Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout1999-03-01 HPC MIN Heritage Preservation Commission March 1, 1999 Present: Howard Lieberman, chairperson Chuck Dougherty, Phil Eastwood, Jeff Johnson, Robert Kimbrel and Roger Tomten Others: Planner Sue Fitzgerald Absent: Katherine Francis and Frank Langer Mr. Lieberman called the meeting to order at 7 p.m. Approval of minutes: Mr. Tomten, seconded by Mr. Kimbrel, moved to approve the minutes of Feb. 1, 1999; all in favor. Case No. V/DR/99-6 A design review request of an internally illuminated sign at 6750 Stillwater Blvd. Jim Palmer, ReMax, applicant. Mr. Palmer was present. Mr. Kimbrel noted a correction to the case number from that listed on the agenda. Mr. Tomten asked about a landscaping plan; Mr. Palmer said that would be completed in the spring. Mr. Tomten pointed out that zoning eliminates internally-lit signs close to residential areas. He asked if the applicant would consider going to a dark background or an opaque background, which he said would actually improve the visibility of the logo lettering. Mr. Palmer said the requested sign would not affect any residential areas. He said the sign will be placed on the former Amoco standard and be within height and size guidelines. Mr. Palmer provided samples of the tenant’s logo colors; after discussion, he agreed that the intent is to highlight the logo signage and that an opaque background would be acceptable. Mr. Johnson moved to approve the requested sign, a 6’ x 5’ monument sign, with the moment structure to be constructed of brick matching the main building, as conditioned, with a third condition that the white background be opaque rather than translucent. Mr. Kimbrel seconded the motion; all in favor. Case No. DR/98-53 A design review request for increasing the channel lettering from 18” to 24” for a previously approved sign at 2510 Curve Crest Blvd., St. Croix Bicycle & Skate and Kennedy Transmission. Kellison Company, applicant. Mr. Kellison was present. He stated Kennedy Transmission would like to use its existing sign which has a 36” K, with the remainder of the letters 18”. St. Croix Bicycle & Skate would like to use 24” letters as allowed by code. He provide a sample of the proposed signs/colors for review. When asked why 18” lettering wouldn’t be sufficient, given the visibility at the location, Mr. Kellison said the ordinance allows 24” lettering, and the applicants desire maximum visibility. 1 Heritage Preservation Commission March 1, 1999 Ms. Fitzgerald noted a variance would be required for the 36” K. Mr. Johnson asked whether the requested signage would fit into the allowable square footage; Ms. Fitzgerald said it is within the allowable square footage. Mr. Johnson moved approval as conditioned, with the additional conditions that the Planning Commission approve a variance for the letters in excess of 24” and that staff verify that the signage does not exceed one square foot per lineal foot. Mr. Tomten seconded the motion; motion passed unanimously. Case No. DR/99-7 A design review request for a sign at 324 Main St. S., Grand Garage, Starbucks Coffee Company. C.M. Architecture, applicant. The district manager of Starbucks and representative of C.M. Architecture were present. A packet of plans was presented, outlining the request. Ms. Fitzgerald noted the Grand Garage management has not provided a sign package for the Nelson Alley side of the building; the requested sign on Main Street is in the previously approved sign package for the Grand Garage. The applicants provided material samples of the umbrellas for tables in the courtyard; there will be no logos on the umbrellas. No additional lighting is proposed. Mr. Tomten moved approval with the condition that the requested sign on Nelson be placed on hold until the landlord brings in a sign package for that elevation of the building. Mr. Kimbrel seconded the motion; all in favor. Holcombe Addition Survey Update – Mr. Empson was present. He said he wished the City would exercise some oversight in some of the remodeling that takes place; he said often the aesthetic value is destroyed in the process of remodeling. Mr. Empson noted that the city of Hastings has a pamphlet of information on how to preserve historic houses. There was a brief discussion on how to provide/share such information with homeowners. Mr. Johnson noted that is difficult to put together an ordinance for a local Conservancy District without the surveys, like the Holcombe Survey, which the City is completing, but agreed that the HPC should pursue putting together an information packet similar to Hastings and Red Wing. Members had favorable comments regarding the draft of the Holcombe Survey; Mr. Johnson suggested adding some type of index reference tool. Mr. Empson said he would try to have the final version by the April meeting. Preservation Awards -- There was a general discussion regarding the categories and the selection process used. Mr. Kimbrel stated his desire to have residential awards included in the future. After discussion, it was agreed to present the following awards: Standard Station for facade and signage; Images of the Past and Present, reuse; and Lamp Shop, renovation; with a special award to artist Randy Raduenz for his public wall murals. Mr. Kimbrel moved to approve 2 Heritage Preservation Commission March 1, 1999 the awards by acclamation; Mr. Johnson seconded the motion. Motion passed unanimously. The awards will be presented at the May 3 City Council meeting. Other business: ? Ms. Fitzgerald asked how many members would be interested in attending the Historic Preservation Conference to be held in St. Peter May 14-15. Members were asked to notify her within two weeks whether they desired to attend. ? Mr. Lieberman asked about the status of the issues with Video Update. Ms. Fitzgerald said she would write a letter before the next meeting. Mr. Kimbrel asked about the Car Wash; Ms. Fitzgerald said it may be necessary to get Mr. Magnuson involved. ? Mr. Eastwood asked about the status of the Victorian Building. Ms. Fitzgerald said Mr. Magnuson is still working on that. ? The issue of lighted pop machines was raised. Mr. Kimbrel will contact Coke/Pepsi to see if there are corporate alternatives. Ms. Fitzgerald will contact Galena, Ill., to see how that city handles the issue. ? Mr. Lieberman referred to an upcoming bridge update meeting and encouraged members to attend with comments if they so desired. Mr. Kimbrel said another draft of the proposed rule change to the Wild and Scenic River Act would be available the following week; he will obtain a copy. There was consensus that the HPC should be involved in the bridge discussions. ? Mr. Tomten asked about the status of the wall pack lighting by the Police Department entrance. Ms. Fitzgerald said she was told it was a security issue. Mr. Tomten will call Mayor Kimble regarding the matter. Mr. Kimbrel, seconded by Mr. Doherty, moved to adjourn at 9:10 p.m. Respectfully submitted, Sharon Baker Recording Secretary 3