HomeMy WebLinkAbout2022-04-14 UC Packet
AGENDA
UTILITIES COMMISSION MEETING
APRIL 14, 2022
8:00 AM
I. ROLL CALL
II. APPROVAL OF MINUTES
1. March 10, 2022 Utilities Commission Meeting Minutes
III. OPEN FORUM – the open forum allows the public to address the commission on subjects which
are not a part of the meeting. Commission may take action, reply, or give direction to staff. Please
limit your comments to 5 minutes or less.
IV. NEW BUSINESS
2. 1315 5th Ave S. Water Service
V. UNFINISHED BUSINESS
VI. DIRECTOR/SUPERINTENDENT UPDATE
3. Monthly water use
4. Update on Utility Dept. capital outlay items
5. Water efficiency grant update – no packet materials
VII. COMMISSIONER ITEMS
VIII. ADJOURN
6. Next meeting date is May 12, 2022
UTILITIES COMMISSION MEETING
March 10, 2022
8:00 A.M.
Utilities Superintendent Benson called the meeting to order at 8:00 a.m.
Present: Chairman Speedling, Commissioners Hutter and Whitcomb
Absent: Commissioners Hudak and Jensen, Councilmember Polehna
Staff: Utilities Superintendent Benson, Public Works Director Sanders
APPROVAL OF MINUTES
Possible approval of minutes of November 4, 2021 meeting
Motion by Chairman Speedling, seconded by Commissioner Whitcomb, to approve the November 4, 2021
meeting minutes. All in favor.
OPEN FORUM
There were no public comments.
NEW BUSINESS
Discussion on water service from Roger Ryan
Roger Ryan, 1016 N 3rd St, presented two quotes from $15,000 to $17,800 for insulation of his water
service. He explained where the freezing is occurring due to the design of the system. When the
waterline was constructed to his property they went out the north side of the line, up and over a
telephone conduit, and then down to his property.
Commissioner Whitcomb asked if repair work between the main and the house is usually at property
owner expense.
Superintendent Benson answered yes. In other areas where water typically freezes in pipes, residents
are asked to leave the water running because the expense of running the water is less than the cost of
repair of the line. This situation is unique due to the design of the waterline. It is the only property
that has the service going up and around.
Public Works Director Sanders confirmed that water service repairs on street projects are typically
assessed 100% to the property owner.
Commissioner Whitcomb commented the City Council may deny the request regardless of the Utilities
Commission’s recommendation. He could not recommend approval because it sets precedent.
Commissioner Hutter agreed.
Mr. Sanders stated Mr. Ryan could bring the request to a City Council meeting during the open forum.
Discussion on funding for Utility Improvements on Street Projects
Public Works Director Sanders stated that staff is considering the replacement of the watermain on
Brick Street between Olive and Myrtle Streets as part of the 2022 Street Improvement Project. The
main was constructed in 1961 and has had eight breaks since 1980. Brick Street will be reconstructed
and now would be a good time to replace the watermain. The estimate to replace the main is $40,000.
Staff is requesting to fund the replacement with water revenue funds.
Utilities Commission Meeting March 10, 2022
Page 2 of 2
Motion by Commissioner Whitcomb, seconded by Chairman Speedling, to recommend approval of the
request to replace the watermain on Brick Street and to use water revenue funds. All in favor.
UNFINISHED BUSINESS
White Bear Lake Court Case Update
Mr. Sanders reviewed a report on the White Bear Lake Court Case, provided by Randall Doneen and
Jason Moeckel, Section Managers, DNR Ecological and Water Resources. He noted that the DNR is to
set a collective annual withdrawal limit for White Bear Lake and adjust permits accordingly. State
Statute deems first priority is domestic water supply, excluding commercial and industrial uses, such
as schools, government agencies, and hospitals. Based on the City’s 20,000 residents the withdrawal
limit would be a little more than 500,000 gallons per year. Current usage is around 750,000 gallons,
so the limit would have a significant impact. Legislation has been introduced that would allow Cities
to continue to operate per their water supply plan that was submitted in 2016 until 2040. The bill has
not gone to a hearing yet.
DIRECTOR/SUPERINTENDENT UPDATE
Monthly Updates
Mr. Sanders provided the monthly gallons pumped, 43,203 in January and 39,409 in February.
Water Appropriation use and efficiency profile
Mr. Sanders provided a water use report from the Department of Natural Resources.
Met Council Water Efficiency Grant Program
Mr. Sanders explained that the City is applying for a grant of up to $50,000 under an 80/20% match.
The grant money may be used to offer rebates to residents purchasing water saving devices.
COMMISSIONER ITEMS
Mr. Sanders noted if Thursday at 8 a.m. is a difficult time for Commissioners, the meeting time can be
changed. This will be discussed at the next meeting.
ADJOURNMENT
Motion by Chairman Speedling, seconded by Commissioner Hutter, to adjourn. All in favor. The meeting
was adjourned at 8:37 a.m.
Steve Speedling, Chair
ATTEST:
Beth Wolf, City Clerk
MEMORANDUM
To: Utility Commission Members
From: Shawn Sanders, Director of Public Works
Date: February 4, 2022
Subject: 1315 Fifth Ave South Water Service
DISCUSSION
This past December, the property owner at 1312 Fourth Ave South notified the Utility
Department of water in their basement. Upon investigation, it was determined there was a leak in
the water service, not for 1312 Fourth Ave South, but for the property located at 1315 Fifth Ave
South. Upon further investigation, water this property is served from a galvanized pipe coming
from the main on Fourth Avenue that was installed over 70 years ago. (There is no watermain
located on Fifth Avenue South). To make matters worse, the service is thought to be located
under the garage and under an inground pool at the property at 1312 Fourth Ave South.
The property owner is reluctant to repair the existing service because of the potential high cost to
repair the pool or garage. Other options considered include connecting to the water main on
either Fourth Ave South or Orleans Street. Both of which the property owner received quotes on
are in excess of $35,000. This high cost may be due in part to winter time construction, length of
service and potential to encounter rock during construction. One last option, the property owner
has considered is the possibility of drilling for private well on the property. City code states that
properties shall connect to water if it is available. The question to ask is city available where the
closest connection to the house is 200 feet away. The property owner has obtained information
from well contractor and indicated that the cost of new well would be around half the cost of
connecting to the water main, not include connection to the house.
RECOMMENDATION
Staff is recommending the commission discuss and consider the option for water service well
for the location at 1315 Fifth Ave S.
1 in = 50 ft
³
Gallons Pumped
2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022
Monthly
Totals
Monthly
Totals
Monthly
Totals
Monthly
Totals
Monthly
Totals
Monthly
Totals
Monthly
Totals
January 45271 47827 54174 47578 43126 44488 43203
February 42187 42360 50969 42335 41409 39016
March 44082 43799 55676 47276 43148 41908
April 48484 45235 52580 45808 44003 41587
May 65753 56415 77250 57949 61400 66124
June 82031 84085 77502 78308 74342 112800
July 99063 93342 89533 78536 81984 110149
August 78478 75439 99896 78626 87645 93628
September 56973 74893 67085 61054 71455 64168
October 46825 49115 48481 50054 52576 49781
November 40135 41620 43112 43786 41754 40311
December 49230 52404 46710 44426 42857 41322
Total 698512 706534 762968 675736 685699 745282
DNR
Permited Amount
865,000,000 MGY
New Single Family Homes 2021
36 Permits
15 Have been turned onC/O
6 are under two months old
39409
41176
MEMORANDUM
To: Utility Commission Members
From: Shawn Sanders, Director of Public Works
Date: April 11, 2022
Subject: Update of Utility Projects in the City
Background
The following is a list of utility construction projects in the City of Stillwater for 2021 and
2022. Projects on the list will be updated to the commission and new projects added as they
made aware to the City
City Utility Projects
• Brick Street Generator Replacement- Scope included replacing the 50-year generator
at the Brick Street Lift Station. Project completed in 2021.
• Market Place Lift Station- Scope included adding a bypass manhole to the existing
Market Place Lift Station. Project completed in 2021.
• Mid Oaks Lift Station - Scope includes replacing the Lift Station at Mid Oaks. The
existing lift station is a wet well/dry well and would be replaced with a submersible
pump. Bolton and Menk is working on the engineering plans. During design staff noticed
that the existing lift station, force man and gravity is located on private property, Staff is
working with property owners to acquire get easements. Project is on hold until easement
can be obtained
• Pump Upgrades – Scope includes rehabilitation of the pumps at Well #6 and Well #9.
Work completed in 2021.
• SCADA Systems Upgrades – Scope includes converting from telephone system to
radios for information monitoring and tying into the SCADA used for lift station
monitoring. Work completed in 2021.
• Brick Street Watermain Replacement. New watermain on Brick Street between Olive
and Myrtle Street. work to be included in the 2022 Street Improvement Project.
• Aiple Lift Station Generator Replacement. Project replaces 60-year-old generator.
Contractor has been selected. Work to begin this Spring.
• Downtown Manhole Rehabilitation Project. Project looks to eliminate I/I in sanitary
manholes from Elm Street to Aiple Lift Station (30 Total). Bolton And Menk is working
on the plans and specifications. Work scheduled to be completed in 2022.
• Lily Lake Sewer Lining Project. Project looks at eliminating flow from Lily Lake from
entering sanitary sewer. Pipe is located on north side of Lily Lake, in backyards of four
properties. Staff is working on correcting easements prior to commencement of work.
• Portable Generator. New portable generator for the pump house at Legend Park.
Purchase has been approved and waiting for delivery.
• Automatic Water Salesman. Project adds a pay station to the bulk water station at the
water department building on Third Street Staff working on obtaining quotes from
vendors.
• Northland Park Watermain Extension. Project extends watermain in Northland Park to
aid in winter time rink flooding. Project is out for bid and scheduled to completed this
summer.
• Transfer Switch/ Generator Hook-up for Olive Street Project add a transfer switch at
the pump house to allow for connection for a portable generator. Contractor has been
selected and work scheduled to begin this spring.
• Hydrant Painting. Second year of three-year project to paint all hydrants n the City.
2022 project to focus on the north half of the City. (380 total hydrants). Project out for
bid and to be completed this summer.
• Fluoride Pumps. New fluoride pumps for Wells 6, 9 and 12. Staff is working with
vendors on quotes.
• Telemetry Upgrades. Staff is looking to add security measures to entry doors using
through the SCADA system. Staff is working with vendors on quotes.
• Well house repairs. Building improvements for Wellhouse 6 8, and 12. Staff is
working with vendors on quotes.
• Lily Lake Tower Pressure Reducing Valve. TKDA selected to complete plans and
specifications.
The following list is the current and proposed Developer Projects and utility impacts
-
• White Pine Estates- New residential development along County Road 12 across from
Northland Park. Utility Work Completed in 2021.
• Central Commons Development- Mixed use development with retail and apartments
located on the southeast corner of Highway 36 and Manning Avenue. There no utilities in
the area and will have to be extended from the west end of Curve Crest Boulevard and go
under Highway 36. Right-of way needed from Lakeview Hospital site for street and
utility extension
• Neal Avenue Reconstruction- Street reconstruction began in 2020 north of Walnut
Creek. Street reconstruction and new sanitary sewer and watermain south of WaLnut
Creek completed in 2022.