The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink About2008-06-02 HPC Packet Heritage Preservation Commission Notice of Meeting Monday, June 2/ 2008 The regular meeting will begin at 7 p.m./ Monday, June 2/ 2008/ in the Council Chambers of Stillwater City Hall, 216 North Fourth Street. AGENDA 1. CALL TO ORDER 2. APPROVAL OF May 5/ 2008 MINUTES 3. PUBLIC HEARINGS 3.01 Case No. DEM/08-23. A demolition request of a residence located at 817 1st Street South in the RB, Two Family Residential District. J.G. Hause Construction, applicant. 3.02 Case No. DEM/08-24. A demolition request of a shed/out building located at 219 N Martha Street in the RB, Two Family Residential District. Andrew and Amber Barnick, applicant. 3.03 Case No. DEM/08-28. A demolition request of a garage located at 1017 West Pine Street in the RB, Two Family Residential District. Andrew and Erin Braun. 3.03 Case No. DEM/08-29. A demolition request of a one car garage located at 116 South Sixth Street in the RB, Two-Family Residential District. Diane and James Kleinke, applicant. 4. NEW BUSINESS 5. DESIGN REVIEWS 5.01 Case No. DR/08-25. Design review for the installation of a 25 square foot sign located at located at 126 South Main Street in the CBD, Central Business District. Yaniv Abotbul, applicant. 5.02 Case No. DR/08-26. Design review for new signage located at 1840 Market Drive in the BP-C, Business Park Commercial District. Nordquist Signs, applicant. 5.03 Case No. DR/08-27. Design review to change the store front facade located at 223 South Main Street in the CBD, Central Business District. Peter Sampair, Bridgeview Stillwater, LLC, applicant. 5.04 Case No. DR/08-30. Design review to change the store front fa<.;ade with window, signage and lighting located at 208 South Main Street in the CDB, Central Business District. Smart Side Realty, LLC, applicant. 6. OTHER BUSINESS 6.01 Discussion on Demolition Ordinance 6.02 Update on Stillwater vs. Bush Leimke 7. ADJOURN City of Stillwater Heritage Preservation Commission May 5, 2008 Present: Phil Eastwood, Gayle Hudak, Jeff Johnson, Larry Nelson and Roger Tomten Staff present: Mike Pogge Absent: Howard Lieberman and Scott Zahren Vice Chair Johnson called the meeting to order at 7 p.m. Approval of minutes: Mr. Tomten, seconded by Mr. Eastwood, moved approval of the minutes of April 7, 2008. Motion passed unanimously. DESIGN REVIEWS Case No. DR/08-18 Design review for replacement of signage at 1750 Frontage Road in the BP-C, Business Park Commercial District. Duane Downey, applicant. The applicant was present. Mr. Johnson noted the pylon sign is higher than allowed by ordinance, but because this request does not represent a change in usage, the height is grand- fathered under the previously granted variance. The size of the signage does meet the ordinance requirements, he stated. Mr. Tomten moved to approve the replacement signage as submitted and conditioned. Ms. Hudak seconded the motion; motion passed unanimously. Case No. DR/08-19 Design review for fac;ade of the proposed storefront renovation and reopening of the second floor window openings at 124 S. Main St. in the CBD, Central Business District. Mark Balay, representing Lynskey Properties, applicant. Mr. Balay was present and explained one change to the submitted plans -- the addition of a location for another second floor stairway to facilitate development of the second floor with a second egress. Mr. Nelson wondered if a handicap-accessible elevator might be needed at some point. Mr. Balay said that would be possible should usage require that at some point in the future. Mr. Balay said the plans are to keep the existing colors so the fac;ade looks like three separate buildings. He expressed a concern about the wording of one of the conditions of approval, that the windows shall be "historically accurate double-hung wood windows," with plans submitted to staff for review and approval. Mr. Balay noted this is not a tax-credit project and said they did not want to commit to Department of Interior standards for restorations. He said the intent is to fill the original window openings with double-hung, custom-sized windows, but would like the option of using vinyl or aluminum clad windows. Mr. Pogge said staff is supportive of the request and would not be opposed to striking the word "wood," if that is a sticking point with the applicant. Mr. Tomten asked about the new lower panels on the front fac;ade. Mr. Balay said the existing brick veneer will be removed and new wood panels attached to the concrete block behind the veneer. Mr. Tomten asked if any thought had been given to utilizing a wider frame for the entry doors, expressing a concern that the thin line Qf the frame brings to mind 1950s-60s architecture and a wider style might be more appropriate. Mr., Tomten used the new door of the Gazette as City of Stillwater Heritage Preservation Commission May 5, 2008 an example of the style he would prefer to see used. Mr. Balay said the applicant would consider that if the cost is similar. Mr. Johnson suggested the possibility of bringing the display windows out to the front of the building in the center section. Mr. Balay said that is a cost issue. Mr. Johnson asked if there would be any work on the parapet, noting there is a piece missing. Mr. Balay stated that is not being considered at this time. Mr. Tomten moved approval as conditioned striking the words "wood" and "historically" from condition of approval No. 3 and adding a condition that the applicant consider using a door profile with a wider style head and rail than the standard aluminum frame. Mr. Johnson suggested adding wording regarding review by staff and that the windows fit the original openings. Mr. Tomten restated his motion to include approval is given to reopen the second- floor windows with the condition that the new windows are a full window infill of the original masonry openings, with final details to be reviewed and approved by staff. Mr. Johnson seconded the motion; motion passed unanimously. Case No. DR/08-20 Design review for installation of a neon channel letter and non-illuminated plastic lettering on a sign at 2510 Curve Crest Blvd. in the BP-O, Business Park Office District. Mary Ferraro, Spectrum Signs, applicant. The applicant was not present. Mr. Eastwood noted the request meets the ordinance requirements and moved approval as submitted and conditioned. Mr. Tomten seconded the motion; motion passed unanimously. Case No. DR/08-21 Design review for installation of two signs, change of windows to doors, and ventilation on the roof of the building at 423 S. Main St. in the CBD, Central Business District. Tim McKee, applicant. The applicant was present and stated that he will reduce the size of the proposed projecting blade sign to meet the ordinance. Mr. Johnson asked about the location of the signage on the south elevation. Mr. McKee stated it would be placed below the Brick Alley sign. Regarding the proposed new roof vent, it was noted there are a number of existing vents on the east side of the building and the vent will not be visible from Main Street. Mr. McKee said they would also like to replace two windows with doors; the existing headers will be utilized, he said. Mr. Eastwood moved approval as conditioned, with the additional condition that the sign on the south elevation be placed under the Brick Alley sign and that the blade sign be no larger than 6 square feet, as allowed by ordinance. Ms. Hudak seconded the motion; motion passed unanimously. Mr. McKee asked about temporary banners; it was noted that such banners can be up for 30 days. Case No. DR/08-22 Design review of signage, new awnings and lighting at 108 N. Main St. in the CBD, Central Business District. AdCraft, The Signmakers, applicant. A representative of AdCraft and Jeff and Kristin Klemetsrud, owners of Savories, were present. 2 City of Stillwater Heritage Preservation Commission May 5,2008 Mr. Johnson opened the discussion by saying he liked the proposed sign but had concerns regarding the proposal to add columns and paint the brick on the infill building. The representative of AdCraft said the introduction of columns was an attempt to unify the fac;ade, carrying over the column elements from the larger building. Kristen Klemetsrud said they had looked at other options of tying the two buildings together, stating they need a cohesive storefront to maintain the integrity of their business. Ms. Klemetsrud also noted that these are not contributing buildings to the Historic District. Mr. Nelson spoke in favor of the plans, saying it makes sense to try to tie the two buildings together and create a cohesive storefront. Mr. Johnson said the proposed awnings would work better if they are at the same elevation and pitch as the Pulp Fashion awnings. Even though the awnings are different colors, keeping the same elevation and pitch will keep the larger building more homogeneous, Mr. Johnson suggested. There was discussion of the request to paint the brick on the infill building. Mr. Eastwood spoke against painting brick. Mr. Johnson noted that painting brick causes moisture to gather behind the brick and eventually causes deterioration and permanent damage to the brick. The AdCraft representative asked if there are options other than painting. Mr. Tomten suggested that perhaps tinting the mortar might achieve the desired look. Ms. Klemetsrud spoke of other nearby buildings where the brick has been painted, and Mr. Klemetsrud noted the brick on the infill building is not historic, quality brick. Mr. Johnson again spoke of the potential deterioration of the fac;ade due to painting, as well as a concern for setting a precedent in approving the request; he stated he would be comfortable allowing the staining of the mortar. Mr. Johnson read Mr. Zahren's written comments into the record. Mr. Zahren stated he would approve the signage and awnings, but would not approve the painting of the brick due to the likelihood of moisture damage or the addition of the columns, which he said create a disconnect with the remainder of the building. Mr. Nelson said he had no problem with the columns. Mr. Eastwood suggested muting the color of the columns around the entrance as a way of framing in the entrance. Mr. Tomten said he likes the awnings and even the columns, but agreed that the awning pitch/height should match the Pulp Fashion awnings. Mr. Tomten also suggested moving the signage up a bit higher on the building, as well as moving in the three new goose- neck light fixtures so all of the fixtures are on the infill building. Mr. Tomten asked about plans for the infill windows at the southern-most portion of the business front. Ms. Klemetsrud stated the plan is to install a wood panel, with perhaps a wrought iron metal grate and window box. Mr. Johnson moved approval as conditioned, with the additional conditions that the awnings be of the same height and pitch as the Pulp Fashion awnings and that the valence be a free hanging valence of the same material; that the three goose-neck light fixtures be moved closer together so all are placed on the infill building and the sign raised slightly to reach the bottom of the light fixtures; that the three southern and two northern columns be of a darker shade than the two columns on either side of the entrance; that the applicant be allowed to stain the mortar but not paint the brick on the infill building; and that the access windows on the southern portion of the building can be filled in with a solid material with a wrought iron or steel grill overlay. Mr. Johnson amended his motion to include the condition that colors and awning material swatch be submitted to staff for review and approval. Mr. Eastwood seconded the motion; motion passed unanimously. 3 ! City of Stillwater Heritage Preservation Commission May 5, 2008 OTHER BUSINESS · Tom Huninghake was present to get the Commission's input regarding possible demolition of a house at 1224 N. Second St. Mr. Pogge stated the house is in very poor condition and the City has issued an abatement order, with the next step a possible request for demolition. Mr. Pogge also stated that Mr. Empson has gone through the structure and suggested it should be demolished. Mr. Huninghake said he might make a bid on the house but would not want to get stuck with it, if it can't be demolished. Mr. Johnson noted that the Commission couldn't give an indication of possible action without going through the nine steps required by the ordinance. · Mr. Pogge told the Commission that the annual Preservation Awards will be presented at the second Council meeting in May. · Members were asked to get their photo assignments completed and to Mr. Pogge at their convenience. Ms. Hudak, seconded by Mr. Eastwood, moved to adjourn at 8:50 p.m. Respectfully submitted, Sharon Baker Recording Secretary 4 illwater -- --~ -~ ,...~. , H f e I "fO, ' LAC, (J' M L N >J f S 0 i A ') Heritage Preservation Commission DATE: May 30, 2008 CASE NO.: 08-23 APPLICANT: Francis Brown REQUEST: Demolition Permit for a House LOCATION: 8171st St S HPC PUBLIC HEARING DATE: June 2, 2008 PREPARED BY: Michel Pogge, City Planner JM~ BACKGROUND Francis Brown, property owner of 81715t St S, made application for a demolition permit for an existing house that was damaged by fire in February. After review of the application and in light of two separate structure engineering reports, staff elected to issue an emergency demolition order pursuant to Section 34-6 of the Stillwater City Code. Since the notices on the request were mailed prior to staff's decision to issue the emergency demolition order the Commission needs to open and close the public hearing. No action is needed to be taken by the Commission on this matter. RECOMMENDATION Open and close the public hearing. . ( . ' Heritage Preservation Commission DATE: May 30, 2008 CASE NO.: 08-24 APPLICANT: Andrew and Amber Barnick REQUEST: Demolition Permit for a shed LOCATION: 219 Martha St N HPC PUBLIC HEARING DATE: June 2,2008 PREPARED BY: Michel Pogge, City Planner ;1ATP BACKGROUND Andrew and Amber Barnick, property owners of 219 Martha St N, are requesting a demolition permit for an existing shed on their property. The exact age of the shed could not be determined and a building permit for the structure was not on file at the City office; however, the property owner believes that the shed was built in the late 1800' s. The style and condition of the structure leads staff to conclude that the shed is more than 50 years old. Since the shed appears to be over 50 years old, it is by definition considered to have potential historic significance. Consequently, the Heritage Preservation Commission is required to review the demolition request. This site is in the Conservation Design District; however, since the main structure is not being removed any new structure would not be subject to the infill design criteria. SPECIFIC REQUEST The applicant requests approval of a permit to demolish the existing shed. EVALUATION OF REQUEST Chapter 34, Section 34-4 of the City Code states that" if buildings or structures are determined by the community development director to be historic or potentially historic, the application must be sent to the [heritage preservation] commission for review... Buildings or structures determined nonhistoric must be referred to the building official for issuance of a demolition permit." A "nonhistoric structure or building" is defined by Chapter 34, Section 34-2 as a structure or building less than 50 years old... Since the age of the structure could not be determined it is assumed that the shed is over 50 years old; therefore, it is of potential historic significance and requires review by the Heritage Preservation Commission. 219 Martha St N Barnick Shed Demolition Permit Page 2 ; t . . Section 34-5 of the City Code lists nine items which must be considered prior to approval of a demolition permit by the Commission. (1) A map showing the location of the building or structure to be demolished on its property and with reference to neighborhood properties; This information is included in the attached application. (2) A legal description of property and owner of record; The legal description of the property was included in the application. (3) Photographs of all building elevations; Photos from various angles are included in the packet. (4) A description of the building or structure or portion of building or structure to be demolished; The existing shed is an approximately 30' by 10' shed. The applicant has indicated in the cover letter that the entire shed structure is proposed to be demolished. (5) The reason for the proposed demolition and data supporting the reason, including, where applicable, data sufficient to establish any economic justification for demolition; The applicant has included a quote from J-Mar builders and remodelers. A new building is estimated to cost $21,174.00 while repairing the existing shed would cost $17,964.00. (6) Proposed plans and schedule for reuse of the property on which the building or structure to be demolished is located; The applicant stated in his application that they desire to remove the shed for additional open space on the property. (7) Relation of demolition and future site use to the comprehensive plan and zoning requirements; The current comprehensive plan land use designation for the property is Single Family Small Lot and is zoned RB, two-family residential. Once the current shed is demolished any new shed in the future would be required to meet all of the requirements of the zoning code. This site is in the Conservation Design District; however, since the main structure is not being removed a new shed would not be subject to the infill design criteria. 219 Martha St N Barnick Shed Demolition Permit Page 3 (8) A description of alternatives to the demolition; The applicant feels the structure is a hazard. The applicant feels that the cost of renovations far exceeds any added value thus the applicant has no intent on renovating the shed. (9) Evidence that the building or structure has been advertised for sale for restoration or reuse and that sale for restoration or reuse is not economically feasible. The applicant has indicated that they have advertised the shed in the Stillwater Courier on May 8, 2008. ALTERNATIVES The Heritage Preservation Commission has the following options: 1. Approve the demolition permit as presented. 2. Deny the demolition permit if the applicant has not proved the necessity for demolishing the shed or if the Commission believes there are altema tes to demolishing the shed. 3. Continue the public hearing until the July 7, 2008 Commission meeting. The 60 day decision deadline for the request is July 15, 2008. RECOMMENDATION Review and take action on the request. attachment: Application and supporting documents from the applicant Heritage Preservation Commission Demolition Request Permit Demolition Permit No. Fee $100* Address of Project: d,\q IY\c,,(y..,'1(' ~}qE€"'( IV i Sf, )11w~\ Parcel No.: li g' 0"30 J. O'=) j 00 ~ I Lot \ 0 Block ~ Subdivision \\\tHvt \~s.~ .v(;~ '{ leEr- o. v- Q ~vl(J 'vv(,0::. d vll1 Applicant: f\Y\d \(6 vJ GlY\A. ~\fv\ ~.f-f ~r (\1 C ,t Address: d\4 Mn~T-"'a ~\- \0 ct>-\.l\lVa}tK ~tJ Telephone No.: S07~:S I?ci. - 60Q J-.-. Owner if different than Applicant: Address: Telephone No. Type of Structure: S\-,ed / Ou.~ \S\A1 \ c\; ",,-OJ Age of Structure: 1910 Condition of Structure: \C-:a '. -rho 'S".n^-ck~ , \:-, "",,,,. v.JG G .\. '0 *. ~~J CA ",c\, <'leA, \." I ~r~ ( 0 (AS I <ij h 2- o.re! So · Intended Use of Site after Demolition: ~V-l \& -C.::- 'f'.C ~ ("'\~ per C\-y r€~jt,fM~ f\+-S t.....V\6 '\J,SS \Q,^~ ~" ~~{~'" C\v\,~ ~().-\:o.. l1,~~ ~~b- Signature of Applicant ~b JSt~~JL Signature of Owner 5~S-02 Date 5 - f5 -JOOg' Date *After review and approval of the demolition permit request with the Heritage Preservation Commission, a building permit must be obtained with the City of Stillwater Building Department. The fee for the building permit is based on the valuation of the demolition project. Office Use Only HPC Review Date: o Approved o Denied Date City Planner/Community Development Director 05/16/2008 City of Stillwater Heritage Preservation Commission 216 Forth Street North Stillwater, MN 55082 Dear members of the Heritage Preservation Commission: This application is asking for a demolition permit for a shed/outbuilding at the rear of my property located 219 Martha Street North, Stillwater MN 55082: Thompson Parker and Mower's 2nd, Lot 10, Block 2. The main dwelling/residence at 219 Martha Street North was built in 1870. The shed/outbuilding was constructed at the same time or shortly after the main dwelling in the late 1800's. The shed has had some updates throughout the years which include concrete flooring, (which is now cracking) a tin roof (which is rusting over in the back with holes), and also the shed was recently painted last year. The shed currently imposes hazards such as exposed nails and rod spikes, loose and rotting lumber, and loose ceiling supports. The structure was constructed originally of two by fours with a flat roof and a limestone base. The shed now has concrete flooring and a tin roof. It also has an updated door. The shed's windows are loose to the walls. The shed is located on my rear property line next to my double garage and bordering the neighbor's garage. The shed measures 30 feet by 10 feet. I have no evidence of any historical significance of the structure. I was told by the sellers of the property that the shed was built around the time of the main dwelling. A. Map: A map showing the location of the structure to be demolished is attached to this application packet. B. Legal Description: Lot 10, Block 2, Thompson Parker and Mower's 2nd Addition to Stillwater, Washington County, Minnesota Note: The warranty deed is attached to this application showing Andrew and Amber Barnick as current owners of the property at 219 Martha Street North, Stillwater MN 55129. We have Homesteaded the property as our primary residence as joint tenants. No. ll-M. WARRANTY DEED or limited liabilitY Company to Joint Tenants DEED r AX DUE: $666.60 Date: April 25, 2008 FOR VALUABLE CONSIDERATION, Hill Properties, Inc., f/k/a Hill Property, Inc., a Corporation under the laws of Minnesota, Grantor, hereby conveys and warrants to Andrew Barnick and Amber Barnick, Grantees, as joint tenants, real property in Washington County, Minnesota, described as follows Lot 10, Block 2, Thompson Parker and Mower's Second Addition To Stillwater, Washington County, Minnesota together with all hereditaments and appurtenances belonging thereto, subject to the following exceptions: easements/covenants and restrictions of record. Check box if applicable: 00 The Seller certifies that the seller does not know of any wells on the described real property. o A well disclosure certificate accompanies this document. o I am familiar with th~ property described in this instrument and I certify that the status and number of wells on the described real property have not changed since the last previousiy filed well disclosure certificate. Hill Properties, Inc., f/k/a Hill Property,lnc. ~ ~~ By:~ Newell Hill Its: "resident Affix Deed Tax Stamp Here By: Its: STATE OF MINNESOTA } 55. COUNTY OF RAMSEY This instrument was acknowledged before me on April 25, 2008, by Newell Hill, the President of Hill Properties, Inc., f/k/a Hill Property, Inc., a CorpOiation under the laws of Minnesota, on behalf of the Corporation. NOTJARlA..l S: AMP OR SEAL (OR OTHER TITLE OR RANK): - ~:r.\ilc~~=~AN} " My Comlllllt/on "1 .Ian 31, 2010 I -~ J Check here if part of all of the land is Registered (Torrens) 0 )' THIS INSTRUMENTINAS DRAFTED BY (NAME AND ADDRESS): J Edina Realty Title 6800 France Ave. South . Edina, MN 55435 I Tax StatementL,for the real property described in this instrument should be sent to (inc;.de name and address of Grantee): Andrew Barnick 219 Martha Street N Stillwater, Minnesota 55082 MINNESOTA. REVENUE Certificate of Real Estate Value PE20 Auditor use only Names of buyers (last, first. MI) Address Daytime phone Barnick, Andrew and Amber Names of sellers (last. first, MI) 10386 Grand Oaks Tr., Woodbury, MN 55129 New address Daytime phone Hill Properties, Inc., 3456 Minnehaha Ave., Mpls., MN 55406 Street address or rural route of property purchased 219 Martha St. N. City or township Stillwater County Washington 1. Date of deed or contract 4-25~08 Financial arrangements 2. Total.pufchaseprice 202,000.00 3. Down payment Was personal property included in purchase price (e.g., furniture, inventory, equipment)? DYes []:No If yes, list property and current (not replacement) value at right, and enter total in Box 5 below. Use back of form if needed. 5. Current value of personal property I $ $ $ $ $ o 4. Points or prepaid Interest paid by seller 5,963.75 6. Type of acquisition (check all that apply) D Buyer and seller are relatives or related businesses D Buyer or seller is religious or charitable organization D Buyer or seller is unit. of government D Buyer purchased partial interest only D Contract paid off or resold D Name added or removed from deed . D Property condemned or foreclosed upon D Property received as gift or inheritance D Property received in trade D Purchase agreement signed over two ) 7. Type of property transferred (check all that apply) D Land only Dl Land and buildings D Construction of new building after Jan. 1 of year of sale 8. Planned use of property (check one) !JtResidential: single family D Residential: duplex, triplex D Cabin or recreational (noncommercial) D Agricultural. Number of acres:_ (attach Schedule PE20A). D Apartment (residential, four or more units). Number of units: (attach Schedule f D Commercial-industrial. Type of business: (attach Schedule PE2 D Other. Describe: (attach Schedule r- 8a. Will this property be the buyer's principal residence? . . Kl Yes D No Method of financing (Complete only if seller-financed, including contracts-for-deed and assumed mortgages) Assumed Contract Mortgage or contract-for-deed Monthly payment Interest rate. mortgage for deed amount at purchase (prinCipal & interest) now in effect Number of payments Date of any lump sum (balloon) payme 9. D 0 .10. D 0 Counties: Complete this section. ~ o ;n- ,: " '!: o o ... o 8 '" ci z 13 o 1;) Co Dc YrSn SD Yr Land Bldg Tot DT Primary property ID number Acres Tillable CER CRP RIM Use Deed Yr Land Bldg Tot Secondary parcellD number Good for stUdy 0 Yes DNo If no, give reason/code b. c. X HC ST Adjc Adjs Use Tillable EMV Apt , FM d. Are there more parcels? DYes 0 No GA C 1 MV 2 MV ID Put additional/D numbers on back of form, Co CT PT Date T M S MINNESOTA nI=PAJ:n"UC"'T nc CC:\J&::""IG: ,.."r->H R77 L1~~ c. Photographs of structure: Attached to this application packet are photographs of the shed/outbuilding. The photographs show the structure from all sides and the interior. Note, the interior photographs show the decrepit and hazardess condition of the shed., loose and rotting lumber, and nails and spikes exposed. Note, the rear photos show the sheds rough and rusted roof condition. ,,/ , / ~.- / / i / / /'... / / I / -- /" I I / ! /~ f ! / D. Description of structure: The structure I wish to remove/demolish from my property is a shed/outbuilding that lies at the rear of my property line. It is 30 feet by 10 feet. I was told from the seller of the home that the shed was built at the time of the main dwelling or shortly after, in the late 1800's. The shed is built from lumber two by fours. Its original wood has grown soft over the years and is loose and rotting in places. The shed originally appears to have had a limestone base. It now has a concrete floor that is cracking. The shed appears to have originally had lumber roofing that was flat. The shed now has a rusted over tin roofing angled. Some of the old roofing lumber is loose and poses safety risks. . The windows and the treatments are loose and very aged. They also appear to pose safety hazards. The shed was recently painted within the last year. It does have an updated entry door in front that has a loose lock joint. The door is not secure for locking. E. Reason for demolition and supporting Data: Bid from Licensed Restoration Contractor. Attached bid shows that it is not economically feasible to restore shed. 81JIWERS & UMODElUS, He 8lendlng 8111ldlng with Sclence P.O. Box 386 . Somerset, WI 54025 . www.j-marbuilders.com Wisconsin Office: (715) 549.5580 · Fax: (7151549.5581 Minnesota Office: (6511 275-3872 · Fax: (651) 275..4081 May 15,2008 Andy Barnick 219 Martha St. N. Stillwater, MN 55082 RE: Utility Shed Proposal We are pleased to present the following preliminary pricing for the removal and reconstruction of your utility shed. Final numbers can be determined after structural and interior details have been finalized. New Building: Demolition of existing building Ex.cavate old slab and prep for new concrete. Form and pour new concrete slab with thickened edge. Furnish and install labor and materials to build new structure with siding and roofing to match existing house as closely as possible. Includes minimal electrical work. Includes cleanup and removal of demolition materials. Includes management time. Includes building permit. No interior finishes are included in this proposal. Total Preliminary Estimate to Construct New Shed- $21,174.00 Repair Existing Shed: Repair existing framing to make structurally sound. No concrete or excavation work. New roofing and siding. Total Preliminary Estimate to Repair Existing Shed - $17,964.00 Thank you for the opportunity to provide preliminary numbers for your project. Please call me if you have any questions or concerns. Jim arty J-Mar Builder & Remodelers, LLC F. Reuse of property/outdoor living space: If the Heritage Preservation Commission grants the demolition permit for the shed/outhouse at the rear of my property at 219 Martha Street North, Stillwater MN 55082 I plan on fencing off the area with a six foot privacy fence(attached to this application is a fence permit application) and creating a patio garden. This will substantially improve the value of property and provide a lush safe backyard where my wife and I can feel our son is safe from the hazards created by the shed. The shed currently takes up the majority of our properties backyard living space and by creating more space and a garden/patio we will significantly improve the properties value and safety. The shed/outbuilding on my property is posing a significant financial determent to my property and a hazard to my family and the public. The shed/outbuildings does not contribute to the historic character of the community. Pending the approval of the shed's demolition, the approval of a building permit, and the approval of a fence permit we plan to fence off the outdoor space formerly occupied by the shed up to my backyard property lines creating space for a small garden and use the concrete slab lying under the shed as a patio surface. Weare not building any new structures other than the fence, per the permit. These plans will not impact the surrounding neighbor's privacy, access to sunlight, or street access. Permit No. Date: Fee: $25.00 Receipt No.: FENCE PERMIT APPLICATION CITY OF STILLWATER Community Development Department 216 North Fourth Street Stillwater, MN 55082 Ordinance No. 792, Section 31.01, Subd. 25(m), Fence Regulations Address of Property: d\G\ \f\O\t \'w1 S~-\- \-06 C~\;\ j s;;~ I / /W t.heR. MiJ5rrf?~ I Legal Description of Property (Lot, Block and Addition): Property Owner: A,^J.n5I~ hl.""""c- \::- Mailing Address: .-Ajq (\ilV.,Hh <;'''kft-Hv ~t.ll\i..''''~.. . Telephone No.: /)(J7- sg,J - fa q J- Signature aJ;71!r~A.l1,v~ Type of Fence ~OOdl Privacy Representative: A-v'\J vt5 v..) ell. {\l' i Ct::. Mailing Address: Telephooe No.: I :51- 77 $' - d [? dJ Signature tubr~,-" .fzv~{,~ Chain Link Other Height ofFence (at ground grade): _ft. front yard .(; ft. rear yard _ft. side yard Include a surveyor accurate site plan showing fence in relation to ~property lines. "I hereby state the forgoing statements and all data, information and evidence submitted herewith in all respects, to the best of my knowledge and belief, are true and correct. I further certify the permit if it is gran~:d \an.dused. ';-., . " C ~~11tl~ ~u~z 5-,5 - (j X Property Owner/Representative Signature Date OFFICE USE ONLY Conditions of Permit Approval: Community Development Director/City Planner Date of Approval A building permit is not required for the installation of fences. However, you must call Gopher State One Call at 651-454-0002 before you dig to identify any underground utility locations. G. Relation of demolition and future site use to the comprehensive plan and zoning requirements: The property on 219 Martha Street North will continue to be used as a single family home. The demolition of the shed/outhouse will not impact the main dwellings use, and there will be no structure built to replace the existing shed/outbuilding-only privacy fencing per pending city fencing permit. H. Alternatives for demolition: I have no intent on renovating the shed/outbuilding on my property. I feel the cost of renovations far exceed any value the renovated shed could bring to the property. I currently do not feel comfortable using the shed for storage of anything but garbage containers and spare lumber. The locks on the shed are not secure enough to store anything of value such as tools or household goods. I have advertised the shed for sale in the Stillwater Courier and have received no responses. The shed is cemented to the ground and would not be applicable for transfer to another site. I would be open to let anyone attempt to transfer the shed off my property as long as my main dwelling would be unharmed. The shed imposes hazards to my family. I feel renovations could limit those hazards but I cannot financially afford those renovations at this time. 1. Evidence of advertisement for sale: The shed/outbuilding was advertised for sale in the Stillwater Courier the week of May 8th, 2008, both on the internet and print paper. Attached to this application packet is a copy of the sales advertisement. .IJ ~" We are lacated 30 minutes fram dawntown SL Paul neighborhood. Rolling hills covered with 15ft - 30ft cedar pines and mature silver maple trees. Road access from front ' and rear of property, Great recreational opportunities abaund with 51. Croix River, Troy Burne Golf Course, Kinnickinnic River, State Parks & more only minutes away. River Falls School Dis- ' trict. Perked for conventional system. Reduced to sell -. $139,900. For more informa- tion call Jeff at (715\381-5975. , 523 Westridge Circle River Falls. WI 54022 danm@westridzefarms.com ~ (3) PUREBRED FJORD HORSES. Make and offer. , 651-351-9356. Stop aut and visit .or call to make an appaintment 715-426-9640 PLEASE NOTE: If you chaose to find a new home for your pet with a "Fre'e to Good Home" ad, please screen patential new .owners carefully to ensure placement in a safe home. "':1 ShWa.CVf(Le.1 S(II\J-.iCAltt:, (O\,\.f i"'(' . VJ E tEe o~ fY")A.y ~~'" ~C MISC. STERLING SILVER souvenir spoons. USA & worldwide, 715-386-3584, afternoons. LAKE MALLALlEU HOME . FOR SALE: Hudson,WI. Older home, large beautiful lot, 200+ feet of shoreiine, great fish' 'and aters lake. ' , . rimjay@hotma 715-386-5498. ~ SHED: UTILITY. 30X15, Con- structed of heavy lumber posted to ground. Best Of- , fer. 651-773-2821, 900 Services '" A QUEEN PILLOWTOP Mattress Set, $98. New in Plastic. 651-487-9595. BEDS: NEW Queen Set, $149. Full, $129. 3-Piece King, $249. Delivery Avail. 651-487-9595. ENTERTAINMENT CENTER, Oak. Excellent Condition I GREAT HO EEPING " Reasonable Rates, Reliable, , References! Call Karen, , 715-529-4329. ' House and Office Cleaning: ' " Affordable prices, excellent re-' suits. Sylvia: 715-254-9116. HOUSE CLEANING, 19yrs Residential'., Cleaning Experience, References Available: 715-684-2726 BLUEBIRD HOUSES: Peterson Style Houses, pine, $15/each. 715-792-5277 after 5pm or leave message. MAYTAG PERFORMA WAsher/Dryer, 3yrs old, Been stored for 2yrs. $500/BO 651-388-2649 after 5pm, USED HOT TUBS, Same Sundance, Starting at $2000, 952_435-4096,507-289-0313. HARDWOOD" FLOORS: Installation and Refinishing, FREE Estimates. Experi, enced, Randy: 715-425-7565. J. I did not retain the service of the recommended historians due to the cost and condition of the shed on my property. BUILDING PERMIT APPLICATION CITY OF STILLWATER, 216 NORTH 4TH STREET, STILLWATER, MN 55082 5' ~c;- 0 <.. ',_ I t~ 550~d- <r IV State Phone Use of building Applicants Name Address ~ \0 City ~ -\-. \\ \, (VlN Phone (q) 7 -- ~,/- r- State State License Number City License Number Separate permits are required for electrical, plumbing, heating, ventilating and air conditioning. This permit becomes null and void if work or construction authorized is not commenced within 180 days, or if construction or work is suspended or abandoned for a period of 180 days at anytime after work is commenced. I hereby certify that I have read and examined this application and now the same to be true and correct. All provisions of laws and ordinances governing this type of work will be complied with whether specified herein or not. The granting of a permit does not presume to give authority to violate or cancel the provisions of any other state or local law regulati~g 7ion ucti n t performance of cons,tr~n., ,__' a~A / Lj~{; , I,) - 5' -o~ IC NT'S SIGNATURE DATE 'R SIGNATURE DATE Move Repair <J ~ "6 ""t><t ~.L 4~\1c;t~ Oe~ y"V'\ 0 \ I ~.'iC/' Brief ~::~:~~iO~ ~'kC \.~'(N\ Valuation of work: NEW CONSTRUCTION ONLY COMPLETE BELOW Parcell.D. No. Lot No. Block Tract Type of Const. Occupancy Group/Division Max. Occupancy load No. of stories SQUARE FOOTAGE CALCULATIONS: 1 st floor: 2nd floor: Basement: Finished: Unfinished: Garage: Additional stories: Fire Sprinkler Required YES NO Plan Review Yes No Number of SAC units SOC Area Yes No Vicinity Map o Scale in Feet ~:~=gj$there~ulto1a ~~~::~~~~~=:;~~:n ~:S~~~,~i;.~~n=~c;:'r~~~~s C(anYlllilccurac" nty,snot =:Washingt.onCc ~ {6.51)430-6875 untySurveyal'''OIf~ ~~I~~~ basad O{l AS400 IMp Prillled~~~;~~. 2c:crmalion 40 t . . G.. ,Sii I Jwa te~ ==-=- ~ ..~... - 0-, , rf~'F BIRTHP;ACF (JF- MiN~-l[SOjA. J Heritage Preservation Commission DATE: May 30, 2008 CASE NO.: 08-28 APPLICANT: Erin and Andy Braun REQUEST: Demolition Permit for a garage LOCATION: 1017 Pine St W HPC PUBLIC HEARING DATE: June 2, 2008 PREPARED BY: Michel Pogge, City Planner 11ft BACKGROUND Erin and Andy Braun, property owners of 116 6th St S, are requesting a demolition permit for an existing garage on their property. The exact age of the garage could not be determined and a building permit for the structure was not on file at the City office; however, the property owner believes that the garage is approximately 60 years old. The style and condition of the structure leads staff to conclude that the garage is more than 50 years old. Since the garage appears to be over 50 years old, it is by definition considered to have potential historic significance. Consequently, the Heritage Preservation Commission is required to review the demolition request. This site is in the Conservation Design District; however, since the main structure is not being removed the new addition would not be subject to the infill design criteria. SPECIFIC REQUEST The applicant requests approval of a permit to demolish the existing garage. EVALUATION OF REQUEST Chapter 34, Section 34-4 of the City Code states that "if buildings or structures are determined by the community development director to be historic or potentially historic, the application must be sent to the [heritage preservation] commission for review... Buildings or structures determined nonhistoric must be referred to the building official for issuance of a demolition permit." A "nonhistoric structure or building" is defined by Chapter 34, Section 34-2 as a structure or building less than 50 years old... Since the age of the structure could not be determined it is assumed that the garage is over 50 years old; therefore, it is of potential historic significance and requires review by the Heritage Preservation Commission. . . f 1017 Pine 8t W Braun Garage Demolition Permit Page 2 Section 34-5 of the City Code lists nine items which must be considered prior to approval of a demolition permit by the Commission. (1) A map showing the location of the building or structure to be demolished on its property and with reference to neighborhood properties; This information is included in the attached application. (2) A legal description of property and owner of record; The legal description of the property was included in the application. (3) Photographs of all building elevations; Photos from various angles are included in the packet. (4) A description of the building or structure or portion of building or structure to be demolished; The existing garage is an approximately 14' by 22' garage. The applicant has indicated in the cover letter that the entire garage structure is proposed to be demolished. (5) The reason for the proposed demolition and data supporting the reason, including, where applicable, data sufficient to establish any economic justification for demolition; The applicant has included a quote from Rydel Homes Inc. for a new addition to the east and a new garage to the west. No quote was provided related to cost to renovate the garage. (6) Proposed plans and schedule for reuse of the property on which the building or structure to be demolished is located; The applicant stated in his application that they desire to construct a new attached 28' by 24' garage with living space above the garage. (7) Relation of demolition and future site use to the comprehensive plan and zoning requirements; The current comprehensive plan land use designation for the property is Single Family Small Lot and is zoned RB, two-family residential. Once the current garage is demolished the proposed garage would be required to meet all of the requirements of the zoning code as proposed. This site is in the Conservation Design District; however, since the main structure is not being removed the new addition would not be subject to the infill design criteria. 4 . 1017 Pine St W Braun Garage Demolition Permit Page 3 (8) A d~scription of alternatives to the demolition; The applicant states that if they are not allowed to demo the garage that they would leave the site as is an move. (9) Evidence that the building or structure has been advertised for sale for restoration or reuse and that sale for restoration or reuse is not economically feasible. The applicant has indicated that they have advertised the garage in the Stillwater Gazette on May 20, 22, and 23, 2008. ALTERNATIVES The Heritage Preservation Commission has the following options: 1. Approve thei demolition permit as presented. 2. Deny the demolition permit if the applicant has not proved the necessity for demolishing! the garage or if the Commission believes there are alternates to demolishing the garage. 3. Continue the public hearing until the July 7, 2008 Commission meeting. The 60 day decision deadline for the request is July 15, 2008. RECOMMENDATION Review and take action on the request. attachment: Application and supporting documents from the applicant . . Heritage Preservation COmmission Demolition Request Permit Demolition pennit No. fee $100* '26, 030 . Zo. ~3. bOg..; , w P' '2.t).()3o.2l>.3'3.005S' Address of Project: 011 . \ '" ~_ St. Parcel ~.: ~~. SAM'" 21 T~e-t ~ lL>+ "t . ~\' D~ L>t '" (,i......l...\\...t I)t'-\-h \0 \o!'(:'\ t'I( L.*t), \\ i", P.>lp~ ~. bt'-~U~\.a....~~-u:s i\o:\.~u~.., \0 'S\~\h.vu..\~ lot Block . SU Msion . Applicant: {tl,AJr ~ iN .a- t:,. :"'" 15 (' tJ-u V"\ , Address: 1 D 1''1 W. Pi 1ft e St. Telephone No.: tJ.r>S/) "t...1{''' IfllLI St.' 11 Wet4-et I IVtN SS D ~r2.. . Owner if different than Applicant S4i'"14? Cf.5 A-lf/1' CecfA.+ Address: , Telephone No. Type of Structure: (; c(". c.... J-€- Age of Structure: too '1".4 Condition of Structure: 7c-o~ Intended Use of Site after Demolition: 2. CA..-" jak:\.j~ Cth ~~ 5-15 'oB 5. Je:; ,O~ ~ ~ AppUrart . Date j~~~ <;./$ . d9 6-F>-O'6 Date Signature Owner * After review and approval of the demolition permit request with the Herbge Preservation Commission, a building permit must be obtained wlth the oty of StIllwater Building Department The fee for the building rmit is based on the valuation of the demolition Office Use Only HPC Review Date: o Approved o Denied aty Planner/Community Development Director Date -~----- 1017 W. Pine Street Stillwater, MN Owner: Andrew and Erin Braun (651) 275-4051 The structure is located directly west of the house. The structure was built in 1948, the same year the house was built. The legal description is: The south 27 feet of Lot 4, all of Lot 6 and the North 10 feet of Lot 8, all in Block 5, Gray and slaughter's Addition to Stillwater. Owner of Record: Andrew R. Braun and Erin C. Braun Please see attached photos of structure. Single car detached garage is the structure to be demolished. An attached two car garage is the structure to be built. Please see attached sketch similar to proposed plans of structure to be built. An attempt to sell the existing structure will be made prior to demolition. ~gJec-t(VLI1/ I ~ I_J 9~i-. 6' ~_~..) ~ .~ ~/VN01.J !./v " {/Z~1/";'-_/ F,t~~ 85/-15/2989 88: 13 6517399899 RVlE.. PAGE 01/81 f rn I ~ tP~.,., - 'F :> \ 24- I I 1 1'1\. I ~ 'f ~ eN ~ ... I ..c 1 0- ... It- I "".,.,.. - ., (:) . ~ J 4~4 tr. '"'6 -" i A ~ I , ~.. ~ f z ~ ,~ 'Z w ) , ~ "7 0 fit <. tG,... ~ . .... tr ~ 4-~~ - V 4""" ~ " 1 :=:. I "- tJj t It !~i1 \. E r~ 11 M-E . ~ \.(> I if.! ,('- t )t' ~-}, 1 j 1:) C f' 0.- . ~ .. ,..) " 3 ~..J 0 - ! -v.' I S" t L- . It 1. :ea O~Nu' - . .e.r -- 17 r- ., .. k .~. , J ... _ ,I .. '" f._ ~ '1rJ".J' J.... ~. ~. _ ' "'- J'.- ".::11, &__ ..... . L -It.~.. . .- _.... _ II:' ..,' ......::~~ ~ - -~. ~g.{' - .. ~ .,.....- , - ... .'..- -..-...:- . . ~ l" lo.ol ~ ~ ~ ~ .....-() o J\ G a... ~ .,.. ": ) J I... " - ..I - I...L.., l "\...., . "" ~ I I ~ I . ,.-.~~- 1 ., .J' fv J '- u ---- "/ 1 // If1 ,,(l :5 /,' '3 ~ o , ~ I i \ "i ....------ 1Il -0 ~ r ii" C) ~ -; a; -0 ~ ~ q Z fi:.11~ :fft1frt,t.S, Inc..' ~1?tm.~A'\fen.,eJ1;ll,st .,t. f'l/Mt, M1f nrtf I I I I I I I I I I I "U Zl ~I fgl ~I ~i 87'-0" ~-I '" Ol ~ 16-6" 31'-0" ~ ~ q \'i ~ Z Gl :r o c (J> m I ~10'-O" I t I OJ i f_ " I ~ L _ _ _ _ _ _ _ - - - - _1- - - --, OWENS STREET Phone: 651-402-1410 fSlC 651~'J3O..&&4'f 30'-0" 28'-0" 0 '" I~ 0 9 -< Andrew and Erin Braun 1011 Pine Street ~5t Stillwater, MN 55082 IDA.... 5-:>>-2tJ08 I I D....... BY, {J.na. I FAGE 10fb IBATs. 5-:>>->WI! I IDBA-a", ''''08. I J{14~et :ff~s, !nc.. m"1ot~""""J'/""I,It"e""ueJ!.Nt ........: 651-102-141. :$t. 1'#l.ul, 1ot1( ffltf """ 651-__ Andrew and Erin Braun 1011 Pine Street Y'{est Stillwater, MN 55052 PA6E 6of6 U\ Cw fil -09 ib -O~ ~m O!~ Ii r ~m ~ < m r -0 ~ 7i 5'-0" 26'-0" 3'-9" 16'-7" 112'-10" L I' 1 1 I I I I I I I I I I J g I I ~ II 1 .....N I ~~ I ~~ i-J I ~ w I ~ J:; 4'-5' 5 JL g .... ~ Ii ~ ATTIC ATTIC 6'-0" 11'-6" 28'-0" 10'-6" I DAm, .....-- I I DBA_ BY' _ 8. I ~~~~~~t PhMw. 651~1410 ~t. "If,ut, )t1l ffltf - 651-............ Andrew and Erin Braun 1011 Pine Street Y'lest Stillwater, MN 550e2 PAGE 5of6 t",,~~~!~ p~, 65'~-l~'O St. r_t, 'M1l nrtf ""'" 65'-1!lU&'I'I (j\ 3: ~ ~ ~ Z ::Or ~m Ii < ~m ~ r -0 s: Z 25'-6" 4 -6" 16 0" 4'- r 7' 0"1 1 m X Ci5 ::! z G) I o C en m ..... ~ -i~~ ..... 0> ~ q ~ I\) t,; I\) Oi w o ~ -oJ 0> Ci ~ ~. 01 Oi && w ~ w .W2 ~ r 1 G) )> ~ G) m .....1\) ......0. 0; ,- ,<;1 ~ 1\)..... .0...... gOi ~ ,--------. I I I (j) ti (j) <1 16'-0"~12'-0" 28'-0" Andrew and Erin Braun 1011 Pine Street Y'lest Stillwater, MN 55082 I DATS, 5->>-:>J<J8 I IDBA_BY' """8. I PAGE 4of6 (j\ ~ l;i G\ (j\ r (i" :J: (\ m ~ ~ III -n ~ (i" -I Ii m ~ ~ r ~ m q m i r ~ m ~ ~ -I (5 (5 z z IDA- >-2I'J.:1W8 I I.........u, _s. I ~~~~:!.:'tt Phone, 651~~14'O :St. r_t, "." nrtf f... 651-........... Andrew and Erin Braun 1011 Pine Street Y'lest Stillwater, MN SSOe2 PAGE !Jof6 (fI ~ 1iI m ii" )> (fI ." ~ ~ O! 1iI ~ m ii" C) Ii r ~ Z Ci m O! -; ~ Ii ~ m :j Ci r m C) ~ z -; <S z IDATB>"~ I IDJtA"'''''' """8. I 1<~(eJ, :tff1ft1,eS, 1~J.C.. fl ?:u~r~l<.1:Nt Phone: 651-402-''''0 t'8lC 651.13O-8&'1CI Andrew and Erin Braun 1011 Pine Street Y'lest Stillwater, MN 55082 PAGE 2of6 t. -. 5.20.08 Addendum to Demolition Permit Application for Erin and Andy Braun 1017 Pine St. W. Stillwater, MN 55082 651-275-4021 F. With the addition of the new attached garage will enhance the existing property only. Existing property will remain as a single family dwelling. H. Description of alternatives to the demolition: If existing garage is not to be tom down or moved off property, owners will leave as is. Single family home will then be put on the market for sale. \-~~- . , a (1) "0 Vi ...... .c Ol C2 ...... c: o ... u.. May 18, 2008 Contractor # 20197734 Rydel Homes Inc. 2138 Minnehaha Ave. E. Sl Paul, MN 55119 651-402-1470 Fax: 651-730-8899 Andrew & Erin Braun 1017 Pine Street W. Stillwater, MN. 55082 Cell: 612-290-5778 Home: 651-275-4021 Work: 651-905-7007 Proposed Work: 16' x 18' Addition (East) As per plans with following exceptions & allowances. Siding based on vinyl products (Northwood's Rough Split Shake). Soffit based on metal products. All windows based on (Hayfield vinyl doublesash, Low E, Argon). Shingles based on 30 year laminates (Green to match existing). Pier footing. Final landscaping responsibility of customer. Primary demo. Responsibility of customer -Detail demo. Responsibility of contractor. Fireplace allowance $1600.00 (including unit, piping &options- selections to be thru contractor accounts). Final millwork related to fireplace design to be determined. Carpet allowance $25.00 per yard (carpet & pad), (26 yd. multiplier). Trim to match existing. Exterior door based on Master Craft full view. 1 24' x 28' Garage Addition & 6' X 15'-4" Mudroom with 2nd floor Master suite & laundry within bonus trusses. As per plans with following exceptions & allowances. Siding based on vinyl products (Northwood's Rough Split Shake). Soffit based on metal products. All windows based on (Hayfield vinyl doublesash, low E, Argon). Shingles based on 30 year laminates (Green to match existing). Full Block footings with crawl space below Mudroom. Final landscaping responsibility of customer. Primary demo. Responsibility of customer (including effected trees) -Detail demo. Responsibility of contractor. Carpet allowance $25.00 per yard (carpet & pad), (56 yd. multiplier). Trim to match existing. Exterior doors based on Master Craft full view. Garage door based on 16' x 7' white "ideal" with Iytes on top panel. Ceramic tile allowance $4.00 per ft. (M. Bath floor, shower walls & pan), (Mudroom & _ bath floor). Shower seat, curbing, comer shelves, threshold & countertops with integral sinks & whirlpool top, splash based on solid surfacing (Corian). _ Whirlpool tub based on 6' fiberglass drop in. Faucet allowance $450.00. Shower door-out swing chromelframed. Full mirrors above vanities. Finish light fixtures supplied by customer. Interior doors based on panel paint grade. HVAC-Ductless heat-pump (heat & A.C.) Electric heated floors beneath ceramic tiled floors. Concrete driveway to Owens St. 2 Existing House 26' x 30' - Siding based on vinyl products (Northwood's Rough Split Shake). - Soffit based on metal products. Existing windows to be exterior clad with metal. Total bid $ 120,000 Accepted by Contractor: Accepted by Customer: Accepted by Customer: * Contract price valid if approved within 30 days. 3 lmcast Webmail - hmaiI Message ~ ". http://mailcenter3.comcasLnetlwmclv/wm/4832EFD400058B2COOOl From: Cindy Lehmann <clehmann@acnpapers.com> To: erinbraun@comcast.net Subject: Order Confirmation Date: Tue May 20 10:18:00 2008 Erin, This ad will be published on May 20th, May 22th, May 23rd for a total of $22.49 which has been paid in full. I will send an em ail of the receipt as proof of payment. Cindy Lehmann 651-796-1103 (Attachments successfully scanned for viruses.) Attachment 1: (application/pelf) fl 5/20/08 10:49 A , . ' STILLWATER GAZETTE Payment Receipt ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ OS/20/08 10:15 ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ Account number: Account name: Phone number: Payment number: Payment date: Payment description: Credit Card Number: Credit Holder Name: Approval Code: Amount: Ad Number: 309317 ERIN BRAUN 651-275-4021 568438 OS/20/08 CREDIT CARD PAYMENT ************9919 ERIN BRAUN 848850Y 22.49 ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ 838168 <.5til~~~ .........--- ~. ') ............ . . :rnE BrRTHPlACt. OF MiNN[SOrA. . Heritage Preservation Commission DATE: May 29,2008 CASE NO.: 08-29 APPLICANT: J ames and Diane Kleinke REQUEST: Demolition Permit for a garage LOCATION: 116 6th St S HPC PUBLIC HEARING DATE: June 2, 2008 PREPARED BY: Michel Pogge, City Planner vt1-<& BACKGROUND James and Diane Kleinke, property owners of 116 6th St S, are requesting a demolition permit for an existing block garage on their property. The exact age of the garage could not be determined and a building permit for the structure was not on file at the City office; however, the property owner believes that the garage was built around 1952. The style and condition of the structure leads staff to conclude that the garage is more than 50 years old. Since the garage appears to be over 50 years old, it is by definition considered to have potential historic significance. Consequently, the Heritage Preservation Commission is required to review the demolition request. This site is in the Conservation Design District; however, since the main structure is not being removed a new garage would not be subject to the infill design criteria. SPECIFIC REQUEST The applicant requests approval of a permit to demolish the existing garage. EVALUATION OF REQUEST Chapter 34, Section 34-4 of the City Code states that"if buildings or structures are determined by the community development director to be historic or potentially historic, the application must be sent to the [heritage preservation] commission for review... Buildings or structures determined nonhistoric must be referred to the building official for issuance of a demolition permit." A "nonhistoric structure or building" is defined by Chapter 34, Section 34-2 as a structure or building less than 50 years old. .. Since the age of the structure could not be determined it is assumed that the garage is over 50 years old; therefore, it is of potential historic significance and requires review by the Heritage Preservation Commission. , 1166thStS Kleinke Garage Demolition Permit Page 2 Section 34-5 of the City Code lists nine items which must be considered prior to approval of a demolition permit by the Commission. (1) A map showing the location of the building or structure to be demolished on its property and with reference to neighborhood properties; This information is included in the attached application. (2) A legal description of property and owner of record; The legal description of the property was included in the application. (3) Photographs of all building elevations; Photos from various angles are included in the packet. (4) A description of the building or structure or portion of building or structure to be demolished; The existing garage is an approximately 15' by 22' garage. The applicant has indicated in the cover letter that the entire garage structure is proposed to be demolished. (5) The reason for the proposed demolition and data supporting the reason, including, where applicable, data sufficient to establish any economic justification for demolition; The applicant has included a quote from D&A Construction of Stillwater related to the cost to renovate the garage. It was estimated it will cost $19,000 to restore this structure. Since it is a block building the entire structure would be deconstructed and then rebuilt in order to restore the building. The applicant states in their application that the structure is in disrepair, is a hazard and liability, does not complement the character of their home, and is not functional. (6) Proposed plans and schedule for reuse of the property on which the building or structure to be demolished is located; The applicant stated in his application that they desire to construct a new 24' by 30' garage with storage above the garage. The new garage will be shifted approximately 10 feet east of the existing garage location. (7) Relation of demolition and future site use to the comprehensive plan and zoning requirements; The current comprehensive plan land use designation for the property is Single Family Small Lot and is zoned RB, two-family residential. Once the current garage is demolished the proposed garage would be required to meet all of the requirements of the zoning code as proposed. This site is in the Conservation Design District; however, since the main structure is not being removed a ne'lU garage would not be subject to the in fill design criteria. 1166thStS Kleinke Garage Demolition Permit Page 3 (8) A description of alternatives to the demolition; The applicant states that there are no alternatives to demolition. Staff would offer that restoration of a structure is always an alternative to demolition. (9) Evidence that the building or structure has been advertised for sale for restoration or reuse and that sale for restoration or reuse is not economically feasible. The applicant has indicated that they have advertised the garage in the Stillwater Gazette on May 16, 2008. A copy of the ad has been included in your packet. ALTERNATIVES The Heritage Preservation Commission has the following options: 1. Approve the demolition permit as presented. 2. Deny the demolition permit if the applicant has not proved the necessity for demolishing the garage or if the Commission believes there are alternates to demolishing the garage. 3. Continue the public hearing until the July 7, 2008 Commission meeting. The 60 day decision deadline for the request is July 15, 2008. RECOMMENDATION Review and take action on the request. attachment: Application and supporting documents from the applicant PROPOSAL PROPOSAL NO. SHEET NO. DATE PROPOSAL SUBMITTED TO: NAME ADDRESS WORK TO BE PERFORMED AT: ADDRESS CITY, STATE CITY,STATE DATE OF PLANS .5 r J L-LvJ I't-1 C42- PHONE NO. ARCHITECT We hereby propose to furnish the materials and perform the labor necessary for the completion of \ ,,(l 6 E... -A. r.J~ ~ de.... c".....';:> 'D v,.:\ ~ l'J ~"""DO~ wo All material is guaranteed to be as specified, and the above work to be performed in accordance with the drawings and specifications submitted for above work and completed in a substantial workmanlike manner for the sum of: Dollars ($ with payments to be as follows Any alteration or deviation from above specifications involving extra costs will be executed only upon written order, and will become an extra charge over and above the estimate. All agreements contingent upon strikes, accidents, or delays beyond our control. Respectfully sUbmitted~ r;,fl~c....JIZl.vb+a//(J)t(.l<r 71JC- I ____ ' Per +~ J 6rl-tY~1\J s- (1-08 Note - This proposal may be withdrawn by us if not accepted within days. ACCEPTANCE OF PROPOSAL The above prices, specifications and conditions are satisfactory and are hereby accepted. You are authorized to do the work as specified. Payments will be made as outlined above. -- .. SIGNATURE DATE arc- 9450 SIGNATURE 'h.. . I ".\ 'I Heritage Preservation Commission Demolition Request Permit Demolition Permit No. Fee $100* Receipt No. Address of Project: II (p $\,Xth S+ Sou-H'l Parcel No.: ~2~ .030-20.3 1.0 ~S5 Lot 3 BIOCk-S- Subdivision ihotnp?t>"h ParteR po Mowers 2nd. kkli -jUy. ~ 1 h \ 1- 4-t/f- If go 1 1 ~ . - Owner if different than Applicant: NIPr Address: - , .- ~ Type of Structure: ~~iy\.e,vd- lbl Dck- :5 t~~le Co.-r tJ C~.e.." C tt CtLr) :..:: Age of Structure:]Cl5J Condition of Structure:\'ery Povr. 1'ad roo~) rn+trn won:;\ ~ _tt/ld p-Mlefs) ~ m clGS j" ,{iiJVlmCL1:Jro (l~d ~ ( ~-tWtt SIc1Pj:;!)r4- mJf7 ~ ?tY1AC~rZlt'M> hetA.YI 'vy in ~. I'\Or-fu ~ ~1IJt',<;J-. IJDt ~9truefvLratll.( -.5O"Und ~ ~ Intended Use of Site after Demolition:--Eallld tL nevv 2 cctr 5crr7^--5C:/ Telephone No."-- ) / I;;yJ 1) t Date ~/ l.riot Date *After Heritage Preservation approval, there is a la-day appeal period. Once the la-day appeal period has ended, the applicant will receive a design review permit which must be signed and submitted to the City to obtain the required building permits. A building permit must be obtained with the City of Stillwater Building Department. The fee for the buildin permit is based on the valuation of the demolition ro "ect. Office Use Only HPC Review Date: o Approved o Denied City Planner/Community Development Director Date 12 May, 2008 City of Stillwater Heritage Preservation Commission 216 Fourth Street North Stillwater, MN 55082 Dear Members of the Heritage Preservation Commission: We have a one and a half car garage located just behind our house on the north west side of our property. This garage is in very poor condition and is a hazard and liability. We have lived in our house at 116 Sixth Street South since 1996 and are now seeking to construct a much needed new two car garage that is functional, safe, matches the character of the house, and meets our needs. In determining the age of the garage, we approached the Charlsen family. This family owned and lived in this home from1911 to 1993.At our request, Pat Downs (Charlsen) contacted her siblings in order to help us give an approximate date to our cement block garage. The family was able to locate photographic evidence that placed the garages age at approximately 1952. This would make our garage 56 years old and require us to pursue demolition authorization through the Heritage Preservation Commission. Prior to 1952 there were several detached structures on the property which included a horse shed and out house. These were all removed many years ago and no evidence remains of them. We have a historic photograph of the property that dates around 1900. This photo shows the north side of the property with out any type of garage or stable / barn structure on the site of the present garage. We do not know of any special history associated with our house. We have been told that Mr. Charlsen was once a Stillwater mayor. Attached to this letter are the following: Item A - Map showing the location of the structure to be demolished. Item B - A legal description of property. Item C - Photographs of building. Item D - Description of the building to be demolished. Item E - Reason for proposed demolition. Item F - Proposed plans and schedule for reuse of the property. Item G - Relation of demolition and future site to comprehensive plan / zoning requirements. Item H - Descriptions of alternatives to demolition. Item I - Evidence that the building has been advertised for sale. Submitted by Diane and James Kleinke Property Owners at 116 Sixth Street South Stillwater, MN 55082 439-4807 ~~~n~~~~~~~~mZoom~Z~Z~n~~~~~~~~m~~n~~~Z~~~O~ ....OooOooZm~oc::: O-...J-...J. ~ Ul-...J010000o~:r:~mH~~H~o:;oZO. I.ZJZZ O~ ~. Z ~ ~:;o~t:l~ooo-...J~~.~. Z ~KlZ!:O ~ ~~ 0 Ul~ <:WH ~~~~H~m ~~H t:lt:lNt:lZt:l-...Jt:l~~H~ ~~moKlm~~~~~'zm~Z H~~ Z:;ot:l~~-~~~~~~ ~~~~ Z:;O~~~O 0 Kld ~~~ n~Q ml:I:~Z~- :;o:;ono:><QQ~QmQ~Q~Z~-Zoo:;o~~~~mHt:lm:;o IUl-...J ~Z~o~oo~Q o:;on~~ W o~o~o~m ~ ~ :;0 ZH ~~m~~l:I:Zoo 0:;0 l:I: ~~- OOOO~~~Ul 01 0:;0 00 ~-O~OOQ~~'l:I:~~~O ~Z~t:l NOZ oo~--O-~-~-~t:l Nt:l~ n~d~~ OZ~~~ ~Ul-...J -...JUlO~ZZ~O @ l:I:Oo ~l:I:oOoO~ZZ :;0 ot:l ~:;o :;o,~~n~~ . ~~Q t:l~o oo~~~~HW 00 00 Q t:l~Q ~~Hm~ ~~~~~~O~~ -...Jt:l~01~ mt:l~~~~==Z=m=~=ZUl~ l:I: ~ ~ ZO~t< 0 ~ ~~ O1Z~O~O ~ ~~~~~~O~ UlZ~OZO@~O~ ~~:;ot:l~moo~~oo ~Q~- ~ZQ~n~~ . ~ ~ ~- ~~o~mZ:;OZ~ ~~H Noo~~t:l ~oZW~t:l O1~O ~t:l~:;o~~t:l ~Zw~a~o~~ - ~m~~m~oo01~ 01 UlH ~Ul:;O:;O# H:;O ~l:I:H~~ O1H oot:l:;o moo~:;o ~~l:I:~ ooo~ ~-oo=~t:l~-- N~mO~QZml:I:Qm=~t:lo~-n t<~~# HW~~~O~ l:I:.Ot:l~ooH!:OWoo~ ~~~Z ~Z t:l~ooHZQooO~~:;O'~Nm~no 01 Zoo Ooo~Ul l:I:t:l 00 00 000 Ul :;o~~~~l:I: ~Nl:I::;O~~~ 0 =~aZ~~=MO~oW~~t:l wnt:l~t:lZ~~01N l:I:~~ ~ 00 Nl:I:t<t<ooO ~~H- :;O~Z~mo~o:;o NO ~H- ~-Z~ ~~~oo~~~~O~HHa~ ..... oooo~ t:l~nN. ~Q~ . ZZ oooo~:;owt:ll:I:oo ~H ~H ~ZZ ~o~ ~~~ 00 01 ~~ o~ ~~Ul o~#m~ Z~ ~~ QQ~~ ~o ~~. ~. ~O~ Ul~ ~ ~ ~o ~~~=~~ N~N~Q~mm~~ ~ Q~ ~. Q~Zoo ~l:I: Z ~ Z~ ~. :;o~~~t:l 00l:I: ~ H~Zoo~~ t:l~ t:l ~Z ~ t:l~ t:lm~~~~H~~~ooZ ~ oo~ N ~ t:l t:l~ N~~ 000l:I: ~nl:I:~t< QOOOo~ t:l ~~ ~~ ~ H ~ Hl:I: ~~ ~ ZnH~ l:I:~0 0 ~~~o ~ l:I:~ t<l:I: 0 00 0 ooZ l:I:~ Q n~ ~o ~~ ~~ ~ Z Z ~ ~ Z l:I: N ooZ ~ ~ZZW~WUln~~~ZZN~ZN~oo ~oo 0~0~00~~0 Zl:I:oZl:I:~ . ~~. . . . Z~~Klo~t:loot:lo Wt:loN~oo~~~ t:lZ ~t:l ~~ O1~~OOOOOUl :;oo~~ ~~~~~~ ~Q~~~~~Z-o:><Q~~mQ~oooo ~~ ~~~~Ooo~~UlHt:lOUlt:lOn ~~ ,0 Ul~ ZUl Z ~-~~~~~t:lN~m-oot:l -~ ~ O~ Ol:I:l:I:l:I:~Zl:I: WOH~Wl:I:~OO ~~o ZZZQt:lO~01Zoo~UlZ~ 'U = 0 00 Ul ~ Z = - ~:;o = :;0 ~ o~-...Jt:lmooooUl~~ ~oo ~~~~O ~ NO~-~ooO ~~ oo~~ ~~~~o~Wt:lO~t:l~~:;o~~:;o~ ~l:I:~t:lt:lt:lUl Z H~-"'] ~ - QZt<~~~ =~ zoot:l. ~Q~~n QQQ~ ~ ~ -...] :;0 0 00 ~~W01 ~~ ~N ~Q ~ t:l :><~NWt:l :;Oo~l:I:~ ~ ~---H~~~~Z~S::t< S::@ ~ ~01~ooO~~. 0 om :>< mooo~~~:;o ~n~~~ ~~ ~ ~~~~ ~~~=~O~Z ~n t:l Z l:I: ~~H -00 -0 H t:lt:lt:l Z 0 Zoot:l 00:;0 00 OHHH o~ ~ ~ ~moooo ~O ~ ~~~ ::0 :x: (J) t:Pd t1 .. 0 (I) I-' (I) rT{Jl!ll(l) ..OrTp.. .. .. (I) 0. ~~ l:I:~~ ONO ~NIi o ~~(I) o 00 {Jl o .-<I-3Zt-t .. ~ 0 :::J~rT ..~.. :;0 ~o ~o :;o~ ~ oo.~ ~ 00 OoO~~ ~o~Klo t:l~ ~ ~~:;o~~ Q-ZQ ~01oo ~ :><01 0000 n-Nt:l- wZ 0 ~1.1It:l~~ !:! - l:I:- ~:g~= ~H ooH ~oo~ooo ~l:I:Z~ <: Z ~~ ~~ n. ~Ul ~ :;0. l:I:~ ~~ 01-3 ~N ~ :;o~ n1-3 1-3 ~O ~1-3 oo~ tlo t:l g ~ ::u tJj N:::J~I-' ..lQO;;-;-' .. ~.. ~ :;00 -0 m~ N Z o o :;0 ;.t1 Ul() N ,tJj o ~w o Ul!-:" 00 '0 ~N3: ~ow ~o ~ OJ ~ (J) ~I-'() wtIj .. ::u :;OUll.I:l wt1 N..::U OON . N o W OH::U .l:jl.I:l N.Q () o~~ . 1-'-'""0 WIi ~ "< () o 011-' ~ I-' O1~(I) W(J)O tOrT PI 1-" 1-'0 ':::J ~ PI (J) 1'1'< o {Jl (J)rT 1-'(1) ;3 ~ o o PI I:.trt ~b- tI::Il:j 00 ~ ~ t:l H ~ tI::I ~ ~ ~ tI::I H ~ tI::I f H t) = 0\ ~ ~,~ ~ ~ ;: $' f;r- ~ r~ ~ ~ ~ V? ~ II m ~ 0 ?'~%. I '%J w /I I.:tJ >< 1-'" rt ~ZZW~w~n~~l.:tJzz~~Z~~~~~~~1.:tJ ~oo o~omoo~~o Z~o~~~o'%Joo~ . ~ ~. . '.' Z ~ ~ I-<: 0 t"' t:I 00 t:I 0 '%J ~ ~ '%J n wt:lo~~oom~1.:tJ t:lZ ~t:I ~t:I~ n~ ~1.:tJ'%J00000~ ~01.:tJ1.:tJ ~~I.:tJ~~1.:tJ ~O Z '%J (i) ~ '%J '%J '%J '%J Z - 0 ~ (i) ~ t:I 00 (i) t:I 00 00 ~. ~ ~ ~ ~~ ~~~~OOO~~~Ht:lO~t:lOn~ ~~~ m~ 0 ~~Z~ Z 01.:tJ '%J ~-~~~~~t:I~~oo-oot:l -~ ~OO o~ o~ O~~~I.:tJZ~ WOH~W~~OOO~OOO ~O ZZZ(i)t:lO~~ZOO~~Z~ ~ ~~~ ~=Ooo ~ ~Z=-~~= ~'%J ~ ~ OI.:tJ~t:loooooo~~~ ~oo ~~~~Ooo ~ool.:tJ ~ ~O~-t:looO ~1.:tJ ool.:tJ~t:I~l-<:t:I~ ~~I.:tJ~O~Wt:lO'%Jt:I~~~~~~~ I-<:H I.:tJ ~~~t:lt:lt:I~ Z Ht:I~ ~ ~~HZ~O (i)Zt<1.:tJ1.:tJ1.:tJ = ~ Zoot:l. ~(i)~~n~Z(i)~'%J (i)(i)(i)~ ~ ~ ~ ~ O~(i) ~ 00 l.:tJ~w~ ~~ ~~ 1.:tJ(i) ~ 00 ~ t:I ~~~Wt:I ~O~~'%J ~ oZ 0 ~---H~~'%JmZ~~t< ~@O OO~ I.:tJ ~~~oo 01.:tJ~. 0 OOO~O'%J~O ~ ooooo~~~~ ~n~~~ ~1.:tJ '%J (i) ~ --- ~~OOI.:tJZ I.:tJ I.:tJ OO~<I ~1.:tJ1.:tJ~ ~~~'%JZ ~ ~n~oo ~ t:I Z ~ ~ ~ H -.00 - 0 n ~ <: H H t:It:It:I Z 0 Zoot:l oo~ ~Z~~ 00 OHHH O~ ~ ~Z n~ ~ '%JOOOOOO ~O I.:tJ oo~ Z .... ~~~ ~ t:I~Z '" '%J ~ ~ /I n PI l:l o (l) ~ :x: C/) t:,...O t:J .. 0 (]) I-' (]) 1t00PJ(]) "Olto.. .. .. (]) 0.. ~~ ~~~ O~O ~~ti o ~~(]) o 00 Ol o ~t-3Zt"i .. ~ 0 ::S~1t ..~.. :::tI ~O I.:tJO ~~ ~ o rt rt o !:i ~ ~ :::0 lJj N::S~I-' .. lQ 0 ;>1 ..~.. I.:tJ ~o -0 oo~ ~ Z o o ~ ' !:tJ Ult) ~ '-.l:II o ~W o Ul ~"... 00 '-.6 ~tv~ ~ow ~o ~oo ~ 00 ~~() W>rj .. ~ ~Ult1:l tvt:J ~..~ ooot> . I-' o W OH:;tl 'l:lt1:l ~.Q () O,::~ . 1-'-"t:J WI1 ~ "< () o o I I-' ~ I-' Ul~(]) ~(l)O lQrt PI I-' - ~o '-::s .~ PIC/) 11"'<: o Ol (l) rt ......(]) :3 ~ o o PI yrt ~ b" 1.:tJl:l 00 ~ ~ t:I H ~ I.:tJ ~ ~ ~ I.:tJ H ~ I.:tJ " . , . ,', '.' \....' I.c:, :> \-- \ , '. \...~\.. _.5-/ . . "::\ I .' ., \' - ~ \C ~,. ~~'.' \",1+01 0\ . ~M'1 o~'h .,' ,;."~M'-",,,. ' , \ . .._W S . II ..\ . I ~\~~~\.,..' \,~~ ...'. .f"~':;~~~~~~-- '~~;,~; i I :\1 ." ..~ ~'_'" f"~~ I . t.::"'i1~:":''''~' f'~ IS'Q'J'~~ ' ' "AI .. .\'t:..... ~..... .'1" 0\ .~.," , ': .l~fJ;. W1 (.7';'''J.t'~. ;.' ,:~l,;~Il 1 ...\ _ .:,~*~L \ . "tt't1'h - 1\"' - - ~ ' ., ..I~~' I .. . 'oJ ~'~:E~5'. . Ltt . ,..,.,.' ~ .. ,,~I ""':t.;~... .,' '. '1'" ~h Ji'1t";.~'" !jt,t.~.,..~. ' ~5'ir . .i---&/ ,,'~ ,r.;.., ",. ".11 ~ .. . II' ' " ....ft. : " ,'. :':~. .. , . >" '\1. " .' " ':;,.t\ . ~ ..11: . ~ . \ ""f:~Sh ... . '<" Ii. ',,~~ ',: . /" .~O . ~ . /.' ,I .....,\; ~.g II~f"'~' .\~;.:. \I 'iJ.!! '.' . ~i..''''. .'. c)" I ~..... 'j':'.:i ""'f'\.S.E . /Iic.. ii, '-4 ..,. ." 't. '.... ~'-+ ~l..' \,~" I' 0 .-' 'J' ,/ r- ..N~ '. r\J : ..~~. -"V;' '.~' ::.-. t'. " <0 0 '0 'r.. '" Ill' ~-48' ~. .'~ .1\".... ~ ~ 11)11\- .-l! .... ,I ." 1ft ~ ". t",:. ~, d ~ CQ !) J .1':-11' "'~.~ ~ 1 ~.~ ~ ..1 ~ql \ .~ _ ~. ,fOQ'1 \. <! ~~_ ~~ ~..~~'-i' ~ ) · l' Jr.. . \'" '1'-) w: ... .,~..:.\. . \ " ~ .. .'~ 'o.1t' \ .f'!, ~I.ij t ~ 1 i>! "" ." If) ~., ~'~ I.Ul~' \ ~...- _ :T ~ 1 '.' J VI ( ~ ~ .~~<I"'~' J7 t : ;- 0\ ~~~ I ? ,-.."....... (J\ I't'l J ".~~ _ (' - \ co';" ....."c~ ~C\.. fj' : . .~~~, 1~ ~ ;~ ~ ~ CQ ~ ~ ....'~il ~ l 1~~i ~i':::: VI o......~ J~~}'I ~ . ~.~~. -...~~ ~"'l ~1"l...~~' l; :~ft....~~t ~t . ~ "~.'9:.. ~, 3f ((~ I,~ ,'oJ !J"~ ~ ~'~Q''': .. t.. ~ I'fl .. , 0.\1 ~.lij.~ t" "I . +- ~~ C;),~~..~ .' '" 0 ..... .... ~ .1:1..", .., . l .' ..,I ~.::..' . ,- ~Ylll('" .. I " ~.n:h~ . 'ti . ~ ~~ ~~~~O' " "'I..,~' -0;; . '<.... .' I" . '\" . :1' .~~ . " ,". ..:10 0 . . ",' I l , I.~J: r" (ilV;'/ ..' ...'...:J ~\: ~.. ''''"'t:.c.,~~ ~tH''>-f' .,'. .:. .: . '. / If:JQ/iI . :.:,.... ". ':'." .. \ +1 + \i. 0- \I) 1O 0- G .J ~ ~ ,110,_ .,1 , I I I I I , I I I I I 10 I~... , ...-.. -... " , ,', ~.., .1 '..: ""~~'OS' ..... - ~ os..... .:;;-S'5'.7 '. -t-- · . I ..... 1 r I <. r.' ---n'.z-> -. ~..~F 6so - :~: _.~' N ..... .....j \. l. .... ..;t~ -'~-'~ . (\ \, ..... \\ <;'"i \\ '-.... .~~ .. \.. h'_:;.:,,:'?/ t?..... . ,- ..... f , , " . . - .L..~ ~. I ,.....r. .J-' . .... ,~ 'c: " " ,- - "') . ,. v"...... . ,~" ...... I , " ..,-~ <:-....., .~ : . . , (..'....... '"'" , , ~...,...' ~ , t --t...,- ..' .. -.. \,....> ,'1. tI' ,.' .. " (fl~ ~-.$ /0- 0'\' _f/\ CXl Q) . t. (-...:....' . ...,- # '.. , , . 4. .. J.- ,. I ' '\ '." ..~ 8 ~ lIi l;) '., ~ ~.II' ~ rt .\,,:jJ -' '" ~ v,~~ ,,~ ~ ;.c:Q) ~ ~ :lIl'~J~ 0"+-" ~ ~ ,~..3 ~ "It) ~ .:: '+ .(S.IIl.... lil ~ 1(1111.J + ~....~..o ....i.,.~:"l... ...J :L., ~ ~V) tJ Oi ~o OC 'l)t.t. " ~ j.:: '- "-) :: i , ___...1 tr: l I . P' '.' ~..... "~"; ~ ,'. ::' + "' S1'-~ _o.tJ. Ij- ~ {J'i ~ is j if ~: ~ s . ,,1"" LfJ-r 2- . .n JNi> ,-totS .".". '1"- I'" I I I I 1__\_- , . t .. I 41!1 ~ .,1 I - --.' I I I I I I I 1 I I I I I I , 1 '" I I ~r .. I I ~~ I 1,1 r 8~ ~ ~ ~, pill V'l ~<' I I ~I I I a~ I I I J I I I I I I I I I +~ ~?t'~'\Y ~~~~ (j" ~ c.)"' ~l 1, ,. z ~ r ~ V' " - -----.. <.:::J --~- --.- - -.--- .... . J .--- .~. . I ,,- ~~ __ __ t........>; _\ ...,.. ~~......... ..,\- :-,."=1:1' ., ;..~\ t.-- -: \ ", ~ ,'>-.1, . :: :l"11 PI . "-"" III' .. till I l' !! ~..~-. ---- -,- i ITEM"D" Description of the building to be demolished. The building is a garage on the northwest side of our property. It was built approximately 1952 by the Charlsen family. It is a cement block structure with a cement floor.The roof is constructed with recycled lumber. It is a one and one half car garage with a small wood storage area off the back. The garage is presently ~ rs X ?:L.- ITEM liE" Reason for proposed demolition. · The structure is in disrepair . The structure is hazardous and a liability · The structure does not complement the character of our home · The garage is not functional . Attached photos show the garage, cracks in the cement brick walls, damaged roof, walls, siding and rotting wood. The whole structure is tipping / leaning to the north and west. ITEM"G" Zoning requirements. The proposed new garage falls within the RB district /Thompson Parker and Mowers second addition to Stillwater and will comply with set backs and other applicable zoning requirements. Our lot is more than 10,000 feet. The garage will follow or exceed the minimum set back of 3'from the side. Our new garage will be 24'x 30' and approx. 720 sq feet ITEM"H" Alternatives to demolition. We see no feasible or reasonable alternative to demolition.The structure is a hazard and liability. It is unsafe and dangerous for our family to use. Beyond that it does not fit our needs and we can not safely park a car within it. The garage does not fit with the character or architectural style of the house and is an eye sore. ITEM"F" Proposed plans and schedule for reuse We have attached some drawings and a footprint of what the foundation will look like. Our plan is to construct a two car garage in approximately the same location as the existing garage. We plan on repeating the dormered look of the houses roof in the new garage. We hope to place windows in the dormers if we can afford the cost. There will be one or two service doors on the south side of the garage. There will be stairs to the storage area and the back of the garage will have room for lawn and garden equipment, bikes,etc. The garage will have two 8'x 9' garage doors that will face East. The foundation will have frost footings and because of the grade will not be a floating slab. We will include as many architectural details as we can reasonably afford in an attempt to build a garage that matches the character of the house. We hope to start the project in June and hope to see it completed by the end of September 2008. Sketches are attached. These are concept drawings. The builder will obtain detail drawings for construction. \\' ;j- (.... I" i~ ! \, I I~ i~ !(:1 1L 1-; I 1m Ir- I,," Ill\1 ~<" '. I'. ........ I) Ji' I . ! , J )..~ ~v T - J + - i~ fft-,m I I I ~. --.-. ",---.........t ! I I I ! I i i i I I ~ t I , i f I , f t I 1, ~. ~ -.... -- - - i\ '1 i; ~ i _~___;::_____.~__.~ _..~ .,'. __w_ \ I ~ 'E~ 1F~ -'Q '5 ~ ~L ~~ '1 A~ , ~\\!~~~ ~ . t7 ~;; .!,\. 1') .~ 0- '. \3 ~ \'i'.: ~ ~1-\ z. g 'T-';;'" l,,~;, '~.'. ' 0.... ...... ".~k' <<1., . . .>: t., :x i') 8 ~ ~~ 0; 11 r'T\ -t 't \}\ ~_... f1 z Cf , I , I ! I ~ f:l. =~ :i~r F...J....~... ~ '" ~.'. tl\ ~ ., ..... ~ .~-- l~ 1- 1<::} ! 1~ '; \~\, 1m . I...... ,. I ~ II. ~...:~. 1> ,,:] Il I If' I \J\' I. I '~.' ~ ~ ~. ~ :\1~@ 1't \1j. &; ~~\l\ Gi rTi ~ l ~.. , I ~ o - lt1^...~ -. " \"\ \ -r \ i ! . I f, l I II Il Ii -"1 ;;f \ I Ii. I ), ) '1~. ~...~.... ~~ ~~ ~~ .~ t.a ~ ft.' _.\ co OJ C 0 .:::t:. 0 C CO N .- .......... OJ N 1.1) ~ - Q) .-- 00 a.. .......... +-' 0 C) 1.1) V'l OJ LI) ro OJ OJ LI) OJ .j.J E lo... !.... C +-' Z "- 'i:: ro Vl en ro 0- ~ .!::. ~ 0 ~ .j.J "'0 +-' 00 ro 0 ~ ~ E c .x OJ ~ !.... ro Vl +-' 0'\ CO ro ..c OJ ~ ro M U Cl C ~ ~ ~ :J .~ \0 - 'l"""" N 0 'l"""" +-' LI) l0- a 'l"""" Vl \0 10/12 Roof Pitch I I lo.....l EI lo..... 81 ~I r- I I I 2 - 8' X 9/ Garage Doors Two Car Parking -----1 R 1------ 1...1 1 1 1 1 I 1 1 1 1 1 ..L 1...1 Equipment / Yard Storage Stairs Up to Storage 1...1 1 I I 1 1 1 1 1 I 1 ..1. 1...1 Structure planned to run parallel to property line / fence 4' off property Ii ne 24' X 30' Grage with storage Roof pitch and doormers on roof to match existing house Wood frame 2 car garage Foundation with frost footings Located behind house on Northwest side in Thompson Parker Mowers 2nd Addition to Stillwater z ---:H) :1 lo..... o o o I I I ....l I~ ... I~ ~ 13 (1) I~ lo..... o o o .. water A (- Of- M~N~JF;~OTA_ :;" ') Heritage Preservation Commission DATE: May 29, 2008 CASE NO.: 08-25 APPLICANT: Yaniv Abotbul REQUEST: Design Review of proposed signage for The Shirt Factory LOCATION: 126 Main St S COMPREHENSIVE PLAN DISTRICT: CC - Community Commercial ZONING: CBD - Central Business District HPC DATE: June 2, 2008 REVIEWERS: Community Dev. Director PREPARED BY: Michel Pogge, City Planner Ph-rP DISCUSSION The applicant is requesting design review and approval to install a wall sign for The Shirt Factory at 126 Main St S. The applicant has indicated on his application that the sign will be 204-inches (17 feet) by 19-inches (1 foot 7 inches) for a total of 26.9 square feet. The sign is proposed to contain the words "The Shirt Factory" and "We customize T-shirts instantly! You Name it, we print it!". The lettering is proposed to be gold black background and gold border. For retail storefront signs the Commercial Historic District Design Manual provides the size of signs shall be consistent with the Sign Ordinance. The sign ordinance states building signs in the CBD '.. . may have an aggregate area not exceeding one square foot for each foot of building face.. .'. The applicant's retail space facing Main Street is 27 feet long. The total sign area of the proposed sign is 26.9 square feet, which is smaller than the square footage allowed by the ordinance. Staff would note that the image supplied by the applicant shows a larger (approximately 25.3' by 2.2') sign than what is described in the application. As a condition of approval staff would recommend the sign be limited to the size of 17 feet by 1 foot-7 inches as described in the sign permit application. 126 Main St S Page 2 RECOMMENDATION Approval as conditioned. CONDITIONS FOR APPROVAL 1. All revisions to the approved plan shall be reviewed and approved by the Heritage Preservation Commission. 2. The surface of the sign must not exceed 17 feet by 1 foot-7 inches from edge to edge. 3. No additional signage. FINDINGS The proposed sign meet the requirements of the zoning ordinance. The proposal meets the intent of the Commercial Historic District Design Manual. attachments: Applicant's Form Drawing/ photo of the proposed sign Case No: b~ og -I>~ Date Filed: /~ 012 I Receipt No.:C' f" CafCl.." Fee: $25.00 DESIGN REVIEW APPLICATION FORM COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT DEPARTMENT CITY OF STILLWATER 216 NORTH FOURTH STREET STILLWATER, MN 55082 The applicant is responsible for the completeness and accuracy of all forms and supporting material submitted in connection with any application. All supporting material (i.e. photos, sketches, etc.) submitted with application becomes the property of the City of Stillwater. Fourteen (14) copies of all supporting materials are required. All following information is required. PROPERTY IDENTIFICATION Address of Project Il~ S,. Mal (1 &r. Assessor's Parcel No. Zoning District hZ Description of Project_in detail ''I hereby state the foregoing statements and all data, information and evidence submitted herewith in all respects, to the best of my knowledge and belief, to be true and correct. r further certify r will comply with the permit if it is granted and used" If representative is not property owner, then property owner's signature is required. Property Owner t- S Representative~bln iv ~!;/ , Mailing Addres~'Jb 8. Ma t') cSt Mailing Address 5,JJJ N. MtV4 Sf. kp+ L City State Zip l ( War--tV'j MN f:t.5O& 1- City State Zip 9ti Wtv; MN 55rlf; 1- Telephone No. ftfj I 50 3 q 10 1-- Telephone No. 0 1- _ f - ~ Signature Signature H:\mcnamara\sheila\sheila\design review permit.wpd February 5, 2003 5/9/2008 Haol'Y bridl!e LLC "THE SHIRT FACTORY" 126 S MAIN ST Stillwater MN, 88052 T AA<:tr ~ TEL: EMAIL: YANIV@GMAIL.COM I '. oiil~e~ -~:-- ~, tHE BIRTHPLACE. OF MiN~JrSO'!A J Heritage Preservation Commission DATE: May 29, 2008 CASE NO.: 08-26 APPLICANT: Nordquist Sign Co REQUEST: Design Review of proposed signage for Leeann Chin LOCATION: 1840 Market Drive COMPREHENSIVE PLAN DISTRICT: BPC - Business Park Commercial ZONING: BP-C Business Park Commercial HPC DATE: June 2, 2008 REVIEWERS: Community Dev. Director PREPARED BY: Michel Pogge, City Planner tw1P DISCUSSION The applicant is requesting design review and approval to replace the existing "DQ" wall signs at 1840 Market Drive with new signs for "Leeann Chin". The new signs will be comprised of red channel letters. The first sign is on the north elevation and is proposed to be 23'1-5/8" wide by 20" tall for a total area of 38.3 square feet. The second sign is on the east elevation and is proposed to be 13'10-1/2" wide by 12" tall for a total area of 13.8 square feet. For retail wall signage the West Business Park design standards provide that the signage shall be consistent with the Sign Ordinance. The sign ordinance states that for a wall sign, 'the gross surface area of a wall sign may not exceed one square foot for each foot of building, parallel to the front lot line'. The applicant's retail space has 46'3" feet facing Market Drive. The total sign area on the north elevation is less than the maximum allowed by the ordinance. A variance was granted for a second wall sign for up to 16 square feet of signage on the east elevation of the building. A variance runs with the property, not the business. So it can be applied to Leeann Chin's signage. The proposed sign on the east elevation meets the stipulations of the existing variance. 1840 Market Drive Page 2 RECOMMENDATION Approval as conditioned. CONDITIONS FOR APPROVAL 1. All revisions to the approved plan shall be reviewed and approved by the Heritage Preservation Commission. 2. No additional signage. FINDINGS The proposal meets the intent of the West Business Park Design Guidelines. The proposal meets the requirements of the zoning ordinance and approved variances. attachments: Applicant's Form Elevation Drawing/Photo DESIGN REVIEW APPLICATION fORM Case No: IJip~ ~& Date Filed: bflte{t3Z R.eceipt No.: ____. Fee: $25.00 COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT DEPARTMENT CITY OF STILLWATER 216 NORTH FOURTH StREET STILLWATER, MN 55082 applicant is responsible. for the completeness and accuracy of aU supporting material submitted in connection any application. AU supporting material photos, submitted with application the the City 5ketcnes materials are is PROPERTY IDENTIFICATION III hereby state the foregoing statements and all data, information submitted herewith in allrespe~ t() the best of my knowledge and belie'" to be true and correct. 1 further certify 1 will comply with the permit If it Is used" Signature Signature H:\mcnamara\sl1eila\200S\deslgn review permitwpd July 13, 2005 DESIGN REVIEW APPUCATION FORM Case .No: Date Filed: Receipt No.: Fee; $25.00 COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT DEPARTMENT CITY OF STILLWATER 216 HORTH FOURTH STREET STILLWATER, MN 55082 The applicant is responsible for' supporting material submi~d matedal {i.e. photos, sketches, property the City ofStiJlwater. required. and accuracy of all and connection with anyappUcation. AJls.upporting s.ubmitted with application the Photos, copies of materials are is PROPERTY IDENTIFICATION ''/ hereby state the foregoing statements and all data, Information and evidence submitted herewith In all respects, the best of my knOwledge be true and carrSd. 1 futthercertifyl Wl11comply with the permit if it is granted and used" If representative is not property owner, then property owner's is Representative rtMalling Address ;;L City State Zip Telephone No. Signatu Signature H:\mcnamara\sheila\2005\design review permIt.wpd July 13, 2005 - Cl ::z: <l: = ::z: t!) v; Co "<T FURNISH AND INSTALL: EXTERIOR WALL MOUNTED ILLUM. PIC LETTERS I:: "iI @-ILLUM. PIC LETTERS - 5" DEEP BLACK RETURNS - 1" BLACK TRIM CAP - 3/16" 2283 RED PLEXIGLAS @-WIREWAY - 5" TALL ALUMINUM - PTD. MATTHEWS "ROANOKE RED" 10A-1A TO BE VERIFIED I I '.. .. .~. ~ . -". .": ~ ~ ! INSTALL: 3/8" LAG BOLT INTO BRICK WALL ELECTRICAL REQUIREMENTS: - 37 FEET (139) RLS-3-12-RX RED LED UNITS - 2 - PSA-12-60 DRIVERS - 1.06A@ 120V - 1 - 20A CIRCUIT REQUIRED ELECTRICAL SERVICE AND CONNECTION BY OTHERS SEE DRAWING: 25790-2 LEEAN CHIN STILLWATER ~ :\ '-1' . . . --r1' · ~. . 4 .1 ..... ~\ ~ ~ ~J .10.".- .i ~ --. d LLJ SIGN SQUARE FOOTAGE = 13.833 SQ. FT. 166-1/2" me. LOCATION c-... me. SWITCH Co ~ ----------1" Y A GD ElEVATION 1.1 SCALE: 3/4" = 1'.011 This drawing is the property of: Nordquist Nordquist Sign Company, Inc. 312 West Lake Street Minneapolis. MN 55408 PH 612.823.7291 FX 612.824.6211 www.nordquistsign.com All design, manufacturing, reproduction, use and sale of this document is strictly prohibitied without the written consent of Nordquist Sign Company, Inc. This document is submitted under a confidential understanding that the recipient of this document assumes custody and agrees that the document and any part of its content is not to be copied, reproduced in whole or part. or any of its contents be revealed in whole or part to other parties except for which it is agreed upon by Nordquist Sign Company, Inc. and recipient, nor shall any design features unique to this document be incorporated in any other projects. SALES: RN DESIGN: AW DATE: 05.14.08 REV 1: 05.16.08 HP REV 2: REV 3: REV 4: REV 5: REV 6: REV 7: REV 8: REV 9: LEEANN CHIN 1840 MARKET DRIVE SUITE 1 STIlLWATER, MN 55082 SIGN TYPE: ILLUM. PIC LETTERS APPROVAL: PREVIOUS DWG: REF: LEEANN CHIN JOB: 25190-1 PAGE: 1.1 .040" PRE-FINISHED ALUMINUM RETURNS 1" TRIM CAP 3/16" ACRYLIC FACE .050" PRE-FINISHED ALUMINUM BACK 3/8" LAG BOLT LARGE WIREWAY 3" CLIP #5988 DRAIN HOLES TRANSFORMER ON TRANSFORMER BRACKET SIGNCOMP SMALL 2-PIECE WIREWAY 1971, 1972 & 1976 cover SMALL WIREWAY CLIP #5989 6' SEALTlTE CONDUIT WI 3 -12 go. WIRE ~ SECTION: SCALE: 3" = 11.0" LEDs This drawing is the property of: Nordquist Nordquist Sign Company, Inc. 312 West Lake Street Minneapolis, MN 55408 PH 612.823.7291 FX 612.824.6211 www.nordquistsign.com All design, manufacturing, reproduction, use and sale of this document is strictly prohibitied without the written consent of Nordquist Sign Company, Ine, This document is submitted under a confidential understanding that the recipient of this document assumes custody and agrees that the document and any part of its content is not to be copied, reproduced in whole or part, or any of its contents be revealed in whole or part to other parties except for which it is agreed upon by Nordquist Sign Company, Inc. and recipient, nor shall any design features unique to this document be incorporated in any other projects. ELECTRICAL BY OTHERS SALES: RN DESIGN: AW DATE: 05.14.08 REV 1: 05.16.08 HP REV 2: REV 3: REV 4: REV 5: REV 6: REV 7: REV 8: REV 9: LEEANN CHIN 1840 MARKET DRIVE SUITE 1 STILLWATER, MN 55082 SIGN TYPE: ILLUM. PIC LETTERS APPROVAL: PREVIOUS DWG: REF: LEEANN CHIN JOB: 25190-1 PAGE: 1.2 l: : :.~ ~.: : f~ iQ~ ~ 8. ~~ ~ . ~ ~: :~~: ~~~ 8 ;~ ~ 6~~ FILE TO BE OUTLINED AS NECESSARY FOR PRODUCTION CUT FILE: 3/1611 ACRYLIC ~ -t-~ CUT FILE: .050 ALUMINUM BACKS ~ -t--+j @ PATTERN FILE, 1.3 This drawing is the property of: Nordquist Nordquist Sign Company. Inc. 312 West Lake Street Minneapolis, MN 55408 PH 612.823.7291 FX 612.824.6211 www.nordquistsign.com 6C==O~N All design, manufacturing, reproduction. use and sale of this document is strictly prohibitied without the written consent of Nordquist Sign Company. Inc. This document is submitted under a confidential understanding that the recipient of this document assumes custody and agrees that the document and any part of its content is not to be copied, reproduced in whole or part. or any of its contents be revealed in whole or part to other parties except for which it is agreed upon by Nordquist Sign Company, Inc. and recipient, nor shall any design features unique to this document be incorporated in any other projects. SCALE: 3/4" = 1'.0" SALES: RN DESIGN: AW DATE: 05.14.08 REV 1: 05.16.08 HP REV 2: REV 3: REV 4: REV 5: REV 6: REV 7: REV 8: REV 9: LEEANN CHIN SCALE: 3/4" = 1'.0" 1840 MARKET DRIVE SU IT[ 1 STILLWATER, MN 55082 SIGN TYPE: ILLUM. PIC LETTERS APPROVAL: PREVIOUS DWG: REF: LEEANN CHIN JOB: 25190-1 SCALE: 3/4" = 1'.0" PAGE: 1.3 c :z: <C = :z: (.!) Vi a '.. SEE DRAWING: 25790-1 LEEAN CHIN STILLWATER ~'. ,~ '\~ :~ J .:~. J .~-', ;; -- SIGN SQUARE FOOTAGE = 38.333 SQ. FT. e::. ('0.1 23' 1-5/8" me. LOCATION e::. ('0.1 ----------------- ~ 3" ____________2" Co w 3" ("J;) ELEVATION 2.1 FURNISH AND INSTALl: EXTERIOR WALL MOUNTED ILLUM. PIC LETTERS @-20" ILLUM. PIC LETTERS - 5" DEEP BLACK RETURNS - 1" BLACK TRIM CAP - 3/16" 2283 RED PLEXIGLAS (D-WIREWAY - 5" TAll ALUMINUM - PTD. MATTHEWS "ROANOKE RED"10A-1A TO BE VERIFIED INSTALL: 3/8" LAG BOLT INTO BRICK WALL 4' OIC ELECTRICAL REQUIREMENTS: - 69.5 FEET (139) RLS-3-12-RX RED LED UNITS - 2 - PSA-12-60 DRIVERS - 1.06A @ 120V - 1 - 20A CIRCUIT REQUIRED ELECTRICAL SERVICE AND CONNECTION BY OTHERS ~ ~ SCALE: 3/8" = 1'.0" This drawing is the property of: Nordquist Nordquist Sign Company, Inc. 312 West Lake Street Minneapolis. MN 55408 PH 612.823.7291 FX 612.824.6211 www.nordquistsign.com All design, manufacturing, reproduction, use and sale of this document is strictly prohibitied without the written consent of Nordquist Sign Company, Inc. This document is submitted under a confidential understanding that the recipient of this document assumes custody and agrees that the document and any part of its content is not to be copied, reproduced in whole or part. or any of its contents be revealed in whole or part to other parties except for which it is agreed upon by Nordquist Sign Company, Inc. and recipient, nor shall any design features unique to this document be incorporated in any other projects. SALES: RN DESIGN: AW DATE: 05.14.08 REV 1: 05.16.08 HP REV 2: REV 3: REV 4: REV 5: REV 6: REV 7: REV 8: REV 9: LEEANN CHIN 1840 MARKET DRIVE SUITE 1 STILLWATER, MN 55082 SIGN TYPE: ILLUM. PIC LETTERS APPROVAL: PREVIOUS DWG: REF: LEEANN CHIN JOB: 25190-2 PAGE:2.1 u This drawing is the property of: LEDs Nordquist 3/16" ACRYLIC FACE Nordquist Sign Company, Inc. 312 West Lake Street Minneapolis, MN 55408 PH 612.823.7291 FX 612.824.6211 www.nordquistsign.com .040" PRE-FINISHED ALUMINUM RETURNS 1" TRIM CAP 3/8" LAG BOLT All design, manufacturing, reproduction, use and sale of this document is strictly prohibitied without the written consent of Nordquist Sign Company, Inc. This document is submitted under a confidential understanding that the recipient of this document assumes custody and agrees that the document and any part of its content is not to be copied, reproduced in whole or part, or any of its contents be revealed in whole or part to other parties except for which it is agreed upon by Nordquist Sign Company, Inc. and recipient, nor shall any design features unique to this document be incorporated in any other projects. .050" PRE-FINISHED ALUMINUM BACK LARGE WIREWAY 3" CLIP #5988 o o o ELECTRICAL BY OTHERS SALES: RN DESIGN: AW DATE: 05.14.08 REV 1: 05.16.08 HP REV 2: REV 3: REV 4: REV 5: REV 6: REV 7: REV 8: REV 9: DRAIN HOLES LEEANN CHIN TRANSFORMER ON TRANSFORMER BRACKET 1840 MARKET DRIVE SUITE 1 STILLWATER, MN 55082 SIGNCOMP SMALL 2-PIECE WIREWAY 1971, 1972 & 1976 cover SMALL WIREWAY CLIP #5989 6' SEALTlTE CONDUIT WI 3 -12 go. WIRE SIGN TYPE: IlLUM. PIC LETTERS APPROVAL: G;) SECTION: PREVIOUS DWG: REF: LEEANN CHIN JOB: 25190-2 SCALE: 3" = 1'.0" PAGE:2.2 This drawing is the property of: Nordquist Nordquist Sign Company, Inc. 312 West Lake Street Minneapolis. MN 55408 PH 612.823.7291 FX 612.824.6211 www.nordquistsign.com SCALE: 3/8" = )'.0" All design, manufacturing, reproduction, use and sale of this document is strictly prohibitied without the written consent of Nordquist Sign Company. Inc. This document is submitted under a confidential understanding that the recipient of this document assumes custody and agrees that the document and any part of its content is not to be copied, reproduced in whole or part, or any of its contents be revealed in whole or part to other parties except for which it is agreed upon by Nordquist Sign Company, Inc. and recipient. nor shall any design features unique to this document be incorporated in any other projects. LEEANN CHIN CUT FILE: 3/16/1 2283 RED ACRYLIC 277W'. (23'.1Y21/) I I {g +18i8+tANW @~G .nN SALES: RN DESIGN: AW DATE: 05.14.08 REV 1: 05.16.08 HP REV 2: REV 3: REV 4: REV 5: REV 6: REV 7: REV 8: REV 9: CUT FILE: .050 ALUMINUM BACKS LEEANN CHIN SCALE: 3/8" = )'.0" 1840 MARKET DRIVE SUITE 1 STILLWATER, MN 55082 277Y2 /I . (23'-lY2 /I) I I {R ~b ~~ +tANW Q ~~ ~ SIGN TYPE: ILLUM. PIC LETTERS APPROVAL: MOUNTING PATTERN PREVIOUS DWG: REF: LEEANN CHIN JOB: 25190-2 SCALE: 3/8" = )'.0" PAGE:2.3 ---- ._'---~ or "'rN"f:,Oi. ") ~, Heritage Preservation Commission DATE: May 30, 2008 CASE NO.: 08-27 APPLICANT: Peter Sampair and Darvy Beberg REQUEST: Design Review of proposed signage and elevation modifications for Maison Galleria LOCATION: 223 Main St S COMPREHENSIVE PLAN DISTRICT: CC - Community Commercial ZONING: CBD - Central Business District HPC DATE: June 2, 2008 REVIEWERS: Community Dev. Director PREP ARED BY: Michel Pogge, City Planner 'Mfi? DISCUSSION The applicant is requesting design review and approval of a new wall sign and store front changes for the building at 223 Main St S. Building signage The sign is proposed to contain the business name "Maison Galleria". The lettering is proposed to be tan with a tan boarder all on a black background. The proposed sign is 3' tall by 8' wide for a total area of 24 square feet. For retail storefront signs the Commercial Historic District Design Manual provides the size of signs shall be consistent with the Sign Ordinance. The zoning ordinance states building signs in the CBD '.. .may have an aggregate area not exceeding one square foot for each foot of building face...'. The applicant's retail space is 28 feet long facing Main St. The total sign area of the proposed sign is 24 square feet, which is smaller than the square footage allowed by the ordinance. 208 Main Street S Page 2 Store Front Facade Changes The applicant is also seeking approval to remove the existing store front framing and install new bronze aluminum display windows and door. The building is located in the core Stillwater Commercial Historic District as listed on the National Registry of Historic Districts. The building itself is a contributing building to the Historic District. The Downtown Design Manual Guidelines provides direction for storefront fa<;ades. Generally, it is encouraged that store fronts be returned to their original characteristics. Bronze aluminum storefronts are not original to downtown Stillwater. However, the Commission has permitted these store fronts on other buildings in the district. AL TERNATIVES The Heritage Preservation Commission has the following options: 1. Approve the requests in whole or in part. 2. Deny the requests. 3. Continue the request for more information. The 60 day decision deadline for the request is July 15, 2008 and the next Heritage Preservation Commission meeting is scheduled for July 7, 2008. STAFF RECOMMENDATION Approve the requested building sign and store front fa<;ade changes as conditioned. CONDITIONS FOR APPROVAL 1. All revisions to the approved plan shall be reviewed and approved by the Heritage Preservation Commission. 2. The brick under the display windows must remain. 3. No additional signage. attachments: Applicant's Form and packet Case No: Date Filed: Receipt No.: Fee: $25.00 DESIGN REVIEW APPLICATION FORM COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT DEPARTMENT CITY OF STILLWATER 216 NORTH FOURTH STREET STILLWATER, MN 55082 The applicant is responsible for the completeness and accuracy of all forms and supporting material submitted in connection with any application. Photos, sketches and a letter of intent is required. All supporting material (i.e. photos, sketches, etc.) submitted with application becomes the property of the City of Stillwater. Fourteen (14) copies of all supporting materials is required. After Heritage PreselVation approval, there is a 10-day appeal period. Once the 10-day appeal period has ended, the applicant will receive a design review permit which must be signed and submitted to the City to obtain the required building permits. All following information is reauired. PROPERTY IDENTIFICATION Address of Project 225 S ~)v;lAssessor'sparceINo. ;)SrOS()- 2t'J.- '/I-{J(}2-r Zoning District G B /j Description of Project in detail f!Rp/~l~b 6'ltss (),.J J'1o;u t:oAl!-: w,71.lhA..Jd;i6/)ooe. IT hereby state the fo.regoing statements and all data, information and evidence submitted herewith in all respects, to the best of my knowledge and belief, to be true and correct. I further certify I will comply with the permit if it is granted and used" If representative is not property owner, t~~n property owner's~nature ~reauiied. . Property Owner fJltlelt. ~JJ/h;t //Jr<J~~~p~~~iatiZ IIt-J.4/2/ LL C Mailing Address 22'5 s: /hJtAl..15l Mailing Address t/fJJ Uk,€, !lvLS: City State Zip sh/lv..Aftzl'Z-, !h.;J s'rZif2 City State Zip !,(litfr.;Jf.A,e Lt!~/l?~/O Telephone No. Telephone No. hj/- ~26 -h6~ S:\Planning\design review permilwpd April 12, 2002 ~5/14/2008 17:25 6514269331 13' /24/2808 13: 67 6514268129 04124/208e 11:36 G5142593~1 WHITE BEAR GLASS SAMPAIR CQMFANIES WHITE BIiAR <<<L.ASS PAGE 01 PAGE 01/61 ~AGE 01 PROPOSAL Jl!!1lDENTIAL . CONTRAer Wbit~ _13~ear Glass, InCalfJJ'd7/D.$'$ You Netd.JJ!.t Om c.ut If 1759 ~ ~ ~JeE:Lab ~tl55110 (651}4~'P ~ ('S~)426-9JJ~ S~ 1m m 5A~t/tf";f t;. _ 1/;/pg I lre Dt'DDM~ Mj!ml.h~ and install as Jisted below includins Wt" JobAddrw.; .:2;25 S"/i1It"/I/ sf . Loaatcd. at: $f,llw~ . MN DisD~illd1ldH.i ,A2.!1?1'VAl-G p{1/A/dJ *,e flpAf: ~9M~ ~ 5~A/PM.. 9/#re.+J-q,v-f- $;t..r~V7/~ i!'-.r~. f'4Il $M...IL;f;f~ /ur;/lAAJr.q..&,,A/~(J.R. &A~ ". h1~~ CAf ~ 1:, '~.~~ ~S"/~~ +b ~~./?.v~ ;fttd JrI/h,:tle41f b t It'ev/41. ~ ....- For7l~o~ l.mDi: $ "",,- ~ d~" P BAJaDa: ... on a.cceptance of proposal,. $ due in full on ~mpletion, ~cr..~I.Q~: rm: PROPOSAL 8TA,TEo ADOVE. SlfALL BECOME TIft QOV PARTU:$IN THE AP.-aliOl"RlATE $PACts PROVRnllD ,a..ow.ERfllJNQ CONTRACl WON EX.ECtITf(tN BV 80m ACiCe_ &:M: Dah '1- 2~,-()f COtltnc:t Wbfh!:Beer G~ 1 Case No: Date Filed: Receipt No.: Fee: $25.00 DESIGN REVIEW APPLICATION FORM COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT DEPARTMENT CITY OF STILLWATER 216 NORTH FOURTH STREET STILLWATER, MN 55082 The applicant is responsible for the completeness and accuracy of all forms and supporting material submitted in connection with any application. All supporting material (i.e. photos, sketches, etc.) submitted with application becomes the property of the City of Stillwater. Fourteen (14) copies of all supporting materials are required. All following information is required. PROPERTY IDENTIFICATION Address of Project~ JOL-L+1C -n(K.-L;''- Assessor's Parcel No. d 3... 0]0 ~ dO'" '<;J-W}}j Zoning District c:: 'UJ WOOD 'KttfJ~'N6 /( I'}: hereby state the foregoing statements and all data, information and evidence submitted herewith in all respects, to the best of my knowledge and belief'; to be true and correct. I further certify r will comply with the permit if it is granted and used" If representative is not property owner, then property owner's signature is required. Property Owner R'466~(/lrlw , L Lt: Representative Do.x~+ Mailing Address W531Ak,fve J. Mailing Address;rob~,~St-, &<..163 City State Zip hlAlk gMIl.!4k _ /hd City State Zip (5-tiflLA'Yl::kY, mfl5S-c€:C I' . Telephone No. ?:,n - 1J.t-(..t 7t Telephone No. ~'S]-?~3'-OO'" Signature d-- Signatur~j(,<:;/,&~, H:\mcnamara\sheila\sheila\aesign rev' w permitwpd February 5, 2003 .. U Application for Sign Permit Fee: $50.00 Community Development Department 216 North Fourth Street Stillwater, MN 55082 651-430-8820 o Attach a plan showing the sign size, location and type of material used. If the sign is to be mounted on the building, show an elevation of the building and sign. Additionally, if the building is historic the sign mounting shall limit damage to the exterior of the building. o Sign Height: (If freestanding) Illumination: If Yes, Type: Declaration must with the City of Stillwater. is available at Stillwater City Hall. Remember to call Gopher State One call at 651-454-0002 before you dig to identify any underground utility locations. This is a FREE service. S:\Planning\FormslApplication for Sign Permit.doc Updated: September 23, 2006 iiiiiIII- . . '~..:..~I ......-- ._--~_.- -. -- 1 'I --~ .... .. ~--:'..... - ..- v - --] ~_._- . - - _............_~- - >- Qj +-' ro E .~ .... c.. c.. ro vi" Q) .L: U C N - .- CV'l ro c o M ..j:j x .:0 -~ ~ ~ II -0 Q)-o .!:::! ro Vl_ c ~ .3 .- -0 Q) II ~ E '::=t:~ "..; o r M N r~ f 01< ") Heritage Preservation Commission DATE: May 3D, 2008 CASE NO.: 08-30 APPLICANT: Smart Side Realty, LLC REQUEST: Design Review of proposed signage and elevation modifications for Smart Side Realty LOCATION: 208 Main St S COMPREHENSIVE PLAN DISTRICT: CC - Community Commercial ZONING: CBD - Central Business District HPC DATE: June 2, 2008 REVIEWERS: Community Dev. Director PREPARED BY: Michel Pogge, City Planner DISCUSSION The applicant is requesting design review and approval a new wall sign and new store front for the building at 208 Main St S. Building signage The sign is proposed to contain the business name "Smart Side Realty Co.". The lettering is proposed to be off white on a black background. The proposed sign is 2' tall by 11' wide for a total area of 22 square feet. For retail storefront signs the Commercial Historic District Design Manual provides the size of signs shall be consistent with the Sign Ordinance. The zoning ordinance states building signs in the CBD '.. .may have an aggregate area not exceeding one square foot for each foot of building face...'. The applicant's retail space is 16 feet long facing Main St. The total sign area of the proposed sign is 22 square feet, which is larger than the square footage allowed by the ordinance. 208 Main Street S Page 2 Store Front Fa<:;ade Changes The applicant is also seeking approval to remove the existing store front and install a new store front including kick panels, transom windows, display windows, and door. The building is located in the core Stillwater Commercial Historic District as listed on the National Registry of Historic Districts. The building itself is a contributing building to the Historic District. The Downtown Design Manual Guidelines provides direction for storefront fa<;ades including requirements for transom windows, display windows, entry doors, and kick plates. The applicant indicated in their letter that the storefront will use wood and glass materials. The applicant's drawings show lights on either side of the entryway. Specific details on the lights were not submitted. The light fixtures would appear to be open unshielded fixtures. Detailed lighting specifications should be submitted and shielded light fixtures should be used with the appropriate wattage of light bulbs. With the exception of the proposed lights, the proposal as submitted meets the intent of the Downtown Design Manual Guidelines for storefront fa<;;ades. ALTERNATIVES The Heritage Preservation Commission has the following options: 1. Approve the requests in whole or in part. 2. Deny the requests. 3. Continue the request for more information. The 60 day decision deadline for the request is July 15, 2008 and the next Heritage Preservation Commission meeting is scheduled for July 7, 2008. STAFF RECOMMENDATION Approve the requested building sign and store front fa<;ade as conditioned. CONDITIONS FOR APPROVAL 1. All revisions to the approved plan shall be reviewed and approved by the Heritage Preservation Commission. 2. The wall sign must be reduced to a maximum combined area of 11 square feet or secure a variance from the Planning Commission to allow the sign area to exceed the allowable square footage. If the sign is reduced in size the new sign design shall be reviewed by City Staff before installation. 3. Detailed lighting fixture specifications must be submitted for review by City Staff before installation. Shielded light fixtures shall be used with appropriate wattage of light bulbs to be approved by City Staff. 4. No additional signage. attachments: Applicant's Form and packet Case No: Date Filed: Receipt No.: Fee: $25.00 DESIGN REVIEW APPLICATION FORM COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT DEPARTMENT CITY OF STILLWATER 216 NORTH FOURTH STREET STILLWATER, MN 55082 The applicant is responsible for the completeness and accuracy of all forms and supporting material submitted in connection with any application. Photos, sketches and a letter of intent is required. All supporting material (i.e. photos, sketches, etc.) submitted with application becomes the property of the City of Stillwater. Fourteen (14) copies of all supporting materials is required. After Heritage Preservation approval, there is a 10-day appeal period. Once the 10-day appeal period has ended, the applicant will receive a design review permit which must be signed and submitted to the City to obtain the required building permits. All following information is reauired. PROPERTYIDENTIRCATION Add ress of Project d.. 010 S. M. tii () Assessor's Parcel No. Zoning District Description of Project in detail K6-Lo"\'TI--vJi"1\.. <b~('L o-At fIJ (}tV' Woo!;. ~ WI\LttltVf. <;;:;~ ~ ~ 1~i\,fWkt{M. "I here'hy state"ihe Mregoing statements and all data, information and evidence submitted herewith in all respects, to the best of my knowledge and belief'; to be true and correct. I further certify I will comply with the permit if it is granted and used" If representative is not property owner, then property owner's signature is reauired. Property Owner A:{leJ\ R~Vo..V4 Representative :5rL(1l\f+~ik R(~+~ I-LC Mailing Address~2...'t() Oo..\i. LJu l>v'. Mailing Address L,f&?'?' H-OJ.(wt()/~ Av(. City State Zip ~VMb.- WI. '3 ~t> City State Zip 6~cJJ I M'l.. 0~ Iz,il I Telephone No. 1tG- 4~q- ~C?~I Telephone No. (P'S(. t;q .,10b , C2ff.. JJ2A/~Q. S:\Planning\design review permit.wpd April 12,2002 5/21/08 Community Development Dept HPC City of Stillwater 216 N. 4th St. . Stillwater, Mn.55082 RE: Building Improvements @ 208 So Main St Overview We were careful in researching and planning our design efforts of the building, and hope that you will agree that not only is this a major improvement, but done so in a historically sensitive way. The building was more than likely updated over the years moving away from its original character and charm for cost and maintenance reasons. We think this is moving back in a direction towards the original character and charm for the era of this building. The building currently contains a steel support beam (horizontally) across the front and above the windows and door. The current materials used are wood, metal, and standard (non-tempered) glass. We propose to reconstruct the front of the building from the beam down. The materials used will all be wood (painted black) and safety or tempered glass. The front will be built to look as though it would have looked in the era it was originally built. We will also bring out the front of the store to both maximize floor space and create a more welcoming facade. We will also be cleaning the brick and removing existing graffiti, adding a sign and lighting. Thank you for your consideration. Phil Soby Smart Side Realty, LLC P . O. Box 83 7 I La keE 1 m 0, M inn e sot a, 55 042 651.275.0200 Telephone 1651.275.0300 Facsimile Table of Contents Pg.1-2 Pg. 3 Pg.4 Pg.5 Pg.6 Pg. 7 Pg. 8 Pg.9 Photo Copies: Archive Photos Photo 1: 1920's Photo 2: 1970's Document: Sign info Document: Lighting info Photo: North building neighbor Photo: South building neighbor Photo: North, subject, and south buildings Photo: Subject building / Current status Rendering: Subject building / Proposed P.O. Box 837 I Lake Elrno,Minnesota, 55042 651.275.0200 Telephone I 651.275.0300 Facsimile N "I ~ en ." n ." s: ... s: -. 0 0 -. ::r N :I 0 ~ :I - -. CD 0 -. c n ... .. ... en :I CD .. ill ::r ~ .. .. ... :I -. .. CD ~ - en .. en .. N :e II' "'II ... W :e .. - ~ '< .. .. >C 0 ~ 0 ..a., - -. "a 0 ... n :I CD ..a., .. ~ ... .. a. .. en CD ." II' II' a. _ ~ ~ C :I n en CD ~ ::r r.a - .. II' 0 c c ~ :I -. - ~ a. a. -. ~ - :I I 0 :e r.a ~ ::r ~ -. ... CD r- CD ... ... CD .. -. :I r.a Display Fixture: gooseneck 19-850 Search By Keyword: Home IGooseneck Information Ipa!!e 1 Ipage 2 lpage 3 l!'age 4 ~"-"- Ipa!!e 6 Ipage 7 lpage 8 IPa!!e 9 IShade Pa!!e 10 Arm Page 11 Page 12 IDesign Your Own fixture I Review and Complete Order IOuote Form IHELP!!! LOV[i Nt; IFixture! Description Outdoor All Aluminum, Gooseneck Sign Lighting, Emblem Sign Shade,Wall Bracket Over all Dimensions: 12" Diameter, 15" Height, 26" Extension, 1/300 Watt Phone #: (732) 297-6606 IHomellColor ChartJlContact usllPoliciesl Head: Emblem Sign, 12" in Dia and standing upright it 19/850 is 15" High, 1/300 Watts Mount: Standard Gooseneck Wall Bracket, Extends 22" eight 8" 99 Degree bend, Cast Canopy for 4" ctagonal Box I Base Price II Option: I Fixture Cost I Quantity II Shipping: , Total EJEJEJ 8 L_""_~~ _~~_J OS/21/200801:09 PM Imoortant Gooseneck Information 190.75 Options Swivel Ballast/Socket fSt~'~d"ard '" Medium EdlsonBas~~oi;';i~1 Special Instructions: Fixture Color Return to Previous Page http://www.loveitlighting.com/cgi-bin/geCfixture.pl?fix_pic= goose neck/ 19-850.j pg Page 1 of 1 ( -J.) ----- Jr'~ I.-;-~r I:.'. I -- III I' · .j · if i I I ~ I. I pi;::, ~Ii \, Il JI I' , r~! it at J' ~.... . ,j -:;'8fA _ -. - .~ ~~Wl, ~.~~~-. t.....-tJ __ - .~_.- - .. ~~~~ a ...~..._~ ~'" .,..- ~ ,,.... ... a a ~ -\1 II IClI 11II -' j ~ ...... " :",'':t~~~ .7- ,~;;,'!'~-1- :~ ...~~~'. ~"""'-, _~l~ ~1 t:; ~'J-:' ,~ I k--;lj~"""" ~- .(,.;,~~~::.~~ ....... '~.' ~~;."! -~~,~ """'4".~~f ~ '.... ....~ I . ..... < .. ," ".~~!""r. . !. ~> ~.- <F:'L:rt~r~~~~i' .":,,;..,",,-:.~,..'>~~~~~ ...~.~ ~.:r.':",,~1.~ _t-i.~~~:.. ~-' - l ....1. - ~:.;" ~. "".' '.. ,,'" ;.;,.;..".. -...~ .~.~. :. . ~) '-''''. - ..., a II II III II II ~ II ~. "" 11'- . .;l'l II;. ......~ - .4 ~ .... '" II ;11I 1I~:;?(~~.;~.0{:J';",~~,~ :..:... .. ~,:~" ^ .~ .~~ - . , :f.J ~~".: .~(: ~ ~~'t1~~ ~ ., :;. t, /~ . --. a III "., 't --a ~ ...._'11 :.: ' fir- 't' .... ; ", .... ~ ,~ ~ . "-.', ...~- ,_ ~ r'> - t" .. a , .. II t-: .:;((.~~.;:~:'~ .~ ~iI;'. .' ~~ 1 ~-\ ..' I :! )~~ ~ ~ . Ib1, , ~, , 1:..; 'I';~ \I) , \l" 1 Ji'~ 11' '. J ' , fN:;~;r~..!,::t~.; ~l . \<.'. t '; . ' ~l . ,~; '.. ,~~.. '. 1'1.:' It..~ . l ~rh 'l!) , f' .~,' l- " ;:~:. 1 \ III ' ~i"i;\ ,'\ \ fl" tl . ,. !: 1 '. l\A, t~~lk .,It :" ~ "J . t .: " j I. ' 1 ~ ~" , . , :1,: ' ,.".,.....".. . /'- t . .., -. .,11 .ip 'I ,f f~ IJji!',:Y1' Ii'! r', i · 1 r. I ~~* u.. .' d lu:o .! -p.... '~~" ~p..Nr~.'~..~i~~ll~.~. ,...'.........~~. .t~.:' ..ft .,~ . p .~I\lIf~l~II~"~ij~~i~ff~~..t~ ~\~!J~tU..f, ~~~:ef ----- afj,,,,,~ .,..~ -..,;..!. " I~,.. c. "'ft. . ... ~ ".... !'~.< . 't:.' :' ' " II '1'\..' " ,I"..., ~; ....t '.' :;,.' !.. . .' ." ~- ~ it! ~. - : ,. '., "., .: l, . 'i ;)': ~ l, ' . ;"~~qJI!~'" ,,~a..,' f ~ 1 ;;1 . '. '";" . ,:.,. ,~~ ~ "t' ~, .. , -. f\ "" ~: I'... .,..... _.~'.' .~ ,~ i :l \ :~ ~ .... ait : !~ * k. .- .~ ~~ II I I I ~-- \ .' l t I "' .. THE B:RTHPI.~ t Of MINNfSO!A. '; Memo Community Development Department To: From: Heritage Preservation Commission Michel Pogge, City Planner yVt .,p Friday, May 30, 2008 Date: Re: Demolition ordinance Message: In 1995 the City passed the current building demolition ordinance that is in place today. The demolition ordinance was for the purpose of: "protecting the historic and aesthetic qualities of the city by preserving, rehabilitating or restoring, when reasonable, buildings or structures which constitute or reflect distinctive features of the architectural or historical resources of the city, thereby promoting the public welfare and preserving the cultural heritage of the city." This ordinance requires the HPC to review and approve all demolition permits for buildings proposed to be demolished that are greater than 50 years of age. The only exception is if a building poses an immediate life and safety hazard the Building Official and Community Development Director can issue and emergency demolition permit. Staff has two areas of the ordinance that we would like Commission to review. 1) Related to the 50 year timeline, staff believes that a set date should be used in the ordiance. The period of influence for Stillwater as identified in Vogel's "Stillwater Historic Context" is between the 1840's and the 1910's. For some neighborhoods the period of influence extends to pre World War II. As it currently stands, as time passes more and more buildings within the Community are becoming subject to this review process even though they were not built within the City's period of influence. Starting injust as little as 10 year portions of Croixwood will become subject to this ordinance. Staff would suggest that the current ordinance be modified to require the review of buildings built only prior to 1940. From the desk of... Michel Pogge, AICP . City Planner . City of Stillwater . 216 N. 4th Street . Stillwater, MN 55082 651.430-8822 . Fax: 651.430-8810 . email: mpogge@ci.stillwater.mn.us BUILDING DEMOLITION ~ 34-5 Sec. 34-1. Purpose of chapter. This chapter is adopted for the purpose of protecting the historic and aesthetic qualities of the city by preserving, rehabilitating or restoring, when reasonable, buildings or structures which constitute or reflect distinctive features of the architectural or historical resources of the city, thereby promoting the public welfare and preserving the cultural heritage of the city. (Ord. No. 814, 12-5-95) Sec. 34-2. Definitions. The following words, terms and phrases, when used in this chapter, shall have the meanings ascribed to them in this subdivision, except where the context clearly indicates a different meaning: Buildings or structures of potential historic significance means a princilJcd building or portion 0/ a principal building IUl:th a inil1:al building permit issued bdon! danuar" 1, 1,940; or any otlJ&Lstructure or-er portion of a stnleturebuilding ruith a initial bw:lding permit issued be/ore ,January 1. 1.940-&F- DtructlU'e {W year:.; of age or older~tllat 1:8 deemed by the CommJlJiitv Development Direc!,or to be gL potential histon:c 8igniti:ccmee. Commission means the heritage preservation commission. Historically significant building or structure means any building or structure or portion of a building or structure on the National Historic Register, a designated local landmark or a contributing structure or building in a designated national register historic district. Nonhistoric structure or building means a structure or building QT..Qit?L'ohILHHlfY.1.L}j}1Qjcs,; than 50 YCfrl"fHJ1d-or a noncontributing structure in a nationally or locally designated historic district. (Ord. No. 814, 12-5-95) Cross reference-Definitions generally, ~ 21-2. Sec. 34-3. Permit required. No building or structure may be demolished without obtaining a demolition permit. An application for a demolition permit must be filed with the city building official. (Ord. No. 814, 12-5-95) Sec. 34-4. Procedure. The building official must forward a copy of each demolition permit application to the community development director for determination of historic significance or potential significance. The community development director must make the following determination: Subd. 1. The building or structure is historically significant or potentially historically significant; or Subd. 2. The building or structure is not historically or potentially historic. If buildings or structures are determined by the community development director to be historic or potentially historic, the application must be sent to the commission for review according to section 34-5. Buildings or structures determined nonhistoric must be referred to the building official for issuance of a demolition permit. (Ord. No. 814, 12-5-95) water "'''::--., Of MINNESO . ') Memo Community Development Department To: From: Heritage Preservation Commission Michel Pogge, City Planner ?t'\ W Friday, May 30, 2008 Update on City of Stillwater v. Bush and City of Stillwater v. Lehmke Date: Re: Message: The City has entered in to a plea deal with Bush and Lehmke related to the barn that was demolished without a permit from the City of Stillwater. The City has agreed to continue the case for dismissal which means that if he has no same or similar violations, remains law abiding and keeps the peace that these charges will go away. As part of the agreement, Bush will donate $1,000 and Lehmke will donate $500 to a historical preservation fund that can be used by the HPC as they see fit for preservation activities in the City of Stillwater. If either party violates the terms of the agreement then they will forfeit the money and will have to answer to these charges. From the desk of... Michel Pogge, AICP . City Planner 'City of Stillwater . 216 N. 4th Street. Stillwater, MN 55082 651.430-8822 . Fax: 651.430-8810 . email: mpogge@ci.stillwater.mn.us