]/oJOh~re[Jhill 5Ir.9'1 l'l Cl~~lS'D' ~! I ; ~~"~ U~L@~~U ro-~~ ~stW m =roStb 0 D [ D~D [J~U;LrD 8wl~~on $1 E_ M:)!'srl Sl W!!2 5. MSl!3n St e; D [ ~n na~tij~Q@rfEt,ijfAtr~r T ~~ns of l}se City of Stillwater HPC -- HHLS Website -- Property Information lof2 . Home . Properties . About the Program . Rehabilitation . Search Property Infonnation Printer- friendly Version Glaspie, Katherine, House Stillwater HPC 6/1/2008 ...... '~'-- ~ -.. ........ ..... Stillwater HPC 6/1/2008 Parcel Identification Number (PIN): 3303020110028 Site Address: 815 2nd St S City of Stillwater HPC -- HHLS Website -- Property Information 20f2 Construction Date: 1893 Builder: Stillwater Manufacturing Company Architect: Architectural Style: Queen Anne Naritive: This house is the second to stand on this site. The first was a house constructed circa 1870 for Patrick and Mary McGoldrick. John and Katherine Glaspie, local real estate dealers, purchased this property in 1891. After John's death in 1893, Katherine hired the Stillwater Manufacturing Company to erect the existing Queen Anne style house. The estimated cost of construction for this two-and-a-half-story home was $1,200. The house has a limestone foundation, clapboard siding, one-over-one double-hung windows, and a hipped roof. Its steeply pitched roof of irregular shape with dominant front facing gable, patterned shingles in the gables, and asymmetrical front elevation are characteristics of the Queen Anne style that was popular in the United States in the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries. Other character defining features include the prominent brick chimney, overhanging eaves with wood brackets, a two-story projecting bay window on the south elevation and the Ionic columns on the now enclosed front porch and second story balcony. The use of these columns indicates that the house falls within the Free Classic subtype of the Queen Anne style. According to the 1898-1899 city directory, Katherine and her son John, a carrier for The Gazette, were the primary residents. By 1910, the property was owned by Daniel F. Doyle, co-owner of the Kilty & Doyle Shoe Store at 211 South Main Street. In 1910, Doyle added the front porch and also added a sleeping porch in 1919. The two-story, hipped-roof addition located on the rear elevation was built between 1910 and 1924 according to historical maps. The interesting garage, which features a cupola, was built circa 1990. j'~. 'oa'tio.;;:P[j. - ~\.. '.~ ~~, ,"..~~,. 'lnG' ~..~ - \ 'E:., ~'"9.' "I r"', ",', (p~, ~ijl.r,} SO., , 0., ~, (J), ,~' ,",' ".~, ,,' .,'[-1\(!.e:5,~O~,\N.' ~,,(t"I.O, 0 .~.O' '" \..~-, @"-., (\ \ 5'~ ~ (~ \", \ \ \ ~O_ U ~ \ \~'\ StW . Will8rdSIE"" \ \ \ ] D~'D [ ] @l \ k \ ,~ ..!J~ ~ ~~\, JC:h1U",r.Chi.ll StD. " .,.. '. . Ch.tJ,idl,.m g;' E ~,.' ~ ,@."", ] D r- ~ lJ ~([1 ,:,.. .'8;,5 m ~ ~ ~ ~ .~ J; @ ~ :-~ ~ .SJW ~ HBn~5IE 0 D n D~D [Ja~;Bon~ . 8urllBglon StE_~ M:)fSh St ,WIj) ~ MBl'9h St E 0 0 I I~ s:1n n [M8'~@~OO~J;rei8l~,t1as i_ .~~ ~ ' City of Stillwater HPC -- HHLS Website -- Property Information lof2 . Home . Properties . About the Program . Rehabilitation . Search Property Infonnation Printer- friendly Version Shattucl<, Thomas, House Stillwater HPC 6/1/2008 Parcel Identification Number (PIN): 3303020110027 Site Address: 819 2nd St S Construction Date: 1880 Builder: Architect: Architectural Style: Folk Victorian Naritive: This simple, one-and-a-half-story Folk Victorian house was built circa 1880 for Samuel C. Norton. The frame building has a limestone foundation, clapboard siding, two-over-two double-hung windows, a front gable roof, and one-story projecting bays on the side elevations. The house features a full-width front porch with a hipped roof that was modified in the early twentieth century with square columns and by adding dentil work under the eaves. The vernacular house originally had a one-story ell attached to the rear of the house, with porch on the south elevation. By 1910, this was enlarged to the two-story rear addition that is visible today. After City of Stillwater HPC -- HHLS Website -- Property Information 20f2 1956, a narrow, two-story, front gable addition was built on the rear elevation. The addition respects the design, scale, and materials of the original building and has a smaller profile so that it is not visible from the street. Soon after Samuel C. Norton built the house, he sold the property to Stillwater policeman Thomas Shattuck and his wife Hannah. According to the 1894-1895 city directory, the Shattuck's son, Francis, who was a lumberman, also resided in the house. By 1910, Thomas had passed away, and Hannah was living in the house with her son James I., an oiler with the Big Diamond Milling Company. James, who later worked in the auto repair business, lived in the house through the 1920s. Jr:JG\ Y'\ ~~~ ~~ ~ ~ ~v~~~b\ ~ ~ S\]\N ~Q O'\:t, .z ~......... ?\Q.8 -;;) ~ C-~ ~ s.~\tJ ~ ~ lu~OG j~ JD~D t jr~~ ~ J~ ~.~,rc~'hi.1L,StD.~._',:~. . _Qlh~,U,.ilJChiUl s;[]~ ! " i_.:6 =- -U) @ 00 ,(,1} .....,.. w - ~ . SIV; rom ~Fct6 0 D D~D UaO;EIlj Burlinglon 51 E ~ M;)t"sh St "VY' {~ ~ MSR)3h 51' E D D D~ O"J ;r+n rl~, QI. 0) J~n n ~~ata l~oO~:fe;:J~las 1~~!*l:t;SI1. ...... City of Stillwater HPC -- HHLS Website -- Property Information lof2 . Home . Properties . About the Program . Rehabilitation . Search Property Infonnation Printer- friendly Version Drews, Herman, House Stillwater HPC 6/1/2008 Parcel Identification Number (PIN): 3303020110091 Site Address: 904 2nd St S Construction Date: 1894 Builder: Bieging., William Architect: Architectural Style: Queen Anne N aritive: This two-and-a-half-story, Queen Anne style residence was constructed in 1894. The frame house has a limestone foundation, clapboard siding, one-over-one double-hung windows, and a hipped roof with lower, clipped gables. Its steeply pitched roof of irregular shape with dominant front facing gable, patterned shingles, asymmetrical front elevation, wraparound front porch, and two-and-a-half-story projecting gable bays on the north and south elevations are all character defining features of the Queen Anne City of Stillwater HPC -- HHLS Website -- Property Information 20f2 style that was popular in the United States in the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries. The scroll-sawn detailing in the pediment over the front steps is another distinctive Queen Anne feature. Based on historical maps, this house was built between 1891 and 1898 and replaced a small one-story structure with rear ell that was constructed on this lot circa 1872 for painter Watson Hall. In 1894, Herman Drews applied for a building permit to have local carpenter William Beiging construct him a house on this lot for $1,700. Unfortunately, Drews does not appear in the Stillwater area city directories during this time period. According to repair permits from 1904, there was a large fire in the house that cost $600 to repair. In 1953, Edward Simonet purchased the property. Simonet was employed as a clerk with the County Register of Deeds. Mr. Simonet and his family resided in this house for over 52 years before finally selling it in 2005. IDU.~, 'U, ,,' \, , " " -,,<n~l\g "',',LO- ""~~' ,I ~ (J) ~~, ,% \\ ~~ p~~etJ, ~~O,,'.'" ...0" ' t,'" " \ @~~ ~Gde_uC~~, \\\,~, I~ ra $1 W Wilrard St' .... 1 \ \ ] 0 02:'0 0 l 0-- ,~, :;to ~'" ~~ .~ @ ,~. ~ ~~~ ]...~ ~"D'J'ah,;rcDhi:1I StO;,rJ, :~'" Y"'~,rLJcll,m,s;D'E,! ;,: l ~:::- ~I ~ ~ ro-~- (r.I fB O'lU (j) 0 D [ oc&SIW. m. =JOStO ' D~D D~D~DQnD 8wlinglon StL M:)rsh 51 W l!2 ~ MS!'!In St enD [ Po noo rol]~n~l J .,- ~n nap da.taQo~ TE(~lAtljl- T~~ City of Stillwater HPC -- HHLS Website -- Property Information lof2 . Home . Properties . About the Program . Rehabilitation . Search Property Infonnation Printer- friendly Version Blal(e-Scott House - ;""-......1 Stillwater HPC 6/1/2008 Parcel Identification Number (PIN): 3303020110092 Site Address: 910 2nd St S Construction Date: 1875 Builder: Architect: Architectural Style: Italianate N aritive: John Blake, who was listed as a laborer in city directories, built this Italianate style house for himself circa 1875. The two-story, frame house has a limestone foundation, clapboard siding, two-over-two double-hung windows, and a flared hip roof. Its low-pitched roof with widely overhanging eaves, decorative brackets, and tall and narrow one-over-one double-hung windows are characteristics of the Italianate style that was popular in the United States in the mid- to late-nineteenth century. City of Stillwater HPC -- HHLS Website -- Property Information 20f2 The house features a full-width front porch that is covered by a hipped roof with flared eaves. By 1882, Fred Scott owned the house. According to the 1894-1895 city directory, Mr. Scott was a druggist with his business located at 202 East Chestnut Street, lived in the house with his wife, Lake, and their daughter, Bessie, who was a seamstress. By 1900, Mr. Scott had passed away, and Mrs. Scott, who was still a co-owner of the Scott Drug Company, was living alone in the house. In 1910, Mrs. Scott took out permits to enlarge the rear ell from one-story to two-stories and to build a porch. According to repair permits taken out in 1922, Mrs. Vera A. Yerka had acquired the property. Mrs. Yerka lived in the house for several decades and in 1956, Vera and Kenneth E. Munson were listed in city directories as the primary residents. ~- U(J)\., \ .......'~......- 0,"" ,," 'LJ'Q "\'oT, ~ .% ~3.. ~ ~ \ -', ~ ~w~$t\N ~a . . .~~ ~, ~ U~\J_GA)~, \ \\~ lard St W ~. . Willard S~E _... ~ '\ ] D D:;rD [ l D~l ~~~~ '~,., ~ a, ,'~ 00 _~ 00 :s= .-U)~. \N 'ChlurchHI St __ Yf:efl,m $t I; ~ ~ :~. ]--..JO'i;.I}D c~~ ~'3D' OifJ ~ ~ ~:!2:!' .:g; ~ I:L .~;5 !SIV: 00 aL~~:ctD DIDO ~.[ D~D [JaD~DonD 8urllnQlon 51 ~ M:)lsh 51 W!!2 . ~ MSr:3h St E D l !n n n~ll~lJ~n~1 ~ $1 ;; . l ~ap d~tal@2~o~ TEJ~ Atl~l- T~ S 0 ..~ se City of Stillwater HPC -- HHLS Website -- Property Information lof2 . Home . Properties . About the Program . Rehabilitation . Search Property Infonnation Printer- friendly Version George F. Sabin House Stillwater HPC 6/1/2008 Parcel Identification Number (PIN): 2103020430105 Site Address: 1022 3rd St N Construction Date: 1885 Builder: Architect: Architectural Style: Gothic Revival N aritive: This two-story Italianate style house was constructed circa 1877 for Daniel O'Neil. According to the 1894-1895 city directory, Dennis Boyle, who was employed in the logging business, had acquired and moved into the house. Anne Johnson, Mr. Boyle's servant, also lived in the house during this time. In 1900, Mr. Boyle and his brother, William H. Boyle, who worked in livestock, were listed as the primary residents. According to the 1906 city directory, Dennis, William, and Edward F. Boyle, all ranchmen, were living in the house. By 1910, Mabel C. and Mildred Boyle joined the three men in the household. The Boyle family owned City of Stillwater HPC -- HHLS Website -- Property Information 20f2 the house through the 1960s, with Edward F. Boyle residing here in 1956. The house has a limestone foundation, clapboard siding, and a front gable roof with a brick chimney on the ridgeline. Its tall, narrow, two-over-two segmental arched windows are characteristic of the Italianate style. This house is a rare example of a front gable Italianate style house. Most Italianate houses have hip roof, and the front gable subtype was an evolution of the then popular G reek Revival style. About ten percent of all Italianate houses have front gable roofs. The wraparound front porch was altered, likely around the turn of the twentieth century, to include the existing columns and the pediment over the steps with scroll-sawn detailing. A very early, one-and-a-half-story rear ell features dormers that break the roofline and a shed roof porch. The ell also features tall, narrow, rectangular and segmental arched windows. A modern one-story, hipped-roof addition has been constructed on the north elevation of the rear ell. An interesting, circa 1920s garage is located in the back yard that retains is original wood-panel sliding doors. This type of door was common during this period; however, most have been replaced by easier to maintain and operate overhead doors. U~~, . ,L! II.~. ...... 0 w ~ J" I~ I!I Moore St " D r~~lf \ I~I _ \;;:1 J St Crnbi A.ve ~ ~ s~~rrve w :~D,~ ~lJ:J J:~ ~[ Slil~rtar~~~ ~[~D D~D ii 1:S St . WLllcin~ St wOO D~ 1 ~D DI~A Q~. A~p8~ Sl E 19~ !D, (D~D, ~.",D," Ilr,. g, ~~ I IzOtQD D~D~I :ro fQ~\ 7 i' DMte St w~QQtttTrle~tl'ts _ Termls ~f:' ~ I r z City of Stillwater HPC -- HHLS Website -- Property Information lof2 . Home . Properties . About the Program . Rehabilitation . Search Property Infonnation Printer- friendly Version Hursey, Wilmot and Mary, House Date Unknown Stillwater HPC 7/29/2008 Parcel Identification Number (PIN): 3303020110057 Site Address: 808 3rd St S Construction Date: 1889 Builder: Architect: Architectural Style: Stick/Eastlake N aritive: This ornate, two-story frame house, with its limestone foundation, clapboard siding, one-over-one windows, and cross-gable roof, was constructed in 1889. The house, with its many details, is an excellent example of the Stick style that was popular in the United States in the late nineteenth century. Its horizontal and vertical wood banding, prominent front gable roof, and decorative trusses City of Stillwater HPC -- HHLS Website -- Property Information 20f2 and brackets are indicative of the Stick style. The corner tower with a steeply-pitched roof, the patterned shingles, and wraparound porch are additional characteristics that the Stick style shared with the slightly more popular Queen Anne style. A sympathetically designed one-story, gable addition that respects the design, scale, and materials of the original building is attached to the back of the house. The existing garage dates from 1992. In 1889, Wilmot and Mary Hursey applied for a permit to build this house. The estimated cost of construction was $1,600, which was above average for this period. The distinctive home was built by local contractors, the Norley Brothers. According to the 1894-1895 city directory, Horace W. Davis, a boold(eeper for the Musser Manufacturing Co., was living in the house along with his servant Martha Fisher. By 1900, Davis was a bookkeeper for the Ann River Logging Company. At some point in time, the structure was used as the parsonage for St. Paul Lutheran Church on South 5th Street (personal communication with Dan & Janelle St. Claire). Condell McPherson later purchased the house from the church and was the primary resident in 1956. The current homeowners bought the house in 1984 from Mr. McPherson's widow (personal communication with Dan & Janelle St. Claire). ~~' --Ef\N ~~ -Q"! .........(:i'-?_: ~ ~'--15i'ti..~j! o..'~ '~~ {fJ ~ '(D C.D 'fS1 ]~ c; ~G~';pLLO?\I\QSb\' "- ]~ ~ T 5\J~ (JiJQ ~ \ 00, :: " ~ \ ~ (a~ \.' ~~ fJ'! U s~ ;!l (Q. \" ]~OStW ~O-Lt5t_:~ ~ ~ I~D D D~D IT ] D~ , ~ ~ W 'Ohurchi'll St h. Chmrcb.m $.; E ~ ]crD~D(.l}D 1';; I ~~D n~ ~. ~,~ U~U@~~ JJ ro~ ~8n~StW m ~D5tD 0 L D~D D~[J;DQnD 8~Ilin~ 1~~-~;~2~~-T.€j~r~~l~J:J L Q City of Stillwater HPC -- HHLS Website -- Property Information lof2 . Home . Properties . About the Program . Rehabilitation . Search Propeliy Infonnation Printer- friendly Version Foley, James W., House Stillwater HPC 6/1/2008 Stillwater HPC 6/1/2008 Parcel Identification Number (PIN): 3303020110046 Site Address: 811 3rd St S City of Stillwater HPC -- HHLS Website -- Property Information 20f2 Construction Date: 1902 Builder: Schmidt., Eugene Architect: Architectural Style: Queen Anne Naritive: In 1902, James W. Foley hired local contractor Eugene Schmidt to build this late example of Queen Anne style. The estimated cost of construction was $1,500. The house replaced a circa 1873 structure that had originally stood on this lot. Mr. Foley was a prominent Stillwater resident; he was the mayor of Stillwater from 1910 to 1911, and according to the 1912-1913 city directory, he was the secretary and treasurer of the Mulvey Corporation. The two-and- a-half-story, frame building, with its concrete block and limestone foundation, clapboard siding and one-over-one double-hung windows is covered by a front gable with lower cross hips over projected bys. The steeply pitched roof, dominant front ga ble with a pent eave and patterned shingles in the gable, and wraparound porch are characteristics of the Queen Anne style. The hipped roof projecting bay on the south elevation features six-over-one double-hung windows and a 16-light fixed window. A second story addition supported by wood posts on the rear elevation was built between sometime 1910 and 1924 according to historical maps. A circa 1950 garage is located behind the house. Despite a number of changes over time-the attic window is not original, the porch columns and railing have been replaced, the southern portion of the wraparound porch was enclosed to create an entry vestibule, and a picture window replaced the original windows on the first story of the front elevation-th e house still retains most of its historic character. ~'llJ' L _____~i( "\1"1 '~U' "\:"-'b.~ -,=,01" ,~..'''''''''-:=" 0"*"''1.: ."'D'. "~,'" ,'~, ',., '~~, . ir.:J.O (D C.D".., W ''lL " ",' ~. 'P\'PI~~'\.O'i';." ,~, " ~ ,(J) ~~, ' . , % .' r.j- :;J,' -.=.' .' ~ . ,'~ ','IJ!,r<1'" ,,?\(L~,SOI<\N,,.,.~.a.. ,..,.., 0,' . '~~'i.., ~a', (ID.,. ~ (\\ s-'tJ ~ ~ ~.... . \ \ \ ~~\\\~O U:~" ... \, ~iII~ rd St W _ 0. - ~ilrercl 51 e; .... . " J D D~O [ ~ D~ i~ ~ ] ~DNOhurDChi:1I St[J - ~Chl]~JI .m $.0: (; ~ ~ ~ """-I 00 ~I f'.J1 (.f);';=C ; ~ . J;L@ ~L ~-~- ~~~~t W m '~=:]C:=tto 0 0 [ D~D JaD~DonD B~linglOn 51 f\fjj)t'~h St w.~ ~ ~1'arah $1 e [ ] I mil [M-ap 9a-tal~fOOtTe el~,~lasl_..:~er s of-l:Js .. City of Stillwater HPC -- HHLS Website -- Property Information lof2 . Home . Properties . About the Program . Rehabilitation . Search Property Infonnation Printer- friendly Version Johnson, Ida, House Stillwater HPC 6/1/2008 Parcel Identification Number (PIN): 3303020110072 Site Address: 906 3rd St S Construction Date: 1906 Builder: Linner, Frank Architect: Architectural Style: American Four-Square Naritive: This handsome example of an American Foursquare was built in 1906. The two-and-a-half-story, frame house has a limestone foundation, clapboard siding, one-over-one double-hung windows, and a steeply pitched hip roof. American Foursquare refers to the nearly cube-like form of the house. They typically has a simple box shape, were two or two-and-a-half stories in height, with a four-room floor plan, which was popular in the United States from the late nineteenth to early twentieth centuries. While many City of Stillwater HPC -- HHLS Website -- Property Information 20f2 were built with a low-hipped roof with deep overhang, a large central dormer and a full-width porch with wide stairs, most foursquare forms borrowed details from other styles, including Prairie, Craftsman, Classical, or even Victorian detailing. This house has all of the typical Foursquare characteristics except that it features a steeply-pitched hipped roof with flared eaves which reflects the influence of the then waning Queen Anne style. The house also features bay windows on the north and south elevations and a pedimented dormer on the front elevation. Sometime after 1956, a small, one-story rear ell was expanded into a two-story addition. The addition respects the design, scale, and materials of the original building and has a narrower profile than the original building so that the addition is barely visible from the front elevation. This house was built by the Frank Linner Co. for Mrs. Ida Johnson, who lived in the house for over 20 years. The estimated cost of construction was $3,000. Interestingly, this home is an early example of a house built in Stillwater with indoor plumbing. 5-lJ~~~ \(J)U~~~~"O :~~I' . U~ I~ ~~~\J,.~~a .t01 IU u~"~\l...' r~ IfDfOuD~D ~J:O~t s ~ ~ 1!,D~,D'~D D~r,' @'!D_n~ !- (;; ;;;.!e ~L..~~~ l J 0' D HartCoc:k St Vv DooD ~ =rEtb ~ lJaO;OORO 8WJ'i;mgl o Ef:[lManFSh St OVtJ ~D~nMa:r. $1 ~n, ~ 0 00 ~ ~l ~ :; !\{lap d?t~ @2POJ8 T11eL Atl~ - T ~5 O. 5e City of Stillwater HPC -- HHLS Website -- Property Information lof2 . Home . Properties . About the Program . Rehabilitation . Search Property Infonnation Printer- friendly Version Gieriet, John, House Stillwater HPC 6/1/2008 Parcel Identification Number (PIN): 3303020110076 Site Address: 1002 3rd St S Construction Date: 1876 Builder: Architect: Architectural Style: Italianate Naritive: This tall and narrow Italianate style house was built for John Gieriet circa 1876. The two-story, frame residence has a limestone foundation, clapboard siding, and a hip roofwith flared eaves and a prominent brick chimney on the ridgeline. Its low-pitched roof with widely overhanging eaves, decorative brackets, and tall and narrow two-over-two double-hung windows with segmental-arched wood surrounds are characteristics of the Italianate style that was popular in the United States in the mid to late City of Stillwater HPC -- HHLS Website -- Property Information 20f2 nineteenth century. Sometime after 1956, the original front porch was removed and an original one-story rear ell was enlarged into two-stories. In 1876, John Gieriet had this grand home constructed on this property. According to the 1877 city directory, Gieriet ran a saloon and billiards on the corner of Main and Chestnut streets. By 1894, Granvill W. Smith owned the property. According to the 1894-1895 city directory Mr. Smith was the chief of police for Stillwater. At this time, Patrick Keyes, a guard at the Minnesota State Prison, rented a room. By 1900, Smith was the sheriff of Washington County. I~ L-J'll~. ,r' \(L~ 51L~"O"", ""U..~I\,,' ~ ,.\~", .. ~:-"""""---"",~~"~.,,,,, ,~\1., ," Q> (\\ 5'~ ~U(~ \~'" I~OU~O_\j ~. \ '" Wjll~ r~ St W , . '. . - - Wilrercl SI e;.... ~ I~D D D~D [ ] D~ i? ~ Ii,,' D~,wDOh;,rcDhiJI Stc ~,-~~."'.~. ChiD rom $, -OF: ![;_ 22 ~ -' ,~t.D 00 100 00 Cf.J ~ ell ~ DC ~H8~.9!~:~LSJ 'vV DooD ~ =rctb ~ . _JaD~'EJ,gIQnD, E1~fl~Jlg!Q1 o M:)tsrl St:w !!2, .. a. MSl!3h $1 e [ q..'..,n n D{QD'92i]-Cil"Dg !:T ~ ......1 ~ f.{) .~ ~I i;t ; ~ ~ ~ V.11 i[J V Orl~M@p1;9ata @200a-Tele AtI~1ii ~;~~[ City of Stillwater HPC -- HHLS Website -- Property Information lof2 . Home . Properties . About the Program . Rehabilitation . Search Property Infonnation Printer- friendly Version Sutherland, Thomas and Susan, House Stillwater HPC 6/1/2008 Parcel Identification Number (PIN): 3303020110077 Site Address: 1006 3rd St S Construction Date: 1881 Builder: Architect: Architectural Style: Italianate Naritive: The original portion of this stately, Italianate style house was constructed in 1881 for Thomas and Susan Sutherland. The two-story, frame residence has a limestone foundation, clapboard siding, a hip roof with flared eaves and a tall brick chimney. Its low-pitched roof with widely overhanging eaves, decorative brackets, and tall and narrow one-over-one and two-over-two double-hung windows are characteristics of the Italianate style. The house features a full-width front porch with mansard and hipped-roof projecting bays on the north and south elevations. A modern one-story rear addition features a second story porch. The small addition respects the City of Stillwater HPC -- HHLS Website -- Property Information 20f2 design, scale, and materials of the original building. A one-and-a-half-story, front-gabled, clapboard-sided garage is located behind the house. In 1881, Thomas and Susan Sutherland built a one-story house on this lot. Thomas was a contractor and builder. In 1894, Frederick P. Swanson purchased the house and hired contractors Baird and Johnson to raise the roof and add a second story for $200. According to city directories, Mr. Swanson was a bookkeeper for the Musser - S L L & Manufacturing Co. Also living in the house were Louisa A. Lammers, a boarder who was a clerk for the Register of Deeds, and Martha Ponath, who was a servant. By 1910, Mr. Swanson, now a bookkeeper with the St. Croix Lumber Company, and his children Florence H. and Sherman F. Swanson, both students, lived in the house. i5G ~ U~~ -\1 _Willard Sl W , Willtlord 51E ... ~ l~DOD~D[JD~ ~ ~ J~D;D, iO~D~L!~~O,lt$loE, !!- HBncocl< 5t W m ' ~nctb 0 [ D~D Uao:[jORo 8urlin~ M~tsh St W!a ~ Marsh St E: [ ~D D DmDro~(]11 i[ Orle~1~~h~ata:@29018-1=ele Atltf~r~s ofCPlse~ N I City of Stillwater HPC -- HHLS Website -- Property Information lof2 . Home . Properties . About the Program . Rehabilitation . Search Property Infonnation Printer- friendly Version Webster, Mortimer, House Stillwater HPC 6/1/2008 Parcel Identification Number (PIN): 3303020110099 Site Address: 1021 3rd St S Construction Date: 1874 Builder: Architect: Architectural Style: Italianate Naritive: This interesting, two-story Italianate style house was constructed circa 1874 for Mortimer Webster, a local real estate speculator. The house has a limestone foundation, clapboard siding, and a hipped roof with a large brick chimney. Its asymmetrical plan, low-pitched roof with widely overhanging eaves, decorative brackets and dentils, and tall and narrow one-over-one double-hung windows with segmental-arched wood surrounds are characteristics of the Italianate style. A two-story rear addition features a hipped roof, clapboard siding, and a sleeping porch on the second floor. The house was originally constructed with a one-story, full-width front City of Stillwater HPC -- HHLS Website -- Property Information 20f2 porch. Between 1898 and 1904, the north elevation was extended and the porch extended to wrap the north, west, and south elevations, much as it does today. During this time a one-story addition was also built on the north elevation of the rear ell. Today, this is a two-story structure. At some point in time, the house was converted to a duplex, and the portion of the porch on the west elevation was removed. Soon after Mr. Webster built the house, it was acquired by Elizabeth Churchill. In 1879, Elizabeth Churchill sold the property to Louise and Sturgess Selleck. In 1882, Louise Selleck sold the property to Alice E. Castle in who lived here until 1895. According to the 1894-1895 city directory, Abraham and Lottie Rohrbach were residing in the house. Mr. Rohrbach worked at a clothing store at 126 South Main Street. In 1899, the Seymour family acquired the house and built a $700 addition. The Seymour family owned the property through the 1940s. In the 1950s, the house was converted into a duplex. ~ U 'tfO Uv~~ \ \~ Jr~o D~D t DfdD~ ... ~ ~ J~DirJD~[~~~D$tD! !-I- mcod\SIW 00 - croStb 0 D [ I D~D [J~D;DonD 8wlinglon $1 ~1~Dr."'jj)rSh St Ow, :~D;IMJa~hD' $1 ~n; D[l~f r.n D 00 ~ I I~ -=: I ~ . . mJ----J it! . ~.... Orl~nS. St Vl/" '6:511i1 St N 00 . I C r--l .- 1 c::l- ~M Map qata J~~008 Tele {\tlas f erms of s, City of Stillwater HPC -- HHLS Website -- Property Information lof2 . Home . Properties . About the Program . Rehabilitation . Search Property Infonnation Printer- friendly Version House Stillwater HPC 7/29/2008 Parcel Identification Number (PIN): 2803020130090 Site Address: 423 3rd St N Construction Date: 1868 Builder: Architect: Architectural Style: Gothic Revival Naritive: This house started out as a modest, one-and-a-half-story, front-gabled Gothic Revival cottage that was constructed circa 1868. While the house is visible on the 1870 Bird's Eye View of the City of Stillwater, little else is known about its early history since it was built prior to building permits. The original section of this house is a frame building with a rough-cut limestone foundation, clapboard siding, one-over-one and eight-over-eight double-hung windows, and gable roof dormers on the side City of Stillwater HPC -- HHLS Website -- Property Information elevations. Although the original design may be difficult to see due to later alterations, the steeply-pitch front gable roof and roof dormers, and the tall side walls indicate the original Gothic Revival style, which was popular in the United States in the mid-nineteenth century. At unknown points in time, the south elevation was extended one bay, the rear portion of the house was widened to the south, and a shed wall dormer was built atop this portion to create a second story. The portico on the front of the original section of the house appears to date from the late 1950s. According to the 1910-1911 city directory, Alexander Mackey, the proprietor of Lily Lake Ice Company at 8 Lumberman's Exchange, lived in this house. In 1914, Mackey was employed as a bookkeeper. Mackey lived in this house for over 20 years. From the mid- to late twentieth century the house was owned by John Giebler, Margaret Carlsen, Evelyn and Terry Giebler, Pat and Pam Rudlick, and Ronald and Barbara Roberts. 20f2 City of Stillwater HPC -- HHLS Website -- Property Information lof2 . Home . Properties . About the Program . Rehabilitation . Search Property Infonnation Printer-friendly Version Searles House Stillwater HPC 7/29/2008 Parcel Identification Number (PIN): 3403020230035 Site Address: 1222 4th Ave S Construction Date: 1880 Builder: Architect: Architectural Style: Queen Anne N aritive: This two-and-a-half-story, Queen Anne style house has an unusual history. The circa 1880 house was originally located near the intersection of Osgood Avenue and Highway 36 in Oak Park Heights, before it was lTIoved to Stillwater in 1974 to save it from demolition during the expansion of Highway 36 (personal communication with Peter Hovland). When the house was moved to its current location, it was set on a concrete block foundation. Today, this frame residence has one-over-one and single-light windows, a large brick chimney centered on the roof ridge, and features a two-story projecting front gable bay and a shed roof porch on the front elevation. The house has a number of Queen Anne details, including a gable-on-hip roof, the decorative shingles in the gable, and the scroll-sawn City of Stillwater HPC -- HHLS Website -- Property Information 20f2 detailing in the apex of the gables. The non-original stucco exterior has concealed other potential character-defining details, such as decorative siding. A one-and-a-half-story, front gable addition is located on the rear elevation. A one-story, shed roof porch is located on the north elevation of the addition. Both are clad in stucco and replicate the style of the main block. A one-story, front-gabled, masonite clad garage is located in the rear yard. No structures were located on this property until the existing house was lTIoved to this site in 1974. According to the 1976 city directory, the primary resident of the house was Oliver W. Oddan, who lived in the house throughout the 1970s and 1980s. - J U~U, ,.tl~ ~~.~ '\ \,\ (Q ~ ;~~", : ,ChUictlill $1: E ~ ~ ~,.'" @,\, @J~D D(~~-~ . ~\\-, : ~:D5tD 0 D ~\~ JaO;O"lj 8mli~~t E ~ ~ \ "'" ]~D~~iDi _i~B\s \ \ ,65th s., N 00 65th St N ~I~' o ~ r--IC S ~~ 3 '~.. '"d1" 64t1~ 5t N '1l. eL l ~ ~l 1;:1 ]~ L--: ;Ii ~r I'~ I I~.' (95i Z ~p ~OO? Tele Atl~ - T r. s 0r0'~ ~ .~ City of Stillwater HPC -- HHLS Website -- Property Information lof2 . Home . Properties . About the Program . Rehabilitation . Search Property Infonnation Printer- friendly Version Sullivan, Robert, House Stillwater HPC 7/29/2008 Parcel Identification Number (PIN): 3403020230084 Site Address: 1030 4th Ave S Construction Date: 1877 Builder: Architect: Architectural Style: Queen Anne N aritive: This grand, two-and-a-half-story house was built in 1877 for Robert Sullivan. The frame residence, with its limestone foundation, cross-gable roof, and interior brick chimney is faced in clapboard siding. Its wraparound front porch, decorative woodwork in the gables, and wide wood window surrounds are characteristics of the Queen Anne style that was popular in the United States in the late nineteenth to early twentieth centuries. The house retains many its historic features, including its original clapboard siding, one-over-one double-hung wood windows, and stylistic details. A circa 1878 carriage house and circa 1974 garage are located City of Stillwater HPC -- HHLS Website -- Property Information 20f2 behind the house. The one-and-a-half-story carriage house has clapboard siding and a front gable roof. The building retains its original double-leaf carriage doors, single-leaf entry doors, and four-light casement windows. Robert Sullivan, the original owner of this residence, was employed by the St. Croix Lumber Company as superintendant of lumber camps in the woods and as the foreman of their log driving crews. According to the 1894-1895 city directory, Mr. Sullivan resided in this home with his wife Mary, a dress maker, and his two sons, Robert T. and John, both lumbermen. In 1899, Sullivan constructed a small addition. Leighton D. and Barbara Charlsen purchased the home in 1944. Over the years, Charlsen's operated The Barn with the Red Door Antiques and Charlsen Trucking out of the carriage house (personal communication with Chris Charlsen). In 2002, the current homeowners removed a circa 1950, one-story, kitchen addition on the rear elevation of the house and constructed a two-and-a-half-story addition that respects the design, scale, and materials of the original building. The front-gabled rear addition is faced in clapboard siding and retains the profile of the original house. A one-story, portico with pedimented gable is located on the south elevation of the addition. " ~ U, ~~\ ..,. lJ' I r~rcJDStE ~~"'fJ. ~,~.., \" , ,'.JI;-' \ .... ,..p - ChurcllJII St E ~ " ~ "@ , S) '~D n~ ;j-~ g\~ - ~~ ,. lJ D~Lf @'I j~8:B~~8 8u.fIinglon $t E ~ \\ "I !!2 ~ Maron $1 E" n D [J~ \ ~,.-':,..~ \ rDroIJ~D!LJiD;O D l:~,-I , 'S5,.1tJ St N 00 . 65tl> St N ~~, \~"~;. laC dl ~] ---- \~ \ '~~ J~ r ~p-data-<929B}-6ftl!1~~~I~~ Te~~e City of Stillwater HPC -- HHLS Website -- Property Information lof2 . Home . Properties . About the Program . Rehabilitation . Search Property Infonnation Printer- friendly Version Hospes, Adolphus and Aurora, House Stillwater HPC 7/29/2008 Parcel Identification Number (PIN): 2803020130125 Site Address: 303 4th St N Construction Date: 1892 Builder: Architect: Architectural Style: Queen Anne Naritive: This grand, Queen Anne style house has a long and interesting history. The two-and-a-half-story, frame building, with its limestone foundation, clapboard siding, one-over-one double-hung windows, and hip roof with lower cross gables was constructed in 1892 for Adolphus C. and Aurora Hospes. The steeply pitched, irregular shaped roof, front-facing gables with decorative wood shingles, scroll-sawn ornamentation, and wrap-around porch are all characteristics of the Queen Anne style. The pediment over the steps to the front porch embraces its stature on a prominent corner lot where this house sits. Although a shed roof greenhouse was constructed at City of Stillwater HPC -- HHLS Website -- Property Information 20f2 the southeast corner of the house in the 1980s, this house exhibits a relatively high degree of historic integrity and is a good example of a well preserved Queen Anne house. A carriage house, built contemporaneously with the house, is located behind the house. Originally, this carriage house was a one-and-a-half-story, side gable structure with a front-facing decorative gable; however, it was extensively remodeled in 2003, by extending the side gable on the north elevation, adding all new windows and doors, and adding a carport on the south elevation. In 1873, Adolphus C. Hospes purchased multiple lots on the east side of North 4th Street. Hospes served in Minnesota's First Regiment in the Civil War and survived the battles of Gettysburg and Antietam. On June 22, 1870, Hospes married Aurora Staples, daughter of Stillwater lumberman Isaac Staples. Hospes, with his business partner William S. Conrad, owned and operated Conrad & Hospes, a meat market and tobacco store that was located at the corner of Main and Myrtle Streets in Stillwater. Hospes had many other business dealings, including owning a dry goods store, acting as an officer in Isaac Staples bank, serving as the secretary and treasurer of the St. Croix Boom Association, serving as secretary of the Stillwater Building Association, serving as treasurer of the St. Croix Lumbermen's Board of Trade, and serving as the surveyor general of Logs. By the early 1890s, Adolphus C. and Aurora Staples Hospes were quite wealthy residents of the St. Croix Valley, and in 1892, they purchased a building permit for this lot and constructed this fine residence. The couple raised four children, 0 livia Jane, Lewis, Eva, and Pauline, in this house. Adolphus passed away in 1911 and Aurora in 1921; they are buried by the Staples Obelisk in Fairview Cemetery. The eldest child, Olivia Jane owned the house for a short time after her parent's deaths. Throughout the twentieth century, the house was owned by George and Caroline Wilson; Amelia Bartlett; the Johnson family; Dr. Kalvin and Kathleen Blodgett; Dennis Murphy and his family; James Cummings and his family; Carol and William Hendrickson, who completely renovated the house and converted it into a Bed and Breakfast; and Cathy and Jerry Heimberger, who currently operate the house as Aurora Staples Bed and Breakfast (personal communication with Cathy Heimberger from research conducted by Brent Peterson). J~,.L. I ~~,',,"~U, ~,I i~",1:\" j ] d'crozU Mallie 5t~\\ 0 I · ] ~ ~ C'~W~6tO I, J~I Qfi O""":.N1 ~O~ ~ 1,- J~~ C~ --;=.; '9 1 f!J ~., a ~ 2:1 .\1'1' U 5t t ~.;II ~ L! 1\<1 en' .'6' 1, tJ,\l \ ."et('j ~ ~ Jc=J ~ ~~ 51 W W MuliJerr~' st r ~GD ~~ \ ]mO D~[ '"i '; ~ \J~ ~ I~::: ~. z'~ p ,I ~;; ~, ~~g;~'0 \1 \\~, J~[l~D;r-' (ft~, Q ~ 3\E. '~~"i;; ]2: _ 2 ~~ . Cbes\r;tJf\ \)~_ % : jStJO ~\ dP ~~d~ ~~QrMa1~a~~-~!fQ~~ City of Stillwater HPC -- HHLS Website -- Property Information lof2 . Home . Properties . About the Program . Rehabilitation . Search Property Infonnation Printer- friendly Version Swedish Evangelical Misson Church Parsonage Stillwater HPC 7/29/2008 Parcel Identification Number (PIN): 2803020130117 Site Address: 314 4th St N Construction Date: 1904 Builder: Architect: Architectural Style: Queen Anne N aritive: This house was constructed in 1904 as the parsonage for Swedish Evangelical Mission Church, located next door at 320 North 4th Street. The one-and-a-half-story, frame parsonage has a rock-faced concrete block foundation, clapboard siding, and a gable-on-hipped roof with a brick chimney on its ridge. The steeply-pitched roof with dominant front facing, hooded gable, the patterned shingles in the gable, the sunburst under the hood, and the full-width front porch are characteristics of the Queen Anne style. The hipped-roof porch with its pedimented gable and slender Tuscan columns, indicate that this house falls in the Free Classic City of Stillwater HPC -- HHLS Website -- Property Information 20f2 subtype of Queen Anne, which is better known for the use of turned columns and spindles. The house features one-over-one double-hung windows and four-light fixed windows with two-light transoms. A one-and-a-half-story ell is located on the southwest portion of the rear elevation and a one-story ell is located on the northwest portion of the rear elevation. Reverend K.E. Peterson, pastor of the Swedish Evangelical Mission Church, was the first resident of this parsonage. According to the 1912-1913 city directory, Reverend N.O. Olson resided here in these years. By 1919, Reverend J.J. Clemens was the primary resident. The church sold the parsonage when they moved locations in 1930. In 1956, Merton G. Schell and Reverend C.R. Chadderdon were the primary residents of this home. LJ;:L-,I LJ-U~U2: d'1-: r 0 DO.. ~.~,IY,. 0;., L,'. t Mte 5tW'j,O Q" o ~ " st 0 SI w, ~ 'N t-aeJ~ at '~cVO\ ~~ ~( en Sl ~L!n<.len',e' <r ql}\~ ., ~~ D L=:J [ .~%- . '.' . *~ .0 D'D~rz .(f.'I Q" n~, ~ ,,.., ..,. OJ ~.' I'" " \.J ~ ~ [~, '!-,$. ~~ 1 ~D'~ ~,.;;;; ~'. . ""~~~\,'(\" ,\1 [I,} m m - {I>. Q u \J~ zoiD;DZ ~~ , C\\~1\\\\~~ Mcr6D C1 \ d9 C\d ~~m~~~~~~~OotPS; City of Stillwater HPC -- HHLS Website -- Property Information lof3 . Home . Properties . About the Program . Rehabilitation . Search Property Infonnation Printer-friendly Version Swedish Evangelical Misson Church Stillwater HPC 7/29/2008 Stillwater HPC 7/29/2008 City of Stillwater HPC -- HHLS Website -- Property Information 20f3 Stillwater HPC 7/29/2008 I' I. I I r.I ~ · I I . I ~ I i I ~ I III I f I 1 I II I Stillwater HPC 7/29/2008 Parcel Identification Number (PIN): 2803020130116 Site Address: 320 4th St N Construction Date: 1904 Builder: Architect: Architectural Style: Renaissance Revival N aritive: This simple, Renaissance Revival style church was built in 1904 for the Swedish Evangelical Mission Church. The masonry building rests on a raised, cut limestone foundation with warm colored orange brick walls laid in a stretcher-bond pattern. A steeply-pitched cross-gable roof covers the structure. Two bell towers with shallow-pitched hip roofs are located at the corners of the fa9ade. The church features large rosette windows located on the second story of the gables and one-over-one stained glass windows with transoms set in round arched openings surmounted by brick drip molds. At the rear of the church is a City of Stillwater HPC -- HHLS Website -- Property Information 30f3 one-and-a-half-story, hipped roof wing that was built between 1904 and 1910. The Swedish Evangelical congregation was organized in Stillwater on September 1,1881 (Peterson & Thilgen, Stillwater: A Photographic History 1843-1993,1992:84). By 1906, their membership included 100 people. The church held Sunday services, Sunday school, weekday prayer meetings, and young people's meetings at this location. Reverend K.E. Peterson was the first pastor of the church and resided in the parsonage located next door at 314 North 4th Street. According to the 1912-1913 city directory, Reverend N.O. Olson was the pastor after Peterson. In 1919, Reverend J.J. Clemens was the church's pastor. In 1930, the congregation built a new church at 124 West Myrtle Street, where Reverend Oscar R. Palm established the Swedish Methodist Episcopal Church. The 1904 structure then became the home of the Bethany Mission Tabernacle and later the Bethany Covenant Church. Today this property is one of Stillwater's many examples of successful adaptive reuse. The building is currently home to the Loome Theological Booksellers and a private residence. ZU0LI' JJ~Ug:u~~r Z' I (f.I z --t r Od'rrOi L o .' ~~, " '~cl,st 0'.'. , ('~] sl:w _ . -z. \f111,..8.tJ~ '. \ O. .~~Q,"'~,',".~"S,o,'i.,"~,I~,o,' 't-'l,i,'" @~SI'5., \, ~ c ~" , ,"$ 'r.... \ ~ "'. .' :;:., ~l ,e ". ' 'r;:,. I :;;;:;1 , . ~ ~ ,'. , 5\ t ojJJ lenst ~L1nd~n.$'j", O~",~'oet(j', 7-',~~ Dr---, [.., ,,2 ~ " L--J . " ~, ~~ -,0 0 D:r:[ ,~. {f'J' 'Q'" r'V~!l, ~ .m :::!J.I ~ .- ' }.) ~ ~.. "'::: ,!-, . z , .~ ,. ~,'D~ ~;, ~',. ,... Wl\\\~~,n \l '[,I} 00 (I) - !J> Q U \J€, I ;rJin;Dz~~ '. c~~~\\\\~ 'My~SI - n \ .dO O~ ~ [~.J~JP~P dat~s~,~s~}t1~~iJ City of Stillwater HPC -- HHLS Website -- Property Information lof2 . Home . Properties . About the Program . Rehabilitation . Search Property Infonnation Printer- friendly Version Staples, Josiah and Lydia, House Date Unknown Stillwater HPC 7/29/2008 Parcel Identification Number (PIN): 2803020130105 Site Address: 402 4th St N Construction Date: 1868 Builder: Architect: Architectural Style: Greek Revival Naritive: This one-and-a-half-story Greek Revival style house was built upon a one-story, exposed limestone basement circa 1868 for Josiah and Lydia E. Staples. The tall and narrow house is clearly visible on the 1870 Bird's Eye View of the City of Stillwater. The frame portion of the house has clapboard siding and a front gable roofwith eave returns. Its gable roofwith cornice line emphasized by wide bands of trim, six-over-six double-hung windows, Tuscan pilaster corner boards, and front doors City of Stillwater HPC -- HHLS Website -- Property Information 20f2 surrounded by narrow sidelights and a rectangular line of transom lights are characteristics of the Greek Revival style that was popular in the United States in the early to mid-nineteenth century. The one-story, exposed limestone basement features a full-width front porch that supports a deck above and six-over-six double-hung windows with stone sills and wood lintels. A lower, one-story ell is located on the rear elevation. This wing features a porch on the south elevation and an exposed limestone basement. An attached concrete block garage was constructed to the north of the house between 1924 and 1956 and is faced with stone to replicate the exposed limestone basement of the house. According to the 1876-1877 city directory, Josiah Staples was employed as a lumberman. In the 1880s, the Josiah's brother Franks, also a lumberman, resided with Josiah and Lydia. By 1890, Josiah Staples was the foreman for his brothers company, the Isaac Staples Lumber Company. After Josiah's death in 1894, Lydia continued to live in this house for many years. - L....-..-I ~ ~.-+ L-1S:&:..........II U{o.:I fooJp ~D~DZD~D~ ~ ~ z w z -t.:. ~D d/D~o~ L ,t MUr\ Q o ~W ule\ st r"\ "S't Vii i1i1 -1.. OW 1.-aD~~ a~l~ (~~. '~l'wOt-1 ~ ~b ~.'y ~ ,~,. -I a~ :;;;:;. , . - -",N.Ji , "5\ 'Co U"J len St, ..' . "- L,_lnQen'.s~,'" .~ ., t>./J\)I p'\je,.'f rj' \\,~ ~,.~". ~,. ~.',' Dc=Jf -' ~ rJ \-\~I )I'!,.,.tory: St, Wo ,DVYl,~.~LU'~l!~'st" ~, ~'" " . .' ',' ~',~' I <..,.,:r:: ' --? ' t.ll "Q: .' .c:;: ." II ::: p.i (", .... == ~ WI, 3. 1--. ~'st'E;.' ~'O~ ~ ;. ~'. ~~~~\j\\). \1 ,f!l,~rJi[l;D;~~", U,Cbe5~n"st~~) rMynleSI ~ \ ~O Ob-U % 11'11 J n r\1ap d~tf ~20~8\T~~.las -_ ~Et[~\U~~ City of Stillwater HPC -- HHLS Website -- Property Information lof2 . Home . Properties . About the Program . Rehabilitation . Search Property Infoflnation Printer- friendly Version House Stillwater HPC 7/29/2008 Parcel Identification Number (PIN): 2803020130109 Site Address: 414 4th St N Construction Date: 1868 Builder: Architect: Architectural Style: Greek Revival N aritive: Little is known about the early history of this small home other than it was constructed around 1868 and it is visible on the 1870 Bird's Eye View of the City of Stillwater. A large outbuilding was located on the northwest corner of the property in the late nineteenth century but was removed in the early twentieth century. According to the current homeowner, a brick lined pit, City of Stillwater HPC -- HHLS Website -- Property Information 20f2 thought to have been a communal outhouse, was recently unearthed on the rear of the property. Although it may be difficult to see due to a number of changes over the years, this house was built as a one-story, Greek Revival cottage. Its style can be determined from the side gable roof without dormers, the narrow sidelights and transom window that surround the front door, the evenly space windows, and by the tall space between the windows and the eaves where the cornice was once located. The house rests on its original foundation that is now covered with a concrete parge coat and the original clapboard siding was covered with asbestos siding, possibly in the early to mid-twentieth century. The existing windows, which have simulated muntins, are more recent as is the small, shed roof porch on the front elevation. Between 1910 and 1924, a one-story gable-roofed addition was constructed on the rear elevation. A half story was later added to the left side of this addition. While early residents are unknown, Mrs. Anna A. Clarey lived in this house throughout the 1950s and 1960s, and in the 1970s, John Korn resided here. J~LJf~dLl~LJ~U U ~' f ~lzD~Dzl J~O~ ; 7 / JrO dJD~SI i /1 J1 OMUO Qst 0 ;1/ rDelSlw ~bl \9~~O\O~,~,'i' :] ,;::;,~'O~ ~ ~ ~ @ it , ' ) a'i; .5\E ' ]deO c=J lunden'$:J.~~,.' ~\~\~1 JU'b;.D~~,DJ :;:::,-[JW,-1;Ul~LIY.U.. ~ ~, \ ~,".. ~ rOi ~! ~,... ~~~~~\\, lI;l 00 00 -tj> a u \.J~ linin;Dz ,<~ Q"~~n\~ :w M'l't1le $1- Mal3-dafcl <62 0 oa..-T ele..,4\;ll~ e~iDs~ J l -, r- J L I.. \ \ J.,- "':_..t .. ~_ City of Stillwater HPC -- HHLS Website -- Property Information lof2 . Home . Properties . About the Program . Rehabilitation . Search Property Infonnation Printer- friendly Version Mace, Nelson, House Stillwater HPC 7/29/2008 Parcel Identification Number (PIN): 2803020130107 Site Address: 420 4th St N Construction Date: 1860 Builder: Architect: Architectural Style: Greek Revival N aritive: Historical records conflict as to when this handsome, two-story style house was constructed. Based on its Greek Revival design, it was likely built circa 1860. The first know resident of the house was Nelson Mace, who was living in the house by 1881. According to the 1881-1882 city directory, Mr. Mace was employed as a lumberman with the St. Louis River Lumber Company. After 1882, Mace no longer resided in Stillwater. Little is known about subsequent residents of house. By 1956, Richard L. City of Stillwater HPC -- HHLS Website -- Property Information 20f2 Balfanz and J.J. Brooksbank were living in the house. Through the late 1950 s and early 1960s, Balfanz resided in the house along with Culver Davis, Jr., but by 1965, Leon D. Berg and William D. Carlson were the occupants of the house. This elegant, frame house rests on a limestone foundation, has clapboard siding with corner boards, tall and narrow one-over-one double-hung windows, and is covered by a side gable roof. The house retains its metal roof, which was a popular roofing material in Stillwater at the turn of the twentieth century. Its gable roofwith a cornice line emphasized by wide bands of trim, the pedimented gables, and a front door surrounded by narrow sidelights and a rectangular line of transom lights are characteristics of the Greek Revival style that was popular in the United States in the early to mid- nineteenth century. The prominent one-story, hipped-roof portico that is centrally located on the front elevation, with its stately square columns and decorative brackets are also Greek Revival elements. A simplified, two-story hipped roof addition is located on the rear elevation. This early addition to the house is faced in clapboard siding and covered by metal roof. A one-story, garage was added to the rear elevation of the historic addition in the 1970s. JUiU~U~U U N L. I I ~J~D'~DZD~D.t... ~ g ~ ~,~ ~ ~ :z: .' .,~. w, z -$ j 0 d/ErOiUL ,St Mr1e fit I/~O a I ] 0 ~~ ., lL(~ st 0 · ~IL, ~~~O\ @ J UiF .) art:,. 5\ 't:. ~ nden St _ ~L1nden',Sl "'\ \IJ\\l~'oef('j - z\'i J D CJ ["~; ;) ] D 0 0 [ ~~. f\~ :E: rn I~ 'ili ,. ~ $ ~ ~ :; ~ ~ ~ "'t z~ '~ l!D~[l!D~C. )~~ r5~~~~ 1 ~:Q~Z_Ma~~e~T~~ City of Stillwater HPC -- HHLS Website -- Property Information lof2 . Home . Properties . About the Program . Rehabilitation . Search Prope11y Infonnation Printer- friendly Version House Stillwater HPC 7/29/2008 Parcel Identification Number (PIN): 2803020130074 Site Address: 503 4th St N Construction Date: 1856 Builder: Architect: Architectural Style: Greek Revival N aritive: The oldest portion of this simple, Greek Revival house is the front gables section, which was built circa 1856. Greek Revival was a popular style in the United States during the middle of the nineteenth century. The most telling Greek Revival feature on this house are the front gable roof, the tall cornice under the eaves, the remaining six-over-six windows, and the wood City of Stillwater HPC -- HHLS Website -- Property Information 20f2 sidelights and transom that surround the front door, which were originally glass lights. The one-and-a-half-story, frame building has a limestone foundation, vinyl siding, and a metal roof. Metal roofs were popular in Stillwater around the turn of the twentieth century. At some point early in the history of the house, the one-and-a-half-story side gable addition was constructed on the north elevation, giving the house an ell-shaped plan. The ell-shaped plan of the house is visible on the 1870 Bird's Eye View of the City of Stillwater. The one-story portico with Tuscan columns appears to date from the early twentieth century, as does the small, one-story, screened-in porch on the south elevation. The modern, attached garage on the north elevation was built in the late twentieth century. Since this house was built well before Stillwater started to issue building permits, little is actually known about its early history. The first known resident was Mrs. Marie R. Tibbetts who was living in the house in 1956. In 1960, Duane F. Nelson owned the property, and by 1965, James W. Rog was residing in this home. < L.....J L-...J:5.L-..J L..J. U LJ L.........J ~~ ~. , a ~,'S~:n St Vii. A'S~nSt E . ~ ~'lmD~D 0 ill n I J ~,._LJ .~,l>, ~ ~_, J ~,', ~ i ZD~D C~D~ ~ ~! 1 ~ ~ 5= ~~, J :z ......--- w z -t:. t , D d' t~~~r OiLJ, I t ., Mafi}le St IN ~O"". , . W,.,' '.', 1. o r -:]~ ,(i)st 0 d. -1 5t w -z; W 1.J YJ~ . J \ 1 ~~ t ~".~"O\ @\, ~l '.. ..,. ....N~... a ' . 5\ t . '1/1, en .st """'Unojen .S'" , , ' t.J1~\'oP' .~, % Dc=] ,~ '- \~ -D'.-'D-O:r::.,C', ,~ ~,' .Q. . ~~- ::E IrrTI ::: ~ .-.' ,- ,,~ == ~ ., ~::: '1.--... -z., ..' 'E;. ~'D'~ ~,: ;. ,'. ~'" ,'.. ~,:~~e. ~.,\\\.', ,\\ w m 00 ~ 11>. ~~UU~ zllinin~ap d~:.'~~qgJLtele-A-Mf -:=,~_I.~~~r, ~~~ City of Stillwater HPC -- HHLS Website -- Property Information lof2 . Home . Properties . About the Program . Rehabilitation . Search Property Infonnation Printer- friendly Version Stillwater HPC 7/29/2008 Parcel Identification Number (PIN): 2103020340155 Site Address: 1410 4th St N Construction Date: Builder: Architect: Architectural Style: _ N aritive: This elegant, Italianate style house was constructed circa 1868 for Jotham and Mary Lowell. The two-story, frame home has clapboard siding with corner boards, two-over-two double-hung windows, a front gable roof, and a full-width front porch with a hip roof. The shallow-pitch, pedimented front gable, overhanging eaves with decorative brackets and dentils, and the tall and narrow windows are characteristics of the Italianate style that was popular in the United States from the approximately 1840 until around 1885. The one-story, rectangular bays on the north and south elevations are another common feature of Italianate style houses. The City of Stillwater HPC -- HHLS Website -- Property Information 20f2 front porch has turned columns and spindles that are evocative of the Queen Anne style and indicate that these features replaced earlier Italianate elements. A one-and-a-half-story, gable roofed wing on the rear elevation was built contemporaneously with the house. According to the 1876-1877 city directory, Jotham Lowell owned a store at the corner of Myrtle that sold general merchandise. By 1890, Jotham passed away, leaving Mrs. Lowell to live in the house alone. ~ ~} ~ 1 11--, ""'t - ~~oplakSt ~r./ I-. '4"l?oplar SE fE 'i'Ja ed~- ~~~ ltrgJ...e~J ~ ,l~ttlJi (~Iif~e.~~ l&L_', ~ ~N . " ~ ) ", ::;. 0- '~' iiii.-r, '" ~ (n Q ~" j' 1~~"oJ~~ W :;~ Ii,. t St c~;LW J~ SICroixAveW ~D D D 0 31 ~ll li~" Slilll/lSter A,."ve E {f.J Sbl[wa'lar ft,ve 1/1/ DCLD D D -, ~ I J ~ ~ \rVl)'IIj:(ins. St \t\lilkins., StW 0 0 D~ l.~D D~D,D I (. ~. , ~, ~Ji! 5t VIJ . ~.'SpBJil St E. ~~ =r~ -:l 11 r--=-1 "1 ~n,~r:lil'Y.l dat;:).@2008 Tell~tlas("lJr~LI Iselt ~.l ::-1 IVI1'fftI R!1L.l I I I ~ - ~~I City of Stillwater HPC -- HHLS Website -- Property Information lof2 . Home . Properties . About the Program . Rehabilitation . Search Property Infonnation Printer- friendly Version House Stillwater HPC 7/29/2008 Parcel Identification Number (PIN): 2803020130169 Site Address: 306 4th St N Construction Date: 1905 Builder: Architect: Architectural Style: American Four-Square Naritive: According to historical maps, this well cared for American Foursquare was built between 1904 and 1909. The two-and-a-half-story, frame home has a rock-faced concrete block foundation, clapboard siding and a hipped roof with flared eaves. American Foursquare refers to the form of the house. Foursquares typically have a simple box shape, are two or two-and-a-half stories in height, with a four-room floor plan, and were popular in the United States from the late nineteenth to City of Stillwater HPC -- HHLS Website -- Property Information 20f2 early twentieth centuries. While many were built with a low-hipped roof wi th deep overhang, a large central dormer, and a full-width porch with wide stairs, most foursquare forms borrowed details from other styles, including Prairie, Craftsman, Classical, or even Victorian detailing. This house is an excellent example of a Colonial Revival foursquare, as exemplified by the two-story pies on the corners of the house; the Composite columns, bal usters, and brackets found on the front porch; and by the pedimented gable roof dormers on all elevations that have circular diamond-paned windows and one-over-one double-hung windows with diamond panes in the upper sashes. The house retains its orig inal form, including the small one-story rear addition, screened-in porch on the southwest corner, and canted bay window on the north elevation. Despite the elaborateness of its design, little is actually known about its early history. After the Swedish Evangelical Mission Church moved locations in 1930, the congregation used this home as their parsonage. Reverend Ernest C. Benson resided here in the 1940s, and Reverend Norman P. Wold lived here in the 1950s. DZd/n~biU\~ \\ [1 DM~QQPO.. 1/ ' ~ W < $ 'N VQt , I I \; :Jt. ~pC\ ~E ~"~ ~st I CJ lURdenos.1 q~~u~~. \\i~ ;OmwO' ~Dw ;,. ut~y st -=t. ~. r,." \ G. cd.", \J u~,),~ r .I~ ~ ~,' tiJ':'", ~\J, ~e S+..'~\J n, ~ ~D~ IU..' 00. ~', Q~ n\, U (f) 00""'" IJI) _ ' u" I ~rJi[l;DZ~5\~, '.. C~e5\~~_~t~ TjStJ 0 (\ \ dP o~~ W fltlr.1~ ~.l. , ~ 5\ n "'.....-; ~~.;--=.'u Map-dal~'I;lI:J~ i[ele Atla~:, T~m; &'f..Use City of Stillwater HPC -- HHLS Website -- Property Information lof2 . Home . Properties . About the Program . Rehabilitation . Search Property Infonnation Printer-friendly Version House 106 Group 10/1/2007 Parcel Identification Number (PIN): 2803020430037 Site Address: 309 5th St S Construction Date: 1862 Builder: Architect: Architectural Style: Vernacular N aritive: It is not known exactly when this house was built. Research indicates it was constructed sometime between 1862 and 1875, and significantly enlarged in 1888. It probably started out as a small, Geek Revival, Gothic Revival or Italianate style house and was enlarged during the booming 1880s. Today, this modest two-story house shows Italianate and Queen Anne design influences. When it was expanded in the 1880s, it took on an L-shaped plan with a complex hipped and gabled roof form, a one-story porch in the ell, a one-story rectangular bay window on the south and a one-story kitchen addition on the rear. The house is clad in shiplap City of Stillwater HPC -- HHLS Website -- Property Information 20f2 siding, rests on a rock-faced, cut stone foundation, and has an elegant brick chimney that pierces the front gable of the roof. The house features narrow, one-over-one double-hung windows with wood surrounds, many of which are paired. The surrounds feature decorative banding and modillions in the upper corners. There is fretwork in the north and west gables and a modern deck off the kitchen in the rear. Sometime between 1910 and 1924, most likely in the late 1910s or early 1920s, the front porch was extended outward and a sleeping porch was added above it. Sleeping porches were popular during this time period because of the tuberculosis epidemic. Sleeping porches provided ample fresh air which was thought to help prevent tuberculosis. The first known residents of this house were Albert C. and Hulda Holquist, who resided here in the 1930s and 1940s. Albert was employed by Ryden and Holquist, a local manufacturer. L--J I, ~'S-~' " ~\ \ \\~~X~~' NO "OW :!:,r,,~[Ulc.-=J1Y SI 't:.," '"" ~,. '" ,." \..-l, ,. """V~'~'. \" ,11,' , : i, ! ~,~".' ~ a~.~~P",~,.',~I(\,.,\1,'.''*,.~,.~,(],'~ i (f) '"""r-- {I), U \.3.-:; 1=!:~ ' : ....... ZI ..... . \N ' ,", s\ ~ , ~ I~ [,l zD~... ~i\!;!.eS\, ...,. CQ'h, es\~n.. \J,i~- ol,~\~"~,'~",,, St ~' %0' " ~U ~~~~ 'tfio' ..... ~, Q'1 O 0 ' ~,' ^,", '.,~' ' , rp~~, ~ \~~ '~ ~~nr1~,_Sb. '~l, o~\~eE~~, ' ~--~<'&'" "- - " 9"- Y .--.J 0.. ,~ liveStW l!R ,,\~,',' '." 5\'N ...e., ,~;!!."" \~~' ~ ~ [ (J) ':g 0*, t (D~ . ~ 1)1?" ,.-\I;,':..~ ~,' Qa~s.tV" ~_" (11" ....."0,, n,' .(fI~, \'i\'i)~"O-",'6",. Jill U-------"'O ' ,d'J. (J) ~\-J 0 ~ ;:J. 10 'ij- \N ~ '..J ~1 ~ fLJ~ 1l p\{Le~a ... .~a\ ~.~ .., D~C\ \\ 't\e~\ld ~J~::Jt WllIl;lrd $t W Wilrerd SI E; ~ CfJll n n~n n J i --, I~J_I ap 9ala @~q08 T~(e Aj~F - ~~~ms,pf Us S City of Stillwater HPC -- HHLS Website -- Property Information lof2 . Home . Properties . About the Program . Rehabilitation . Search Propeliy Infonnation Printer- friendly Version Moodhe, John, House Stillwater HPC 6/1/2008 Stillwater HPC 6/1/2008 Parcel Identification Number (PIN): 3403020220028 Site Address: 911 6th Ave S Construction Date: 1880 City of Stillwater HPC -- HHLS Website -- Property Information 20f2 Builder: Architect: Architectural Style: Italianate Naritive: This stately, two-story Italianate style house is one of the few brick constructed houses in the Hersey, Staples Addition to Stillwater. The house was built sometime between 1878 and 1883 by a local mason named John Moodhe. The house rests on a limestone foundation is cover by a hip roof. Its low-pitched roof with widely overhanging eaves, tall and narrow arched windows with projected hoods, the brick quioning on the corners and two-story bay window are distinctive characteristics of the Italianate style. The ornate brick lintels above the windows and doors, the dogtooth pattern brick between the first and second stories and the shutters further embellish the design. The hipped-roof porch on the southeast corner of the house has chamfered columns and decorative brackets that are features found on high-style Italianate houses. In the late 1880s, Moodhe was employed as a mason and the 1892-1893 city directory indicates that he was employed as a rafter at the Musser - S L L & Manufacturing Company. After Mr. Moodhe's death in 1893, his widow, Christine, lived in the house until she sold it to John's brother Erick Moodhe around 1896. John had previously resided next door at 915 6th Avenue South. The property was subsequently acquired by Rutherford Goff, and in 1913, he sold the house to the parents of Ella Carlson for $800 (Ellen Carlson oral interview 1984 provided by homeowner). According to Ellen Carlson, who lived in this house from 1913 to 1978, a large frame addition was constructed on the rear elevation sometime prior to 1912. The addition had 14 rooms and was used as a boarding house (Ellen Carlson oral interview 1984 provided by homeowner). Circa 1950, the Carlson family demolished this addition and replaced it with the existing two-story brick addition on the rear elevation that generally respects the design and scale of the original building. The hipped-roof garage that is located behind the house was built circa 1980, after Ms. Carlson moved out of the house. ~" ~,~U,.~~'i:I, S \,h't,"".',, ~, i Q' \ i1~~ \ ~ ~ ,t, ~ @~"\ ~f.P'" '5\,' '.tJ, ~, (ll.a, " W \ \,' ,\.., }OLi' ~ ,\ \~ - 1'''iIr~rd 5t 'I:, .... 1, ~' , "\ ] D ] O~ I 'to \, ~,.. ?},... , " ~.,:" '\\ "i ~,';'-" ""\ (n :: " ~~ 'I$', \ ChurcllHr Sf E ~ ~ ~. \ --'~,.r[, ,~'. ~,'D - 0-, ~Li ~ ~,\ ,',\, J~I ~ ~ . 00-'" \\-, (IlLI 00 0 D ' ,36 ~ ==rc~tb \.. ] Dao;oOAo 8mlinglon 5t l~ tShSt\f\l!a 5. MarshSte, n,D, D~ l ntr,.noo~ (i1-!:laJ, " ..... Ma~~,'ata ~~OO~~t1~J~ I ,.....Ic. L .L j ele 1''k.1 ~ L City of Stillwater HPC -- HHLS Website -- Property Information lof2 . Home . Properties . About the Program . Rehabilitation . Search Property Infonnation Printer- friendly Version Moodhe, Ericl< and Charles, House Stillwater HPC 6/1/2008 Stillwater HPC 6/1/2008 Parcel Identification Number (PIN): 3403020220027 Site Address: 915 6th Ave S Construction Date: 1884 City of Stillwater HPC -- HHLS Website -- Property Information 20f2 Builder: Architect: Architectural Style: Italianate N aritive: This handsome, Italianate style residence was constructed circa 1884. The two-story, frame house has a limestone foundation, clapboard siding with corner boards, and a hip roof with a brick chimney. The house retains its historical clapboard siding, one-over-one double-hung windows, and fixed leaded-glass windows. Its low-pitched roof with widely overhanging eaves with decorative brackets and tall and narrow windows with decorative wood surrounds are characteristics of the Italianate style. The house maintains its historic character by retaining its full-width, mansard roof front porch and other Italianate details. A two-story, hipped roof addition on the east elevation was constructed at the same time as the original building. The addition featured a one-story porch on the north elevation, which has been converted into a two- story deck that wraps the north and east elevations of the addition. According to the Washington County Tax Assessor's Office, a garage was constructed in the rear yard in 2004. The one-story, hipped roof, clapboard-sided garage features a cupola on the peak of its roof. This house was built circa 1884 for Erick and Charles Moodhe. The 1887 city directory lists both men as plasterers. By 1890, the brothers had sold the property, and in 1956, Axel E. Johnson owned the house. L-J ,~(P,'~.O?Vil;'~~'l.O-,~' r a ~, 0,. f!.. . .. ~ ~ ~e_\1~\ J' Wilrard St E ",...',_.,', ,... '.\,," [ ] D~ ~~~~ '" 1____ ChulfcililP S. I; i Y 1. .~ ~ \ J~I ~~D []cnLf: ~ ~~ go - CL .ji -= ' !B I @ !i? f,I) - ...~ \ ' '-., O'lL (,Q 0 D @ ] ~ =retD ,.' \\ , . Uau;o.IOllo 8UfllnO.' Ion $t.1: ~ rsh St w ~ ii Mars._h $-1: en .' D. ~ l ncnnroilvflg rT'"O lMa~atal~L200~elel~!laS I City of Stillwater HPC -- HHLS Website -- Property Information lof2 . Home . Properties . About the Program . Rehabilitation . Search Property Infonnation Printer- friendly Version Rooney, John F. and Melinda House Stillwater HPC 7/29/2008 Parcel Identification Number (PIN): 2803020310043 Site Address: 231 Everett St N Construction Date: 1873 Builder: Rooney., Thomas Architect: Architectural Style: Gothic Revival N aritive: This Gothic Revival style house was constructed circa 1873 and is one of the oldest homes in the neighborhood. The one-and-a-half-story, frame home has a limestone foundation, clapboard siding with corner boards, and tall and narrow two-over-two double-hung windows with large wood surrounds. The buildings steeply-pitched cross gable roof, narrow windows, decorative bargeboards (vergeboards) and pendants are characteristics of the Gothic Revival style that was popular in the United City of Stillwater HPC -- HHLS Website -- Property Information 20f2 States in the mid nineteenth century. A one-story, hipped roof porch is located on the west elevation. A modern, large one-and-a-half-story garage is located in the back yard, fronting West Mulberry Street and incorporates many design elements from the house. This house was built for John F. and Melinda Rooney by John's brother, Thomas Rooney, a local homebuilder. According to the 1894-1895 city directory, John had passed away, leaving Melinda and their children Josephine, a seamstress, and William A., a laborer to live in the house. According to city directories, Melinda Rooney resided here until 1925. 11 1 U U U LJ ~~ 1 W Mall19St M~,O O. \-, ~--J{=~ 0 ~ ". aU~(>\ ~\ t' ~"" ~.'l.,au..el:3t ""'-",' 1-""O\'~,'l.-..r\,.. ,',i.if."'~"'" . I ~'uua~' ." \.~...ta.. :J: ~ S'i..'\NI W ~ . ~~. C~~O Q . d st zJ ~iLI ..I!en' ~~~ -..N !n s~ W VI/l\...ln' en" . n';.L ' - DD@DC~ l . .% ~,' ~'.-. <>MUIM,trY. St. Y, WM.UI~.!!YuS'l, t!l,,' ID~D\!l'D~DiU~[Jfl ~~ 'i (]I , Z 2 iI Om- ::r ,... ~ ~' Rloo St 1f~r 3 :;. ~ 22 'rP Z[l 0 [lilJi[lDZ~~ DU~j I WTjSb 0 r1 \- r( Ram~ 5t 'iN ,0<,. W IRam~~ :J~,. '.0,' X~-..I~e.~,5\\ :=J~:=J Dr;) ~~ 51 W ~~ \_ ~ St llii -. UI I I .....\ \-- h.gll n:~~?ta @200a]Tyle AtlaslT r Lof U~.!t City of Stillwater HPC -- HHLS Website -- Property Information lof2 . Home . Properties . About the Program . Rehabilitation . Search Property Infonnation Printer- friendly Version Staples, Roy G., House Stillwater HPC 7/29/2008 Parcel Identification Number (PIN): 2803020130070 Site Address: 212 Cherry St W Construction Date: 1872 Builder: Architect: Architectural Style: Greek Revival Naritive: This handsome, two-story Greek Revival style house was built circa 1872. The frame house has a limestone foundation, clapboard siding with corner boards, and a front gable roof. Its gable roof with return eaves and a tall cornice line, and the pedimeted (pointed) door and window surrounds are characteristics of the Greek Revival style. The full-width porch has been replaced by a one-story, front-gabled portico. The two-story, gable-roofed addition on the rear elevation was constructed circa 1880. A City of Stillwater HPC -- HHLS Website -- Property Information 20f2 two-story sleeping porch is located on the rear elevation of the addition and was built circa 1885. The house features six-over-one, one-over-one, two-over-two, and eight-over-eight double-hung windows. The first known resident of this house was Roy G. Staples, who was living in the house by 1901. Mr. Staples was the grandnephew of Stillwater lumber baron Isaac Staples (Peterson & Thilgen, Stillwater: A Photographic History 1843-1993, 1992:97). Staples and his wife, Clemetine, raised their two children, Eleanor and Wilson, in this house. Over the years, Staples served as the president of the Cosmopolitan State Bank of Stillwater, treasurer of the Washington County Building Loan Association, manager of the Stillwater Insurance Agency Secretary of the Lowell Inn Hotel Company, secretary of the Western Shoe Company, and vice president of the Smith-Staples-Robertson Agency, an insurance firm. After Mr. Staples passed away in this home on October 30, 1931, his family continued to own the property until the 1970s (Peterson & Thilgen, Stillwater: A Photographic History 1843-1993, 1992:97). J c-~ -----m,..- --- I I L..--..I -.,..- L u r 'QI!ii U,'.~;c ~.,',-"D~n,',.DJ.".,~ r,~~'SP'BJijm~,"=,I",I'.I, O'J "'" ,,:T {r.:I ~11" ~ L~ ;;D~D' :ZD~C~ ~ g 1 l ~ ~ ~ :r, ~ ~ '-~- :z _. ' {f} Z --::.. I 50otroi L' F;l'tEiSt " M8,c:JIr\,. .."",0,'" , '. ',', /' ,I.: :=J D C~\.-~U!e\ s~ r\ I aurel51 W ~ -t- Y ,Q<i\./ I" ~~~ ~,~fi,"S,\YO\," ,@,.. JUil ,.,i a k / ~inde, dl cSt,. ~UnQen ,s~. ' ",' 1Jj'0"..~~>,-,,'{~' ~ D~DCJr. ' %- ~\\~ DMulb,'~,",tDry. s~,w'D'l , "[Jw ':r..Mbu,~.!!Y.st" ~? ~,",'"" .,', u ~",',.','". I I, ,~;ii .,~',' ~,' r:.t,. ';.,.. '~,". ','G..,' ,55 a.Ii ;:+ IIi 1;.,1'" , ~e S\ ''J 3D~ s; ~" Q~~ n\ ~r (f) 00....... ,(I)' U n~~ ~n'-n2:'5.r ~ ~\ ,-'Ji. S\'! Zn2: ,2:Map datctJ92oa~~le""'Atlas - .lJpn(il~.Jf~~.e i , l i l......-"'Nff!...r--- ~~ ,_ ,"_ I I City of Stillwater HPC -- HHLS Website -- Property Information lof2 . Home . Properties . About the Program . Rehabilitation . Search Property Infonnation Printer- friendly Version Christopher Deithert House and August Senl<beil House 106 Group 10/1/2007 Parcel Identification Number (PIN): 2103020130004 Site Address: 1812 Broadway St N Construction Date: 1850 Builder: Architect: Architectural Style: Greek Revival Naritive: This modest, Greek Revival style house has a long and interesting history, although very little is actually known about its early history. The one-story, frame building, with its limestone foundation, clapboard siding and six-over-six windows, was constructed as a schoolhouse in the 1850s or early 1860s. Its triangular shaped pediment and fluted pilasters are characteristics of the Greek Revival style that was popular in the United States in the mid 19th century. At some point in time, the north side gable wing and the front porch were removed. Although this structure was built before the end of the Civil War, it may have been moved to its present location within a decade or two after its construction since it does not appear on an 1870 bird' s eye view of Stillwater. The house first appears City of Stillwater HPC -- HHLS Website -- Property Information 20f2 on a map in its present location in 1892. Throughout the 1890s and into the early 20th century the house was owned by the Schulenburg & Boeckeler Lumber Company. According to the 1892 city directory, Andreas and Augusta Senkbiel were the primary residents, and John and August Senkbiel were boarders. August was employed by Schulenburg & Boeckeler and likely secured this home for his parents and sibling. In 1902 August Senkbiel (spelled Sinkbill on the deed) purchased the property from the Schulenburg & Boeckeler Lumber Company. August Senkbiel owned the house through at least 1927, when his is listed in city directories as an operator at the Stillwater Mfg. Co. Herman W. Senkbiel, a laborer at T.C. Forge & Foundry, also resided in the house in 1927. In the late 20th century, Donald Teske purchased the property and sensitively restored the house and constructed a sympathetic addition on the rear that respects the design, scale and materials of the original building. Another interesting fact about this property is that the only remaining well in Dutchtown is still located behind the house, along with one of the few existing woodsheds in the neighborhood. .-r"'4)Oct~ ~<:o. ~~W#'~ J~, ,r-----......J----- -:;;Jf. - - ~ ..---- ""'-~ -...........: v I ~J ~Alde(~~;~ J ~ ~~E U) :2 ~ \J,.J 0 ~~.. ~nL- ,J is.b l L{~ ~ 0 J ~ S: ...., ,_ %JQ0- t l5 ~ ~~ I I L----.. 4 ....ll?QpISlr.St fE ~N' I. ~~ ~, \ z \~J I :2: ..; I ,I -;; ~ 'r! '... (;; c.j ~ 1 ,--,MaP-da~g,~,8)T~ Atlas - Terrr,s of I 's~ )r'I3' Sl \'V , ~ City of Stillwater HPC -- HHLS Website -- Property Information lof2 . Home . Properties . About the Program . Rehabilitation . Search Propeliy Infonnation Printer- friendly Version Krone, Charles, House Stillwater HPC 7/29/2008 Parcel Identification Number (PIN): 3303020110130 Site Address: 924 6th Ave S Construction Date: 1886 Builder: Architect: Architectural Style: Queen Anne Naritive: This vernacular, two-story house was built in 1886 for Charles Krone. The ell-shaped frame residence has a poured concrete foundation, clapboard siding, a cross gable roof with a brick chimney, and a wraparound front porch. This house is a simplified example of a Queen Anne form, but lacks the rich adornment that was common to Queen Anne style. The Queen Anne style was popular in the United States in the late nineteenth to early twentieth centuries. The defining features of this house include the City of Stillwater HPC -- HHLS Website -- Property Information 20f2 original clapboard siding with corner boards, tall and narrow one-over-one double-hung windows, a steeply pitched cross-gable roof, and the decorative scrollwork in the pediment over the front entrance. Over time, the wraparound front porch has been enclosed with four-light hopper windows; a one-story, front-gabled addition with clapboard and masonite siding has been added to the rear elevation; and a modern two-car garage was built in the back yard. Charles Krone applied for a building permit in 1886 to build a one-and-a-half-story $200 house on this lot. Krone was an agent for the Singer Sewing Machine Company. According to the 1894-1895 city directory, John F. O'Rourke, a guard at the Minnesota State Prison, was the primary resident of the house. According to historical maps, between 1898 and 1904, O'Rourke enlarged the house to a full two-stories and added the wraparound porch to the front elevation. He also constructed a one-story addition on the rear elevation. In 1910, O'Rourke built a one-story barn on the property for $400. In 1910, O'Rourke was employed in the fuel business located at 316 Commercial Avenue. According to historic maps, between 1910 and 1924, a large two-story hipped roof outbuilding was constructed behind the house near the one-story barn that was built in 1910. Neither of these historic outbuildings remains. John F. O'Rourke and his family resided in this house for over thirty years. J J'aJ.. .~.Q,',,5,,;';',\N Uu',' .~",~~.. ~\,"'\ ~am~O' \wWr~ \ \" 0. - _" ' ]~D [DrdO~ _ '., ~~~ \. rC~'{]iDsr~ ; ~ ~~ 00 ~ cro5tb 0 D ]~D l JaO;E:ro 8UllinJon $1 E:~ MaIsh 51 IN!!2 ~ M~~h $1 e: [[j~ to D~D:[J!iU,8_1e~r1tl se City of Stillwater HPC -- HHLS Website -- Property Information lof2 . Home . Properties . About the Program . Rehabilitation . Search Property Infonnation Printer- friendly Version Andrews, Albert F., House Stillwater HPC 6/1/2008 Stillwater HPC 6/1/2008 Parcel Identification Number (PIN): 3303020110010 Site Address: 822 6th Ave S Construction Date: 1887 City of Stillwater HPC -- HHLS Website -- Property Information 20f2 Builder: Architect: Architectural Style: Queen Anne Naritive: This circa 1887, Queen Anne style house was built for Albert F. Andrews. The one-and-a-half-story, frame building features clapboard siding with corner boards, one-over-one double-hung windows and a gable-on-hipped roof with lower cross-gables. There are projecting gable bays on the north and south elevations. The roof is covered with metal panels, a feature that is common to many nineteenth century Stillwater homes. The asymmetrical fa<;ade, the gable-on-hip roof, lower cross gables, the vertical and diagonal siding in the gables, and the wraparound porch with scroll-sawn detailing in the pediment above the steps are characteristics of the Queen Anne style that was popular in the United States in the late nineteenth to early twentieth centuries. This particular house is an example of the Free-Classic subtype of Queen Anne, which is characterized by the use of classical columns on the porch instead of turned posts. Albert F. Drews had this two-story house built circa 1887. In 1888, Drews applied for a permit application to have local contractor and builder Edward Olson construct a one-story kitchen addition on the rear elevation. The estimated cost of the addition was $200. A front gable dormer and shed roof porch were added to the south elevation at a later date. According to the Washington County Tax Assessor's Office, the one-story, frame garage that is located in the back yard was built in 1968. According to the 1890-1891 city directory, Albert Drews and his brother Herman operated the Drews Brothers Flour and Feed Mill located at 211 South Water Street. According to the 1894-1895 city directory, Leo H. Drews, who was employed as a clerk, was a border with Albert. By 1894, the family business was known as Drews Brothers and Muller after Albert and Herman partnered with Henry Muller. By 1896, Albert Drews had retired from milling, and by 1898, he had sold the property. ~~~~YO..~..~ ,., , \ ~ waO~ ~\ '@', ' ~e_\\0f\ \ "\" Wilrarcl 5t . ..." ~' ~ ]~D [ ] 0: ~~ ~\\ ~ I St I Churd!jl' SI r: f ~ ~ "@ \ ] D;[@ J~D []~!-, 9\ ~ ~\ m "-T ~nEtb 0 D ~\l ]~D I~D;DQnD 8wrlin~Qn 51 E ~ \ \ M3rsh St,W~ [Margh $1 E D D D~ I l n_n3'r.fa~~~~18 TEj~rP;tl~~~r s City of Stillwater HPC -- HHLS Website -- Property Information lof3 . Home . Properties . About the Program . Rehabilitation . Search Property Infonnation Printer- friendly Version Harry and Mae Farmer House Washington County 6/1/2006 Taken while hOlne was being stripped for painting 106 Group 10/1/2007 City of Stillwater HPC -- HHLS Website -- Property Information 20f3 Post Painting Stillwater HPC 6/1/2008 Parcel Identification Number (PIN): 2803020430080 Site Address: 411 6th St S Construction Date: 1916 Builder: Architect: Architectural Style: Craftsman Naritive: Constructed around 1916 for Harry R. and Mae Farmer in the Thompson Parker and Mower's Addition, this two-and-a-half-story, L-shaped house is an excellent example of the Craftsman style. Defining characteristics of this house include its wide eaves with exposed rafters and triangular shaped knee braces. Other notable features of this house, which sits on a rock-faced cut limestone foundation, include the shallow pitch roof on the porch, the use of clapboard siding on the first floor and square cut wood shingles on the second story. Hipped roof dormers are located on the side elevations. Prior to constructing this house, Harry and Mae, and Harry's father Henry C. Farmer resided nearby at 418 6th Street South. For many years Harry worked in the garage at the Ford Motor Company's sales and service department, located at 124 2nd Street South. After Harry passed away in 1942, Mae continued to live in the house through the mid 1940s. --'~U~U~'.w'i,,'J.,\, r 'V~~',".~,~'J'.,...ln W J~ 2J 00 ' ' \-.-.. ~ n\ U f'.f) m '""'" 'tflo, ' U . ,... -- 2: ..... , . '., 3\ e. ' ~~ J, _ Z,-,'.Ll, _ zD . . tJ,'l~st\J'.l, ... Q". ..~~\\... ~i~ ~jSb~.. c dP.O~~d~ I,JVR~rn,; ;,~,__S~ ~" ,I ,". ,,~',-.J ,e., s~.'tJ. ". ~~, " 'S~ ~ -o'we~T1 l~\(.) ~ oa~5\\N '; .~~ ~..m" SPN~", ~<F(,[j .'~O,',.." D,_,~,.,' ,'(/J,."O?I~'(I.0~,\[.,. ~~ . 0. r:J " ~ Q'..J ~ ~ ..~ o\(Le ~~~ . ~ .~ .. ~ \ . ..\(1). 'I Pine 8t'hi ,00_ Mapr~..9-ta-@~Op8 Trle,kll~ijr_"?Ii*~~ . City of Stillwater HPC -- HHLS Website -- Property Information 30f3 City of Stillwater HPC -- HHLS Website -- Property Information lof2 . Home . Properties . About the Program . Rehabilitation . Search Property Infonnation Printer- friendly Version Hogstrom, John, House Stillwater HPC 7/31/2008 Parcel Identification Number (PIN): 3403020220026 Site Address: 919 6th Ave S Construction Date: 1886 Builder: Architect: Architectural Style: Italianate N aritive: This Italianate style house was constructed circa 1886 for John Hagstrom. The two-story, frame dwelling, rests on a limestone foundation, is faced with clapboard siding, and has a hip roof with an interior brick chimney. The house retains its clapboard siding with corner boards, and one-over-one and two-over-two double-hung windows. I ts low-pitched roof with wide, overhanging eaves and tall and narrow windows with decorative wood surrounds are characteristics of the Italianate style that was popular in the United States in the mid- to late-nineteenth century. A two-story, hipped roof addition on the north elevation was constructed at the City of Stillwater HPC -- HHLS Website -- Property Information 20f2 same time as the original building. A two-story, hipped roof addition on the east elevation features an enclosed porch on its south elevation. This addition replaced a circa 1900 one-story addition that also had a porch on its south elevation. This addition respects the design, scale, and materials of the original building. According to historical maps, sometime after 1956, the original full-width porch was removed from the front elevation and the current one-story, front-gabled, masonite clad garage was built in the back yard. Based on its form, materials, and historical maps, the garage was constructed circa 1960. The house was built circa 1886 for John Hagstrom. According to the 1890-1891 city directory, Hagstrom owned a confectioner and grocery business at 115 East Myrtle Street. Hagstrom and his family resided in this house until the turn of the century. In 1956, William C. Roloff owned this property . ~ 'I.r"",,~~,.... \ \% ~Q O~\---'~ r~\) "U\ :1 - J 0 jrdO~ ~~~@ ~ ...., ChUfclljlf St ~ ~ y ~ ~ ~rl. ~~lJ n~Lt ~ J;LJ@ J~ l J w-~ · =roStb 0 D ] D!t;' E trtjngton $1 8"rli:J~QIl)n 5t E ~ tShStw~D~~J:ln D D! l n~nro~J~i~oo~~ e City of Stillwater HPC -- HHLS Website -- Property Information lof2 . Home . Properties . About the Program . Rehabilitation . Search Property Infonnation Printer- friendly Version Campbell, Hugh D., House ~.I. ;~ -~ ~j~ J~ ~_ ~'~~~ ,~,:,:! I ~t.- ,'.~".~~~~-'l I,r~i < .' ,,(~..,'~. J' :r .""-..0. i I ~ ~,;"-,;,~)~.::' _ V"~.'''''~~' /.,.'~ ~~ ~-;~,~~~~-(~. ;".~:' ~ 1-:.~ -"-='L-,~;~~"~ '".~~ ~.,-- , ~'!>i:';"~, { , "''' If I_:IIIJ ~, ,. -~..,....- 0' I' ',. ~ ......(~ E. '" . .. _ .... ~"I I 1, ~ r'1~'\" ~I ~~=-I '~-i-- ~- ~.-r~'; ..' ~ " ~.,.,' ~\~~ _ -f .,,~. . :~ \ -", - -------: ---~~ -==---~.~-~ ..tj;.;...~~" -' . ._...-----~-~- Stillwater HPC 6/1/2008 Parcel Identification Number (PIN): 2803020340068 Site Address: 506 Pine St W Construction Date: 1890 Builder: Architect: Architectural Style: Queen Anne Naritive: This grand Queen Anne style residence was constructed circa 1890. The two-story, frame house has a limestone foundation, clapboard siding, a hipped roof, and one-over-one double-hung windows with transom windows above. The steeply pitched roof, irregular roofline with a dominant front facing gable, patterned shingles, sunburst patterns, and the wraparound porch with turned columns and spindlework in the railing and frieze are characteristics of the Queen Anne style. The house features many dormers of different shapes and sizes including hipped and pedimented front gable with a small window. A highly ornamented, City of Stillwater HPC -- HHLS Website -- Property Information 20f2 one-and-a-half-story carriage house is located in the rear yard. The carriage house has a limestone foundation, a jerkinhead roof with a central cupola, front gable dormers, one-light fixed windows, and double-leaf sliding glass doors. Both the house and carriage house have been converted into apartments. It is unknown who constructed this house. According to the 1908-1909 city directory, Hugh D. Campbell, the treasurer of the Eclipse Sawmill Company, lived in the house with his wife Minnie and their son Hugh B. who was a student. Mr. Campbell added the one-story porch on the rear elevation in 1909. By 1910, Campbell owned his own lumber business at 113 South Main Street. In 1912, Campbell's business moved to 226 East Myrtle Street. When Campbell was elected to serve as a Stillwater councilman in 1917, he, his wife, and their daughter, Dorothy M. Campbell, lived in the house. According to the 1927-1928 city directory, Minnie Campbell, Hugh D. Campbell's widow, was the primary resident and continued to inhabit the house through the 1930s. . - , . :L.lIL-.JI,v[lwD - r ~ ~, \~ .~ ] [lirJi i Zll, ~, .t(JJ&..... s~\N. " ' "b.efEA~,~ . ~--- ~J""i~ CO'~. ti~ j ~WMLjtJ 0 . dP ~ ] ~~' . - g. 0 ~ ~ 'OUve $1 'N ' m~ .::. \N .,) J[ ~'I II ] ~ ~. O~-A ~ ..:]!..,D~ s: O<t~~",...,.,.";I;~'",,, ,.' "~(\'" .". n,~"t,fI", '., J~DOOD~."-n(~~",- ~ .u)~~Q' l(hU U. , ~'~\(IJ~ ~ ] 0 Pinastj~ On \\ ~$e .<:1 Sl W C::;;::UlaQt Willard Sl W 0. - -, JOiO Cf.~ 0 0 D~D [ ~[$tWJ~D C~J~ ~ 1,: . c'~lIrpCDhm Sf WO"D., ~,',IlI--.jW Cib~,rchiJ'15t I.,."" j(f.l!1 aJ'l I9=Q.mr:rQg , -. ....' 001 fp '~I T 00 ~ (fJ __._ . u' ~~c1f>eaal~Y~2~~ Tej~ AtlC\~ Te~ s 0 ~k City of Stillwater HPC -- HHLS Website -- Property Information lof2 . Home . Properties . About the Program . Rehabilitation . Search Property Infonnation Printer- friendly Version Lund, Franl(, House Stillwater HPC 6/1/2008 Parcel Identification Number (PIN): 2803020340005 Site Address: 804 Olive St W Construction Date: 1882 Builder: Lund., Frank Architect: Architectural Style: Queen Anne Naritive: This small, vernacular house was constructed circa 1882 by Frank Lund. Lund was a carpenter at the Stillwater Manufacturing Company, one of the largest home builders in the 1880s and 1890s in Stillwater. In 1890, newlyweds Peter and Mary Ryhn purchased the small house. Mr. Ryhn was the engineer and chief custodian a t the old Stillwater senior high school from 1888 until his death in 1940 (Brent Peterson, Stillwater Gazette, no date). Mrs. Ryhn continued to live in the house until her death in City of Stillwater HPC -- HHLS Website -- Property Information 20f2 1954. Howard Mason owned the property in the late 1950s. The current resid ents have lived in the house since 1966. The one-and-a-half-story, frame building, with its stuccoed foundation, elegan t brick chimney, tall and narrow one-over-one windows, and clapboard siding is covered by a cross gable roof. The house features Queen Anne style influences including the fishscale-shaped wood shingles in the front gable end and tall and narrow one-over-one windows. An enclosed porch is located on the southeast corner of the house. Based on its form and materials, the two-story, front-gabled ell on the rear elevation appears to have been constructed in the 1920s. A one-story, gable-roofed enclosed rear porch, which was originally open, was added by Mr. Ryhn in 1928. ,-~" -. .. D D~L:rD c=J [- ~%\.. ~~',., ",~" ~." MUlb,.,P..,',tly' Sl W , w ,~,~UIb.!?lI~\1S' , " g.l"~,' 'a.D~ n~ 0 .....Dr.rnO.......O:Ll rt:- I JI~~, ,~, .I~,', ,~ ~ ~,'.' ~.,", , c~ ern -- 3 D~ m.r.., ~, JLJ~nRiD'ftl~nD;D;~ rr9 Slrr:j ~ ~t~,I;~~ 0 rd \ ~ ::=:JRam~StW Do;;:. \<7~D S~e\ wr"-' ~ ~c.......: .. _ ':5 r:- ~j---.J L-J,r;) =, :Oltve 51 W. l (/), M St ~ :[D~ I I [ ~ \ ] Os 0 D~, ~ s: Oa!l..SIW ,if (J) IkSt\~J Z""O D~DI"..Q[]~[jJ'[ '~ ] '---JOi fA ~ I~ '11: ~ 0 0 r-i~~-SJ_Wl~D D'~O \ ~ ~~'lard"S~" '.' inil1ard S~ ,,~Icl St' '. 4eoR~~!008-reIG~jr~s Of ~ City of Stillwater HPC -- HHLS Website -- Property Information lof2 . Home . Properties . About the Program . Rehabilitation . Search Property Infonnation Printer- friendly Version Sutherland, John, House Stillwater HPC 7/29/2008 Parcel Identification Number (PIN): 2803020320078 Site Address: 120 Owens St N Construction Date: 1883 Builder: Architect: Architectural Style: Folk Victorian N aritive: In 1883, John Sutherland filled out a permit application to construct a $250 house on this lot in Greeley's Addition. The 1892 city directory, lists Charles Wigren, a rafter, and Malcolm Christianson, a laborer, as the primary residents of the house. Johan G. Johnanson, a laborer, also lived here as a boarder. This simple, one-and-a-half-story, Folk Victorian frame house has City of Stillwater HPC -- HHLS Website -- Property Information 20f2 clapboard siding, a cross gable roof, and two-over-two and three-over-one double-hung windows, the latter of which date from around 1920. The house originally had a wraparound front porch that was removed and replaced sometime after 1956 by the one-story, enclosed porch now located on the southeast corner of the house. This porch features decorative stick detailing in the gable. Also after 1956, the one-story, gabled wing on the rear elevation had a second story added to it. This addition respects the design, scale, and materials of the original building. A circa 1950 garage is located in the back yard. f:~~~~~l?\U! -------- - ~ Linden St W' ~r.1 ~indeJiJ St -.. ~~D~D~QJ;~~J=;J ~ Ja-~~~ I:D~D~D:::Daf r 5 ~~ rn == ~ ~ ::: ~' ~ ~ :.- Z ~D:l't ~ ~ :L ...~ iu ~I, i OW[lilJi[l;O; t:JWCJresl rWij' WMLjStJ 01 Ram5~ St W flams~ $t W ~ _ VOl R~m~S.L-. ~J c--=:J~C DQ ~~~~ 'IV OWe St !1I -,owl ] I D[U~[J Of 0 OJ ~ ~~ 5rW ~ !n~StWl~n D~n(QIl~~ ~lJ;;1 . ~L-Map-datal@26o.8_T.ele_Atla~LJ !::. '^( PJi"ICI .s::~ 'OJ........ "-'II' ,...." ,~ City of Stillwater HPC -- HHLS Website -- Property Information lof2 . Home . Properties . About the Program . Rehabilitation . Search Property Infonnation Printer- friendly Version Moore, George A. & Bridget, House Stillwater HPC 6/1/2008 Parcel Identification Number (PIN): 2803020330044 Site Address: 1018 Olive St W Construction Date: 1873 Builder: Architect: Architectural Style: Italianate Naritive: In 1873, George A. and Bridget Moore had an Italianate style house built 0 n this property. According to city directories, George A. Moore, a local lumberman, resided in the house from 1892 to 1905. By 1919, John E. McCarthy was the primary resident and Alger M. Halvorsen owned the property in the 1940s and 1950s. This circa 1873 house was designed in the Italianate style and was one of the first houses to be constructed along 0 live Street, which was historically known as the old St. City of Stillwater HPC -- HHLS Website -- Property Information 20f2 Paul Road that connected Stillwater to St. Paul. The two-story, frame buil ding, with its limestone foundation, clapboard siding, and hip roof with a chimney centered on the ridgeline, is located in Greeley's Addition. Its low-pitched hipped roofwith overhanging eaves and decorative brackets, tall and narrow one-over-one windows with decorative wood surrounds, square plan, and corner boards are characteristics of the Italianate style that was popular in the United States in the mid to late nineteenth century. A one-story, hipped-roof addition on the east elevatio n appears to date from the turn of the twentieth century, based on its design, materials, and historical maps. According to the 1904 Sanborn Map, a one-story porch was attached to the south elevation of the addition, which abutted the corner of the main block, and a one-story porch was located on the south elevation of the original structure. Sometime after 1956, the se two porches were remodeled to create a one-story screen porch that extends across the entire south elevation of the additio n and across one-bay of the original building. The existing garage dates from 1993. ~ ' LJoLJG)L] 1-.1 L---...J L ~Ol.r ~ an ~ a Mulberry' 8t VtJ VV MulE $, 6r ~ * I D\}. , IDiD~DfDDID~D![ ~. I .:i,:,....". ;nRiC:eoSI wD~ 92D~D~Lr- ~;51 _ ~D2: _ z =J.w Crre, i" Ltya,~, t,:1 W ~rl, ,SO 0 1 !!!:5~ Sl loJ . Fla.m5~ SI6l) 0 _ WFlf.m~ St - j ~~D YJr;) ~~IIVeS1W ':J:O" Q W QWe St ~ ~D~'I I L ~I,.~.~gksO~DDD D:,~D.~[]f_',',a J;: :;1 00 IOJ ~ rn L-J ~ W Pll n 13' 8t Pine ~: '!Afro . U ~ODIID[ [- ..-...~ "'-...",.- - ......... \Nllli;t!f(~ St W rn VlJ vVlrla!i'd $t ~'. . O,p~D []~ Map data @2~~ere=)\t~~-=r-e~fOf~e-' City of Stillwater HPC -- HHLS Website -- Property Information lof2 . Home . Properties . About the Program . Rehabilitation . Search Property Infonnation Printer- friendly Version Wright, Addison, House Stillwater HPC 6/1/2008 Parcel Identification Number (PIN): 2803020340084 Site Address: 518 Olive St W Construction Date: 1871 Builder: Architect: Architectural Style: Folk Victorian Naritive: This ornate, Folk Victorian style house was built in 1871 for Addison Wright. This was one of the first houses constructed along Olive Street, which was historically known as the old St. Paul Road that connected Stillwater to St. Paul. The one-and-a-half-story, frame building, with limestone foundation, is clad in cedar shakes and has a front gable roof with two gable wall dormers on the east elevation. The decorative woodwork in the gable, known as bargeboards or vergeboards, the window City of Stillwater HPC -- HHLS Website -- Property Information 20f2 surrounds, and other details are evocative of the Italianate and Queen Anne styles, which are characteristics of the Folk Victorian style that was popular in the United States in the late nineteenth century. The three windows surmounted by a half-round window in the gable is called a Palladian window. The wraparound porch with turned columns with scroll-sawn brackets and frieze details are also features of Folk Victorian architecture. The four-over-four, and eight-over-eight double-hung windows were recently installed to replace non-historic, circa 1950s windows (David & Madeline Rogers). At some point in time, a side gable addition was constructed on the rear elevation, giving the house an ell-shaped form. This addition generally respects the design, scale, and materials of the original building. A one-story, front-gabled garage is located on the rear of the property and has been designed in the same style and constructed with the same materials as the house. This property is located in Greeley's Addition to Stillwater and is sited on the south side of the Greeley-Olive Street ravine. Addison and Jeannie Wright built this house in 1871 for an estimated cost of$800. Wright was a partner in Smith, Wright, and Mosier, a house painting firm with offices on 2nd Street between Myrtle and Chestnut Streets. The painting company later became Wright & Booke. Mr. and Mrs. Wrights lived in this house through the 1890s. In the late twentieth century, David and Madeline Rogers purchased the property and sensitively restored the house. They converted the house from a duplex back to its original use as a single family home. During restoration they added the ornately decorated wraparound front porch (personal communication with David & Madeline Rogers). ~G)D D CJ r ~~ ~~'-,- .,(;. "MlIn;i,',e..lly.S,t".,W \iYM,'UI~1!Y.~" - ".",. ?", ~~.,'.," ..','.',".' '. '~D D 0 U L "",,"' '(;L- .~ " rn ' :L rt.: tJI I~ ~ ~' ~~, ~t; ~'\ ~si~r !C~ ~ ~ 't ... ~~. J [lilJi[lDZ~~ ~ [j -WTjSt{ D~ ~ dP ,\- v .1- I.....,., WRam~~.t ~ ,6J ", '\'-.J,c,S'/.~,\tJ~,. , " ,\", , O U....L-. Y g. 0 \. \ r;). ~ O-IlVe"S1 V" _ ' CJl, .- '. ,5\ ~tJ ~. ,\ ~D~I I [ l U1 ~ oal' D'~ D~. 92 5:., Oak StVII ~, w. 1~,G, . 'i] DooDooDIlIWcr -,' ,(j) " % I 16; ~~'" ~,.,",;;\;;N .(1)\1, , . -fft ~~. ?ttte. ~~ OJ] (nsStwto D~oG ~~ 1I:ji:"oj St W m VIi WlIlarrdl 5t . WIIII;;l rd $t \~~J JAhb~!LM~p!data12oo1 t~\q ~rm ~ City of Stillwater HPC -- HHLS Website -- Property Information lof2 . Home . Properties . About the Program . Rehabilitation . Search Property Infonnation Printer- friendly Version Gardner, I.C., House ~ ,...~ -..... Stillwater HPC 7/29/2008 Parcel Identification Number (PIN): 2803020310070 Site Address: 618 Myrtle St W Construction Date: 1873 Builder: Architect: Architectural Style: Vernacular Naritive: This vernacular house was built for J.C. Gardner in 1873. Gardner built the original, one-and-a-half-story portion of the house, which has a front gable roof, for an estimated cost of$I,500. The house is prominently visible on the 1879 Bird's Eye View of the City of Stillwater. The frame home rests on a limestone foundation; is faced with clapboard siding; has tall, narrow, one-over-one double-hung windows and an enclosed, full-width front porch. A later brick chimney is located on the rear City of Stillwater HPC -- HHLS Website -- Property Information 20f2 elevation. At some point prior to 1910, the one-and-a-half-story side gable addition was added to the west elevation. The addition has a one-story porch and gable wall dormers that break the roofline on the north and south elevations. The porch on the north elevation has been enclosed. A modern, front-gabled garage, front-gabled shed, and hipped-roof gazebo are located behind the house. The original homeowner, J.e. Gardner, was a guard at the Stillwater Prison in the late 1870s. According to the 1892 city directory, George H. and Kittie Sullivan were living in the house. Mr. Sullivan was a partner in the law firm of Manwaring & Sullivan, which had an office at 104 North Main Street. The Sullivan's lived in this house until 1905 when they moved to Mahtomedi. It should be noted that Sullivan was elected to the Minnesota State Senate in 1906, and from 1916-1917, he served as the lieutenant governor of Minnesota (Peterson & Thilgen, Stillwater: A Photographic History 1843-1993, 1992:95). ~u~r n n =1!~, "~O J u U U:<:!,.-Nl nstwo D:[rt~J c=J T'nden,s'~~ ID!D!DMUrb~rj;[]J fOi i[U'bell'f. st '1.-, ::::J r;+ -. ~ ;:::L -, ":'I 00 Z :::: rP !R :::T!!. % J~nRiD'^tJ;B~l~D;L-4~ o rWJ WM(jStJ 011\ rC RamS'ID' St ~flw!' ,11_" IN R,"m~, ,J~U,'. ~'-..Ipe,~ s~~,~ --, r --. [] U~L-_ . . g 0'\ I ---..J, ~,' L......J, r;;), . ~ Olli.i(lSl W l en ,St ~ - [D~'I II .~ % Os D D,~ gl s: Qa~ St W 5=- (J) 'l!~ nw ..~D D~"" DooD~. [JOB_. ~'" u" O .-+ i'j;J ::r:;J, (.I} ~ i:iT 1.1, r' (L I:! "~ [[I ~ Pin5!,SlW (J) Q>~ \ ~ n l'\/Ia~p'dat~-<9200a Tele'Atl~s-=1~ rms l)Jse I 'I I L I ( , J . 1 .. . City of Stillwater HPC -- HHLS Website -- Property Information lof2 . Home . Properties . About the Program . Rehabilitation . Search Property Infonnation Printer-friendly Version Johnson, Adam, House Stillwater HPC 7/29/2008 Parcel Identification Number (PIN): 2803020310036 Site Address: 209 Martha St N Construction Date: 1883 Builder: Johnson, Adam Architect: Architectural Style: Queen Anne N aritive: This modest, Queen Anne style house was constructed circa 1883. The one-and-a-half-story, frame building has a limestone foundation, clapboard siding, one-over-one double-hung windows, and a cross- gable roof with a brick chimney centered on the ridgeline. The prominent front facing gable, patterned shingles in the gable, and wraparound porch are characteristics of the Queen Anne style that was popular in the United States in the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries. The hipped-roof porch, which is now enclosed, has square Tuscan columns, which indicates that this house is an example of the Free Classic subtype of Queen City of Stillwater HPC -- HHLS Website -- Property Information 20f2 Anne architecture, which is more commonly associated with turned spindles. A one-story, front-gabled ell is located on the rear elevation. This house was built by carpenter Adam Johnson circa 1883, who resided in the house for a short period of time. According to the 1892 city directory, Johnson and Frank Anderson, a rafter, were the primary residents of the house. Jenney Linn, a clerk, was a boarder in the house in 1892. Adam Johnson lived in this house for over thirty years. :J~~I 0 ~U Wst~O. \ JI~,a,~&3il $ 0, :\-,:,.O'.9,ot~\,..o. .. \~,t ~ ~~l' ' .' '0" ,~ ~, ,.,' '~ 4 ,_~\I'I ViI l-inden Sl ~lI!lo;l~n .6~ ' ., ~ D9D~D. D 0,[ ,. % ~ : ~ ~~. MUlbe,tr~ St, Vi) ~"." M _ul~l!y. st " g!. '~, ..', "05::DJDri:"""O 0 :~.i'~l rz ~ ~. 0 .~ r ~. ~.' ~. '~ I .~ :::: .~ Dl ~; ~, " IR.e:.e,St '/l,r '00, (f). " m =1.., ,', '(J)., , " . ~n D D;DiD~Dz~~ r~J. WljtJ 0 \\ I de f!.e:y~t W , ~, '" Vi/IRiftm,'_.~.. . 'CiJ.' , ,nxr.Jc,S'l.L::. ' lrL.J;--l ~c::=:=::....~ g ~ rl ,LJ"c;) :;:,: OIM':~tW l ~tQ". ',..',' eJ ~ & ~ I ] [ (J) ~ O~, i D 0..:)1 Dro g: Oak Sf IN , if (J) ':!l ~n n~n(QiMap data ~OO8nTele ~Ias ~$trm Q City of Stillwater HPC -- HHLS Website -- Property Information lof2 . Home . Properties . About the Program . Rehabilitation . Search Property Infonnation Printer- friendly Version Magnuson-Ryden House Stillwater HPC 7/29/2008 Parcel Identification Number (PIN): 2803020310137 Site Address: 202 Martha St N Construction Date: 1891 Builder: Magnuson., Sven Architect: Architectural Style: Queen Anne Naritive: This one-and-a-half-story, Queen Anne style house was built in 1891 by carpenter Sven Magnuson for a cost of$900. According to the 1892 city directory, August Ryden, a clerk, was the primary resident of the property. Ryden lived in the house until 1899 when his brother Magnus Ryden purchased the property. According to the 1900-1901 city directory, Ingra R. Ryden, widow of Magnus, was the primary resident. The frame building, with its limestone foundation, clapboard siding, and one-over-one City of Stillwater HPC -- HHLS Website -- Property Information 20f2 double-hung windows is covered by a gable-on-hipped roof. A brick chimney is located at the apex of the hipped roof. Its steeply-pitched, irregularly shaped roof, dominant facing front gable, decorative wood panels in the gable ends, and asymmetrical front elevation are characteristics of the Queen Anne style. The hipped-roof wraparound porch has Tuscan columns, which is a common variation of Queen Anne architecture, which is more commonly associated with turned spindles. A one-story, front-gabled addition has been constructed on the two-story rear cross-gabled ell. The addition respects the design, scale, and materials of the original building. Sometime after 1956, the wraparound porch was extended north where it has a conical roof. A one-story, front-gabled garage is located in the rear yard. The frame structure is clad in clapboard siding with vertically laid masonite siding in the gable end. ~-__JZ{ I L_.-J ~~~ ~st 0 a laurel Sl W . "t- \N VoW'" ... [J. ' ,iw-~~I O. .' f'j,'~,'~,~.,r.. ' 00 ~~ C \, \-J';l;\- J - ~! ,.~ ( it ~v VI/'Lindef71 St --Unojen .s" \. ] DoDGlD D CJ ~ J~,'"'D',~n,, .'-t,~DMulb:tDry. S~",'JII~J "'.--'~"",'Dw '::t...M'CUlbeJ[y'~, . "," """;t:,.',., C (n I -;:;;: ~~n ,.....,,' DJ i'"t ""t. r+ !O == ,.,,::: .. . 5 2: I~ ~. . ,!i t.;I"1 J~n ,~i'D~StlN[l' ~D~[l~D;~ "".~~,I",.,--- ~r1~ Z' ~ I .-J ~i~ JrW?J WMCistJ 0 \ d~ ~a.ri,i'!:i.'",~~t\N 11<., wR~m~. St ' ~o~~\Ie,sL~~ --, r . [] U~ _. ~ . --..J. ~,' , L-I 1(;), ~ Olive $t W l (/) : ~D Dir--:~'I 11 ~ ~ o~ J~ 1'(1 Uoo ' ."'T" , ~I .::;. '.....: '"':'" ~ OalcSt W i5"" to ..... ~ ,ro (f,I '001 I [lI I ""' l~ rj:J 'l~n nC;;~ap' data @2q;~ Te~ Atla~ir Te. 0 City of Stillwater HPC -- HHLS Website -- Property Information lof2 . Home . Properties . About the Program . Rehabilitation . Search Property Infonnation Printer-friendly Version House Stillwater HPC 7/29/2008 Stillwater HPC 7/29/2008 Parcel Identification Number (PIN): 2803020130137 Site Address: 110 Mulberry St E Construction Date: 1865 City of Stillwater HPC -- HHLS Website -- Property Information 20f2 Builder: Architect: Architectural Style: Italianate N aritive: This house is one of the few reaming one-story, side-gabled vernacular house s that were common on Stillwater' s North Hill. The frame structure, with its limestone foundation, clapboard siding and one-over-one double-hung windows was constructed circa 1865. The side gable roof with eave returns, the tall and narrow one-over-on e windows, and the handsome, hipped roof portico that is centrally located on the front elevation and features stately chamfered piers are characteristics of the Italianate style that was popular in the United States during the mid-nineteenth century. A rear addition was constructed circa 1870 and features an exposed basement due to the steep slope of the lot. The one-story house and the rear addition are visible on the 1870 Bird's Eye View of the City of Stillwater. According to historical maps, sometime between 1904 and 1910, the rear addition was extended across the entire rear elevation to give the house a square plan. The second addition features one-over-one double-hung and one-light casement windows. A one-story, hipped-roof addition with exposed basement was added across the rear elevation in 2008. Little is actually known about the early residents of this house. According to the 1956 city directory, Mrs. Carrie Levi, Mrs. Ruby Tanner, and Helen Swaner were the primary residents. By 1965, Victor H. Dacuuha was the primary resident. In 1970, Mary Newago and Mrs. Marie Ledding were residing in the house. J {~~U~U~ d~ J,1I t,.,\~j~" b; L StViJ 6'0 O. I ~' " I J I ~f!. os't j :=].~ ~ l-Se)tO II \ ~~~0~ @ ',-~- ~ \? ,} u ~." \ (:. p:I ~ ~~ ~ ' -------.un<:len'.$~ J \J ~\l\'oD~nj' \\~I~ I~ =:J[ ~ G 'Ut~', w r...]ulberrv. SI. tI! ~ ~ \ I, D::r:[ ..~ ~ ~ f\~. ~ ~ m ~ ~ :;~, ';.&-, ~ ~ ~ ~ '!!. '" ~ $\ (\ {\ ~~\ ~ ZJ (f.I ~, ~~\ n, \J U G) ~ ~;I ~ ~ I ~ ~ st ~ i zD ~ s~\foI c~:Je;~ ~l~\\\~ \ J2111 %0 \ ~U -' ~~\ Q (JiJ ~gl (j1 ~ a~~ f p '" ~~g g~,~20b8\Te!e Atl~~ of. City of Stillwater HPC -- HHLS Website -- Property Information lof2 . Home . Properties . About the Program . Rehabilitation . Search Property Infonnation Printer- friendly Version House Stillwater HPC 7/29/2008 Stillwater HPC 7/29/2008 Parcel Identification Number (PIN): 2803020130102 Site Address: 122 Linden St W Construction Date: 1872 City of Stillwater HPC -- HHLS Website -- Property Information 20f2 Builder: Architect: Architectural Style: Italianate Naritive: A carpenter named James Heffernan built this quaint, Italianate style house for his family circa 1872. The two-story, frame building is clad with its clapboard siding and corner boards, and has a hip roofwith a prominent brick chimney. Its low-pitched roof with widely overhanging eaves and decorative brackets are characteristics of the Italianate style that was popular in the United States in the mid- to late- nineteenth century. The front entry is adorned by a large, arched entablature. The house features six-over-six double-hung windows with wood surrounds. According to historical maps, this house was originally built with a one-and-a-half-story, rear wing with a gable roof. A one-story, gable roof addition was located on the rear elevation of this wing. This long, narrow, rectangular plan of the house is still present today. According to city directories, James and his wife Anna, a teacher at the Central School, lived here through the turn-of-the-century and raised two children in the house, Mary and James Jr., a onetime bookkeeper at the Stillwater Hardware Company. \ I Mr~t ViJ\~Q 0 1/. ': . JI o ~~'-- el.st ~ j t Vtl ''$ Q\N l.-&b61~ I, 'II~, \1P~~~}O\ @ \'1 ~I \- a - c. ~ St oz. -...... L1n'iien.:t.... ~~ 'W'I)~D~Jj 5\~'t:. Z:I~~ :Jc=J ~I t~ rr) St \iJJ ~v Mul~cE'Iry' Sl ~ % \ D.iD~Of[~, ~ q u~ ~ D~[l!D~1 \ ~--' ~.t~~~~~~ [J~ z v~~~ ~ ctJ' e!;\~ ~~~_ ~ ~Yllle $t ~1 \ ~,.~Q l ~\.l % l r I J n ~Map d,atf @2~Oq8-Te[&t\"~s - er~f11:~:~ City of Stillwater HPC -- HHLS Website -- Property Information lof2 . Home . Properties . About the Program . Rehabilitation . Search Property Infonnation Printer- friendly Version Olson, Andrew and Anna, House Stillwater HPC 7/29/2008 ..",i,.'~",.',' I " . 4- Stillwater HPC 7/29/2008 Parcel Identification Number (PIN): 2803020130079 Site Address: 107 Laurel St E Construction Date: 1860 City of Stillwater HPC -- HHLS Website -- Property Information 20f2 Builder: Architect: Architectural Style: Greek Revival Naritive: Andrew and Anna Olson built this large, Greek Revival style house, which is visible on the 1870 Bird's Eye View of the City of Stillwater, circa 1860. According to the 1881-1882 city directory Andrew Olson was employed as a clerk at Bronson and Folsom, a general merchandise store on Main Street between Chestnut and Myrtle streets. The Olson's lived in this house for over 40 years. The two-story, frame house rests on a limestone foundation, has clapboard siding and a prominent front gable roof. Its triangular shaped pediment with wide band of trim at the cornice line and two-over-two double-hung windows with decorative crowns are characteristics of the Greek Revival style that was popular in the United States in the mid-nineteenth century. A two-story, gable-roofed rear addition was constructed by the Olson's in 1878. The rear addition features a one-story portico on the east elevation and a brick chimney on the exterior of the west elevation. The one-story bay window that has a hipped roof with scrolled wood brackets and is located on the west elevation of the original house may have been added around the same time or slightly later. Overall, this house is a good example of how to preserve a historic house. --Wil~n~ $t, 1# ~D Oi" i.,..., " D~D 0 1_, 8.0' O~D:;: ~ ~J I ::! ____ (f.I z -t:.. WH\~n~SI iUL \ ,./ D 0 0 (~"._."'" 1/ /o!1i;:1PI,e SlW_%-Q,. ' ',0" ',' '" \. ,':..,..,",, . ~';. \j'J 1.#r-"\,I(,\ st"10, ' m . O~~' r ~ i1 , C~\fi~O" ~,,,~ ~ "-'-, . fa~ . '. V 0' --? () 0 ~I ", ~.~Ior , ,~t ~ ~1 --unQen,"'6",.)~,." '.' 'tJl~\'p,'Ge,flj" ., \\: ~I_"'~,.~,~"~"./,';"" CJ[ ~ ~ -\j~g ojIJ W M,. L1lbcorrl.~:st "....,. ~~, .,'., ,', m, -;" .,... O -D:r:[ rt:- ~ ' "0~~' ~ I ~ ~ o:;~ ~ w ~ iii' t,. ,~_~ ':~ : if;;; Map~ata ~2QQ.8)rE!I~~\\V\r~ ~~~ " I I ) City of Stillwater HPC -- HHLS Website -- Property Information lof2 . Home . Properties . About the Program . Rehabilitation . Search Property Infonnation Printer-friendly Version House Stillwater HPC 7/29/2008 Parcel Identification Number (PIN): 2803020130129 Site Address: 115 Linden St E Construction Date: 1905 Builder: Architect: Architectural Style: Vernacular N aritive: This large, corner house was constructed circa 1905 and replaced a small, one-story structure that was built on the western edge of the lot and was visible on the 1870 Bird's Eye View of the City of Stillwater. The existing, two-story frame house has a limestone foundation, clapboard siding, and a cross gable roof with two brick chimneys on its ridgeline. The vernacular style house features one-over-one double-hung and one-light square and round fixed windows. The ell-shaped form of the house and the overhanging eaves are indicative of the Italianate style while the square-butt wood shingles in the gables and window surrounds are indicative of City of Stillwater HPC -- HHLS Website -- Property Information 20f2 the Queen Anne style. The hipped roof porch on the front elevation was enclo sed at some point in time. The different porch styles and enclosed sleeping porch on the second story show how the house has further changed over time. Historical photos show a hipped-roof porch supported by brick posts. Throughout the twentieth century, the property changed hands many times. Some of its owners include Marl McFarlane and Donald C. Ancke, Catherine F. and Duncan Chisholm, N. A. Anderson, and Eugene Fischer. The current homeowners purchased the house in 1975, at which time it was used as a duplex. The house has since been converted back to a single family dwelling. ~~Ll~, u ~I ~~ r ~D~ ~ 1 . ~ ,5= {!2' I' St Vi' 0:5'0 Q 1/ I . ~ j ::J~ w~e5P . I " ~~c~ @ _ ~-~-, .~ aU5\b ~~JJ t" -----....uR<ien',s., w.\l~Det~ \\~ ~ _ t =:J[ ~ ~ \j\<;\\ ViJ Mulberr~' st tQ ~ ' ~, ~. ~ l~ J"i ~ cd rVJt ~. r 1m ...);..1! .~. ';k '~ E:. ~ . :D~[ \1\ - ~~~~t\\) \1 ~\~@/ -02' Jd~ U 5\~ ~~c~ : ~~..---1 C'oes\~n \\~_ ~,~ ~~ p-\) \j~ (p U1 n r\ \ fI1aPr-dat~",~20.!28aj\tJ.aS._~_ ,- 0_ U ~ , City of Stillwater HPC -- HHLS Website -- Property Information lof3 . Home . Properties . About the Pro graIn . Rehabilitation . Search Property Infonnation Printer- friendly Version Fry, Daniel, House Date Unknown S till water HPC 7/29/2008 S till water HPC 7/29/2008 City of Stillwater HPC -- HHLS Website -- Property Information 20f3 S till water HPC 7/29/2008 Parcel Identification Number (PIN): 2803020240002 Site Address: 222 Laurel St W Construction Date: 1860 Builder: Architect: Architectural Style: Greek Revival Naritive: County Assessor records indicate that this house was built in 1873; however, the oldest portion of the house, which is the two-story section with the front gable roof, appears to date from the early 1860s based on its design. This section of the house has clapboard siding with corner boards, wide trim in the gable, a cornice under the eaves, and tall baseboards. These features are common the Greek Revival style, which was popular in the United States in from around 1825 up to approximately 1860. The porch in front of the section of the house is a later addition. The one-and-a-half-story, side gable addition on the east elevation features a steeply pitched side gable roof, a narrow gable wall dormer that breaks the roofline and has a trefoil motif in its gable and decorative brackets. These are design elements associated with the Gothic Revival style, which was popular from approximately 1840 until about 1880. Based on the assessor's records, it is likely that this addition was built in 1873. Another interesting feature of this house is its metal roof, which was a popular roofing material in Stillwater at the turn of the twentieth century. Other features of the house are its one-over-one and two-over-two double-hung windows and two-light casement windows. The first known resident of the house was Daniel Fry and his wife Margaret. According to the 1876-1877 city directory, Mr. Fry worked at a confectionary located at the corner of Myrtle and Main streets. Around 1890, a small, one-story structure was built on the southwest corner of the property. According to historical maps, throughout the 1890s this structure operated as a fruit stand. Circa 1905, Fry converted the structure into a confectionary where he worked until his death. According to the 1910-1911 city directory, Mr. Fry had passed on; however, Mrs. Fry continued to live here through the 1910s. WVl/llkinS.'.St \lVilkin9.. St'.,N, 0 0 0, ,::0 " ~D Ds:D 0 ,L- ~ ~ ~,5 . Ii ~ ~ t.~.~rn St E. ( I~ I !!II M~~_~20p~ T elEf FtI~s rretms .p! Use, City of Stillwater HPC -- HHLS Website -- Property Information 30f3 City of Stillwater HPC -- HHLS Website -- Property Information lof2 . Home . Properties . About the Program . Rehabilitation . Search Property Infonnation Printer- friendly Version House Stillwater HPC 7/29/2008 Parcel Identification Number (PIN): 2803020240007 Site Address: 215 Laurel St W Construction Date: 1864 Builder: Architect: Architectural Style: Italianate Naritive: This elaborate, two-story Italianate style house was constructed circa 1864 on Stillwater's North Hill. The large, frame house has a limestone foundation, clapboard siding, and one-over-one double-hung windows. It is covered by a cross gable roof with clipped gables. Its scrolled wood brackets at the corners, centrally sited tower with small wood brackets, overhanging eaves, the chamfered columns on the front porch, and the tall and narrow one-over-one windows are characteristics of the Italianate style City of Stillwater HPC -- HHLS Website -- Property Information 20f2 that was popular in the United States in the mid- to late nineteenth century. Little is known about the early residents of this house. Based on its design, the garage appears to date from around 1920. The first know residents were William J. Glennon and Charles E. Ebert, who lived in the house in 1960 according to the city directory from that year. By 1970, James L Borden was living in the house, and in 1978, it was converted to a duplex. The curren t homeowner has sensitively restored the house based on a historical John Runk photo and returned the house to its original use a single-family residence. Jc-Ll LJ~U LJ. U U L-.J-l- U.~ :..~ .. . ~.'. ~l.~, Sl W ":"S\I'8A 51~. . ~ !DfD~u~D. r~.'. !S'~ . .~~.' St \l'lJ zD~D ~~D. *' ~ <>-1 l ----, ~ ~ ~ ':'". ~ ,----I:z . . (f.I Z -$ 5 0 d/D~O;U I ~~. tOM. [~1~\S@,Qst.'... J laurelS! W !2 "tCu y. PeJP I 1JO~.1 . . .... ~~'ii..\J.t~. 'I ~."O '. t-'.~., ...@.\5,"" ~F= v" "t.. ~ J ~ 4. . - ~ \,f'J.-'" a '5\ ~ ;cY'rst I c=J. ~U!ldl!n. oS-,; ...... ~u~~.;\ '. .], ~. MUIl).etr~ 8t. W. W M... UI~d!~~' st. . w,. ~G.'.... u. ::0 ~DrnD cO::r:[ ~ (fI ~~ g? ~: :S; ~~. ~t. .,~~. . '.rG.' :::: tp :!; :::E: III' tiJ'" . ro.e St '( 3D~ ~;; r;.. ~~-~~~1 '^f. ........ .,j)~. -- , .' \ I n:: .---,;n~aPl~ta @20~~~Jl9-S--.fe{r€ ~_~VJd,~ City of Stillwater HPC -- HHLS Website -- Property Information lof2 . Home . Properties . About the Program . Rehabilitation . Search Property Infonnation Printer- friendly Version Randall- Willim-Densmore House Stillwater HPC 7/29/2008 Parcel Identification Number (PIN): 2803020340115 Site Address: 504 Holcombe St S Construction Date: 1852 Builder: Architect: Architectural Style: Greek Revival N aritive: According to the Washington County Assessor's Office, this modest, Greek Revival style house was constructed circa 1852, when Stillwater was still part of Wisconsin Territory. The one-and-a-half-story, front gable house appears on the 1870 Bird's Eye View of the City of Stillwater. The frame residence has a limestone foundation, clapboard siding, and six-over-six double-hung windows, one of which is prominently centered in the front gable end. The house retains many of its Greek Revival details, including the wide trim band under the eaves, the sidelights and a transom windows around the door, and the six-over-six windows. At some point in City of Stillwater HPC -- HHLS Website -- Property Information 20f2 time, prior to 1900, based on the form and materials of the additions, a hipped-roof front porch, rear one-story front gable ell, and south one-story side gable addition were added to the house. A brick chimney, located on the north elevation, appears to date from the early to mid-twentieth century. The current ell-shaped form of the house appears today as it did on the 1956 Sanborn Map; this is the first map in which this neighborhood, Williams Division of Holcombe's Addition, is represented. The spindlework detailing on the porch is evocative of the Folk Victorian style that was popular in the United States in the late nineteenth century, and reflects its late nineteenth century construction date. A one-story, front gable, clapboard sided garage is located in the rear yard; based on its form and materials, the garage was built circa 1930. This interesting garage retains its original, paired doors. Dr. Andrew Randall, a medical doctor and geological surveyor for the Wisconsin Territory, was the original owner of the house (personal communication with Michael Mikkelson). William Willim, a skilled craftsman and laborer who built many houses in Stillwater, came into possession of the property in 1860 (personal communication with Michael Mikkelson). Mr. Willim was a member of the sixth Minnesota Territorial Legislator and served as mayor of Stillwater in 1856, 1866, and 1867 (Peterson & Thilgen, Stillwater: A Photographic History 1843-1993,1992:105). In 1868, John D. Densmore and his wife, Sarah Palmer, purchased the property. Mr. Densmore fought in the Civil War and survived the Battle of Gettysburg. Densmore and his wife raised six children in this house (personal communication with Michael Mikkelson). According to the 1876-1877 city directory, Densmore was employed as a lumberman. Densmore passed away on July 5, 1879, and was buried in Stillwater's Fairview Cemetery (Nick Coleman, Star Tribune, July 5, 2008). Densmore left the property to his wife and two surviving children. Sarah Palmer Densmore sold the property in 1910 to Christian Henningsen (personal communication with Michael Mikkelson). According to the 1912-1913 city directory, Henningsen was a policeman. The Henningsen family retained the property until 1969. J L 11-,1.. L. 1 LJ.. V-....W1.~ ~....'.,.,. .-."'O...C....~1. J WMDtJ~. . \- sOP ~ [J. VI/R~.rn~S...t.. ...L.. \..Ie,g~',\fJ... .' ~..". J',r;).. !~~, w l ~~~O'\'... . B\ \N I~.., Jl1 ~ I ] I ~ ~ Oa\<.; ~D~ s: ITw,....l.~-. (f) ~'G, D.. . .(/!.....~. ~.' J~D(nD~ ... g '~ (J) % \ rn ~ ,.:1 5'i\N (JlJ } - ~.... - '. i[.l, ~~(l.~ -0....0 '!l:' I " .., u:. .. .' ..,. ,.:\\fJ J 0 (Ime6tW(o u,;Q U~~\~~\J <.l st w . rn W 'Milar:! $1 . Willard Sl W 0., J.DlD CIJ 0 D D'~D [ J;r-qtt $1 WJ~D ctJ~ .~ ~. CI~llr(;Dltill .St WO" .' 01.- ~ w. .' ,CtI,~rchijl St. -Ib-. .1.---. !Q) a:I'D~Dm~ Dg\ : e,;' .. . '. Anderson 51 W: ~,~ ~L La.k.EIIJ18W ~;. I . BHospml ~Map data @201~l[<5I~~~~ I-T e~m,s of, U;;e City of Stillwater HPC -- HHLS Website -- Property Information lof2 . Home . Properties . About the Program . Rehabilitation . Search Property Infonnation Printer- friendly Version Greeley, Douglas, House Stillwater HPC 7/29/2008 Parcel Identification Number (PIN): 2803020320088 Site Address: 126 Greeley St N Construction Date: 1883 Builder: Architect: Architectural Style: Gothic Revival Naritive: In 1883, lumberman Douglas Greeley built a modest house on this lot. This one-and-a-half-story, Gothic Revival home is a late example of Gothic Revival that was popular in the United States from around 1840 until approximately 1880. The frame dwelling has a stone foundation that has been covered with a concrete parge coat, clapboard siding with corner boards, and a prominent front gable roof with a tall brick chimney on the ridgeline. The tall, narrow one-over one double-hung windows with City of Stillwater HPC -- HHLS Website -- Property Information 20f2 decorative drip molds and the steeply-pitched roof are characteristics of the Gothic Revival style. Based on historical maps, the one-story, gable-roofed rear addition, the shed extension on the north elevation, and the one-story, hipped-roof bay on the northwest portion of the house were all constructed prior to 1910. The full-width front porch, with its battered wood piers set on concrete block piers was added circa 1940 and reflects a Craftsman style influence. According to the 1892 city directory, George P. Green, a machinist, was the primary resident of the house after Greeley. Green later became an engineer with the Stillwater Fire Department and resided in this house through 1905. In 1956, Arthur L. Skramstad resided in the house. LaureJ St ~rtl --,E-'- Wl,:'! ~~ ' ~d~I~~Dxl 0 . .. .. ~F \ LrMen St w 0 . O:Crr st I c=J IUlldi . In[~Obirj~t}Di[ ~.J,~ ;n, R~~[J'. \Dr~D~_"D!D~' ~.:fi zD~ ~ ~ =f[ WTrs, S!, L~j W MU, StJ Dr ~ ~ ~.mSp'.Et ~ [J~~Ra~- Sl ~ '-----.J~~-.J L.....JG) == ,Qiwe S1'N WOWe St ~ ;;lOW'1 ] I [U~[J D~, 0 D.~ . ~ 5:,' Oak :S.t"IN ! ~:~rr~~n D~[JOO ~ n :;;I__~_~_ ~. Map~a~O~le~tlas_ - T "s oflUse City of Stillwater HPC -- HHLS Website -- Property Information lof2 . Home . Properties . About the Program . Rehabilitation . Search Property Infonnation Printer- friendly Version Nicholas and Agnes Backe House 106 Group 10/1/2007 Parcel Identification Number (PIN): 2803020210041 Site Address: 412 Ehn St W Construction Date: 1894 Builder: Architect: Architectural Style: Queen Anne N aritive: This Queen Anne style house was built in 1894 for Nicholas H. and Agnes Backe, who lived here until 1931. Mr. Backe held a nUlnber of jobs over the years. In the late nineteenth century he worked as a clerk at the Stillwater Hardware Company, then as a clerk at a local store through the 1910s, and finally as a stove repairman throughout the 1920s and 1930s. In 1942, salesman Sherman A. Backe and his wife Olga resided in the house. City of Stillwater HPC -- HHLS Website -- Property Information 20f2 The land on which the house sits is part of the Staples and May's Addition, which was surveyed in 1871 and officially recorded in 1873. This plat has a noteworthy layout with lots on the south half of the block oriented along east-west streets and lots on the north half of the block aligned along the north-south st reets. The fact that this house was built more than twenty years after this area was platted, shows how slowly this area developed. This house itself is characterized by its stone foundation, clapboard si ding, and a cross-gable roof. The defining Queen Anne features of the house include a front porch that is adorned with turned spindles in the balustrade and frieze, decorative brackets, a steeply pitched roof, and scalloped shaped shingles in the g abies. Later additions include the one-story addition on the east and the two-story addition behind the original structure. tD S l. I!I ) W [ ~ .l~-~-J:I 1~1 I st eror. ~o, ~ AVB W !, .~tCrlJiX, ,lJ,va W ~,.O D [ ~LJ31 ] C=:JS2 .(,>Still'tlstel n' !_",_ {,OJ 8tmwal,,8f/>'vev," 20aO [ ~ . -I II. ~ i 'Z. 'N V'l,I'lIFdnS, Sb "^,.ij~4n~ St V"" 0 0 C, D D r-l<91- -0 [J I ~ L.. ~ , . _ . .~.. ' "'7 ~,~'-,' Imr~.g,MnSDIW ?~ ~: ~ r&U~ J ra) Em-.. SJJfJ, ~Dl\D::::D0D.;I&_. a."s.1 ~J ~ ~,~ ~ ~\ _ ~ '. UJ z ,-t:. ~c~Dd/D~O;.J~. \ )^rMa~~eS,-t , MstJle5tW ~O', ." ,', 0", ==:=Jz~ I 0 r - ~!fl.. ... 1110\ st r\ _' :r Laure] st W rr1 .-z.. 'NJflO'i.\.,...--I fl~':1n ~~,I~ 0" ..iN" S~'~I ~,\i'~----" (Q l n. _S('lp 1_ \ .t)i'l~~! , ~ \ '...... n M1p dat;~@2ee8 Tele Atla~r lS U e I L I~L __ City of Stillwater HPC -- HHLS Website -- Property Information lof2 . Home . Properties . About the Program . Rehabilitation . Search Prope11y Infonnation Printer- friendly Version Vernacular House 106 Group 10/1/2007 Parcel Identification Number (PIN): 2803020240081 Site Address: 451 Everett St N Construction Date: 1910 Builder: Architect: Architectural Style: Vernacular N aritive: This one-and-a-half-story vernacular dwelling is located in Sabbin's Addi tion to Stillwater. The rectangular-shaped frame house sits on a foundation faced in lattice and is clad in vinyl siding with corner boards. This modern siding is consistent with the lap of the original siding. The most prominent feature of the house is its steeply-pitched hipped roof with large, hipped roof dormers on the front and side elevations. The front dormer has an open-air balcony with turned columns and square City of Stillwater HPC -- HHLS Website -- Property Information 20f2 balusters. A full-width front porch is located below and is covered by a shed roof with a pedimented gable over the steps. The porch is supported by wood posts. The house features one-over-one double- hung sash windows with wood surrounds. A modern, large two-story addition with a hip roof extends from the rear elevation. Little is known about the history of this house. It is located in an area that was slow to develop, quite possibly due to its proximity to the nearby creek. Consequently, this property does not appear on historic maps and it is not listed in city directories, which are similar to modern day phone books. ~~ rElmst"N'~DfiD' ZD~D~I [ &,'[ 1 ] ~ . ::: g: ~ ~' 2:----..- _ ((.I, z -$ ~ U 0 Dnryoiu~ \ . W M~~le St ',_ M~~e fit V~\\_"", ,0", . U, " . ~~\I 0 r I~W alL~e\st .-- jU, ~_" laurel St...,.J .."-",',,,', , ,'1-' O\fJ_ "l.-".,.~ ","{j}J,',','I.,..-'""..,.' ," '~.' m, ~~ ~.r'O- ~ ~~, st"~ W\ "\ 0 O~::J ~O~ ~ ~I .~\fr ~ St 'IlV Vl/ Il.irpje,n St --Unden .'6'" ~ DoOQOD c=J,. '% , ~ .. ~, ?~. MUrl),e, fry' St, '1/1/ ,~r, M,' uICerr~~' St.. , ~DiII D(!oO D ODe ~"" :~ i~ : ,-~ 1/11 :: ~ ~ j~. , i~",', I,.'g?,, .~, :i,.-'. ~._',' i.','.,',' ,.:;,t",,'..,_.,. ~, i'Z. 12 ~D~ ~ =r ~. \ ~ IRII:;e S' "I! en 00 ~ .(J) d Z[l 0 [l~ni[l;Dz~~ Ie St Stillwater W Myt11e Sl ~ ~ I 1- .. - "I ~ab 6~ @20b8~~!AL tlas ~\T' rms~o~~ ~ _ _ llv.. I I I J II e I j City of Stillwater HPC -- HHLS Website -- Property Information lof2 . Home . Properties . About the Program . Rehabilitation . Search Property Infonnation Printer- friendly Version House Stillwater HPC 7/31/2008 Stillwater HPC 7/31/2008 Parcel Identification Number (PIN): 2803020210060 Site Address: 213 Elm St W City of Stillwater HPC -- HHLS Website -- Property Information 20f2 Construction Date: 1895 Builder: Architect: Architectural Style: Queen Anne N aritive: According to historical maps this ornate, Queen Anne style house was built circa 1895. The one-and-a-half-story, frame structure, with its limestone foundation and clapboard siding is covered by a cross-gable roof. A large hipped roof dormer on the front elevation covers a second story balcony that is adorned with turned spindles and pendants. The steeply pitched, irregular shaped roof; the two-story, octagonal tower; patterned shingles; and spindlework are characteristics of the Queen Anne style. The tower, with its bell-shaped roof, is located at the center of the ell-shaped plan. The tower features fish-scale shingles between the first and second stories and sunburst patterned details on the second story. The house features one-over-one double-hung windows, one-light fixed windows, and a shed roof front porch with turned columns and spindles. The limestone basement is partially exposed on the rear elevation due to the steep slope of the lot. The early residents of the house are unknown. The first known resident was Elmer W. Larson, who was living in the house by 1956 and remained through the 1960s. In 1970, Gilbert D. Holst was residing in this handsome house. I I ~.~c== ] L-J L.J L-J L-J) ----.J;;: z .St Croci-x Ave. I: IB~W ~ 31 Croix Ave W ~D 0 D 0 . ~at,,!::J, iD'~[JstillvD...::a.:teli A" ',I,":] I II ~ i ~l ""iX' Wllldll:!l :ilt \M~M St,\r.J", ,0 0 _ Oi: ~~D D~D_ r~=lJ - --l ~,~,',J ,,'~"D'S I.l.",..~",.I.~""Ii(... nAS Ji :8't E. ~'lmD~ ~~ r II L~, :LJ,~, , ; :/~~:9J, ~', ~I ~~1 :~.m St w "+D~ nl 0- - ~..I& Q. 0.1 ~~ ~ ~l ~ ~ ~l '------ -J ,:Z ____ WI Z ~\ ~~~~D OCrOiUL :l...Mi!F;l~Ei s, t, Mri~ Stw"10',',', "',, ,0,' , ' _ =:=J 0 \S \J.(eI st 0 ~u!eJ st W "7.-. W l.-8.D\il .. ~[,-'",'_. Q~sO.'i.,',~\O,t..,.,',' @ - . ....... .. ... -I --11. indo>.. ,::t ilMap-~ata-'Rf~2&Td.re\A~aS\T~"",,-~..~ City of Stillwater HPC -- HHLS Website -- Property Information lof2 . Home . Properties . About the Program . Rehabilitation . Search Property Infonnation Printer- friendly Version McKusicl<-Converse House Stillwater HPC 7/31/2008 Stillwater HPC 7/31/2008 Parcel Identification Number (PIN): 2103020430003 Site Address: 106 Wilkins St W Construction Date: 1885 City of Stillwater HPC -- HHLS Website -- Property Information 20f2 Builder: Architect: Architectural Style: Queen Anne Naritive: This handsome, Stick style house was built in 1885 by Chester McKusick, a local real estate speculator. The grand home cost $1,800 to build. The two-and-a-half-story, frame residence has a cut limestone foundation, clapboard siding, and a hipped roof with prominent cross gables. Its steeply-pitched roof of irregular shape, dominant front facing gable, patterned shingles, trusswork in the gable peaks, and the character defining stickwork that wraps around the house above the second story windows are characteristics of the Queen Anne style that was popular in the United States from the late nineteenth to early twentieth centuries. The house features one-over-one double-hung and one-light casement windows that replaced the original windows. In 1905, the house was purchased by Theodore R. and Minnie Converse. According to the 1908-1909 city directory, Converse was the treasurer of the Bronson-Folsom Company. Soon after purchasing the house Mr. Converse had Stillwater contractor, Frank Linner build a $1,100 addition on the house. The two-story, side-gabled addition was built on the east elevation. Later Converse paid $1,200 to construct a small, one-story, gabled addition on the rear of the house and to replace the front porch. The hipped-roof wraparound porch has square Tuscan piers and an elaborate cornice with dentils that are Free Classic details, a common variation of Queen Anne architecture, which was a closely related relative to the Stick style. Mr. Converse lived in this house into the 1930s. ~~~5 ~ Moore St w ~u~~ -, I~t J I!I I D tJ1 l ;;:;1 ~zl -I ~, .Sit Cror;( Ave E ~. StCmix Ave W ~Q~. D D % ~L~ l !m.,.~ ., Still'IIi3':ell' .Ave E. I ~. Stillwa1sr Ave Vj 6CI!!.1J D~D i [ l C J % (;) ~. :0 D~DWO 0 0 OiL: - ~ ~ AS~11 st ViI ....s\I'8n St E @ ~'~D~D~D Ilf ~~~!I ~D~q/Q:g~u~ ~~ II t D J:~lJ~:,~~p_d ala i920Q8" T e~ A!J;fs - T er~s 0 · City of Stillwater HPC -- HHLS Website -- Property Information lof2 . Home . Properties . About the Program . Rehabilitation . Search Property Infonnation Printer- friendly Version McBeath, S. Blair, House Stillwater HPC 6/1/2008 Stillwater HPC 6/1/2008 Parcel Identification Number (PIN): 3303020110034 Site Address: 203 Willard St E City of Stillwater HPC -- HHLS Website -- Property Information 20f2 Construction Date: 1911 Builder: Linner., Frank Architect: Architectural Style: American Four-Square N aritive: This elegant, two-story American Foursquare was built in 1911 by Frank Linner & Co. for S. Blair McBeath. The estimated cost of construction was $4,000. The existing house replaced an earlier house that was built circa 1874 by Michael O'Brien. The present residence, with its stuccoed concrete foundation, is a typical Foursquare with one-over-one double-hung windows, clapboard siding, and a pyramidal hipped-roof with flared eaves. Hipped roof dormers are located on the north and west elevations, and a brick chimney is located on the west elevation. Prairie School influences of the day are reflected in the banding between the first and second floors and the wide eaves, while a Colonial Revival influences are embodied in the geometric leaded-glass windows. A two-story, sleeping porch with six-over-one double-hung windows was added to the rear elevation around 1920. According to the Washington County Assessor's Office, the existing frame garage was built in 1984. Mr. McBeath was an attorney and manager of the collection department for the Northwest Thresher Company with an office at 211 East Chestnut Street. According to the 1919 city directory, the Honorable S. Blair McBeath died on July 2, 1918, at the age of 58. His widow, Catherine, continued to live in the house for many years. w~~" \}~U" 'c.sQSN ,.,)~ . "!. .4 ..tJ II 0; ~ ~. . o~n" .~~,',.. ";~~.,, ,~~.,' ~G~ ?\~~$tJ ~, (f.I, ,S\J,\N, ,%,dJ_-L, a "'0",, ~.. .~',_, ~, ~tuL~ '-"~ . c.~', Z! ~ ~ , . \N ~ (\, ' , \ '~,.I' ~\~IJ.'t, f\~. tD" ....".._",_j., (f} lU 0 \-/ U(;) JD~D [j Jr(O~ ~ Jt CtTI,~rcD"htll Stc~1j jOh;'O-r1lill' $'OE ! :~ ,g.,'~' ~,'". CL , ;i_ . ~ 'oou~ 00 ,(.I} "':t ,00 ...... I ..... ,1ft' ql ()) St Vv HsncocR5t IE" , 0 D lnoon~ ~DD ~ Map d-arraB]~~iB~~g'J:"~'e Atljls~~r'" "Lon s$t~tJ.. . ' , . J I I l -I L J . ... '\ City of Stillwater HPC -- HHLS Website -- Property Information lof2 . Home . Properties . About the Program . Rehabilitation . Search Prope11y Infonnation Printer- friendly Version Butts-Cool< House Stillwater HPC 7/31/2008 Parcel Identification Number (PIN): 2803020320132 Site Address: 106 Sherburne St S Construction Date: 1881 Builder: Architect: Architectural Style: Gothic Revival N aritive: In 1881, Edmund G. Butts constructed a modest Gothic Revival style house on this property. Butts was an attorney and real estate investor. He also built the house at 122 North Sherburne Street. According to the 1892 city directory, Henry Cook, a laborer, was the primary resident. Cook resided in the house for approximately 20 years. This house started out as a simple, City of Stillwater HPC -- HHLS Website -- Property Information 20f2 one-and-a-half-story Gothic Revival style residence. Gothic Revival was a popular style in the United States from around 1840 until approximately 1880. The frame dwelling has a limestone foundation, clapboard siding, and a cross-gable roof. The character defining Gothic Revival features of this house are its ell-shaped plan and steeply pitched cross-gable roof that are found on approximately a third of the Gothic Revival houses in the United States. The Classical Revival door surround with fluted pilasters and entablature reflects earlier and later Greek Revival and Colonial Revival influences. Over time, the original windows were replaced with one-over-one, three-over-one double-hung windows and fixed, six-light windows. At some point in time, a shed roof extension was added to the rear of the side gable wing and the front porch was enclosed. ~~~-V",gl~-i U U UUU~[ :=r Linclen Sf W V'/l\..ind:en :st DOQODC :r 1,0!,'D!DMUlD;D~,Wo: '""1, r+ ~ = ~ ! 5 2: :2: ,ji" m : .,~ f;'i' RICle Sl 'II' .~D~ : ..JUL' 7'n 0 D'..... ~D" ,~ @-._zDZ__~~ ~~ OMY[j rWj WTj$tJ l'l"m5~ Sl \1\ . Ra.ros~':;It W ~... W Il'ltlmWl I c=..l~~CJ CI, ~~1Nes; ~D D[ ~ITDtD olD!1 I ~Doak: S,t~~_~)lJ~DI Oaf:: sot W ~D D~D.-.nD rJ I\.I~L--1;;';1 {JJ , ;m ,Vl,i ~ji"l8' 8t Pine 8.: VI! D.g~~ IDQ~I _,-~ ____ -,~ Map dat;r@20~~lm!~~1 ~ r .. ~J City of Stillwater HPC -- HHLS Website -- Property Information lof2 . Home . Properties . About the Program . Rehabilitation . Search Property Infonnation Printer- friendly Version Lofgren, Lars, House Stillwater HPC 7/29/2008 Parcel Identification Number (PIN): 2803020320038 Site Address: 225 Sherburne St N Construction Date: 1896 Builder: Lofgren, Lars Architect: Architectural Style: Vernacular N aritive: This small, vernacular house, located in Greeley's Addition, was built in 1882 by Lars G. Lofgren. According to the 1892 city directory, Lars G. Lofgren was employed as a carpenter and lived in the house with Andrew Johnson and John Ekstrom, both laborers. The Lofgren family owned this house for over seventy years. Harry W. Lofgren was the primary resident in 1956. The one-and-a-half-story, frame building has a concrete block foundation that replaced the original stone foundation, vinyl siding that does a good job of mimicking the lap pattern of the original clapboard siding, and a prominent, front gable roof. The house features City of Stillwater HPC -- HHLS Website -- Property Information 20f2 one-over-one double-hung windows and a full-width, hipped-roof front porch that is supported by square wood posts. A one-story addition, located on the rear elevation respects the design, scale, and materials of the original building. It features one-light casement windows and a wood deck on the east elevation. '- 1 I ] L.--.J L....J L ::.____Jz.(N Map4t OMre 5t v ~'" L,~l', - ~~ iUUj~l Ji~eadOWJa~ 0; ~C ~ Linden St W \flJ 'Lind'en St r[Loo~ Ul g,.~~,- Do. ~D~l,ePDr) 8l wOl, ['lJ ~- , ,,~0 [, LI~ Jlf .=E 'r11l"I ==,,' tr-- ~. r+ '~ ~ i ~ 4~ ..J ~ <> z ~ 1>> D~ '::f J ujW~nRiDwD~D~D~[ ] L~f Crre.',1l,1J1tW?,_j -W,rJ,.le,',tJ, [ C5~ sr 1 ~msp'.J.!t \~ U<I ViI R~m~ L ---.JWI~ L-.J....... ~ 'Ol~re 51;'11/ W - ViJ Owe St 'ji; ~p (ii' ,....., l nn lWIM~p ~ata :~m ~}~~~~rms Of Il~~ City of Stillwater HPC -- HHLS Website -- Property Information lof2 . Home . Properties . About the Program . Rehabilitation . Search Property Infonnation Printer- friendly Version Ruehle, Gustav A., House Stillwater HPC 7/31/2008 Stillwater HPC 7/31/2008 Parcel Identification Number (PIN): 2103020430047 Site Address: 214 Stillwater Ave E Construction Date: 1897 City of Stillwater HPC -- HHLS Website -- Property Information 20f2 Builder: Architect: Architectural Style: Queen Anne Naritive: This modest, Queen Anne style house was constructed in Carli and Schulenbergs Addition in 1897 for Gustav A. Ruehle. Mr. Ruehle worked as a laborer and warehouseman for the Chicago, St. Paul, Milwaukee & Omaha Railway. By 1930, John E. and Delam L. Roy are the primary residents of this house. Roy was employed as a machinist. The one-and-a-half-story, frame house has a limestone foundation, clapboard siding, and front gable roof that is punctuated by a tall brick chimney. The house features a one-and-a-half-story, side-gabled addition on the west elevation, one-over-one double-hung windows, and one-light fixed windows with leaded glass transoms. A one-story, hipped-roof addition located on the north elevation of the main addition was constructed prior to 1924, according to historical maps. The patterned shingles in the gables, the ornate hipped-roof porch with its turned columns and spindlework, and the leaded glass transoms windows are characteristics of the Queen Anne style that was popular in the United States in the late nineteenth to early twentieth centuries. The current owners purchased the property in 1964 and added the one-story screen porch to the east elevation in 1976. g::[ ~ z 1 1 I~t I~~ I 1- ~ I ~r \ riJ I I ~ l I l I I L2 .;)':1 9 :: Moore St V'.' r+ I ] ~I) R~~~' J-;I ] ~ Ci~X Ava W ~D crLi r I ] I I~ ~ .still'lfa.:er Ave E ~ jal Ave W J ZD~D D~D Ij' Wl.1kdm.L St VJ/ 0 D~' I ~~~ 0 Zl J JD~D~ ~~~ .1 -11 '7~e'tQ7 f1-1 i Ma1p\ d~ta\@?008 T ele 419S - ~ Qf USf\ ..:;.:, MINNESO A 'J Memo Community Development Department To: From: Heritage Preservation Commission Michel Pogge, City Planner ~ Thursday, July 31, 2008 Date: Re: Demolition ordinance Message: Attached is a revised proposal that takes into account the Commission's recommendations from your June meeting. The revisions leave the 50 year review requirement in the ordinance and sets up guidance on when staff should require HPC review of non-principal building demolition requests. lfthe Commission would chose to precede with these changes it would require public hearing and action by both the HPC and City Council. Action Requested Review and discuss. From the desk of... Michel Pogge, AICP 'City Planner' City of Stillwater' 216 N. 4th Street' Stillwater, MN 55082 651.430-8822 ,Fax: 651,430-8810 'email: mpogge@ci,stillwater.mn.us BUILDING DEMOLITION Chapter 34 Sec. 34-1. Purpose of chapter. This chapter is adopted for the purpose of protecting the historic and aesthetic qualities of the city by preserving, rehabilitating or restoring, when reasonable, buildings or structures which constitute or reflect distinctive features of the architectural or historical resources of the city, thereby promoting the public welfare and preserving the cultural heritage of the city. (Ord. No. 814, 12-5-95) Sec. 34-2. Definitions. The following words, terms and phrases, when used in this chapter, shall have the meanings ascribed to them in this subdivision, except where the context clearly indicates a different meaning: Commission means the E'fJreseruatio n('eo m missio n. Historically significant building or structure means any building or structure or portion of a building or structure on the National Historic Register, a designated local landmark or a contributing structure or building in a designated national register historic district. Nonhistoric structure or building means a structure or building less than 50 years old or a noncontributing structure in a nationally or locally designated historic district. (Ord, No. 814, 12-5- 95) Cross reference-Definitions generally, S 21-2, Sec. 34-3. Permit required. No building or structure may be demolished without obtaining a demolition permit, An application for a demolition permit must be filed with the city building official. (Ord. No. 814, 12-5-95) Sec. 34-4. Procedure. The building official must forward a copy of each demolition permit application to the community development director for determination of historic significance or potential significance. The community development director must make the following determination: Subd. 1. The building or structure is historically significant or potentially historically significant; or Subd. 2. The building or structure is not historically or potentially historic. If buildings or structures are determined by the community development director to be historic or potentially historic, the application must be sent to the commission for review according to section 34-5. Buildings or structures determined nonhistoric must be referred to the building official for issuance of a demolition permit. (Ord. No. 814, 12-5-95) Sec. 34-5. Demolition plan review. Demolition plan review shall be conducted as follows: Subd. 1. Not less than 30 days after the community development director determines that a building or structure is historically significant, the applicant for the permit must submit to the commission 15 copies of a demolition plan which must include the following information: 1) A map showing the location of the building or structure to be demolished on its property and with reference to neighborhood properties; 2) A legal description of property and owner of record; 3) Photographs of all building elevations; 4) A description of the building or structure or portion of building or structure to be demolished; 5) The reason for the proposed demolition and data supporting the reason, including, where applicable, data sufficient to establish any economic justification for demolition; 6) Proposed plans and schedule for reuse of the property on which the building or structure to be demolished is located; 7) Relation of demolition and future site use to the comprehensive plan and zoning requirements; 8) A description of alternatives to the demolition; and 9) Evidence that the building or structure has been advertised for sale for restoration or reuse and that sale for restoration or reuse is not economically feasible. Subd. 2, The commission must hold a public hearing according to chapter 31, of this Code on the pending application, (Ord, No. 814, 12-5- 95) Sec. 34-6. Emergency demolition. If a historically significant or other significant building or structure poses an immediate threat to health or safety due to its deteriorated condition, the owner of the building or structure may request issuance of an emergency demolition permit. If both the community development director and building official find that the condition of the building or structure poses a serious and imminent threat to public health and safety and that there is no reasonable alternative to the immediate demolition, the community development director and building official may issue an emergency demolition permit. (Ord. No. 814, 12-5-95) Sec. 34-7. Injunction. In addition to any other relief provided by this chapter, the city attorney may apply to a court of competent jurisdiction for an injunction to prohibit the continuation of any violation of this chapter. This application for relief may include seeking a temporary restraining order, temporary injunction and permanent injunction. (Ord. No. 814, 12-5-95) Sec. 34-8. Violation of chapter. Any person violating any provision of this chapter shall be guilty of a misdemeanor, and a separate offense shall be deemed committed on each day during on which a violation occurs or continues. (Ord. No. 814, 12-5-95) MI'~~,l-_~\O A ~, ~ Speed Memo Community Development Department To: City Council, Parking Commission, Heritage Preservation Commission, Planning Commission, Trinity Lutheran Church, Lowell Inn RE: Date: Update on Municipal Parking Ramp July 31, 2008 Message: Yesterday City staff met with the parking ramp design consultants, LSA Design, to discuss the status of the parking ramp project. Key points of the meeting are: · Construction drawings are 50% to 75% complete. · Civil engineering plans have identified ways to provide on-site utility improvements and site grading more cost effectively. · Bridge design has been revised to create a squared off approach from the 3rd Street surface lot to the ramp deck. Though this will result in parking on only one side of the bridge, it will be considerably less expensive than the previous angled approach, · To accommodate the Lowell Inn's future banquet facility, the pillar support system in the southwest comer of the ramp has been redesigned. This allows the banquet facility to have an open area by cantilevering support. However, by moving the pillar out of the banquet area three parking spaces will be lost (one on each level of the ramp). · Even with the bridge and pillar changes, the total number of spaces will be over 300. The exact number is still being determined as the construction plans are finalized. The maximum number of spaces that could be created by this project has changed back and forth with various versions of the structure, but 313 was believed to be the maximum, · It appears that hand laid masonry will be able to be used on all four sides ofthe building at an affordable cost. · The target date for sending the project out for bids is September 9, 2008. Bids would then be due on October 14, 2008. Under this schedule, the City Council could consider awarding the contract on October 21, 2008. · Probable start date would be November 1, 2008, A 10 month construction period would bring completion of the project in August of 2009, From the desk of... Bill Turnblad, Community Development Director, City of Stillwater bturn blad(@ci.stillwater,llU1,_Q;>, 651.430-8821